HomeMy WebLinkAboutCAO-17-019 - Downtown Strategic Priorities: Shape DTK 2020
REPORT TO: Finance and Corporate Services Committee
DATE OF MEETING: June 12, 2017
SUBMITTED BY: Cory Bluhm, Interim Executive Director, Economic Development 519-
741-2200 ext. 7065
PREPARED BY: Emily Robson, Interim Manager, Downtown Community Development,
529-741-2200 ext. 7084
WARD (S) INVOLVED: 9 & 10
DATE OF REPORT: May 26, 2017
REPORT NO.: CAO-17-019
SUBJECT:Downtown Strategic Priorities: Shape DTK 2020
___________________________________________________________________________
RECOMMENDATION: That the Shape DTK 2020 Strategic Priorities (as shown in
Appendix A) be approved as the guiding document for downtown community
development initiatives of the Economic Development division in collaboration with the
Downtown Kitchener Business Improvement Area.
That staff be directed to develop an implementation plan based on the Strategic
Priorities in collaboration with the Downtown Kitchener Business Improvement Area.
BACKGROUND:
Downtown Kitchener is in the midst of a tremendous transformation. The arrival of the ION light
rail transit line will accelerate change by attracting more people, more density, new shops, new
buildings, and new ideas. The last 15 years has marked a significant shift in the downtown
landscape, and the future is poised to be just as revolutionary.
Downtown Kitchener (DTK) plays a major role in both pillars
development strategy, Make it Kitchener: building a dynamic economy, and cultivating a
compelling city in which to live. focus on urban development, anchored by
alively urban core,
emphasis on downtown revitalization, and the catalytic investments of the Economic
Development Investment Fund (EDIF).
Economic Development and Downtown Kitchener Business Improvement Area (BIA) staff
began the process of informing the Shape DTK 2020 Strategic Priorities in late 2016. This
included extensive consultation to provide a guiding document that establishes clear priorities
for the next 4 years, a foundation for the development of a collaborative work plan, and
ensures alignment with the corporate Strategic Plan, and the economic development strategy
Make it Kitchener.
*** This information is available in accessible formats upon request. ***
Please call 519-741-2345 or TTY 1-866-969-9994 for assistance.
2 - 1
REPORT:
Why Joint Strategic Priorities and Why Now?
The City and Downtown Kitchener BIA have a strong history of collaborating on actions and
initiatives that guide Downtown’s future - a common understanding that, by working together,
we can effect greater positive change than working separately.In 2012, the City and BIA
jointly approved the Downtown Kitchener Action Plan 2012-2016 which served as the blue
print for how the City (e.g.: Economic Development staff) and BIA would focus their resources
during that time.
With ION construction nearly complete, and trains expected to be operational in 2018,
Downtown will continue to experience significant development pressure over the next 4
years. Today is an opportune time to re-establish community values and priorities, in hopes
that we can shape the kind of change our community wants, rather than let changeshape us.
Consultation Findings
The Shape DTK 2020 Strategic Prioritiesconsultation processfocused on the aspects of DTK
that the community loves and doesn’t want to see lost, and ideas about what would make DTK
even better. The suggestions and thoughts of nearly 15,000 community members and
stakeholders were collected, synthesized and categorized. What emerged was a clear set of
values—qualities that people appreciate about DTK and want to see preserved—and three key
themes that suggest ways to improveon what already makes DTK compelling.
Values:
- Local and Unique:The communitylikes findinguniqueproducts, servicesand
interestingfoodoptionsthat are local, nurturing personal relationships with business
owners, and having a truly “made in Kitchener” experience.
- Diverse and Inclusive: DTK should not only be a place for everyone, it should have a
little something foreveryone too—it must be welcoming to all people and representative
of the community’s many cultures.
- Bold and Authentic: Downtown is a place that feels real—buildingssteeped in history,a
place rich in character, anda local population made of many cultures and sub-cultures.
- Community-centric: Community connections fuel DTK, whether that means bumping
into friends on the street, coffee shops and pubs that feel like home, businesses being
more collaborative than competitive, or facing complex social issues head on and with
empathy.
Themes:
1.A Larger Marketplace: Stakeholders want greater diversity and variety in shopping,
services, and dining options.
2.Heartfelt Experiences: Downtown Kitchener is a place for discovery, exploration, and
there is a lot of interest in experiencingits unique offerings.
