Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPSI Agenda - 2023-04-03Planning & Strategic Initiatives Committee Agenda Monday, April 3, 2023, 7:00 p.m. - 8:00 p.m. Council Chambers - Hybrid City of Kitchener 200 King Street W, Kitchener, ON N2G 4G7 People interested in participating in this meeting can register online using the delegation registration form at www.kitchener.ca/delegation or via email at delegation kitchener.ca. Please refer to the delegation section on the agenda below for registration in-person and electronic participation deadlines. Written comments received will be circulated prior to the meeting and will form part of the public record. The meeting live -stream and archived videos are available at www.kitchener.ca/watchnow. *Accessible formats and communication supports are available upon request. If you require assistance to take part in a city meeting or event, please call 519-741-2345 or TTY 1-866-969-9994.* Chair: Councillor P. Singh Vice -Chair: Councillor D. Chapman Pages 1. Commencement 2. Disclosure of Pecuniary Interest and the General Nature Thereof Members of Council and members of the City's local boards/committees are required to file a written statement when they have a conflict of interest. If a conflict is declared, please visit www.kitchener.ca/conflict to submit your written form. 3. Consent Items The following matters are considered not to require debate and should be approved by one motion in accordance with the recommendation contained in each staff report. A majority vote is required to discuss any report listed as under this section. 3.1 None 4. Delegations Pursuant to Council's Procedural By-law, delegations are permitted to address the Committee for a maximum of five (5) minutes. All Delegations where possible are encouraged to register prior to the start of the meeting. For Delegates who are attending in-person, registration is permitted up to the start of the meeting. Delegates who are interested in attending virtually must register by 5:00 p.m. on April 3, 2023, in order to participate electronically. 4.1 Item 6.1 - Chris Pidgeon, GSP Group and Alex Vandersluis, Schlegel Urban Developments Corporation 4.2 Item 6.2 - Pierre Chauvin, MHBC Planning 5. Discussion Items 5.1 None 6. Public Hearing Matters under the Planning Act (7:00 p.m.) This is a formal public meeting to consider applications under the Planning Act. If a person or public body does not make oral or written submissions to the City of Kitchener before the proposed applications are considered, the person or public body may not be entitled to appeal the decision to the Ontario Land Tribunal and may not be added as a party to a hearing of an appeal before the Ontario Land Tribunal. 6.1 Official Plan Amendment Application 30 m 3 OPA22/015/C/KA and Zoning By-law Amendment Application ZBA22/026/C/ICA, 265 Cotton Grass Street, Schlegel Urban Developments Corporation, DSD -2023-111, DSD -2023-111 (Staff will provide a 5 minute presentation on this matter.) 6.2 Official Plan Amendment Application 30 m 70 OPA22/013/MBB and Zoning By-law Amendment Application ZBA22/024/M/BB, 7 Morrison Road, Klondike Homes Limited, DSD - 2023 -120, DSD -2023-120 (Staff will provide a 5 minute presentation on this matter.) 7. Information Items 7.1 None 8. Adjournment Mariah Blake Committee Administrator Page 2 of 164 Staff Report J IKgc.;i' r� R Development Services Department www.kitchener.ca REPORT TO: Planning and Strategic Initiatives Committee DATE OF MEETING: April 3, 2023 SUBMITTED BY: Garett Stevenson, Interim Director of Planning, 519-741-2200 x7070 PREPARED BY: Katie Anderl, Senior Planner, 519-741-2200 x7987 WARD(S) INVOLVED: Ward 5 DATE OF REPORT: March 8, 2023 REPORT NO.: DSD -2023-111 SUBJECT: Official Plan Amendment Application OPA22/015/C/KA By-law Amendment Application ZBA22/026/C/KA 265 Cotton Grass Street Schlegel Urban Developments Corp. RECOMMENDATION: That Official Plan Amendment Application OPA22/015/C/KA for Schlegel Urban Developments Corp. requesting a change to the Land Use Designation on the parcel of land specified and illustrated on Schedule `A', be adopted, in the form shown in the Official Plan Amendment attached to Report DSD -2023-111 as Attachment "A", and accordingly forwarded to the Region of Waterloo for approval; and That Zoning By-law Amendment Application ZBA22/026/C/KA for Schlegel Urban Developments Corp. be approved in the form shown in the "Proposed By-law" and "Map No. 1" attached to Report DSD -2023-111 as Attachment "B". REPORT HIGHLIGHTS: The purpose of this report is to evaluate and provide a planning recommendation regarding the Official Plan Amendment and Zoning By-law Amendment applications for the subject lands located at 265 Cotton Grass Street. It is planning staff's recommendation that the Official Plan and Zoning By-law Amendments be approved. The proposed Amendments support the creation of a 32 unit stacked townhouse development within the Williamsburg Town Centre. Community engagement included: o circulation of a preliminary notice letter to property owners and residents within 240 metres of the subject site; o installation of a large billboard notice sign on the properties; o Neighbourhood Meeting held on January 31, 2023; o follow up one-on-one correspondence with members of the public; o postcard advising of the statutory public meeting was circulated to all property owners within 240 metres of the subject site, those who responded to the circulation; and those who provided comments following the Neighbourhood Meeting; o notice of the public meeting was published in The Record on March 10, 2023. This report supports the delivery of core services. *** This information is available in accessible formats upon request. *** Please call 519-741-2345 or TTY 1-866-969-9994 for assistance. Page 3 of 164 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: The owner of the subject lands addressed as 265 Cotton Grass Street is proposing to change the Official Plan designation from `Commercial' to `Commercial with Specific Policy Area 61', in the City of Kitchener Official Plan (2014), and to change the zoning `Neighbourhood Shopping Centre Zone (C-2) with Special Regulation Provision 356R' to `Neighbourhood Shopping Centre Zone (C-2) with Special Regulation Provision 356R and Special Use Provision 483U, Special Regulation Provision 787R, and Holding Provision 99H' to permit a standalone multiple residential dwelling, a reduced setback to Cotton Grass Street, a parking ratio of 1.5 parking spaces/dwelling unit, and to require a Noise Study to the satisfaction of the Region of Waterloo. Staff are recommending that the applications be approved. BACKGROUND: The subject lands are located in the Williamsburg Community and were originally approved for development in 2002 through the approval of Plan of Subdivision 30T-96005 and associated Official Plan and Zoning By-law amendments. The Williamsburg Town Centre was conceived as the focus for this community and includes commercial lands, medium density residential lands, and a central park space (Max Becker Commons). This community has been developed by Schlegel Urban Developments Corp, who remain situated and invested in this community. The subject lands are located on a vacant parcel of developable land that fronts onto `Main Street' (a privately owned `urban' street) in the Williamsburg Town Centre. The lands are located in a `Community Node', designated `Commercial' and are zoned `Neighbourhood Commercial Zone (C-2)'. The existing policy and zoning permissions permit a mix of commercial and residential uses, and dwelling units are currently permitted on upper floors of a mixed commercial/residential building and having a maximum Floor Space Ratio of 2.0 and a maximum building height of 15.0 metres. The applicant is proposing a development in keeping with the permitted height and density, however, is requesting special policies and regulations to permit a standalone multiple dwelling with residential units on the ground floor. REPORT: The applicant is proposing to develop the subject lands with a 3.5 storey multiple residential development consisting of 2 and 3 bedroom stacked townhouse units. These two floor units are planned to be purpose-built rental. Site specific regulations are proposed to permit: - a parking rate of 1.5 parking spaces/dwelling unit - setback reductions to Cotton Grass Street - a reduced lot area of 3,400 square metres rather than required 4000 square metres - permission for a standalone multiple residential building with dwelling units on the ground floor Through the application review process, staff have worked with the applicant to update the site design in order to create an improved site layout by eliminating a secondary driveway connection to "Main Street". This driveway was determined not to be needed for the appropriate functioning of the site, and a single driveway access to Cotton Grass Street is preferred. The original development concept included a secondary driveway connection to `Main Street' immediately next to a below grade parking entrance for Building 700 which has been removed. The drive aisle will connect with adjacent commercial parking lots providing for appropriate circulation of the overall block. This design has been reviewed by Transportation Services staff and is supportable and safe. This redesign has allowed for additional landscaped space between the residential building and the adjacent commercial building 700 to the south, and an additional block of residential units, so that 32 units are now included rather than 28 (see Figure 3). Page 4 of 164 Figure 1 — 265 Cotton Grass Street (Onpoint 2023) Figure 2 — Williamsburg Town Centre view from north-east (Urban Design Brief 265 Cotton Grass Street, November 2022) Page 5 of 164 mm MAINSTIR � �r ice. _.._ FET LA)' � f�lall.IN 7 BY OTHERS TXISTIIF — ----- ------------------- f�C' .RM LU -&Xj�,TING PUBLIC PARK W Figure 3 — 265 Cotton Grass in context of Buildings 600 (existing) and 700 (approved) (Conceptual Site Plan, February 2023, 4 Architecture Inc.) Planning Analysis: Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.13 25. Section 2 of the Planning Act establishes matters of provincial interest and states that the Minister, the council of a municipality, a local board, a planning board, and the Tribunal, in carrying out their responsibilities under this Act, shall have regard to, among other matters, matters of provincial interest such as, f) The adequate provision and efficient use of communication, transportation, sewage and water services and waste management systems; g) The minimization of waste; h) The orderly development of safe and healthy communities; j) The adequate provision of a full range of housing, including affordable housing; k) The adequate provision of employment opportunities; p) The appropriate location of growth and development; q) The promotion of development that is designed to be sustainable, to support public transit and to be oriented to pedestrians; r) The promotion of built form that, (i) Is well-designed, (ii) Encourages a sense of place, and (iii) Provides for public spaces that are of high quality, safe, accessible, attractive and vibrant; s) The mitigation of greenhouse gas emissions and adaptation to a changing climate. These matters of provincial interest are addressed and are implemented through the Provincial Policy Statement, 2020, as it directs how and where development is to occur. The City's Official Plan is the most important vehicle for the implementation of the Provincial Policy Statement, 2020 and to ensure Provincial policy is adhered to. Provincial Policy Statement, 2020: The Provincial Policy Statement (PPS) provides policy direction on matters of provincial interest related to land use planning and development. Section 1.4.3(b) of the PPS promotes all types of residential intensification, and sets out a policy framework for sustainable, healthy, liveable and safe communities. The PPS promotes efficient development and land use patterns, as well as accommodating an appropriate mix of affordable and market-based residential dwelling types with other land uses, while supporting the environment, public health and safety. Provincial policies promote the integration of land use planning, growth management, transit -supportive development, intensification, and infrastructure planning to achieve cost-effective development patterns, optimization of transit investments, and standards to minimize land consumption and servicing costs. Page 6 of 164 To support provincial policies relating to the provision of housing, optimization of infrastructure, transit and active transportation, the proposed designation and zoning facilitate a compact form of development which efficiently uses the lands, is in close proximity to transit options including iXpress and other public transit routes and makes efficient use of both existing roads and active transportation networks. The lands are serviced and are in proximity to commercial and service uses, schools, parks, trails and other community uses. Provincial policies are in support of providing a broad range of housing. The proposed multiple dwelling includes 2 and 3 bedroom ground -oriented rental apartments. Planning staff is of the opinion that the proposed applications will facilitate the development of the subject property with housing that is compatible with the surrounding community, helps manage growth, is transit -supportive and will make use of the existing infrastructure. No new public roads would be required for the proposed development and Engineering staff have confirmed there is sufficient existing servicing. Based on the foregoing, staff is of the opinion that this proposal is in conformity with the PPS. A Place to Grow: Growth Plan for the Greater Golden Horseshoe, 2020 (Growth Plan): The Growth Plan supports the development of complete and compact communities that are designed to support healthy and active living, make efficient use of land and infrastructure, provide for a range and mix of housing types, jobs, and services, at densities and in locations which support transit viability and active transportation. Policies of the Growth Plan promote growth within strategic growth areas including major transit station areas, in order to provide a focus for investments in transit and other types of infrastructure. Policy 2.2.6.1(a) Municipalities will support housing choice through the achievement of the minimum intensification and targets in this plan by identifying a diverse range and mix of housing options and densities, including additional residential units and affordable housing to meet projected needs of current and future residents. Policies 2.2.1.4 states that complete communities will: a) feature a diverse mix of land uses, including residential and employment uses, and convenient access to local stores, services, and public service facilities; b) improve social equity and overall quality of life, including human health, for people of all ages, abilities, and incomes; c) provide a diverse range and mix of housing options, including additional residential units and affordable housing, to accommodate people at all stages of life, and to accommodate the needs of all household sizes and incomes; d) expand convenient access to: i. a range of transportation options, including options for the safe, comfortable and convenient use of active transportation; ii. public service facilities, co -located and integrated in community hubs; iii. an appropriate supply of safe, publicly -accessible open spaces, parks, trails, and other recreational facilities; and iv. healthy, local, and affordable food options, including through urban agriculture; e) provide for a more compact built form and a vibrant public realm, including public open spaces; f) mitigate and adapt to the impacts of a changing climate, improve resilience and reduce greenhouse gas emissions, and contribute to environmental sustainability; and g) integrate green infrastructure and appropriate low impact development. The Growth Plan supports planning for a range and mix of housing options and, in particular, higher density housing options that can accommodate a range of household sizes in locations that can provide access to transit and other amenities. Page 7 of 164 The subject lands are located within the City's delineated Built-Up Area, and within a planned mixed- use commercial plaza (Williamsburg Town Centre). Dwelling units are currently permitted to be located on upper floors of commercial buildings and co-location of commercial and residential uses helps support the development of completed communities. The proposed site-specific designation and zoning will support the applicant in delivering a missing-middle, 2 and 3 bedroom, rental housing option in the Williamsburg Town Centre. The location will help make efficient use of existing servicing infrastructure, parks, roads, trails and transit, while also being conveniently located near commercial and service uses, as well as community uses and schools. Planning staff is of the opinion that the applications conform to the Growth Plan. Regional Official Plan (ROP): Urban Area policies of the ROP identify that the focus of the Region's future growth will be within the Urban Designated Greenfield Areas. The subject lands are designated `Urban Designated Greenfield Areas' in the ROP. This neighbourhood provides for the physical infrastructure and community infrastructure to support the proposed residential development, including transportation networks, municipal drinking-water supply and wastewater systems, and a broad range of social and public health services. Regional policies require Area Municipalities to plan for a range of housing in terms of form, tenure, density and affordability to satisfy the various physical, social, economic and personal support needs of current and future residents. Regional staff have indicated that they have no objections to the proposed applications (Appendix `D'). Planning staff are of the opinion that the applications conform to the Regional Official Plan. City of Kitchener Official Plan, 2014 (OP) The City of Kitchener OP provides the long-term land use vision for Kitchener. The vision is further articulated and implemented through the guiding principles, goals, objectives, and policies which are set out in the Plan. The Vision and Goals of the OP strive to build an innovative, vibrant, attractive, safe, complete and healthy community. Urban Structure The Official Plan establishes an Urban Structure for the City of Kitchener and provides policies for directing growth and development within this structure. Intensification Areas are targeted throughout the Built-up Area as key locations to accommodate and receive the majority of development or redevelopment for a variety of land uses. Primary Intensification Areas include the Urban Growth Centre, Major Transit Station Areas, Nodes and Corridors, in this hierarchy, according to Section 3.C.2.3 of the Official Plan. The subject lands are identified as being located with a `Community Node' on Map 2 of the Official Plan and are designated 'Commercial'. Community Nodes are located along existing or planned transit corridors and provide for commercial uses with a mix of residential and institutional uses necessary to support and complete surrounding residential communities. Applicable land use designations include Commercial, Mixed Use, Medium- and High-Rise Residential. The subject Community Node is located along a transit corridor and is intended to achieve a mix of uses and includes lands that are designated 'Commercial' and `Medium- Rise Residential'. The proposed development is in keeping with the contemplated uses, height and density of the Community Node. The Commercial land use designation permits a broad range of uses, including dwelling units on upper floors of buildings also containing other permitted commercial uses. The applicant is proposing to add a Specific Policy Area to the subject lands to permit residential uses to be permitted in a stand-alone building and on the ground floor. Staff is of the opinion that permitted ground floor residential in a stand-alone building on the subject lands will not compromise the planned function of the commercial lands. The proposed building has been designed and is proposed to be located so that it completes `Main Street' and also providing enhanced elevations along Cotton Grass Street, and additional dwelling units in close proximity to the commercial uses will help to support nearby Page 8 of 164 restaurants, stores and services. The commercial plaza continues to include vacant commercial pads which could provide for additional commercial or mixed-use development allowing future intensification and infill opportunities. Urban Design Policies: The City's urban design policies are outlined in Section 11 of the City's OP. In the opinion of staff, the proposed development satisfies these policies including: Streetscape; Safety; Universal Design; and Site Design, Building Design, Massing and Scale. To address these policies, an Urban Design Brief was submitted and has been reviewed by City staff. The Urban Design Brief is acceptable and outlines the vision and principles guiding the site design and informs the proposed zoning regulations. Streetscape — The proposed building has been oriented with frontage onto "Main Street" of the Williamsburg Town Centre and Cotton Grass Street. The proposed building has been designed and is proposed to be located so that it completes `Main Street' with front doors facing the private road, new parallel parking, and landscaped areas which will help continue the private streetscape which was previously established near Max Becker Drive. The proposal also provides enhanced elevations along Cotton Grass Street, and new street trees and private landscaping will be implemented through the Site Plan process along property boundaries, including the interface with Max Becker Common. Safety — As with all developments that go through site plan approval, staff will ensure Crime Prevention through Environmental Design (CPTED) principles are achieved and that the site meets emergency services policies. Universal Design — The development will be designed to comply with Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act and the Ontario Building Code. Site Design, Building Design, Massing and Scale — The subject site is designed to have a building that will be developed at a scale that is compatible with the existing and planned surroundings. The 3.5 storey brick building has been designed to complement and continue the vision for a traditional `Main Street' and is in keeping with the architecture and scale of the condominium buildings recently constructed along Commonwealth Street (opposite Max Becker Green), and anticipated future medium rise residential developments north of Cotton Grass Street. Transportation Policies: The Official Plan supports an integrated transportation system which incorporates active transportation, allows for the movement of people and goods and promotes a vibrant, healthy community using land use designations and urban design initiatives that make a wide range of transportation choices viable. The subject lands are located in close proximity to several bus routes, include an Npress stop within about a 2 minute walk. The building has good access to cycling networks and is within walking distance of elementary schools. The location of the subject lands, in the context of the City's integrated transportation system, supports the proposal for residential development on the subject lands. Housing Policies: Section 4. 1.1 of the City's Official Plan contains policies with the primary objective to provide for an appropriate range, variety and mix of housing types and styles, densities, tenure and affordability to satisfy the varying housing needs of our community through all stages of life. The proposed development increases the range of 2 and 3 bedroom purpose-built rental units available in the city. The proposed development represents 'missing middle' housing that bridges the gap between low rise, low intensity dwellings, and high-rise towers. The 2 and 3 bedroom units will appeal to a variety of household needs and directly responds to the need for more affordable housing types and tenures during the current housing crisis. Page 9 of 164 Official Plan Conclusions The Official Plan Amendment application requests a Specific Policy Area be added to the subject lands to permit a standalone residential building with ground floor dwelling units. Based on the above -noted policies and planning analysis, staff is of the opinion that the proposed Official Plan Amendment represents good planning and recommends that the proposed Official Plan Amendment be approved in the form shown in Appendix "A". Proposed Zoning By-law Amendment: The subject lands are currently zoned `Neighbourhood Commercial Zone (C-2)' with Special Regulation Provision 356R which limits the maximum gross floor area of a single retail outlet. The applicant has requested a Zoning By-law Amendment to add a new Special Use Provision to permit a standalone multiple dwelling, and a new Special Regulation Provision to allow a reduced lot area, reduced setbacks and a reduced parking rate to the existing Neighbourhood Shopping Centre (C-2) Zone. In accordance with Regional comments staff recommend that a new Holding Provision be added to require the completing of a Noise Study. The proposed regulations and a brief explanation of the purpose are provided below. Proposed Special Use Provision 483U: to permit multiple dwelling The existing C-2 Zone permits a broad range of uses, including dwelling units in a mixed-use building. Staff is of the opinion that permitting a building to be used for 100% residential in the context of a mixed-use plaza will not compromise the planned function of the commercial plaza. While standalone, the multiple dwelling has been designed to complement and contribute to the private urban street, and residential uses will help to support surrounding commercial uses. This permission will only apply to the subject lands and the balance of the plaza will continue to allow for additional commercial development should commercial land needs increase overtime. Proposed Special Regulation Provision 787R Lot Area: The minimum lot area shall be 3400 m2 The C-2 Zone includes a minimum lot area regulation of 4000 m2. The purpose of this regulation is to provide a sufficient size for a commercial plaza. The subject lands are currently located on a lot having an area of about 14,185 m2. Development of the subject lands will be coordinated with the overall Williamsburg Town Centre, and the commercial pads and parcels are part of a Vacant Land Condo. The applicant anticipates that the commercial components of the subject block, which includes commercial Buildings 600 and 700 will also form part of the Vacant Land Condo. Should this occur, the subject parcel will form remnant lands falling outside the condominium and will legally be considered a separate parcel, while benefitting from access easements through the plaza. The proposed regulation ensures the parcel will be a legal size in the future. Future applications will be necessary with respect to the Vacant Land Condominium. Location of Dwelling Units: The dwelling units are permitted be located in a building not containing commercial uses and may be located on the ground floor. The existing C-2 Zone permits a broad range of uses, including dwelling units on upper floors of buildings also containing other permitted commercial uses. Staff is of the opinion that permitting ground floor residential in a standalone building on the subject lands will not compromise the planned function of the commercial plaza. The proposed building has been designed and is proposed to be located so that it completes `Main Street', while also providing Page 10 of 164 enhanced elevations along all facades. While Main Street is privately owned, it has been developed and planned comprehensively as a pedestrian focussed street and town centre, rather than as an auto -oriented commercial plaza driveway. The proposed multiple dwelling has an urban character and scale and will contribute to the look and feel of both `Main Street' while providing for a transition to future residential on the north side of Cotton Grass, and the existing park and residential uses to the west. Additional dwelling units in close proximity to the commercial uses will help to support nearby restaurants, stores and services, and are well located to access the existing public park, schools, trails and natural areas. The commercial plaza continues to include vacant pads which could provide for additional commercial, office or mixed commercial/residential development in the future. Setbacks: a) The minimum setback to Cotton Grass Street shall be 1.95 metres. b) A porch attached to a multiple dwelling shall be set back a minimum of 0.9 metres from Cotton Grass Street, whether or not covered, provided it is not enclosed. c) An architectural screening feature may project up to 0.6 m from the dwelling or porch. Planning and Transportation Planning staff are of the opinion that a reduced setback to Cotton Grass Street for the building and porch are appropriate. The reduced setback is being requested due to the atypical property line associated with the roundabout's right-of-way. The design of the roadway ensures visibility for vehicle, cyclist and pedestrian movements on the road and on sidewalks. The building has been designed to appropriately address the streets and intersection, and sufficient space remains for landscaping. The proposed architectural screening feature projection will help to screen gas meters from public view. The utilities have been dispersed around the building and screening will be required through the detailed Site Plan review process. Figure 3 — Conceptual Site Plan (February 2023, 4 Architecture Inc.) Page 11 of 164 'v1G;IN STREET" rn,wxm rn .�,u w� - "I( 2wzrar Torr �r �,J ,✓/ 'Lwint1srt'.uVn�f Ln d­p.d Lmndvcarymd Lcndaropsrd Lond scapad � HEIH ` /r7lBAC r , BUIL INta8DO TO -BACK 'STACKED TOWNHO E 5 E 3V4 "aWeauarn fGl£ F.� W19TaM{s(tI'q L4,Lc i A ♦ � ♦ r � � '�L Vs"Su! 