3.Community Connections: The supportive, collaborative and inclusive spirit ofthe
downtowncommunity will be critical in ensuring DTK, as it continues to grow and
change, remains a place for all.
2 - 2
A full description of the findings, values, and themes can be found in Appendix B (Shape DTK
2020 Findings).
Strategic Priorities
Based on the consultation findingsnoted above, and in response to thesevalues and themes,
threestrategic prioritiesare proposed:
1.Ignite the downtown as a platform for the next generation of urban shops, restaurants,
businesses & services: Create the runway for businesses to succeed by providing tools
to compete in an increasingly disruptive, digital marketplace.Examples of possible
initiatives include: retail/food incubator program, retail market analysis, and physical
enhancements that improve the customer experience (e.g.,wayfinding signage).
2.Foster heartfelt urban experiences: Support those who are creating meaningful, layered
urban experiences today, and those who want to offer new ones tomorrow.Examples of
possible initiatives include: shifting programming to evening and weekends,
programming laneways, and signature outdoor art installations.
3.Champion a caring and collaborative community: Enable community builders by
creating venues, spaces and opportunities for people to unite. Work together to tackle
difficult challenges, like supporting those in need.Examples of possible initiatives
include: hosting community-building events (e.g.,art crawls), developing urban
amenities (e.g.,dog parks, sitting areas), and engaging diverse populations in relevant
programming.
A full description of the strategic priorities can be found in Appendix A (Shape DTK 2020
Strategic Priorities).
Staff sought feedback on these strategic priorities by soliciting comment cards at a public open
house, a drop-in BIA event, an information station at the Kitchener Market, and an Engage
Kitchenersurvey. In general, the proposed priorities were positively received by the
community. Many commentssimplysought further detailand clarity on the initiatives and
actions associated with each priority area. For this reason, City staff and staff from the BIA
propose to undertake collaborative work planning to identify the specific programs, initiatives,
and tasks required to address the strategic priorities. Staff will develop and present a draft
workplan and anticipate bringing a report to Council inthe Fallof 2017.
Building off the 2012-2016 Priorities
The previous plan focused on 4 key areas of focus. Three of these priorities - a vibrant King
Street, residential intensification and growth of the Innovation District – are still critical
objectives of a vibrant Downtown. However, all three have a degree of momentum behind
them. While they still need support, it is possiblefor the City and BIA to turn the attention on a
new set of top priorities. In fact, the three new proposed priorities will only help strengthen,
support and build off of the previous priorities.
ALIGNMENT WITH CITY OF KITCHENER STRATEGIC PLAN:
The recommendation of this report supports the achievement of the city’s strategic vision
through the delivery of core service.
2 - 3
Downtown plays a critical role in Make it Kitchener, the City’s economic development strategy
by developing a dynamic downtown, facilitating and encouraging sought-after urban amenities
(Make it Urban), encouraging our creative community to use the city as a stage, and
supporting strong communities and neighbourhood identities through distinct events and
creative expressions (Make it Vibrant).
In particular, Shape DTK 2020 Strategic Priorities supports a strong and resilient economy by
nurturing quality of life, supporting job creation and facilitating the ongoing development of
Downtown Kitchener (items 2.1, 2.4 and 2.5).
As well, Shape DTK 2020 Strategic Priorities supports safe and thriving neighbourhoods, by
encouraging people to come together in a public space, supporting health and well-being, and
providing a venue for citizen-led events and experiences (item 3.6).
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS:
None at this time.
Any disbursementsrequired to support future actionswill be funded through existing Economic
Development operating budgets and/or the Economic Development Reserve Fund. Any
disbursements outside of existing budgets or outside the parameters of the City’s Purchasing
Policywill be brought forward to Council for approval with a supporting business case.
COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT:
Staff engaged nearly 1,500 people in consultation to inform these strategic priorities. A
comprehensive approach was used to try to achieve representation across the community.
This included five digital surveys, a community forum, 10 stakeholder round tables, an open
house, a BIA member event, a drop-in information booth at the Kitchener Market, and advisory
committees. Great detail on the number of participants can be found on page 2 of Appendix 2).
The BIA Boardhas been a collaborative partner throughout this process, and greatly
contributed toward the development of the strategic priorities.The BIA Board supported the
rd
strategic priorities at their May 23meetingandis scheduled toformally approve them on
th
. The Downtown Action and Advisory Committee (DAAC) passed a motion supporting
June 28
th
the strategic prioritiesat their May 25meeting.The Economic Development Advisory
Committee (EDAC) also provided feedback on the survey results and strategic priorities.
CONCLUSION:
Shape DTK 2020 delivers a strongand compellingdirectionfor the future growth of the
downtown. The proposed strategic priorities will provide 1)a guiding document for
implementation by Economic Developmentand BIAstaff; and 2) a point of entry for the
community and future partners to engage with the City on the future growth of the downtown.
Economic Development and BIA staff will develop a work plan and resource model to align
with the implementation of these strategic priorities.
ACKNOWLEDGED BY: Jeff Willmer, CAO
2 - 4
CAO-17-019Downtown Strategic Priorities: Shape
DTK 2020
Appendix A: Shape DTK 2020 Strategic Priorities
2 pages
2 - 5
of
do we get
olders, we’ve been
DIVERSITY
shops and restaurants which
UNIQUE
AUTHENTICITY.
that they love about DTK. It’s the
—
of anyone and everyone. It’s the
character is proof of its
BOLD
INCLUSIVE
dings, r restaurants or parks
that truly defines Downtown Kitchener. It’s where dreamers, creators and makers find
like buil
—
’s the belief that DKT’s
COMMUNITY
feel. It
LOCAL
SHAPING DTK: A VISION FOR 2020 Five years ago, downtown stakeholders challenged us to energize King Street, add more housing in the core, and build out an Innovation District. Thanks
to the work of countless partners and stakeholders, this change is happening! And while they remain key priorities, the arrival of ION will only accelerate change. As such, today marks
a critical inflection point. With input, thoughts and ideas from downtown stakehable to shape a vision and mantra for the future of DTK that builds on success and positions downtown
for the change ahead. Shape DTK 2020 started with 3 simple questions: What do you love about Downtown today? What’s your vision for its future? Howthere? Respondents told us that it’s
not just the tangiblespeople, businesses, festivals and community groups that are give downtown a decidedly Simply put, it’s the unwavering sense of neighbours, collaborators and friends.
No matter the size, scale or type of change a person wants to champion, if it betters our community, people here will help. And for those who simply want to be part of something, there’s
a place in DTK.
2 - 6
it’s
–
it’s a
–
to all work
Come Shape DTK together.
nity. But we need
ldy, because we can shape change
spaces and opportunities for people to unite. We can help neighbours come together and support collaboration among businesses, residents and community groups. We can work together to
tackle difficult challenges, like supporting those in need. Because at the end of the day, it’s not the size of our buildings or wealth of our companies that will define DTK the openness,
inclusiveness and authenticity of DTK people that will.DOWNTOWN IS CHANGING.But change doesn’t need to be scary or unwietogether. Remember, Downtown is much more than a physical place
community. We will champion positive change through programs and investments that make Downtown Kitchener a destination of choice for our entire commutogether.
ing
ant to
mportant
want a
support
necessarily
engaged!
or comedy, all
t’s the
i
were also very
URBAN
often as i
is
Respondents said that
.
role to play in
ayered urban experience, and
are done
e can support our community
them downtown,
might be the events, stores,
want the chance to dine at an
significant
things
were clear that doesn’t mean Disney.
PRIORITY #2 FOSTER HEARTFELT EXPERIENCESWhen folks are downtown, theymeaningful, ltheyTheyinnovative restaurant, explore interesting shops, visit a gallery or museum, go for a drink
and take in live musicin one trip. Respondentclear that you want these experiences all the time, evenings and weekends, designed for all types of audiences.While the City and BIA don’t
need to create those experiences, they have those who are creating heartfelt experiences today, and those who woffer new ones tomorrow.PRIORITY #3 CHAMPION A CARING & COLLABORATIVE
COMMUNITYHow as what gets donewhile it restaurants, experiences or work that brought community that keeps themTogether wbuilders. We can create the venues,
e
-
but that’s
–
ital
enabling the
experience; provide
, RESTAURANTS,
, partners and agencies, the
SHOPS
opportunities for those who want
Stakeholders want community leaders, stakeholdersBIA and City included, champions of positive change, and creatingto be part of it. These three proposed strategic areas of focus may
not be grandiose, transformative ideas the point. They simply set the stage for the kind of positive change our community wants: PRIORITY #1IGNITE DOWNTOWN AS A PLATFORM FOR THE NEXT
GENERATION OF URBAN BUSINESSES & SERVICESStakeholders want more and better shops, restaurants and services. And respondents were clear on what the parameters are unique, local, independent
places that offer products, services and an experience that can’t be found at a mall or online. The opportunity is to create the runway for businesses to succeed. Together we can identify
and provide the tools to compete in an increasingly disruptive, digmarketplace; enhance the customer shopping and diningspace, opportunity and mentoring for thoswho want to test new
concepts; andpromote and amplify all of the amazing experiences DTK has to offer.