'Ye 01rt 1ft ♦'� .. rnernha Lrd—wr wTG I6i 2U.xwNIT..S uer ¢3,r2r� ,.. n 'zmnM rupa ^�Tt/I' 'urG�' Er �r"eE\a,,`, Lk LL F; fJ �v .;..,,♦ d) ITE �„d�ud,i�,e,n4 w� — FlE;3 r.m,r a wr�ux wa;r� ax�rr.oria. 01 us n — — EXISTING' PUL?LIC; PAPK Figure 3 — Conceptual Site Plan (February 2023, 4 Architecture Inc.) Page 11 of 164 Parking Rate: a) That parking be provided at a minimum rate of 1.5 parking spaces per dwelling unit. b) That visitor parking be provided at a rate of 15% of required parking c) Class A bicycle parking for a multiple dwelling shall be provided at a rate of 0.5 stalls per dwelling unit and 6 Class B bicycle parking spaces shall be for a multiple dwelling. d) That a minimum of 20 percent of the parking spaces shall be designed to permit the future installation of electric vehicle supply equipment. The purpose of this regulation is to provide for a parking rate which is appropriate for the development. The proposed ratio results in a requirement of 48 parking spaces overall and 7 parking spaces being reserved for visitors. The applicant is providing 51 parking spaces, which includes 48 parking spaces in the parking lot, and 3 short-term parallel parking spaces along `Main Street'. The subject lands have good access to public transit and pedestrian/cycling networks and secure, weather protected bike storage will be provided within the development for residents. Further, the applicant has indicated that they intend to provide unbundled parking, and that there is an existing car share vehicle located in the Williamsburg Town Centre. Staff also note that the proposed number of parking spaces exceeds the maximum parking ratio of 1.4 parking spaces per dwelling unit permitted by By-law 2019-051. While the new ratio is in effect in many areas of the City, the subject lands continue to be zoned under Zoning By-law 85-1 and have not been incorporated into Zoning By-law 2015-051 yet. Planning and Transportation Services staff is of the opinion that the proposed parking rate of 1.5 parking spaces per dwelling unit will meet parking demands for the subject site. In addition to the foregoing, staff also recommend that new bicycle parking and electric vehicle parking requirements be added to the special regulation so that parking aligns with the regulations of By-law 2019-051. In addition to the regulations, definitions of Class A and Class B bicycle parking are provided. These definitions are consistent with those contained in By-law 2019-051. Prohibition of Geothermal System: The Region of Waterloo has requested that a zoning regulation be added to prohibit geothermal energy systems due to the sensitivity of ground water. Holding Provision 99H: Official Plan policies require that holding provisions will be applied in those situations where it is necessary or desirable to zone lands for development or redevelopment in advance of the fulfillment of specific requirements and conditions, and where the details of the development or redevelopment have not yet been fully resolved. The City will enact a by-law to remove the holding symbol when all the conditions set out in the holding provision have been satisfied, permitting development or redevelopment in accordance with the zoning category assigned. In accordance with Regional comments, Planning staff are recommending the following Holding Provision as part of the Zoning By-law Amendment: "No residential use shall be permitted until such time as a Road Traffic and Stationary Noise Study is submitted and approved to the satisfaction of the Regional Commissioner of Planning, Development and Legislative Services, if necessary. This Holding Provision shall not be removed until the City of Kitchener is in receipt of a letter from the Regional Commissioner of Planning, Development and Legislative Services advising that such noise study or studies has been approved and an agreement, if necessary, has been entered into with the City and/or Region, as necessary, providing for the implementation of any recommended noise mitigation measures." Page 12 of 164 Proposed Zoning By-law Amendment Conclusions Staff is of the opinion that the proposed Zoning By-law Amendment to change the zoning of the subject lands to `Neighbourhood Commercial Zone (C-2) with Special Regulation Provision 356R, Special Regulation Provision 787R and Special Use Provision 483U and Holding Provision 99H' represents good planning as it will facilitate the redevelopment of the lands with a multiple dwelling that is compatible with the existing neighbourhood, which will add visual interest at the street level, provide enhanced landscaping that will contribute to the streetscape, and which will appropriately accommodate on-site parking needs. Staff are supportive of the proposed development and recommend that the proposed Zoning By-law amendment be approved as shown in Appendix "A". Department and Agency Comments: Circulation of the Official Plan Amendment and Zoning By-law Amendment was undertaken in December 2022 to all applicable City departments and other review authorities. No major concerns were identified by any commenting City department or agency and any necessary revisions and updates were made. Copies of the comments are found in Appendix "D" of this report. The following Reports and Studies were considered as part of these proposed Official Plan and Zoning By-law Amendment Applications: Planning Justification Report and Addendum • Prepared by: GSP Group Inc., November 2022 (updated February 2023) Urban Design Report and Addendum • Prepared by: GSP Group Inc. and 4 Architecture Inc, November 2022 (updated February 2023) Conceptual Site Plan • Prepared by 4 Architecture Inc., September 2022 (updated February 2023) Elevations & Floor Plans • prepared by 4 Architecture Inc., October 2022 (updated February 2023) Existing Conditions Plan • prepared by MTE Consultants Inc., September 2022 (updated February 2023) Preliminary Grading Plan • prepared by MTE Consultants Inc., September 2022 (updated February 2023) Functional Servicing and Stormwater Management Report & Plan • prepared by MTE Consultants Inc.,October 5, 2022 (updated November 2022 and February 2023) Salt Management Plan • prepared by MTE Consultants Inc., November 29, 2022 Noise Feasibility Study • prepared by HGC Engineering, February 23, 2023 Risk Management Plan, Section 59 Notice of SPP Compliance and Section 58 Notice of Agreement • prepared by the Region of Waterloo, November 29, 2022 Page 13 of 164 Sustainability Checklist • prepared by Schlegel Urban Developments Corp., November 28, 2022 Community Input & Staff Responses 504 households (occupants and property owners) were circulated and notified Approximately 9 people/households provided comments A City -led Neighbourhood Meeting was held on January 31, 2023 and approximately 9 different users togged on Staff received written responses from 9 people/households with respect to the proposed development. These are included in Appendix `E'. A Neighbourhood Meeting was held on January 31, 2023. In addition, staff had follow-up one-on-one correspondence with members of the public. A summary of what we heard, and staff responses are noted below. What We Heard Staff Comment Loss of open space and The subject applications affect vacant commercial lands which are parkland located next to Max Becker Commons. In accordance with the City's vacant land requirements, the developer has seeded and maintained the vacant lands for the past 20 years. While the parcel of land may be interpreted as an extension of the park it is privately owned and has been planned and zoned for development since 2002. Increases to traffic The subject lands have been comprehensively planned and zoned for a range of uses including residential, commercial, office and service uses. Roads and intersections including Cotton Grass Street, Max Becker Drive and Commonwealth Street have been designed to accommodate traffic generated by the Williamsburg Town Centre. Transportation Services staff are of the opinion that the level of traffic generated by residential uses will likely generate less or a similar amount of traffic as commercial uses. Residents also questioned whether lights might be added to the intersection of Cotton Grass Street and Fischer Hallman Road. This is a regional intersection and at this time the Region does not have plans to install a traffic light at this intersection. Concern with on -street Transportation staff comment that on -street parking is available parking on local roads equally to the general public, however is limited to a maximum Page 14 of 164 Page 15 of 164 length of 3 hours. Parking is available on many local roads in the area, however, is restricted along park frontages. In addition, several new parallel parking spaces will be added to `Main Street', which will provide for short-term parking, delivery and drop-offs and visitor parking. The subject lands are somewhat separate from the surrounding neighbourhood, and Transportation Services staff do not expect that there will be a significant impact to on -street parking on nearby local streets as a result of this proposal. Concern with proposed The proposed parking ratio of the subject lands is in keeping with parking reduction the parking study completed in support of the parking rates contained in Zoning By-law 2019-051. This Zoning By-law is being applied in phases across the City however has not yet been applied to the subject lands. The Zoning By-law recommends a minimum of 1 parking space per dwelling unit with a visitor parking rate of 0.1 parking spaces per dwelling unit, to a maximum of 1.4 parking spaces per dwelling unit (inclusive of visitor spaces). The applicant is proposing a rate of 1.5 parking spaces per dwelling unit with 15% reserved for visitors. This rate exceeds the maximum permitted by the new Zoning By-law, and staff is of the opinion that the proposed rate is sufficient. The subject lands are also walkable with convenient access to shopping, banks, restaurants, services, parks, schools and community facilities. The lands are within 200 m of several bus routes, including an Xpress Route, and there is an existing Car Share parking stall and vehicle available in the Williamsburg Town Centre. Further, the applicant is proposing to utilize Transportation Demand Management techniques including unbundled parking for residents and provision of secure and weather protected bike storage. Interface between the A number of residents raised concerns with the proximity of the parking lot and Max proposed parking lot to Max Becker Common from both an Becker Common aesthetic and safety perspective. Through the review process, the applicant has agreed to update the site design to include additional space between the parking lot and the edge of the park so that a landscaped strip and a fence/physical barrier can be installed. The applicant is proposing a decorative style fence that provides for a positive esthetic along the park boundary, while also providing physical separation and safety. This treatment will be continued along the entire park frontage, including both the parking for the townhouses, as well as the previously approved parking lot for the commercial buildings. In addition, the applicant has agreed to work with staff to incorporate additional trees and plantings into the park where possible. Staff notes that there is a large gas main which is located beneath the park, which may restrict plantings in some areas, however effort will be made to locate trees wherever possible. Residents also suggested flipping the parking so that it was located adjacent to Main Street so that buildings were located Page 15 of 164 Page 16 of 164 adjacent to the park. While `Main Street' is privately owned and operated, it has been a long time vision for Williamsburg Town Centre to create a walkable, urban style street as a focus for the community. The subject proposal, along with the approved office building (Building 700) will help to complete the west side of Main Street. While privately owned and managed, this neo -urban street contributes to the community, by creating a community hub that provides sense of place that is unique. Staff is of the opinion that providing appropriate a landscaped buffer together with a fence will provide appropriate screening and physical separation between the parking lots and Max Becker Common. Proximity of driveway to Concerns were identified with respect to the proximity of the roundabout driveway to the Cotton Grass St roundabout. Transportation Services staff has reviewed the proposed driveway location and is of the opinion that it is sufficiently setback from the roundabout for safe traffic movements and visibility. Plans for Community Staff received questions about future plans for a community Garden garden in Max Becker Green. Staff of the Neighbourhood Development Office are currently in the early stages of neighbourhood engagement and planning for a community garden in this park. This project may be completed within the next 1 — 2 years if there is sufficient community interest. Site Design - garbage Concerns were raised with the location of the deep well garbage system in proximity to the park. Deep well systems are designed to be minimally intrusive. Waste is stored below grade so that odour is minimized and containers are secure and esthetically appealing. Staff is of the opinion that the proposed deep well system is appropriately located. Integration of residential Concerns were identified with the introduction of residential uses uses into a commercial into a commercial plaza. Staff note that dwelling units are already area permitted within the existing zoning and designation, however, are currently restricted to upper storeys. Residential uses are compatible with commercial, office and service uses and integration on a site, or within a building is supported. In fact, establishing a mix of uses is encouraged in many areas including Mixed Use Nodes and Corridors throughout the City. The nature of the subject applications is to permit ground floor residential units and units in a standalone building. As previously discussed, the proposed multiple dwelling has an urban character and scale and will contribute to the look and feel of both `Main Street' while providing for a transition to future residential on the north side of Cotton Grass Street, and the existing park and residential uses to the west. The commercial plaza continues to include vacant pads which could provide for additional commercial, office or mixed commercial/residential development in the future. Page 16 of 164 Planning Conclusions In considering the foregoing, staff are supportive of the proposed Official Plan Amendment and Zoning By-law Amendment to permit 265 Cotton Grass Street to be developed with a standalone multiple dwelling. Staff is of the opinion that the subject applications are consistent with policies of the Provincial Policy Statement, conform to Growth Plan for the Greater Golden Horseshoe, the Regional Official Plan, and the City of Kitchener Official Plan and represent good planning. It is recommended that the applications be approved. STRATEGIC PLAN ALIGNMENT: The recommendation of this report supports the achievement of the City's strategic vision through the delivery of core service. FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS: Capital Budget — The recommendation has no impact on the Capital Budget. Operating Budget — The recommendation has no impact on the Operating Budget. COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT: INFORM — This report has been posted to the City's website with the agenda in advance of the Council / Committee meeting. A large notice sign was posted on the property and information regarding the application was posted to the City's website in December 2022. Following the initial circulation referenced below, an additional postcard advising of the statutory public meeting was circulated to all residents and property owners within 240 metres of the subject lands, those responding to the preliminary circulation and who attended the Neighbourhood Meetings. Notice of the Statutory Public Meeting was also posted in The Record on March 10, 2023 (a copy of the Notice may be found in Appendix C). CONSULT — The proposed Official Plan Amendment and Zoning By-law Amendment were circulated to residents and property owners within 240 metres of the subject lands on December 16, 2022. In response to this circulation, staff received written responses from 9 people/households, which were summarized as part of this staff report and are appended in Appendix E. Planning staff also had one-on-one conversations with residents on the telephone and responded to emails. PREVIOUS REPORTS/AUTHORITIES: • Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.13 • Growth Plan, 2020 • Provincial Policy Statement, 2020 • Region of Waterloo Official Plan • City of Kitchener Official Plan, 2014 • City of Kitchener Zoning By-law 85-1 REVIEWED BY: Malone -Wright, Tina— Interim Manager of Development Review, Planning Division APPROVED BY: Readman, Justin - General Manager, Development Services ATTACHMENTS: Attachment A — Proposed Official Plan Amendment Attachment B — Proposed Zoning By-law Amendment Attachment C — Newspaper Notice Attachment D — Department and Agency Comments Page 17 of 164 Attachment E — Community Comments Page 18 of 164 Z a (n Y u Y a �n Q UC N w d W (1) _0 @ W u, ¢ Q L •� o U W Q Q -C 3 >1 a N `-' o N N z =JOS V d H U c ° m N O N Q CO z _HJ�J Yawa Cha aC7 N L Q �V o a o ° cn U W Gi W wcn d -0 N Cp Z V W aN 4? E a Q �� Z W V a �' o Q w Q Q Z a Q J > �� CO F- �W g 0LU U z V o LL Z w O o Z J W Y CO O w (fl 0 0 LO M N Rp E 0 C14W ESTMpUNT � o ri F o 0 = LO 0� Q C:)Q - F- U) U o Z Oa0 H d U) 0� co Q O W Q LV (D J J Z D UW Z O s LJJ U) 0 �sb Z o (V/' Q > 0 U �p U W LO a N Q PROPOSED BY — LAW 2023 BY-LAW NUMBER OF THE CORPORATION OF THE CITY OF KITCHENER (Being a by-law to amend By-law 85-1, as amended, known as the Zoning By-law for the City of Kitchener — Schlegel Urban Developments Corp. — 265 Cotton Grass Street) WHEREAS it is deemed expedient to amend By-law 85-1 for the lands specified above; NOW THEREFORE the Council of the Corporation of the City of Kitchener enacts as follows: 1. Schedule Number 66 of Appendix "A" to By-law Number 85-1 is hereby amended by changing the zoning applicable to the parcel of land specified and illustrated as Area 1 on Map No. 1, in the City of Kitchener, attached hereto, from Neighbourhood Shopping Centre Zone (C-2) with Special Regulation Provision 356R to Neighbourhood Shopping Centre Zone (C-2) with Special Regulation Provision 356R and Special Use Provision 483U, Special Regulation Provision 787R, and Holding Provision 99H. 2. Schedule Number 66 of Appendix "A" to By-law Number 85-1 is hereby further amended by incorporating additional zone boundaries as shown on Map No. 1 attached hereto. 