2 - 7
CAO-17-019Downtown Strategic Priorities: Shape
DTK 2020
Appendix B: Shape DTK 2020 Findings
21 pages
2 - 8
STAKEHOLDER VISIONS OF A NEW
SHAPE
ACTION PLAN FOR DOWNTOWN KITCHENER
FINDINGS
DTK 2020
2 - 9
| 1
PHOTO: JOE MARTZ - JOEMARTZ.COM
S |
by
that they
ONE VICTORIA RESIDENTIAL CONDO
HOW DO WE GET THERE?
and
DOWNTOWN KITCHENER
love about
COMMUNITY
MAKE THIS PLACE EVEN BETTER,
Downtown Kitchener (aka DTK) is in the midst of a tremendous transformation. The arrival of the ION transit line will accelerate change: more people, more density, new shops, new buildings,
new collisions and creations. Today is a critical moment in time because we have a chance to shape the change to come. We can shape it to match our collective values and desires. We
can make sure were all proud of those changes and involved in realizing them. Together as a community, weve been considering this opportunity discussing two big questions:What does
the dont want to see lost? What will The thoughts, ideas and answers of nearly 1500 community builders and stakeholders were collected, synthesized and grouped. What emerged was a
clear set of core values qualities that people appreciate about downtown and want to see preserved and three key themes that suggest ways to improve on what already makes DTK compelling.
Weve While the City of Kitchener and Downtown Kitchener BIA may have undertaken this research, there is only one way to move these strategic priorities forward and into reality: by
changing things together. Before we start, we want to check back in with you. Did we capture the communitys thoughts, feelings and desires correctly? Do the proposed hope youll continue
to Shape DTK with us!
SHAPE DTK 2020:CREATING OUR
2 - 10
| 2
AGED 35-59
MALES
were
of respondents
KITCHENER
IN DOWNTOWN
LIVE OR WORK
respondents
of survey
LESS THAN
FEMALES
years old
of survey respondents
were 35
as
respondents
of survey
to
PHOTO: MATTHEW WARTMAN - BARNDOORCREATIVE.CA
CT |
SURVEYS
ONLINE
DTK 2020
four distinct Shape
PEOPLE RESPONDED
2
THE INNOVATION DISTRI
and at
by DTK
and
+
GATHERINGS
SURVEYS
captured by
stakeholders were
COMMENTS
ROUND TABLE
COMMUNITY
a FORUM
at DISCUSSIONS
their DTK vision
locals shared
FOSTER HEARTFELT EXPERIENCES
DOWNTOWN KITCHENER
2 - 11
| 3
MEG LESLIES AWESOME WALL AT THE HOUSE OF FRIENDSHIP
Kitchener has a
heart and grit that
everywhere doesnt.
2 - 12
| 4
B@THEMUSEUM
FOSTER HEARTFELT EXPERIENCES
We asked stakeholders to explain their attraction to DTK, and four sets of core values emerged.
YOU SHARED YOUR CORE VALUES
2 - 13
| 5
CORE VALUES
LIVE MUSIC IN VICTORIA PARK
DIVERSE & INCLUSIVE DTK should not only be a place for everyone, it should have
I want to feel like
a gated community.
Im in the world, not
LOCAL & UNIQUE
2 - 14
| 6
to
CORE VALUES
YETI CAFÉ IN THE MARKET DISTRICT
BOLD & AUTHENTIC doers.