3. Appendix "C" to By-law 85-1 is hereby amended by adding Section 483U thereto as follows: "483. Notwithstanding Sections 8.2 of this By-law, within the lands zoned Neighbourhood Shopping Centre Zone (C-2), shown as affected by this subsection, on Schedule 66 of Appendix "A", a Multiple Dwelling shall be permitted." 4. Appendix "D" to By-law 85-1 is hereby amended by adding Section 787R thereto as follows: 787 i. Notwithstanding Sections 5.6 and 8.2 of this By-law, within the lands zoned Neighbourhood Shopping Centre Zone (C-2), shown as affected by this Page 20 of 164 subsection, on Schedule 66 of Appendix "A", a Multiple Dwelling shall be permitted in accordance with the following: a. The minimum lot area shall be 3,400 metres squared. b. Dwelling units are permitted to be located in a building not containing commercial uses, and may be located on the ground floor. C. The minimum setback to Cotton Grass Street shall be 1.95 metres. d. A porch attached to a multiple dwelling shall be set back a minimum of 0.9 metres from Cotton Grass Street, whether or not covered, provided it is not enclosed. e. An architectural screening feature may project up to 0.6 metres from the dwelling or porch into a required yard abutting a street. ii. Notwithstanding Sections 6.1.2a) of this By-law, within the lands zoned Neighbourhood Shopping Centre Zone (C-2), shown as affected by this subsection, on Schedule 66 of Appendix "A" the following off-street parking regulations shall apply: Use Minimum Off -Street Parking Spaces Class B Bicycle Stall Required Multiple Dwelling 1.5 spaces per unit Visitor 15% of required parking iii. The following minimum bicycle parking requirements shall apply: Use Class A Bicycle Stall Class B Bicycle Stall Multiple Dwelling 0.5 per unit without a 6 private garage iv. A minimum of 20 percent of the parking spaces required for multiple dwellings shall be designed to permit the future installation of electric vehicle supply equipment. V. For the purpose of regulation iii. above, a Class A Bicycle Stall shall be a bicycle space which is either in a building or structure or within a secure area such as a supervised parking lot or enclosure with a secure entrance or within a bicycle locker. Page 21 of 164 vi. For the purpose of regulation iii. above, a Class B Bicycle Stall shall be a bicycle space which is located in accessible and highly visible locations near the entrance of a building and are accessible to the general public. vii. Geothermal Energy Systems shall be prohibited." 5. Appendix "F" to By-law 85-1 is hereby amended by adding Section 99H thereto as follows: 1199. Notwithstanding Section 8 of this Bylaw, within the lands zoned C-2 and shown as being affected by this Subsection on Schedule Number 66 of Appendix "A": i) No residential use shall be permitted until such time as a Road Traffic, and Stationary Noise Study is submitted and approved to the satisfaction of the Regional Commissioner of Planning, Housing and Community Services, if necessary. This Holding Provision shall not be removed until the City of Kitchener is in receipt of a letter from the Regional Commissioner of Planning, Housing and Community Services advising that such noise study or studies has been approved and an agreement, if necessary, has been entered into with the City and/or Region, as necessary, providing for the implementation of any recommended noise mitigation measures." 6. This By-law shall become effective only if Official Plan Amendment No. _, (265 Cotton Grass Street) comes into effect, pursuant to Section 24(2) of The Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.13, as amended. PASSED at the Council Chambers in the City of Kitchener this day of 2023. Mayor Clerk Page 22 of 164 a LU LU Z w �i Z Mw MM O O iu Y -a W Z� ZZ H F— N LLmE U 0Z 00 w j X Z N z jU LU j -m U w > > ¢ m a O (7 O> w C� U)} O Q QIN z LL W O 1 adz= d 0 Q Q Z °' d -i U coo U) za zzo°' O ¢ w w-- F- 0 Q Q U Y 0 p0= OODZ =w U) U (> W W W (n J IN \ U _ Q 0 Q 0 a J of O w ~ (.D U U Of Z m 0 ��J Z_ (/1 = 7 0 7 Z a-� 0 W w W W w W ( O � O Z Q m W WLU U) OfC7w = UOf�to ofo Z J ? N z W O 0 �� T��a Co �� a w w �oQZ W o N N ¢ Q ~ m QO QQQZ -0 Q w� z >X � �OZXO 0 m Q La H W ON W 2N W UU0 00= E 00 N F- d> O�Zw N N a �Z w D�zU��U�da-0 �� Z 0 C9pdw zQ�w=wW=tnu�z Q LU Q Q -w CV V� C0 wW a= Z H H m W WOzF- 000 JNZ J UZ Of In U w Z2¢U "i"�u� W Z cr0-00It: zzz 0 }=Ow W W W OUw� W (�a U) QQW N�F—NmU �¢¢Q N U m ZN O d N(nOY Q C }'Q 1 \ G ■� =1111111 III ' O� W 0 N O IIII IIIIIIIII 1IVpIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIVVVVIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII V V �P� C w IIIIIIIf.V G C � M VVIVpIVI Q G � � O W NIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII Q U IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII ml Q Z lel J Q LU jl j IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII co tL0 �! m a 0- 111,1111111 WIW M V O N � I M � 1 I J I 22 III I � w U U I I 1 III I Q 111111111puuuu�uull1a3H III E 37l1a3H 9 37na3HaS 1 O3H5S "' Z U 0 1- N puuuuuuuuuuuuuul78"uu_1 Z LL LL � o III 1° � IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII ON O � 1 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IVpIIIIIIVVVIIIIIIIIIIIIIII M 1 III (IDN toIIII I IIIIII1 M IIIII� = IIIIIIIII I V 04 J' plplplplplplpppp v o N C) WIW Vuuuuuuuu N T Z W M � IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 1 U U COW) o N O11,111,111111111111 Cl) LO= 1 tD� W CD O U Q (n 2 LU Q II 1 O uuuumuuullllluumuuuuuuuuuuuu II "• 1 Ji J W ..,...1111111 III __ . Ipl�luuuuuu i"""�S, "�i"."�"�",t'S'ar'�4r�""t° "� S S� " � '"1IIIIIIIIIII (� Q ir'�,t � IIIIIIII , U) Q LU ""yi,"r "� "� ;Gr r"ray"� �r''i" „" IIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIII � �P " it 1 "� � � 111111111111111111111111 Z W Iu"rc ;c"r' S " jiei" It " t, 44"i,���Sr"'�S"�""'ii U� i "i, 'i , ��" ,�" " ,t�"ui""I�"'rl"""r"i" O (A 5ui;, " S, a,� "y��"�� "i" �,", "� "�" ti r 1 J , "i' M Si 7"; M D C)0 Z bt ,"";�'"� ��^�,' ",'"� Z tif" 4 ," ri"�" " `u ""bt (A Q V O , r � m ro �;``,"``"",�� � ��"(;�";;j"�,,""1/ v WLO 1 "Sri"jj �rr�,y"i, ,,, U ;",i�?;gi",4;"�i 1 U) NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING � for a development in your neighbourhood 265 Cotton Grass Street I TCT 11,"NER Have Your Voice Heard! Concept Drawing Date: April 3, 2023 Time: 7:00 p.m. Location: Council Marn eirs,, Kitchener City Hall 200, King Street West orVirtual Zoom Meeting To view the staff report, agenda, meeting details, start time of this item or to appear as a delegation, visit: kitchener.ca/meetings To learn more about this project, including information on your appeal rights, visit: www.kitchenenca/ Plan n i ngAppl ications or contact: 32 I..Ji i.. ii t 3.5 S i. s Katie Anderl, Senior Planner S a 111<ed Spaces 519.741.2200 x 7987 0W i IIL q �.. � �t katie.anderI@kitchener.ca The City of Kitchener will consider applications to amend the Official Plan and Zoning By-law to permit the property at 265 Cotton Grass Street to be developed with a standalone multiple residential building with a reduced front yard setback and a parking rate of 1.5 spaces per dwelling unit. The applicant is proposing a 32 -unit, 3.5 storey stacked townhouse development. Page 24 of 164 W T C O co N N N O N T N 7 >, 3 V) C l0 _ }+ U 0 v ai '^ N ry co 'ai O ro T •N v s o Q ate-+ O +' t 3 T O p 3 tB ro 3 +� o v s v nn o env = -0 � v O v co n Q o CM o o m t +, c a o v �[ p m to an s v 3 c C p to _ Ln LA N-0 Ln l6 by N •U 41 N O N L L7 0ca N +� In N +, v T —_ p �_ •� O O rz � to 4J C_ In Zn Y a1 ++Ln ' f6 N ++ — N _ U U C In U (6 T Q- O +' +� V)++ Q 4 1 C O O EO > N U C L1 ~ U p X O v N *' L 'L N Q Q CL OJ _ oiL '� VI �-d Q tw L E W � O C n Qj Q �--� v >` L N v .� O Qj .� a b0 0 of p N t6 C ?) +� Q 07 N C I�l E V L c ' '� v E c to n — c +� � o L I a, « C al+ O N v U� p N p t }' �� T E O L +� A `�ro L t N O s U - � -p T �O ,� O � N C to t to O p O p N }, T C L+J T N E N p pci Oto C to tLv CCA 2 qp M O �n .`^ O �, _ CW *' O N t N U C O � C f0 T U C N -S- C YO V) �+ w ao L is �' v Q E �° - o U CL Lj 4t; (o L C 'vi,� L O L C to N of toCL lD L ra Qj a"' O *' +, +, v-0 N v v 0 y O ++ tvp C p C -C v oaA = + 3 m +'Ln (uN N co O C — -6 t T +, co NCL " L N U C N MO -0 f0 l% +� ++ +� m (0 5 N U UA L1 -C N C 3 �O U Y E O XGJ N E �' +' Q >- p L +' bp..0 m j +, N p U a•• U1 E 0 ++ C Laj L O M S .c C •VI In _ C U O W m > O M — �-•i 41 aj cr-L f6 f6 > > 0 +' m C N� L O C O CU c6 � a1 C - >„ E O ,-C W L T C L Q Q U r6 _ T �n E �O ++ `^ O >. f6 N +, 41 �J Q O X N 7 bA p c U N v� C N r6 @ co +, r6 i -O C ra — O .0 C E v N > `L O D i-, ) L O vi O N > +•• L N +, N v •� E to -a 7 N ca N E p- Q T 3 O =� N ?� N E o v E U a Y v E +�' > C to E m v> to N N dA O O c c O c6 Y O In U U m m m \ \ \ m m N a) 0 0 m N N N O O O LM In 72 U1 N > C C cu Q 0 (15 0 06 N N N C C c N U1 C C C 41 E f6 N m N m 'C N Z Ln Ln Ln 0 W It 7- 4- 0 N N co 0- O a U Vi Qj c Q U a r0 c a••O a L a3 f6 � v)� a o o LL CL u 06 C4 E Z *' p 0 O_ a N v a c a a E cB 3 r6 pc bA a a --i U L r6 — O O c U ° 3 H c ++ `.� rti • O ' o °1 D o s v) +� U a a ani Ln o a +� o Q 3 u L 3� 3 a 0 0 �' ° a L a 0 O CL p O n c a f° O c a v 0 a-0 a 0 bA a o N> ao� O v L O T 3 a •� L C Q L M1• O U ++ Q- t +-' aj Q bA a p a t N a v t +� Q Q >, +� a ++ p a L a a C E tts +� c a a L O O c +� o - « tin a L E a a« ro n u0 a o 0 saW o L L o un o a a ai 3 c W O a a O 1 Lai -6 ° V=5 o o a�a u a a -apa }' ) ce aj U> N r0 ++ c a N a � C (IJ a 0 O U E (� u +' a_ ° a o a a o a a ao 5, M c 3 >, - u ,� W - a o c as -0 a v 3 c a ci In a a o a °1 ° > a) Ln co o v 5° o ro 3° E> L o° v t — -O M o '� v 3 c t M ++ a o T O �O L M O L a E H 0 c O a - U L— a a c a a '� w E a 3— - a a 3 > Q E ns U u o a +� ai - o �' +� o '5 In - a 3 c o rot o n E° o- 3 v t a Q a a m o *' p o o a� m o 3 a M1• +� t c Q +' ° ° Q Ln a Y o ° a a Z)° o O o Ln +� a°, ro c c a + c c 3 m a o o= M u°° v v 'v a v u 0 O x C *' a s -O a O ,� p L Ln c a a Q L '� c c O +� r j Ln w .c 3 N a+ c L ' b.0 a t p a +� O T c c L O c L a m .� a -O v a E O ro L tko c } a n a M a �° c L W O L V O a c 0 -° L i 0 ro c T� U O O a a ° ai O O 2 . _c aj a c 3 ra +� Q C L O CU u.) c E a +� > ro O O> a O O > T C: m wa-+ Q Ln c O O O L -0 L L +' bD r0 O N (6 a M v a U +� U ro Q c E O —� a C 7 a ra cu � L ro O 3 0 a X C a Q +� L t v m 0 GD 1]O +' V) vi c c u +, p p CO O fl- > n 3 C O a a 'a Q- C a N 'O rn c bo +-' t 7 O T a c O N (6 a a L a -O Mo v) O U pp s -6 ro C c O ca a `n Q t > O C i c0 O .� LO ?� a v M u u ~ •� v a L L a o L M1, ate-+ a s 3 a Q a; n, Q a a ° a � p Q U a O M L _T — a qa w L a C Q ° C U Q (n V p_ L L T Q i c (9 (n qj a +�.+ •� a a p U a c L In OA C a' vi c a a M n V t E c 1 c �� O_ � a ut vai -6 Q to 'C >" c ,} a tO E •� 7 '—n c Q L) >, H 'ra c!i L O Q>� C— 'cn O >' to N ro L i *' � cn a M O U Q L H U Q Y �--I to N Q .� Q a a 0 Q M -O u a . L L Q C a L O a L to O p c 0 LL ++ 3 ut Q 3 +, M N W O c -I O In a D a c C 14 N N It 7- 4- 0 N N co 0- W v c_ O -a , V)+ — +� > CLO > •3 v an 'O °n cpv O N v @ - N) 0 : c L Cl a1 an N + t 7 t6 p (� N i O L � � � a) vp Vf CaU w � � L C VI +, p c O W p L7 > v +, L2 w c ro 'L +, O a aJ •> bA c6 O— _ O wCL C: c t p O c ra t Q O •>1 p .*- O 0 C o ;� N U p I a, +� o o 'c 'v, O `° +, O 3 3 v c E 3 a� [ v O +� — ami ao c Q o •� o O Q v v t E �, v > v� v O °° a_ 0 L !' 0 w — nn t u o 0- Ln 0 ,,, E O N O c p O 4-; -O O 0 0 >� +' *' O dA `~ `n E N � W N O E O 0 s O� -p O > � s bA L 7 +- ca ++ N � _ O u� 3 c + 3 a� a� v (a a) v an ns N i Q O +' E Q O o -r W +� c c O a -0 ++ +� to L C7 +-' E c c +� > 00 L ++ c a v wo 0� a 0 aaj ° u ai t c Q E — OL '� v a� m (a p v n3 C:> ate-+ L v E c o U aJ (a T (D E aJ al O v co O y p O aJ O N> i co 7 oE +� co O ra -O O a1 O O O v O O N N O E E co ++ dA E p Q) v) v E c+ O c v .� `L° a� N 'O v aJ to aL+to +' p E a) a1 p p v p v tiA E o E v p t E v a v O c ra cpp m OcaE-- cO -6 `tL~ a) 0W >' u�Eco O a O r O o v v �L0 O U Q a +v a O Q) c -0 mO CL Qi Q O L m O m r.. >t1 O c O +OMO u LO 3u6 C) p O O� O O m c c 0 E Q) 3 a3 � v v m o U o° E 3 _ n L _UO L OL i N _ O • a1 �O a1 Q O> in c 2 N a O _ O -he a 3 v~ ` a — E O = p E c cu°� s O C v O O m Q ca N N O +� v +� >- +-� 4A ut t }' 6 0 LL I]a tlA }' + r6 CL m E � C Oa ++ i O 7 L -6 l6 C L >- (6 O U a-+ O O U Q 3 O Y L a1 U Q L aL-O — ra Q >i O _ .� aj LA b0 O c t C Y E c 7 O >v • a) UV as -p .2aJ 0 N3 c O -o c c v 0,0 c O E 0)0 aci > �o 0 t sEv v Ln OE o tvL ° vc ut ,� L O >-in t Q Q N N ++ i.i c c 1 v) EL 0)ao c E *' O s a dA E v in v i O O N c v v O H in Q ate-+ `� 2 O O LA ab 0aL+ i.� i.� Q O 3 Q vii Q E m N a) O N O v ai v C C L O U Q) m L QJ 0 +' Q) o v W T E S O N '> co — " — E `6 ° m o v Q) W v a-0 Q ._ S H s O -0 "6 a) (n 0 c m L 3 3 7 L S O o 0 L Q) 0 o w c 3 N 6 Oa o + L O V OLV fL6 T'0 1-- N Q p o m v Q -0 - Q_ v no l6 v, O_ f6 V1 a1 V Q) 7 .0 S 3 c> m c S bD 0 a1 m v a) co +� c c NE E o N Oai N bD m m aj S S C E >- Q .--I p T j trs a1 T m -C a) Z, O v v U f9 0 V, a1 O� 00 w 3 v a c � -0 Ec w a) 0 Q) — N m Q •— c > aJ O U Q) o to -0 0 i N c c p Q) p m ° p O Ln am a) N C 0 O S N Q) O Q) Q) +' E E ca -0 p Q O_ c bp c r v a� Z E E j5g c >> m N — ro v () a) (U L m 7 .0 CI -0 U — -0 S L b4 c m a) O m v, 0 -0 �, O U ate-+ ,� N +� L 0au a) v s S S D w m E° CL m GA 7 bo w O 7 '^V) c }) C L -0L m 0 w w a) m �n aci -I-- o t an N 0 CL o OJ v m > o > L Q s Es M o m = � ma 3 O L c f0 o aXi Q) c OOD .3 ' v a� c ° v Q) a v v ca > O v O_ Ecn Eus w m N m O N O a� o C o c a, E ObD aS-+ 'W L 3 Q a -0 Cl m> aH O 3 o ai m CU a v E N N L �••' m VI L ^ Q co yQ., S Y U N T X _0 "a C: `+° =-0 c 3 u o v, L O +� E O ° v s ° a) +' v E t ,J +, v 3 0 ° Sr 3 v 03 0_ .0 fl_ O SIn O L a) L O O 1 +� o N rou Oy CLO U O L `..' c ++=-+ •c N ate+ -a m e ai E v t ar bA CL 0*+ a Ep+ m c +- � 0—+� S Qv �— > > L o -0 L_ ai t 0- 0--a0)O 0 Q)4• a) L c O a) v) a1 i U m N (6 L CO p+••� co yL., Q w O O c E c o 3 n> t> co v > 0 C t Qi += O (a S CL O a1 4t m .L Q_ E i >• O + _° + � aJ Q) v> E� V) c L Cl v Q O m O O *' N m* o ta0 c E m v E v m mi °J 3 E •5 -0 S .N N a n o bn .° O S ca -0 S S O > }, X 0 Y T bA v m � M1• f6 ' 3 0 _v 3 ar In O v, OL a-+ 0 O L Q Q (U Q W +� = Q_ +� p S Z *_ O 0 v S '+, U v EC -'W bA ++ O (6 ul N +� E E° L c° m E 00 c ro s a) c -0 t o > aUi *' T V) E ° v O L o v, o n a c c> c c O v tM O N N m m S c O c CL = ^ i 3 a bo �_ 3 v -0 � La'a c +' -a 3 -0 t � Ln 3 °u � Q 3 t o ° +� *) � �° C) O Q) T T m N fD V) •+� +•• 7 -O c a) o o o > C m J c .� L ++ -0 o 2 • v ° +; a) o .c ^m O m — ° E O N > S U 3 M O O M -0 m -0 a) 3 W E S o — 6 Q! (A_ m S m bA v r o fl_ 0 L �~ L '>-° 0 Ln p +� O — c O M a) O0 u r6 U' S 0° O E} c O S a) S to a) .� 0 O is 0 E O E 4) �O O U •�, 0 a) -° -0 v 3 w a) ° m v O bbn L C M S — (6 > N i v U U A V, i . ° v S 3 ro UN ++ •� Q ra N O ) 0 *' p > > 'v, 7 O O 4; pE S cv N ^T S L 0 O S v C: c Q) M bo `� S -0 (O S -0c Q) >; a.., o — 0 c •v E (O to 7.> C Q) _T -0 O -0 Q) O -0 C: -a U O Q Y a) C) "6 N ) c am Q 0 + o p O_ SOA N -0 cv 3 L O c> m a) O '0 U 7 bo — . O c O v 0 a) U N bn o E 3 c S m ram m a) bo E U t t — � O E Q L E N S T Cc: c�a Q L c m _0 > Ln QQ ° Ln C . 3 c °1 v °1 0- m c E m z) o .Q .3 3 c v v O CM v •> 0--o a In -S--° o 3 OIn m bA c w c m a, (n 3 O o boo o a.,Ln ms W It 7- 4- 0 - O N co 0- C O a Y 0-0 U O � a L C 7 t6 L ° (6 a +' of c L a -6 w i C— +� T L f6 p a cn +.+ +' @ .7 +, m >, +a, tab c bA (6 a ° v - a E_ t EQJ-O t +� — L u OA a a a a +J ° _ M +� o O a > }' Q) bA 70- +O, t0 a +� C 7 vEi Q @ O t v U O c i O O— 7 -p O V) m L h '++ .� Q) c °' ap E bio = > c ao ' ° > °�' +� 3 ro +; L c o a w ° v E a° E u +' 3 m a a ° o E m o M O +� a° u E 16 w CL ,n +, Q p O L c OU +-+ — -p L p m to ca p E a E p- +� ?� +, > c0 m -O O 3 m > b0 .Qj o N N U a _ o2 O va M C) I 0 Q) +, to L }, t +-+ u '� t U c C O Q_ U p +, a Q_ -6 T n a O w E 6 O t 14 U >, -O to Q(U O aCo v a ate-, ° m c tco " -a u ra o O o c-0 3 o �^ m 3 W N m L s a " c a°o ro to m n a �, t � -6 c L > z a � � .c � � Q ap E 'er a p C > w L +-+ Ea by M� c L M O +-+ 7 p by +� a a) L O O to u p Q T O U +-+ O O -o a) Y by Y *L' m +�, ° E Y Q O O a a N > _ E t6 v v kip Q ra ro '6 c N N L m c_ O — in +-+ O > aL, L 3 m a +; u c OU by -0 Ln c O O_ Q a O O u to a v C O +, Q °- �O p -a L +, by +, a O •in C > *' > a O U L O Y E a to O +-+ +� O a O b0 c O E c a-, , c '� Q c 7 -O +, +, O t O L a Q_ O a +' +, a u O by v -° o a '� ° 3 0 v bD a .v m o o .0 a 'm to vi by by T j r6 by a T +, a - p i _ a O m Q_0 a E c a - E Y M1 O a L i a C O u a *' Q U V) +� - +� O tD a -Q T t6 t L p u > a O t6 p a a u N O30 +�, +�, by a L LO "c t N -C C �,, 4J 0 m L a 7 >j t L vii U E v 3 bA C O > O E LO � v ° 3 +T, j �� bLaA +c+ a tb ° Q E a s a° t6 O -O bA ° N Q N a — c ++ L.L E O •C m -O `� O o +� L a O c E a} c c v o ° a M -Q c o o c c Q -E o bC: E �_ - E a T_ +, 0 u E CL O v a Q° c M Q bA > SZ . h N +�, - c O O E OU M O OD C a) MOp m b O Q t O O M +�+ a c a `^ N L [6 Q_ c a- a E c O Y u t M c >' a .b_A O c a c c 0 i T E s v a� E d T o =- I^ a> 1 o +' > a v, a u E 0 o 3 by c a t O* +, u c O - Y Cl_ o u '^ � c a a a-, L a T >, +' u L m O O °- E v a C c> c Q) O '^ -Q T a >' c a 0 -6 i c +, U a O_ E aL m t T C a t 0} .'^ t v p a t t +�+ m Q ate,, E -o c s L -0 to a a ° t to t to N p ,, a in O ++ N 7 u +, a }' of a O c p+ U +, o c a E +-+ +, ++ i a > O U s O U. O a }, c c a pJ C O p U +, O L m 00 ay-+ O +, m u m +-+ M a E ubn ?�, +, Y c > a a M E L a M a tO tp s L U +-+ t0 yam., Q +, c +' E 'up I ap o by c a E u t c 3 3> a .� t tw m— O O c c� m c +, to L u a -O � 0= 0 a +�, +, c c m E L a a a O •N s L m CL to m a c M >' O M L -Q O -6 -O O_ >- M '� c m O_ LJ ° L bc0 ro -O �n O I c a bA ° L m 02 *' C L C O L U }, a L •� +, U a u >- L t a N m L a L a-, - }, a ° u Q_ a a •C 3 L �, IE a - a + c p >` v) i) +-� U1 c o OL = �, N �--� -C /rip m V i f6 m vi L a ° L a +, N T C -p O , p) > *' VI t6 a a s *' a +, Q t6 Q Q> bA v L a O o° t °- - > - 3 c Q c +, 3. L a L a E o i v a 3 '� N a m e O' +, m bD a', a) -0 3. c c0 a 3 by O v> > +, a Y a T +, O u u c— C c Q a O v �^ .c O } c O tp E CU b° a s °) E ° E �_ E a 0 u 3 c> •- c a c a t E E > a Q c a '� Q E 3> Q a c 3 E a Q Q � Y 3 a E to a Q bA _ 'c 'Q 7 O m Q_ f0 � Q_ m t6 to by U ° w (9 ° c n a Y c L U +, C) bA -O N ^ v O �O t O +, N yam., Q *' c a c O by c CO 2� — h\ bq a Y n U +, n a t6 C m .° c o •+� a s °°° Q� *n ap Y to E .c '„ - C> -a � v v, v Q Q c-0 Y _ c O U a tv L a a a 0 0°+ a s � E bA L to O> m m a E N Y a m °v c u 0 m u M fl_ E E E � to O Q_ 3 Q °u O } 3 s t6 3 �' to ap +, a tp +, .E +, �, +, .E +, -0 m N O M r -I a .c� G a c c .c O U It 7- 4- 0 - O N co 0- It 0 7- 4- 0 0 co a� c� Co ctf CL 7— G �� M o% y i, 04 • i iii • J ��f • °/%j i ✓/ i /ii ai • CL m 0 CL 0 • to It 0 7- 4- 0 0 co a� c� x Ln L f6 O 'L U NIn p a) O T a) .> •� -6 C p u OLn a) O U O c C U ; ba ,L ? .� L s Y C N Q E O c O p O p Ln v m U U � O do c a) O Q O v v L Q +� v L n3 O C i Q N v, C N -0 a -- v + O c c c6 n3 a) -0 O >: ++ 6 = c6 L N O00 �O C c L T p i a) v (D a) = L c s E .v Q O H v a1 vv) 0 - CU v x .� o +� C +' L o s pis3." w C Q O + O �O + T n3 v1 >i ate-+ ut t m s L v 3 c — fO Y c O U U T s p` O O Q ++ p m n3 Oai L — L m -t3 U Q -0 a) C C .� s O Q s O U N ca E Lj a) � ++ t O L +� u C bn ca + a) C p 4] C t L u tO + �O O C a) O L (� O N t 0 b(i Esv C s o '7 i �O O N Q v U +�.+ +�-+ as-+ coin '� o !- a) (o 3 — ++ tv i) r6 a) - O N •C s C: > .0 C Q w O O L a) (a " `� 0 O •C a1 T C > > > + O a-+ = N 3— Q 'p C O Q U �, a-+ 7 L v) E N E LJ *' (0 W O O r6 _ a) C C t 3 `n U (Ca i ba Q Q Q Q = -p ^ N s U +� ba i C a1 v a) V)++ ra M to C M p "p c bl) �, a) — — n3 s C L C L bA ca O a) 3 a) �o c s ca s cLo o as OQ bA t U a) '� bbD u E bD -0 � s n -p 7 s v Q Q s n3 N p >� �' �'• v ns m E to C v a) O O a) �, CL a) E a) C0J = O ai a) L E ++ E o v c aJ v 3 Y ¢ - s u C @ c O= t aci O `n Q L 41 c A vt m Q a) v O s v L N E F- E +� Q L a) E 30 Q C T +' U o of O n5 fl s O N T f6 > E n3 u a1 C Q c6 L N (6 +� s > Z L O ++ U n3 L L -6 O> u) s a) v n3 v .� 3> oQ c a . 0 O +� o °' M o v -C o v ,v E >, Q l6 �i Ln aJ N .E p Y O = r � a) +�+ � O p " C " -o N a) a) m s� Q) u ci s O O ca •� Ln +� vi n3 a) p •C "a > o p p +� c O N +� n3 00a) +� Q O c Ca1 O + v -6 -p a) c u p by C N u N N N a) v) I E> O O to C C m C vlC •7, U O "7 O O of to C '— via) U tD i 7 a) of 7 C T a) u +� u Q c v M ai -0 o o p a) c o Q s u co O O '� i n3 n3 a E o O > T 3 s 7 T O co Q +� a) O C +-' v� Q v bA � a) 4 7 p u O CUcco a) W� v ra Q + a) —a0i v— cuo c +' E a1 +'' O � roo +-+ ' N u C `� ,C N j, u `� 'L vi O E E > T .� 'ts L m T a) 7 ca O m O +�•, O_ — E O -p a) E O +-+ -0 M Q ''^ = ut O O +L•' N >, U a) E Q m U 4A C W N > Ll L = Y Ln Q) L E Q a) p CL 7 fO � N > C = +_ co '> C o u O O Q 3 co p Q U O +5 aJ v C N +, tin C C E += o O 6 ns C a) c a) C Q C `° L Q s bD a3 v s c o Q � a, m 3 a p L C C Ln Ln N E a) Q O t5 Q U� 6 O CT+� O v N O O O L ai C (E O -"r--o bTn °) `° a E Q 0 a, �, v m O O a) '�' +� c ra c T O U C O_ E E m O C (O U a! +' C ,� to L > M `� C i o O to O 2- +� ++ O Q) u •� w >i N N O � �' O C •aJ O a) n u +� C C C a) be Q v +� c Q Q a) v Y L a) .0 bA >• ++ C C E E Q T (o a) 6 In O C a — Q O O + C L c c F aci = -o O L w m ^ O a) E > c 0) N s N E ca p o O v> b .� o v u v Q c v s �' O s o> n E ++ co -6 C m 7 0 a) m M Y a) s -O ++ i v p S Q 7 s O Q C O .N � p- Q m � = m N U f0 U (Ovii w m W a) Ov) —_ L u `n Q) O U Q) ++ L_Q O QJ `1 _ ra L O c 'N N ,V a) Q N vi Q1 t >, + Q p N � VI > �••, = +� ao N +' °' L L ° ra Q) c Q) -O OA c v w O -O •� a1 N O Q L ai p C ra - ?i ra O v .v co O *' 41 L m v 3 > v +�+ v) as L= o .� > v Q E L m 2 *' � M Cl u v v O w o — - ,� E c °°° +� o to ++ s a) aj L O a) oL .E O C) > > L n n *' n 0 +' p 7 of m Q) O u T N O u LL 0 > 0 p L v C6 v v �_ ++ L 0° Q v 0 d *' ii `i' ?� m O �O +' +� 4A 0 Y O �h0 p L +� 'N O L O 41 , L o p o O O � + L a) r�6 r6 o a1 .L L a1 ° Q a E ° a) — L L O n N N } L— T 7 +� o �% O vn Y aF + co p �, v a�L1 -0 C Q) h0 v .— rN6 O -0 a1 -E 0 w p o a) +' N a + a) LA 07 -0 — ) E O E u O a E >Pj 'u L -0 v L L E o p CL u .E m 0 ai uN O—cOJ OU + o a >- f6 c E-0 v) an a u m Q) a a) a) c c W — COp Q) ra S 0 O >• c v co cn ca C yam'' ) N Q X c Cr0 U C: >� N a) J Q Q �J t a) p E a)— a) c� c a�O+ O c to Q > 6 L p cn N+ > O 6 _p -p c c c 3 c L O aJ O O v a) +O+ N a) "6 c:u O O +'' '_O a) Q +�+ N > L ha dA O O N > -p O +' Q) '6 O vOi t trs .T 'a O Q) L .� N —_ "a +J C u l0 — rub a) T Q1 al N L Q +' }, v o p� +' p '3 t Q) Y v aJ O � OD U O +F O vi O a) 3 Q) *' L O to + ro Q p v N bA } a) 0 6.� Cl +� Q O v 1 3 t a to > Q1 v m v) Q p cf t u Q) v O aJ to p n v� c t pa 'n E E L +� Q) c m O L -0 0 3 O o E ai +O � E U E v o 'o v p �° s u+� C a)�Q+� ° O O Q-0 m O a>, +,•v L a) C L a) r6 U O ++ j OA +� L a) Q Z, p c .� N L c 7 Q m v O c ++ ++ Lz O O C u c p ra o ra p O N ,v 3 7 a t n a) >O _ CL a +� > 7 j .v O a) � •+, c w p 00 L bc.O L �"> +� O 3 C ° E L 0 U Vl 'Q Q) c 4) ra +--� Y a1 Q V1 L 7 p Q) O L O m >- �; C ra a) >� a) Q • ai H Q o .L in O �n $ Q U t o O u -6 O L �n O O C c +� a1 m _� > Ln a) p ra = O O � ++ a +� c L a) m 0 a ++ � L N O u aJ U N > ° U Q) Q) a) > ai E c9 tc Q Y Q O �' U "6 O Q) ate-+ 4-; N O_ dJ c Q) Q ++ C: O a) `� O Q) a) >' Q) H r6 O O �' O ro m a) > V L Q 1 —_ Y c o N V c U i c L L U v v � L c o O u a) p > v v v w un > Q is v 7 > Q +� Ln m � u Q +� -C m O L L t 7 co r6 E w 0 O +� +� co i 7 t N v� 'O ra i a) p 'O Q Q) Ln Q O O +� O .0 O �> N N m -0c E -0p p .� m L E m Q) ro u v ° ro O oa v N t L s Q Ou ra Q N > +-+ � ra u m v ++ H O u ro ro d Q ++ N N c\i Q\1 ci N O O tA a) U — c 0 E m _g_- 0 u It 7- 4- 0 — O N co N W It 0 co c� N cv > v °p s0 •3 N a, ° v w z E o L v 3 0 0 0 M o v CO v Ln c X o O ++ a1 U ha c a1 H (IJ Ln •� qp c C a1 ns a t N> N _N -p U a 3 7 E > }' (UM ( i- �O U w t m U1 > a1 () Q E -c c p O N i- O a) _0 E 0 O O O L p vi +� p Q to w a1 Oa) L + O w !n C 0 41 > 0 t6 O 0— qA Q WLn .@ w O m c O ++ tOa > ° on n n u - v c N a� > M = a) co CL O O a) Y a) O Uin O c_r_ '+-+ L O o� M L C m (n C (6 T �"� Ln Q CD ate -+ T L Yai a1 O al m m O E— nE a0 O 'n v (a 7 _ Q n3 c > Q-0 U + ca Q L O v c v ° ^ >v E p > a� � CO 3: ~ C Q1 ° .m v of s Q),°In 3 ago 3 E (U 06 p —CL v v� v bn 0 CL 4J ° n, 5 Q O -0 Q E aJ L O Q 7 LnO C L p p_ Q }' 'C) +� }' Q u p N c0 O O Q N � L -6 E N m O In v, L, v t L p U w 3 ° v° O L ++ a) ut O L 'qn -0= f6 L p O 3 v p E p O ° T c 0 M U N c U E Q — o v o c L o ,, u .E ° ) E m N w C E0 c N 06 w 0 +� n3 N CT L v 025 v U x O U v Q L L OD 7- bA m V1 (6 � ++ — a) QI -6 C U C O ai c � +--� _ N� �„� m Q O c m ° E +' �° o • o +., 0 to v, n3 L v+ O v O +� c t o '� 0 n3 aTi -C 3 tin aJ Q C L i H T O L O C L LO O C a1 U LnT L n3 C U- O c C a) i Q) L L O i 00 n3 O= U (6 L a) a) a! ' to f6 i Ln a + L z a Q C of Q aj U U m C'. -I --n3 ai a) Q) Ln c +� + +� p Q N o c > C O � _ v -p -° _ In c v a, ao p' '° >_aLn 0 S ba `n Q in a1 7 Q O T �°, > 3 a, m E E a°° o f ° 3 +� ++ c Q U O p vi Y= 0 v U O >, Q X a1 •i r6 vii t}a t tU ,c a! ns O "6 .� Q = 41 a1 C L CL bA ro m m m N c -I i N N r \ \ \ N N rl a– O v) a1 0 O LU 76U 06 ra U f6 Ln f6 Q) T c f6 ao O 1 7 N It 0 co c� N cv W p LO O i v� v v E 72 v > E °C v o '> w o z l _0 o a) ' Ln v o . E o ov o ra a) a O E a) o E O Q U L CL O U V) Ln C Q a p E O O cu '� a) m a) M 2 � U Q0) ca + =5 C U �_ -0,+ v N NLnt m a1 O L p O ai .� a1 •— —> +� L vl O U 7 (6 O �--� yi L O L a) Q� {n c >1 0 }1 M Q 'a Q 0 > a) i +' O V) C aj — a) N L — 7 U a1 C L �.. E M L a1 +� Q1 in L � a) �+ — L F U O _ m— 41 U O '6 > 2i a1 O 0 « ao �OQj O ai Cl) t p ai J T +-% E N > ++ L � a1 -p v _� Q O = -O �v) a) O -Q tv Q O O_ cv O v) E u 'n E v o °i3 CL O a) O c +� X 0 O N O L Q) ca �-+ Q `~ ai ba O a) � O C:-6 Q O_ O CL l T v _ M m o O v cum v O >, a, m a E O by L Ut ba >� +� O ++ 0 o c � = � a) D c) -0 bU Q w m ca 'N ' -6 O � .O ate-- 7 m U v '7 L p a) L a OE _ a O O O mu (O6 U j O L } U o O— C .ba L �--L O O bQ.O a) �. L •�-- V1 0 > O a O n3 bn E Q E > O L a) a v o c a) t o V) > � L L �--� L ++ E U O � _ > � M � a1 E � a) � .� a) O .� m t +' E a) > C O O ++ Q) O >• OU O E w c in ria p .'^ �., s -Q ns E o E@ m v 7 a, u v v O > v E z v — v p E ca U +� to u s t v n o c v Q) CL u- m N i Q V) E m N m 0 0 CL) t CL L cO C u U C m z AMENDMENT NO. ### TO THE OFFICIAL PLAN OF THE CITY OF KITCHENER CITY OF KITCHENER 265 Cotton Grass Street Page 35 of 164 AMENDMENT NO.### TO THE OFFICIAL PLAN OF THE CITY OF KITCHENER CITY OF KITCHENER 265 Cotton Grass Street iinFx SECTION 1 TITLE AND COMPONENTS SECTION 2 PURPOSE OF THE AMENDMENT SECTION 3 BASIS OF THE AMENDMENT SECTION 4 THE AMENDMENT APPENDICES APPENDIX 1 Notice of the Meeting of Planning & Strategic Initiatives Committee of April 3, 2023 APPENDIX 2 Minutes of the Meeting of Planning & Strategic Initiatives Committee APPENDIX 3 Minutes of the Meeting of City Council Page 36 of 164 AMENDMENT NO. ### TO THE OFFICIAL PLAN OF THE CITY OF KITCHENER SECTION 1 — TITLE AND COMPONENTS This amendment shall be referred to as Amendment No. ### to the Official Plan of the City of Kitchener (2014). This amendment is comprised of Sections 1 to 4 inclusive. SECTION 2 — PURPOSE OF THE AMENDMENT The purpose of the Official Plan Amendment is to amend Map 5 to add a site specific policy area to permit dwelling units to be located in a building without other permitted commercial uses, and to be located on the ground floor. The amendment is comprised of the following changes: • Map 5 is amended by adding Specific Policy Area 61 Adding Policy 15.D.12.61 to Section 15.D.12 to permit dwelling units to be located in a building without other permitted commercial uses, and to be located on the ground floor. SECTION 3 — BASIS OF THE AMENDMENT Planning Analysis: Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.13 25. Section 2 of the Planning Act establishes matters of provincial interest and states that the Minister, the council of a municipality, a local board, a planning board and the Tribunal, in carrying out their responsibilities under this Act, shall have regard to, among other matters, matters of provincial interest such as, f) The adequate provision and efficient use of communication, transportation, sewage and water services and waste management systems; g) The minimization of waste; h) The orderly development of safe and healthy communities; j) The adequate provision of a full range of housing, including affordable housing; k) The adequate provision of employment opportunities; p) The appropriate location of growth and development; q) The promotion of development that is designed to be sustainable, to support public transit and to be oriented to pedestrians; r) The promotion of built form that, (i) Is well-designed, (ii) Encourages a sense of place, and (iii) Provides for public spaces that are of high quality, safe, accessible, attractive and vibrant; s) The mitigation of greenhouse gas emissions and adaptation to a changing climate. These matters of provincial interest are addressed and are implemented through the Provincial Policy Statement, 2020, as it directs how and where development is to occur. The City's Official Plan is the most important vehicle for the implementation of the Provincial Policy Statement, 2020 and to ensure Provincial policy is adhered to. Provincial Policy Statement, 2020: The Provincial Policy Statement (PPS) provides policy direction on matters of provincial interest related to land use planning and development. Section 1.4.3(b) of the PPS promotes all types of residential intensification, and sets out a policy framework for sustainable, healthy, liveable and Page 37 of 164 safe communities. The PPS promotes efficient development and land use patterns, as well as accommodating an appropriate mix of affordable and market-based residential dwelling types with other land uses, while supporting the environment, public health and safety. Provincial policies promote the integration of land use planning, growth management, transit -supportive development, intensification, and infrastructure planning to achieve cost-effective development patterns, optimization of transit investments, and standards to minimize land consumption and servicing costs. To support provincial policies relating to the provision of housing, optimization of infrastructure, transit and active transportation, the proposed designation and zoning facilitate a compact form of development which efficiently uses the lands, is in close proximity to transit options including iXpress and other public transit routes, and makes efficient use of both existing roads and active transportation networks. The lands are serviced and are in proximity to commercial and service uses, schools, parks, trails and other community uses. Provincial policies are in support of providing a broad range of housing. The proposed multiple dwelling includes 2 and 3 bedroom ground oriented rental apartments. Planning staff is of the opinion that the proposed application will facilitate the development of the subject property with housing that is compatible with the surrounding community, helps manage growth, is transit supportive and will make use of the existing infrastructure. No new public roads would be required for the proposed development and Engineering staff have confirmed there is sufficient existing servicing. Based on the foregoing, staff is of the opinion that this proposal is in conformity with the PPS. A Place to Grow: Growth Plan for the Greater Golden Horseshoe, 2020 (Growth