6
The unique grassroots
to move here from Toronto.
community vibe compelled us
COMMUNITY-CENTRIC
FOSTER HEARTFELT EXPERIENCES
2 - 15
INTERESTING
FACTOID:
Historically, survey
respondents have always
THE CONUNDRUM:
and services. People who live and work
wider variety of restaurants
LEGACY GREENS ON KING STREET
FOSTER HEARTFELT EXPERIENCES
Stakeholders want greater diversity and variety stores, restaurants 7 |
LOCALS WANT A LARGERMARKETPLACE
2 - 16
8
LIKE OUR
of downtown
RESTAURANTS.
I prefer to shop
I prefer power
45%
I prefer to
shop DTK even if there were shop in Toronto.
LARGER MARKETPLACE
COFFEE SHOP
of survey respondents visit a DTK OR CAFÉ eat at a downtown RESTAURANT
...and with nearly 100 FOOD & DRINK PROVIDERS DOWNTOWN...
How do DTK EMPLOYEES CURRENTLY SHOP?care where I shop. If I with the current shops.
to locals
LIKE
STORES.
OUR RETAIL
IS IMPORTANT
of downtown
AUTHENTICITY
of stakeholders PLEASURE SHOP downtown on DESTINATION SHOP downtown on a
52%independent businesses
The public will COME TO DTK FOR MORE/BETTER Shops and servicesFestivals and events
90 RETAIL BUSINESSES DOWNTOWN...
MORE/
AS
RD
RD
said
FOOD
when
3 CHOICE UPSCALECASUAL 243 VOTES
MORE 3 CHOICE RARE FIND/ ANTIQUE/ VINTAGE STORES 241 VOTES
INVESTMENT SHOPS
MORE/BETTER SHOPS
do people want to see?
ND
ND
2 CHOICE ETHNIC 307 VOTES
2 CHOICE CLOTHING/SHOE/GIFT STORES 360 VOTES
TWO TIMES AS OFTEN
60% OF DTK EMPLOYEES
MORE
STST
VARIETY & QUALITY
Stakeholders chose & SERVICESRESTAURANTS & COFFEE SHOPS Nearly BETTER RETAIL
1 CHOICE DAILY SERVICES 466 VOTES 1 CHOICE UNIQUECONCEPT 321 VOTES
WHAT KIND OF do people want to see?WHAT STYLE OF & DRINK
2 - 17
| 9
LARGER MARKETPLACE
BLACK ARROW CYCLES ON QUEEN STREET
downtown more often.
We need more services
in order to bring people
S
A
E
D
I
M
U
R
O
F
K
T
D
E
More street food
P
A
passport
eats or
H
S
2 - 18
10
LARGER MARKETPLACE
would be lovely. I would also love to see
We need to concentrate on cultivating
services that you cant buy online: eating,
attract and keep people downtown.
2 - 19
WHAT WE
HEARD A LOT:
THE OPPORTUNITY:
wider audience.
CANADA DAY FESTIVITIES IN 2015
FOSTER HEARTFELT EXPERIENCES
Downtown Kitchener is a place for discovery and exploration,authenticity, ideally on foot. Shape DTK stakeholders want their 11 |
LOCALS LOVE HEARTFELTEXPERIENCES
2 - 20
12
want daily
CURIOSITIES
SENSES
OUTDOORSPACESLIVEMUSICIANSPEDESTRIAN EXPLORATION
HEARTFELT EXPERIENCES
of survey respondents said theyrestaurants downtownof respondents asked for
of public survey respondents festivals to happen downtownof respondants said they want
%
%
%%
LOCALS VIBRANCY
32.123.1
STIR THEIR
47.524.1
FEED THEIR
302 votes
230
222
OVER LARGE
203
SPECTACLESAN AUDIENCE
OVER BEING PART OF
163
146
PARTICIPATORY
NIGHTLIFE
57
A GROUP
EXPERIENCES
COMMUNAL
& BEING PART OF
376
364
328
380 votes
such as
287
ACTIVE
MORE THAN
basketball court
EXPERIENCES
creating a laneway
PREFERRED
such as
participants to rank their
87
Shape DTK surveys asked
SOCIAL
LOCALS WANT
INITIATIVES
EXPERIENCES
as hangout spots
reimagining laneways
where restaurants, patios and pubs
2 - 21
| 13
S
A
E
D
HEARTFELT EXPERIENCES
I
Art crawls every
Outdoor winter events
M
U
A Ferris wheel at Victoria Park
R
O
F
K
PHOTO: MATT SMITH - MATTHEWSMITHPHOTO.NET
|
T
D
E
P
A
H
S
or mysterious in nature.