Plan): The Growth Plan supports the development of complete and compact communities that are designed to support healthy and active living, make efficient use of land and infrastructure, provide for a range and mix of housing types, jobs, and services, at densities and in locations which support transit viability and active transportation. Policies of the Growth Plan promote growth within strategic growth areas including major transit station areas, in order to provide a focus for investments in transit and other types of infrastructure. Policy 2.2.6.1(x) Municipalities will support housing choice through the achievement of the minimum intensification and targets in this plan by identifying a diverse range and mix of housing options and densities, including additional residential units and affordable housing to meet projected needs of current and future residents. Policies 2.2.1.4 states that complete communities will: a) feature a diverse mix of land uses, including residential and employment uses, and convenient access to local stores, services, and public service facilities; b) improve social equity and overall quality of life, including human health, for people of all ages, abilities, and incomes; c) provide a diverse range and mix of housing options, including additional residential units and affordable housing, to accommodate people at all stages of life, and to accommodate the needs of all household sizes and incomes; d) expand convenient access to: i. a range of transportation options, including options for the safe, comfortable and convenient use of active transportation; ii. public service facilities, co -located and integrated in community hubs; iii. an appropriate supply of safe, publicly -accessible open spaces, parks, trails, and other recreational facilities; and 4 Page 38 of 164 iv. healthy, local, and affordable food options, including through urban agriculture; e) provide for a more compact built form and a vibrant public realm, including public open spaces; f) mitigate and adapt to the impacts of a changing climate, improve resilience and reduce greenhouse gas emissions, and contribute to environmental sustainability; and g) integrate green infrastructure and appropriate low impact development. The Growth Plan supports planning for a range and mix of housing options and, in particular, higher density housing options that can accommodate a range of household sizes in locations that can provide access to transit and other amenities. The subject lands are located within the City's delineated Built -Up Area, and within a planned commercial plaza (Williamsburg Town Centre). Dwelling units are currently permitted to be located on upper floors of commercial buildings and co -location of commercial and residential uses helps support the development of completed communities. The proposed site-specific designation and zoning will support the applicant in delivering an efficient and cost-effective missing -middle, 2 and 3 bedroom, rental housing option in the Williamsburg Town Centre. The location will help make efficient use of existing servicing infrastructure, parks, roads, trails and transit, while also being conveniently located near commercial and service uses, as well as community uses and schools. Planning staff is of the opinion that the applications conform to the Growth Plan. Regional Official Plan (ROP): Urban Area policies of the ROP identify that the focus of the Region's future growth will be within the Urban Designated Greenfield Areas. The subject lands are designated Urban Designated Greenfield Areas in the ROP. This neighbourhood provides for the physical infrastructure and community infrastructure to support the proposed residential development, including transportation networks, municipal drinking -water supply and wastewater systems, and a broad range of social and public health services. Regional policies require Area Municipalities to plan for a range of housing in terms of form, tenure, density and affordability to satisfy the various physical, social, economic and personal support needs of current and future residents. Regional staff have indicated that they have no objections to the proposed applications, subject to the application of a Holding Provision for noise. Planning staff are of the opinion that the applications conform to the Regional Official Plan. City of Kitchener Official Plan, 2014 (OP) The City of Kitchener OP provides the long-term land use vision for Kitchener. The vision is further articulated and implemented through the guiding principles, goals, objectives, and policies which are set out in the Plan. The Vision and Goals of the OP strive to build an innovative, vibrant, attractive, safe, complete and healthy community. Urban Structure The Official Plan establishes an Urban Structure for the City of Kitchener and provides policies for directing growth and development within this structure. Intensification Areas are targeted throughout the Built-up Area as key locations to accommodate and receive the majority of development or redevelopment for a variety of land uses. Primary Intensification Areas include the Urban Growth Centre, Major Transit Station Areas, Nodes and Corridors, in this hierarchy, according to Section 3.C.2.3 of the Official Plan. The subject lands are identified as being located with a `Community Node' on Map 2 of the Official Plan and are designated `Commercial'. Page 39 of 164 Community Nodes are located along existing or planned transit corridors, and provide for commercial uses with a mix of residential and institutional uses necessary to support and complete surrounding residential communities. Applicable land use designations include Commercial, Mixed Use, Medium- and High -Rise Residential. The subject Community Node is located along a transit corridor and is intended to achieve a mix of uses and includes lands that are designated Commercial and Medium -Rise Residential. The proposed development is in keeping with the height and density contemplated by the surrounding Medium Rise Residential and is also a suitable height and density for this site. The Commercial land use designation permits a broad range of uses, including dwelling units on upper floors of buildings also containing other permitted commercial uses. The applicant is proposing to add a Specific Policy Area to the subject lands to permit residential uses to be permitted in a stand-alone building and on the ground floor. Staff is of the opinion that permitted ground floor residential in a stand-alone building on the subject lands will not compromise the planned function of the commercial lands. The proposed building has been designed and is proposed to be located so that it completes `Main Street' while also providing enhanced elevations along Cotton Grass Street, and additional dwelling units in close proximity to the commercial uses will help to support restaurants, stores and services. Integrating residential uses, can also help make efficient use of parking with shared visitor/commercial parking. The commercial plaza continues to include vacant commercial pads which could provide for additional commercial or mixed use development allowing future intensification and infill. Urban Design Policies: The City's urban design policies are outlined in Section 11 of the City's OP. In the opinion of staff, the proposed development satisfies these policies including: Streetscape; Safety; Universal Design; Site Design; Building Design, and Massing and Scale. To address these policies, an Urban Design Brief was submitted and has been reviewed by City staff. The Urban Design Brief is acceptable and outlines the vision and principles guiding the site design and informs the proposed zoning regulations. Streetscape — The proposed building has been oriented with frontage onto "Main Street" of the Williamsburg Town Centre and Cotton Grass Street. The proposed building has been designed and is proposed to be located so that it contributes to `Main Street' with front doors facing the private road, new parallel parking, and landscaped areas which will help continue the private streetscape which was previously established near Max Becker Drive. The proposal also provides enhanced elevations along Cotton Grass Street, and new street trees and private landscaping will be implemented through the Site Plan process. Safety — As with all developments that go through site plan approval, staff will ensure Crime Prevention through Environmental Design (CPTED) principles are achieved and that the site meets emergency services policies. Universal Design — The development will be designed to comply with Accessibility for Ontarian's with Disabilities Act and the Ontario Building Code. Site Design, Building Design, Massing and Scale — The subject site is designed to have a building that will be developed at a scale that is compatible with the existing and planned surroundings. The 3.5 storey building has been designed to complement and continue the vision for a traditional `Main Street' and is in keeping with the architecture of the condominium buildings recently constructed along Commonwealth Street (opposite Max Becker Common). The building also presents a front fagade toward Max Becker Common, and through the site plan process, Page 40 of 164 appropriate fencing, barriers and landscape screening will be provided between the parking area and the park. Transportation Policies: The Official Plan supports an integrated transportation system which incorporates active transportation, allows for the movement of people and goods and promotes a vibrant, healthy community using land use designations and urban design initiatives that make a wide range of transportation choices viable. The subject lands are located in close proximity to several bus routes, include an iXpress stop within about a 2 minute walk. The building has good access to cycling networks and is within walking distance of elementary schools. The location of the subject lands, in the context of the City's integrated transportation system, supports the proposal for residential development on the subject lands. Housing Policies: Section 4.1.1 of the City's Official Plan contains policies with the primary objective to provide for an appropriate range, variety and mix of housing types and styles, densities, tenure and affordability to satisfy the varying housing needs of our community through all stages of life. The proposed development increases the range of 2 and 3 bedroom rental units available in the city. The proposed development represents `missing middle' housing that bridges the gap between low rise, low intensity dwellings, and high-rise towers. The wide range of units, in this location, will appeal to a variety of household needs and directly responds to the need for more affordable housing during the current housing crisis. Official Plan Conclusions The Official Plan Amendment application requests a Specific Policy Area be added to the subject lands to permit a standalone residential building with ground floor dwelling units. Based on the above -noted policies and planning analysis, staff is of the opinion that the proposed Official Plan Amendment represents good planning and recommends that the proposed Official Plan Amendment be approved. SECTION 4 — THE AMENDMENT. The City of Kitchener Official Plan (2014) is hereby amended as follows: a) Part D, Section 15.D.12 is amended by adding Specific Policy Area 15.D.12.61 as follows: "15.D.12.61. 265 Cotton Grass Street Notwithstanding the Commercial land use designation and policies, on lands municipally known as 265 Cotton Grass Street: a) Dwelling units are not required to be located in the same building as commercial uses and may be permitted on the ground floor. b) A Holding provision pursuant to Section 17.E.13 of the Official Plan will apply to residential uses, day care uses and other sensitive uses. The Holding provision will be lifted through a by- law amendment and will not be removed until such time as a Road Traffic, and Stationary Noise Study has been approved by the Region and a release has been issued by the Region. Page 41 of 164 b) Part F, Map 5 — Specific Policy Areas is amended by adding Specific Policy Area No. 61, to the lands municipally known as 265 Cotton Grass Street, in the Area of Amendment, as shown on the attached Schedule `A'. Page 42 of 164 APPENDIX 1: Notice of the Planning & Strategic Initiatives Committee Meeting (March 10, 2023) NOTICE IF PUBLIC MEETING ,,,JIJf liar a development in your neighbourhood ii 265 Cotton Grass trivet �a r I. . N i l Have Your Voice Heard! Concept Drawing, Date: April 3, 2 23 "firTie: 7:00, p.,im. (Location. Council Chambers, Kitchener City Hall 2 King, StreetWest a rViirtual Zoom Meeting Tb view the staff report, agenda, meeting details, start flume of this item or to appear as adelegation, vislt: kitcheiner.ea/meetiin s %learn more, aboutthis project, including iinformation on your appeal rights, visit: rr wr.kitehenenca ` Pllainnin�ppl i�cation r n 0 or contact: (J�� Nhl rr°l, Senior �"larrr 1.41. 7987 J 11:c,u,J "Ii k.atie.alnd rl( kitchener.c "Fhe City of i itchener will consider applications to amend the Official Plan and Zoning By-law to permit the property, at 265, Cotton Grass Street to be developed with a standalone Multiple residential buil61nwith a reduced (Tont yard setback and a parkin rate of 1.5 spaces per dwelling, unit., The applicant is proposing a 32 -unit„ 3..5 stored stacked townhouse develcmprnent. Page 43 of 164 APPENDIX 2: Minutes of the Planning & Strategic Initiatives Committee Meeting (April 3, 2023) 10 Page 44 of 164 APPENDIX 3 - Minutes of the Meeting of City Council (April ##, 2023) 11 Page 45 of 164 Katie Anderl From: Mike Seiling Sent: Friday, December 16, 2022 3:03 PM To: Katie Anderl Subject: FW: Circulation for Comment - 265 Cotton Grass Street (OPA/ZBA) Attachments: department & agency letter - 265 Cotton Grass.pdf; ZBA22026CKA_MAP1.pdf, OPA22015CKA_MAP5.pdf Building; no concerns From: Christine Kompter<Christine.Kompter@kitchener.ca> Sent: Friday, December 16, 2022 2:42 PM To: _DL_#_DSD_Planning <DSD-PlanningDivision@kitchener.ca>; Bell - c/o WSP <circulations@wsp.com>; Carlos Reyes <Carlos.Reyes@kitchener.ca>; Darren Kropf <Darren.Kropf@kitchener.ca>; Dave Seller <Dave.Seller@kitchener.ca>; David Paetz <David.Paetz@kitchener.ca>; Ellen Straus <EIIen.Straus@kitchener.ca>; Enova Power Corp. - Greig Cameron <greig.cameron@enovapower.com>; Enova Power Corp. - Shaun Wang <shaun.wang@enovapower.com>; Feds <vped@feds.ca>; GRCA- Planning (planning@grandriver.ca) <planning@grandriver.ca>; Greg Reitzel <Greg.Reitzel@kitchener.ca>; Hydro One - Dennis DeRango <landuseplanning@hydroone.com>; Jim Edmondson <Jim.Edmondson@kitchener.ca>; Justin Readman <Justin.Readman@kitchener.ca>; Katherine Hughes <Katherine.Hughes@kitchener.ca>; Mike Seiling <Mike.Seiling@kitchener.ca>; Ontario Power Generation <Executivevp.lawanddevelopment@opg.com>; Park Planning (SM) <Park.Planning@kitchener.ca>; Region - Planning <PlanningApplications@regionofwaterloo.ca>; Property Data Administrator (SM) <PropDataAdmin@kitchener.ca>; Robert Morgan <Robert.Morgan@kitchener.ca>; Steven Ryder <Steven.Ryder@kitchener.ca>; Sylvie Eastman <Sylvie.Eastman@kitchener.ca>; WCDSB - Planning <planning@wcdsb.ca>; WRDSB - Board Secretary (elaine_burns@wrdsb.ca) <elaine_burns@wrdsb.ca>; WRDSB - Planning <planning@wrdsb.ca> Cc: Katie Anderl <Katie.Anderl@kitchener.ca> Subject: Circulation for Comment - 265 Cotton Grass Street (OPA/ZBA) Please see attached. Additional documentation can be found in AMANDA folders 22-128716 & 22-128724 (City staff) and 5h.2 r..e F.J.. (external agencies). Comments or questions should be directed to Katie Anderl, Senior Planner (O<atie.ander kitclheneir.ca; 519-741-2200 x7987 . .......................................................@.......................................................... ) Christine Kompter Administrative Assistant I Planning Division I City of Kitchener 200 King Street West, 6t" Floor I P.O. Box 1118 Kitchener ON N2G 4G7 519-741-2200 ext. 7425 1 TTY 1-866-969-9994 christine.kompter@kitchener.ca Page 46 of 164 Katie Anderl From: Niall Melanson Sent: Monday, December 19, 2022 2:58 PM To: Chelsea Dahmer Cc: Angela Mick; Katie Anderl Subject: 265 Cotton Grass St - 1 st submission FSR comments Attachments: 265 Cotton Grass St - 1 st Submission ZBA Engineering Comments.pdf Hey Chelsea Please see attached. I don't have any concerns but would request you update the FSR and I am curious what your responses are to my comments. Cheers Niall Melanson, C.E.T. Project Manager I Development Engineering I City of Kitchener 519-741-2200 Ext. 7133 1 TTY 1-866-969-9994 1 niall.melanson@kitchener.ca Page 47 of 164 91 December 19, 2022 MTE Consultants Inc. Chelsea Dahmer 520 Bingemans Centre Drive Kitchener, ON N2B 3X9 Dear Ms. Dahmer DEVELOPMENT ENGINEERING SERVICES Niall Melanson, C.E.T. Project Manager 200 King St. W. 9th Floor Kitchener, ON N2G 4G7 Phone: (519) 741-2200 ext. 7133 niall.melanson@kitchener.ca Re: 265 Cotton Grass Street, ZBA22/025/N/BB - 111 Submission ZBA Engineering Comments City of Kitchener Sanitary Servicing: 1) Please note that with a Floor Space Ratio of 0.92 this development is probably closer to a MIX -1 zoning which has a population of 312peo/ha. With that said, since the subdivision was given a unit count to adhere to the increased flows generated were not reviewed. 2) Please be advised that with the decommissioning of the Interim Bleams Road Pumping Station the flows generated along Commonwealth Crescent, Commonwealth Street (south of Max Becker Drive), Frey Crescent, Helena-Feasby Street, Harding Crescent and Riehm Crescent now all drain into the City's Middle Strasburg Sanitary Sewer. This would remove 201 units from the Appendix B count. Water Servicing — Comments provided by Angela Mick with Kitchener Utilities: 3) No Concerns Storm Servicing & Stormwater Management: 4) Detailed review of the SWM design will be reviewed during the Site Plan Application process. Please make the requisite revisions and resubmit one (1) copy of same for review at your earliest convenience. Sincerely, Niall Melanson, C.E.T. Project Manager Page 48 of 164 SAGeneral\03-06-002 Site Plan Files\Site Plans\265 Cotton Grass St\ZBA22 026 C KA\265 Cotton Grass St - 1st Submission ZBA Engineering Comments.docx From: Niall Melanson Sent: Tuesday, February 28, 2023 9:19 AM To: Katie Anderl Subject: RE: 265 Cotton Grass - Resubmission Thanks Katie. No concerns. Niall Melanson, C.E.T. Project Manager I Development Engineering I City of Kitchener 519-741-2200 Ext. 7133 1 TTY 1-866-969-9994 1 niall.melanson@kitchener.ca From: Katie Anderl <IKatiie.Anderil@ ukiitcheiner.ca> .......................................................................................................................... Sent: Monday, February 27, 2023 4:12 PM To: Niall Melanson <NiiallL.Melanson... kiitcheneir.ca> ................................................................................................................................... Subject: FW: 265 Cotton Grass - Resubmission Hi Niall, Forwarding to you for your information and records. I don't think you had concerns, however the SWM/Servicing have been updated in accordance with the updated site design and extra block of units. Thanks, Katie From: Katie Anderl Sent: Monday, February 27, 2023 3:59 PM To: Shilling Yip <S ilp. r giipinp onr ir�pp..,� .>; Lenore Ross <li.: rn it �Ikii.tc.lhener.:_ �>; Katey Crawford <I.�l�itche .er:ca>Steven Ryder < teven.K t �_.......................Ry it kit h in ra > Subject: 265 Cotton Grass - Resubmission Hello, A revised submission for the OPA/ZBA/SP has been received. New materials have been added to ShareFile : Ihtt s: kiitcherneir.shairefille.com Ihoine shared fo�.7c1b6 360a-42.ef 1kn433-f8759dda1.66c folldeir 12.......f/................................................................................. .............................../.........................../................................../.............................................................................................................................................................................................../............................... Please review and advise if you have any further outstanding comments or concerns that need to be addressed prior to moving forward with a Recommendation Report. Shilling — there is an updated Noise Study. Please let me know how you wish to address the implementation piece. Thanks, Katie Katie Anderl Senior Planner I Planning Division I City of Kitchener 519-741-2200 x7987 I TTY 1-866-969-9994 1 katie.anderl@kitchener.ca ��0111111pIllNNylbn �� U a ggtt°� Page 49 of 164 Page 50 of 164 Katie Anderl From: Chris Foster -Pengelly <cfosterpengelly@grandriver.ca> Sent: Monday, December 19, 2022 10:15 AM To: Katie Anderl Subject: RE: Circulation for Comment - 265 Cotton Grass Street (OPA/ZBA) The subject property is not regulated by the GRCA under Ontario Regulation 150/06. As such, we will not be providing comments. Chris IIP o teir llf:Ieingelllllly, 11%. c.., Office: 519-621-2763 ext. 2319 Toll-free: 1-866-900-4722 ry iiI it�uoinii ll imedi ..................................... y lr. �.. ......:..._::..... ......... ......... From: Planning <planning@grandriver.ca> Sent: Friday, December 16, 2022 3:34 PM To: Chris Foster -Pengelly <cfosterpengelly@grandriver.ca> Subject: FW: Circulation for Comment - 265 Cotton Grass Street (OPA/ZBA) From: Christine Kompter<Chrii_stiine....IICg.irrn_Ipj�ir@I it plh irn it c > Sent: December 16, 2022 2:42 PM To: _DL _# DSD Planning<IfyS.:::IIgIn_Imiirglfiliisiicpnleillnir.>; Bell - c/o WSP <ciiirrull.tii0lnsCarlos Reyes <Carllos, Re es Ikitclheiner.ca>; Darren Kro f <Dairirein.IKro f Ikirtclhener.ca>; Dave Seller <Dave.Sellleir kirtclheineir,ca>; ............................................Y........... �.......................................................... P...................................................Ip.....@.................................................................................................................@.......................................................... David Paetz <If yi .I.......................... C Ikii c In lr.E >; Ellen Straus < Il 11 .......................................................n.@Iki.t lh lneir.ca>; Enova Power Corp. -Greig Cameron <gU pg Uon@ Inovalpr�wer c u >, Enova Power Corp. - Shaun Wang <s_haun _wra_ung_ rDan glp r.cg >; Feds <vfrc @fie s.c >; Planning <raV lnrroo_15.g_@.8r rr riv rr._c9>; Greg Reitzel < r9 . go_tzeV_@k t.cbener c >; Hydro One - Dennis ...... .. DeRango <V ndusglnl n.ru%Ing V�ydroong coal>, Jim Edmondson <Jum Ed_rrnondsoriCa_.C. tc_h rier._ca>; Justin Readman <Juston Re ad ma n@kotchener ca>, Katherine Hughes <Kath rune iiu ghos@.V itchener ca.>, Mike Seiling ......... .... <Mike.Seiling@Vcp.t ro r g>; Ontario Power Generation <Sx cutiy �rip.0 vv r7 ev to ug In.t@a lag.pp >; Park Planning (SM) < >arVco(Ig�nwurDg@ J .n ro >; Region -Planning <ja] roruiung ppVJca.ti_g.Ins@ -...guonofwaterl_oo.o_ca>; Property Data Administrator (SM) <i'rq I�ataC urporJ lkii c_ neir.ca>; Robert Morgan <Ro ert I\llcargaru kutch ner >; Steven Ryder .... <Stey n R d U..@.._ ptc roc >; Sylvie Eastman <S.yVyue_.IE stuvo n @ t Ih rJ r.c >; WCDSB - Planning _...................... < V rrrpP_IS.g..@v c l .c >; WRDSB -Board Secretary (V pn _ _rin_s.. a sCa.c) «I.a.ing_b.arns.�rs..c2>; WRDSB - .l Planning <plannin @wrdsb.ca> Cc: Katie Anderl<IKatie..A,rn.derll..@_V<iltclheln lr.._ca,> Subject: Circulation for Comment - 265 Cotton Grass Street (OPA/ZBA) Please see attached. Additional documentation can be found in AMANDA folders 22-128716 & 22-128724 (City staff) and Slha r IJI.e (external agencies). Comments or questions should be directed to Katie Anderl, Senior Planner (Ikatis�.anded Ikirtclherreir,ca; 519-741-2200 x7987 . ........................................................@.......................................................... ) Page 51 of 164 Christine Kompter Administrative Assistant I Planning Division I City of Kitchener 200 King Street West, 6t" Floor I P.O. Box 1118 Kitchener ON N2G 4G7 519-741-2200 ext. 7425 1 TTY 1-866-969-9994 christine.kompter@kitchener.ca Page 52 of 164 Katie Anderl From: Deeksha Choudhry Sent: Tuesday, January 10, 2023 4:13 PM To: Katie Anderl Subject: Re: Circulation for Comment - 265 Cotton Grass Street (OPA/ZBA) Hi Kaite, No heritage planning issues or concerns for this application. Thanks! Kind Regards, Deeksha Choudhry, MSc, BES Heritage Planner I Planning Division I City of Kitchener 519-741-2200 ext. 72911 TTY 1-866-969-9994 deeksha.choudhry@kitchener.ca From: Christine Kompter<Christine.Kompter@kitchener.ca> Sent: Friday, December 16, 2022 2:42 PM To: _DL_#_DSD_Planning <DSD-PlanningDivision@kitchener.ca>; Bell - c/o WSP <circulations@wsp.com>; Carlos Reyes <Carlos.Reyes@kitchener.ca>; Darren Kropf <Darren.Kropf@kitchener.ca>; Dave Seller <Dave.Seller@kitchener.ca>; David Paetz <David.Paetz@kitchener.ca>; Ellen Straus <EIIen.Straus@kitchener.ca>; Enova Power Corp. - Greig Cameron <greig.cameron@enovapower.com>; Enova Power Corp. - Shaun Wang <shaun.wang@enovapower.com>; Feds <vped@feds.ca>; GRCA- Planning (planning@grandriver.ca) <planning@grandriver.ca>; Greg Reitzel <Greg.Reitzel@kitchener.ca>; Hydro One - Dennis DeRango <landuseplanning@hydroone.com>; Jim Edmondson <Jim.Edmondson@kitchener.ca>; Justin Readman <Justin.Readman@kitchener.ca>; Katherine Hughes <Katherine.Hughes@kitchener.ca>; Mike Seiling <Mike.Seiling@kitchener.ca>; Ontario Power Generation <Executivevp.lawanddevelopment@opg.com>; Park Planning (SM) <Park.Planning@kitchener.ca>; Region - Planning <PlanningApplications@regionofwaterloo.ca>; Property Data Administrator (SM) <PropDataAdmin@kitchener.ca>; Robert Morgan <Robert.Morgan@kitchener.ca>; Steven Ryder <Steven.Ryder@kitchener.ca>; Sylvie Eastman <Sylvie.Eastman@kitchener.ca>; WCDSB - Planning <planning@wcdsb.ca>; WRDSB - Board Secretary (elaine_burns@wrdsb.ca) <elaine_burns@wrdsb.ca>; WRDSB - Planning <planning@wrdsb.ca> Page 53 of 164 Cc: Katie Anderl <Katie.Anderl@kitchener.ca> Subject: Circulation for Comment - 265 Cotton Grass Street (OPA/ZBA) Please see attached. Additional documentation can be found in AMANDA folders 22-128716 & 22-128724 (City staff) and SIh.alrelFii.11e (external agencies). Comments or questions should be directed to Katie Anderl, Senior Planner Ikatie.andeirll .........!kitclheneir.ca:.519-741-2200 x7987 . ................................................................................. Christine Kompter Administrative Assistant I Planning Division I City of Kitchener 200 King Street West, 6t" Floor I P.O. Box 1118 Kitchener ON N2G 4G7 519-741-2200 ext. 7425 1 TTY 1-866-969-9994 christine.kompter@I<itchener.ca Page 54 of 164 City of Kitchener Comment Form Project Address: 265 Cotton Grass St File Number: OPA22/015/C/KA; ZBA22/026/C/KA; SP22/184/C/KA Date of Site Plan Review Committee Meeting: Jan 19 /25 2023 Comments Of: Parks & Cemeteries Commenter's Name: Lenore Ross Email: Lenore. ross@kitchener.ca Phone: 519-741-2200 ext 7427 Date of Comments: Jan 19 2023 Documents Reviewed: Cover Letter prepared by Schlegel Urban Developments Corp; Planning Justification Report prepared by GSP Group Inc.; Urban Design Report prepared by GSP Group Inc.; Conceptual Site Plan, Elevations & Floor Plans prepared by 4 Architecture Inc.• 3D Massing Model prepared by Schlegel Urban Developments Corp.• Existing Conditions Plan and Preliminary Grading Plan prepared by MTE Consultants Inc.; Site Plan Application Form; Site Plan; Elevations; Functional Grading Plan; Urban Design Report. D 1 plan to attend the meeting (questions/concerns/comments for discussion) ❑ No meeting to be held ❑ I do NOT plan to attend the meeting (no concerns) 1. OPA and ZBA Comments Parks and Cemeteries has no concerns with the proposed OPA22/015/C/KA and ZBA22/026/C/KA and have no further requirements for these applications. A City for Everyone Working Together — Growing Thoughtfully — Building Community Page 55 of 164 Katie Anderl, MCIP. RPP Senior Planner DSD — Planning Division City of Kitchener 200 King Street W. Kitchener, ON N2G 4G7 Dear Ms. Anderl: PLANNING, DEVELOPMENT AND LEGISLATIVE SERVICES Community Planning 150 Frederick Street 8th Floor Kitchener Ontario N2G 4,13 Canada Telephone: 519-575-4400 TTY: 519-575-4608 Fax: 519-575-4466 www.reedionofwaterloo.ca Shilling Yip (226) 753-1064 (C) Files: D17-40/2/22015 C14-60/2/22026 January 25, 2023 OPA 22/015/C/KA ZBA 22/026/C/KA Schlegel Urban Developments Corp. 265 Cotton Grass Street CITY OF KITCHENER Region staff has reviewed the above -noted applications and provides the following comments for your consideration at this time. The applicant is proposing a 28 unit back- to-back stacked townhouse development which includes 52 parking spaces and 14 Class A bicycle spaces. The OPA is to add a Specific Policy Area to permit multiple dwellings in a stand-alone building. The ZBA is to add: • A special use provision to the existing C-2 zone to add multiple dwelling as a permitted use; • A special regulation to permit a minimum setback of 0.5m to a porch and 1.5m to the bldg. for the NE corner of the bldg; • To permit dwelling units on the ground floor; and • To permit a parking rate of 1.5 spaces/unit and a visitor parking rate of 0.15 spaces/unit. Document Number: 4290042 Version: 1 Page 56 of 164 -2- A site plan application, SP22/184/C/KA accompanies the applications. The lands are designated Urban Area "Designated Greenfield Area"on Map 3a in the Regional Official Plan (ROP). Water Services Water Services Engineering and Planning staff has no concern with the applications and offer no comments. Hydrogeology & Water Programs (Source Water Protection) The lands are designated Wellhead Protection Sensitivity 8 on Map 6a of the Regional Official Plan (ROP). The purpose of the mapping and policies contained in Chapter 8 of the ROP is to protection long-term municipal groundwater supplies. Hydrogeology and Water Program (HWP) staff request that a prohibition on vertical closed-loop and open -loop geothermal energy systems be included in the Zoning By- law amendment for the subject property. Salt Management Plan A Salt Management Plan (MTE, November 29, 2022) has been submitted in support of these applications. This report is currently under review and comments will be provided as soon as they become available. Corridor Planning Corridor Planning staff provides the following comments at this time. A noise study entitled, "Noise Feasibility Study, Proposed Residential Development, 265 Cotton Grass Street, Kitchener, Ontario" (HGC, November 29, 2022) has been submitted in support of the applications. The report is currently under review and comments will be provided as soon as they become available. In the meantime, should the application move forward staff supports the use of a holding provision to secure review of the report to the Region's satisfaction. Archaeology No comments. Housing General The following Regional policies and initiatives support the development and maintenance of affordable housing: • Regional Strategic Plan o Objective 4.2 requires the Region to make affordable housing more available to individuals and families. Document Number: 4290042 Version: 1 Page 57 of 164 -3- • 10 -Year Housing and Homelessness Plan o contains an affordable housing target which is that 30% of all new residential development between 2019 and 2041 in Waterloo Region is to be affordable to low and moderate income households. Building Better Futures Framework o shows how the Region plans to create 2,500 units of housing affordable to people with low to moderate incomes by 2025. Region of Waterloo Official Plan o Section 3.A (Range and Mix of Housing) contains land use policies that ensure the provision of a full and diverse range and mix of permanent housing that is safe, affordable, of adequate size, and meets the accessibility requirements of all residents. The Region supports the provision of a full range of housing options, including affordable