Canadian version of Portland.
Keep it weird, keep encouraging
experiences that are hard to explain
Kitchener could be a kind of smaller,
NIGHT\\SHIFT: BALLOON ROOM @ CITS FEATURING FROG IN HAND PRODUCTIONS
2 - 22
14
HEARTFELT EXPERIENCES
pedestrian walkways, cafes, outdoor continue to attract crowds. This concept series at DTK businesses that invites the counter and learn about how we do
houses into a downtown with personalibeen a place that is for everyone, where food & that it has such an enviable social
spaces be experimented with
Laneways are hidden gems!! I think the
idea of using laneways for seating areas,
patios and festivals would greatly increase
encourage land owners to let their empty
Foster a climate of openness to space usage,
2 - 23
INTERESTING
FACTOID:
WHAT THIS MIGHT MEAN:
connections and relationships with others that keep us
PHOTO: DEAN LANDRY - DVISION.CA
RK |
Connecting the people and places that make DTK compellingProviding amenities, services and spaces so locals can do life in DTKThe collison of community-minded people and organizations
to create a breeding ground for grassroots innovation
YOGA IN VICTORIA PA
FOSTER HEARTFELT EXPERIENCES
The supportive, collaborative and inclusive spirit of downtown is important and energizing.
15 |
LOCALS VALUE COMMUNITYCONNECTIONS
2 - 24
16
339 votes
PARK
WALK
VICTORIA
STREET
140 votes
DOWN KING
COMMUNITY CONNECTIONS
131 votes
FESTIVAL
227 votes
DINNER
LUNCH OR
(THEMUSEUM, KPL, KWAG)
OUT
4
NIGHT 114 votes 9150403827
A
230 votes
MARKET
KITCHENER
connect
& the
(40% OF VOTES)
VICTORIA PARK
COMMUNAL VENUES TAKE A VISITORDOWNTOWN?TOP TWO CHOICES are KITCHENER MARKET local communities and individuals
than
(with Wi-Fi)
or
(like Ping Pong)
by survey respondents.
AND
of downtown residents is
RANKED 1ST MORE OFTEN
Popup Retail/Restaurant shops (ex: shipping container)
TOP PRIORITY
votes 341
464418
423
DTKS FABRIC TO STRENGTHEN The A DIVERSE WELCOMING COMMUNITYwhich was great shops and restaurantsvibrant street life
INTERVENTIONS SHOULD ENCOURAGE INTERACTION spontaneous activity.108
2 - 25
COMMUNITY CONNECTIONS
contribute to this place.
make me want to do more to
here that are really collaborative
The businesses and organizations
PHOTO: CHRISTINE REID - CHRISTINEREIDPHOTOGRAPHY.COM | 17
|
S
A
E
D
I
M
U
R
O
F
K
T
D
E
MANULIFE RED LAB IN THE COMMUNITECH HUB
P
A
H
S
services and business
collaboration
foster this kind of creative
everyone to
Space for
2 - 26
18
COMMUNITY CONNECTIONS
spaces be experimented with.
spaces be experimented with
encourage land owners to let their empty
encourage land owners to let their empty
Foster a climate of openness to space usage,
Foster a climate of openness to space usage,
infrastructure that we already have collaboration between downtown food &
2 - 27
| 22
PHOTO: JOE MARTZ - JOEMARTZ.COM
|
Anything is possible and
anyone will help you in DTK.
BRIDGE TO VICTORIA PARK ISLAND
FOSTER HEARTFELT EXPERIENCES
City of Kitcheners strategic priorities for downtown, we need to know how well weve captured your thoughts, feelings and desires.Please keep sharing your thoughts on how we Shape DTK
at downtownkitchener.ca/ShapeDTK
NEXT STEPS
2 - 28
City of Kitchener
#SHAPEDTK
Downtown Kitchener BIA
LINDA JUTZI
Questions?
CORY BLUHM
cory.bluhm@kitchener.ca
THE PEOPLE OF
BROUGHT TO YOU BY
@DTKITCHENER
Executive Director,
Executive Director of Economic Development,
2 - 29