housing. Should this development application move forward, staff recommend that the applicant consider providing a number of affordable housing units on the site, as defined in the Regional Official Plan. Rent levels and house prices that are considered affordable according to the Regional Official Plan are provided below in the section on affordability. In order for affordable housing to fulfill its purpose of being affordable to those who require rents or purchase prices lower than the regular market provides, a mechanism should be in place to ensure the units remain affordable and establish income levels of the households who can rent or own the homes. Staff further recommend meeting with Housing Services to discuss the proposal in more detail and to explore opportunities for partnerships or programs and mechanisms to support a defined level of affordability. Affordability For the purposes of evaluating the affordability of an ownership unit, based on the definition in the Regional Official Plan, the purchase price is compared to the least expensive of: Housing for which the purchase price results in annual accommodation costs which do not exceed 30 percent of gross $385,500 annual household income for low and moderate income households Housing for which the purchase price is $576,347 at least 10 percent below the average Document Number: 4290042 Version: 1 Page 58 of 164 -4 - purchase price of a resale unit in the regional market area "Based on the most recent information available from the PPS Housing Tables (2021). In order for an owned unit to be deemed affordable, the maximum affordable house price is $385,500. For the purposes of evaluating the affordability of a rental unit, based on the definition of affordable housing in the Regional Official Plan, the average rent is compared to the least expensive of: A unit for which the rent does not exceed 30 per cent of the gross annual $1,470 household income for low and moderate income renter households A unit for which the rent is at or below the Bachelor: $950 average market rent (AMR) in the 1 -Bedroom: $1,134 regional market area 2 -Bedroom: $1,356 3 -Bedroom: $1,538 4+ Bedroom: $3,997 'Based on the most recent intormation available trom the PNS Housing I ables (2021) In order for a rental unit to be deemed affordable, the average rent for the proposed units which have fewer than 3 bedrooms must be at or below the average market rent in the regional market area as shown above. For proposed units with three or more bedrooms, the average rent for the units must be below $1,470. Please do not hesitate to contact Judy Maan Miedema, Principal Planner (Housing) directly by email at JMaanMiedema(a-).regionofwaterloo.ca should you have any questions or wish to discuss in more detail. Proposed Zoning By-law Amendment Staff continues to review the proposed zoning for the lands. Regional Development Charges Any future development on the subject lands will be subject to provisions of Regional Development Charges By-law 19-037 or any successor thereof. Other Staff acknowledges the Region's required review fees for the OPA and ZBA applications were received January 13, 2023. Document Number: 4290042 Version: 1 Page 59 of 164 -5 - Staff continues to review the applications. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me (226) 753-1064 (c). Yours truly, Shilling Yip, MCIP, RPP Senior Planner cc. Applicant Document Number: 4290042 Version: 1 Page 60 of 164 Katie Anderl, MCIP. RPP Senior Planner DSD — Planning Division City of Kitchener 200 King Street W. Kitchener, ON N2G 4G7 Dear Ms. Anderl: PLANNING, DEVELOPMENT AND LEGISLATIVE SERVICES Community Planning 150 Frederick Street 8th Floor Kitchener Ontario N2G 4,13 Canada Telephone: 519-575-4400 TTY: 519-575-4608 Fax: 519-575-4466 www.reedionofwaterloo.ca Shilling Yip (226) 753-1064 (C) Files: D17-40/2/22015 C14-60/2/22026 March 14, 2023 OPA 22/015/C/KA ZBA 22/026/C/KA Schlegel Urban Developments Corp. 265 Cotton Grass Street CITY OF KITCHENER Further to the Region's comments of January 25, 2023, staff provides the following additional comments at this time. Salt Management Plan A Salt Management Plan (MTE, November 29, 2022) has been submitted in support of these applications. The report is acceptable to the Region, and must be implemented as part of the site plan. Draft Zoning By-law Amendment Staff has reviewed the draft zoning by-law amendment which includes provision to prohibit the use of geothermal energy systems, and a holding provision to secure the submission and approval of a road traffic and stationary noise study to the Region's satisfaction. These provisions are satisfactory to Region staff. Other Subject to the above, the Region's comments of January 25, 2023 continue to apply. Document Number: 4334347 Version: 1 Page 61 of 164 -2 - If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me (226) 753-1064 (c). Yours truly, Shilling Yip, MCIP, RPP Senior Planner cc. Applicant Document Number: 4334347 Version: 1 Page 62 of 164 City of Kitchener - Comment Form Project Address: 265 Cotton Grass St Application Type: OPA and ZBA Comments of: Environmental Planning (Sustainability) — City of Kitchener Commenter's name: Gaurang Khandelwal Email: gaurang.khandelwal@I<itchener.ca Phone: 519-741-2200 x 7611 Written Comments Due: January 18, 2023 Date of comments: January 18, 2023 1. Plans, Studies and/or Reports submitted and reviewed as part of a complete application: • 265 Cotton Grass Street OPA/ZBA/SPA - Sustainability Checklist prepared by Schlegel Urban Developments, dated November 28, 2022 2. Comments & Issues: I have reviewed the documentation (as listed above) to support an Official Plan Amendment and a Zoning By-law Amendment for the proposed 28 unit stacked townhouse development, regarding sustainability and energy conservation and provide the following: • Although the Ontario Building Code (OBC) is advanced, going forward all developments will need to include robust energy conservation measures as the City (and Region of Waterloo) strive to achieve our greenhouse gas reduction target. • Based on my review of the supporting documentation, the Official Plan and Zoning Bylaw Amendments can be supported as several sustainable measures have been proposed or are being considered for the development. • A Sustainability Statement (as per the City's Terms of Reference) will be required as part of a complete Site Plan Application which can further explore and/or confirm additional sustainability measures that are best suited to the development as the design evolves. • Potential items for consideration: o Electric vehicle charging stations o Alternative water supply systems such as rainwater harvesting or grey water reuse, or the ability to incorporate such systems in the future o Alternative energy systems such as solar panels or the ability to incorporate such systems in the future Page 63 of 164 3. Policies, Standards and Resources: • Kitchener Official Plan Policy 7.C.4.5. The City will encourage and support, where feasible and appropriate, alternative energy systems, renewable energy systems and district energy in accordance with Section 7.C.6 to accommodate current and projected needs of energy consumption. • Kitchener Official Plan Policy 7.C.6.4. In areas of new development, the City will encourage orientation of streets and/or lot design/building design with optimum southerly exposures. Such orientation will optimize opportunities for active or passive solar space heating and water heating. • Kitchener Official Plan Policy 7.C.6.8. Development applications will be required to demonstrate, to the satisfaction of the City, energy is being conserved or low energy generated. • Kitchener Official Plan Policy 7.C.6.27. The City will encourage developments to incorporate the necessary infrastructure for district energy in the detailed engineering designs where the potential for implementing district energy exists. 4. Advice: ➢ As part of the Kitchener Great Places Award program every several years there is a Sustainable Development category. Also, there are community-based programs to help with and celebrate and recognize businesses and sustainable development stewards (Regional Sustainability Initiative - http://www.sustainablewaterlooregion.ca/our-programs/regional-sustainability- initiative and TravelWise - http://www.sustainablewaterlooregion.ca/our-programs/travelwise). ➢ The 'Sustainability Statement Terms of Reference' can be found on the City's website under 'Planning Resources' at ... https://www.kitchener.ca/SustainabilityStatement Page 64 of 164 From: Steven Ryder Sent: Friday, March 10, 2023 11:31 AM To: Katie Anderl Subject: RE: 265 Cotton Grass - Resubmission -OPA/ZBA comments from TP Hi Katie, We have reviewed the updated materials from the applicant and are generally supportive of the overall site plan concept, as well as the proposed parking rates. I do not have any more concerns regarding the OPA/ZBA applications. If you have any questions or concerns, please let me know. Regards, Steven Ryder, C.E.T. Traffic Planning Analyst I Transportation Services I City of Kitchener 519-741-2200 ext 71521 TTY. 1-866-969-9994 1 Steven. Ryder&kitchener.ca. �1plUrrrrairiwHlyu, ���., mmi i ���� n r ,',e i,oJns 1 l 1) eU)/JJ'"'1J"'7J"1NeLt k7e if/i,f". J.7111nrL1) 1 From: Katie Anderl <IKatt_e_: Indeirll.. .II<iitclhelnelr._ca> Sent: Monday, February 27, 2023 3:59 PM To: Shilling Yip <SXilp. Eggiion_ofwateir.�o�n..,e�>; Lenore Ross <II.:e_rnore._R ss ii.t lh in ir: >; Katey Crawford <I..... r vy it ll�itchener g�>; Steven Ryder <Steve.n.Ry er�!l iitcllhener ca> ......... ..... .................. Subject: 265 Cotton Grass - Resubmission Hello, A revised submission for the OPA/ZBA/SP has been received. New materials have been added to ShareFile : I�tt s:. k�tchener.slharefille.com Ihorne shared fo�.Zclb6 360a 42.ef..Ila433 f.8759dda1.66c ffollder 12.......f1................................................................................................................f...........................1..................................1...............................................................................................................................................................................................1............................... Please review and advise if you have any further outstanding comments or concerns that need to be addressed prior to moving forward with a Recommendation Report. Shilling — there is an updated Noise Study. Please let me know how you wish to address the implementation piece. Thanks, Katie Katie Anderl Senior Planner I Planning Division I City of Kitchener 519-741-2200 x7987 I TTY 1-866-969-9994 1 katie.anderl@kitchener.ca Page 65 of 164 iU�UNuir�rrrririflu� - R�r , / /ao, Y �n��, � St Page 66 of 164 From: Katey Crawford Sent: Wednesday, March 1, 2023 9:18 AM To: Katie Anderl Subject: RE: 265 Cotton Grass - Resubmission Hi Katie, No concerns or comments. Thanks, Katey From: Katie Anderl <Katie. der[(J_ itcheneir._�a> Sent: Monday, February 27, 2023 3:59 PM To: Shilling Yip < Yp.. Egg_o �_ofwatedo 2 �a>; Lenore Ross <..:e_nore Ross kitchener._ca>; Katey Crawford <Katey r aaUd kitchener c. a>,Steven Ryder <Ste.ver..R 'er kil..hener ca> ......... ..... ............................... ................ Subject: 265 Cotton Grass - Resubmission Hello, A revised submission for the OPA/ZBA/SP has been received. New materials have been added to ShareFile : Ihtt s:. kiitcheneir.slharefille.com Ihorme shared fob.7c..b6..360a-42.ef..b433.-f87 a9dda166c ffolldeir 12.......// ............... ... .............................................. ................................................f.........................../................................../................................................ .................................................... ............................................... ...... ...... ...... ......................./............................... Please review and advise if you have any further outstanding comments or concerns that need to be addressed prior to moving forward with a Recommendation Report. Shilling — there is an updated Noise Study. Please let me know how you wish to address the implementation piece. Thanks, Katie Katie Anderl Senior Planner I Planning Division I City of Kitchener 519-741-2200 x7987 I TTY 1-866-969-9994 1 katie.anderl@kitchener.ca �Pr�rUmurauiy Y4,f Page 67 of 164 Katie Anderl From: Planning <planning@wcdsb.ca> Sent: Monday, January 16, 2023 3:11 PM To: Katie Anderl Subject: RE: Circulation for Comment - 265 Cotton Grass Street (OPA/ZBA) Good Afternoon Katie, The Waterloo Catholic District School Board has reviewed the subject application and based on our development circulation criteria have the following comment(s)/condition(s): A) That any Education Development Charges shall be collected prior to the issuance of a building permit(s). If you require any further information, please contact me by e-mail at Jordan. Neale@wcdsb.ca. Thank you, Jordan Neale Planning Technician, WCDSB 480 Dutton Dr, Waterloo, ON N2L 4C6 519-578-3660 ext. 2355 From: Christine Kompter<Christine.Kompter@kitchener.ca> Sent: Friday, December 16, 2022 2:42 PM To: _DL_#_DSD_Planning <DSD-PlanningDivision@kitchener.ca>; Bell - c/o WSP <circulations@wsp.com>; Carlos Reyes <Carlos.Reyes@kitchener.ca>; Darren Kropf <Darren.Kropf@kitchener.ca>; Dave Seller <Dave.Seller@kitchener.ca>; David Paetz <David.Paetz@kitchener.ca>; Ellen Straus <EIIen.Straus@kitchener.ca>; Enova Power Corp. - Greig Cameron <greig.cameron@enovapower.com>; Enova Power Corp. - Shaun Wang <shaun.wang@enovapower.com>; Feds <vped@feds.ca>; GRCA- Planning (planning@grandriver.ca) <planning@grandriver.ca>; Greg Reitzel <Greg.Reitzel@kitchener.ca>; Hydro One - Dennis DeRango <landuseplanning@hydroone.com>; Jim Edmondson <Jim.Edmondson@kitchener.ca>; Justin Readman <Justin.Readman@kitchener.ca>; Katherine Hughes <Katherine.Hughes@kitchener.ca>; Mike Seiling <Mike.Seiling@kitchener.ca>; Ontario Power Generation <Executivevp.lawanddevelopment@opg.com>; Park Planning (SM) <Park.Plan ning@kitchener.ca>; Region - Planning <PlanningApplications@regionofwaterloo.ca>; Property Data Administrator (SM) <PropDataAdmin@kitchener.ca>; Robert Morgan <Robert.Morgan@kitchener.ca>; Steven Ryder <Steven.Ryder@kitchener.ca>; Sylvie Eastman <Sylvie.Eastman@kitchener.ca>; Planning <planning@wcdsb.ca>; WRDSB - Board Secretary (elaine_burns@wrdsb.ca) <elaine_burns@wrdsb.ca>; WRDSB - Planning <planning@wrdsb.ca> Cc: Katie Anderl <Katie.Anderl@kitchener.ca> Subject: Circulation for Comment - 265 Cotton Grass Street (OPA/ZBA) Caution - External Email - This Message comes from an external organization. Do NOT click on unrecognized links or provide your username and/or password. Page 68 of 164 Please see attached. Additional documentation can be found in AMANDA folders 22-128716 & 22-128724 (City staff) and Slh_ r. (.Jt.e. (external agencies). Comments or questions should be directed to Katie Anderl, Senior Planner O<atieoande�rV kutchener.ca; 519-741-2200 x7987). ..............................�............. ............................................. Christine Kompter Administrative Assistant I Planning Division I City of Kitchener 200 King Street West, 6t" Floor I P.O. Box 1118 Kitchener ON N2G 4G7 519-741-2200 ext. 7425 1 TTY 1-866-969-9994 christine.kompter@kitchener.ca Disclaimer - This email and any files transmitted with it are confidential and contain privileged or copyright information. You must not present this message to another party without gaining permission from the sender. If you are not the intended recipient you must not copy, distribute or use this email or the information contained in it for any purpose other than to notify us. If you have received this message in error, please notify the sender immediately, and delete this email from your system. We do not guarantee that this material is free from viruses or any other defects although due care has been taken to minimize the risk. Any views expressed in this message are those of the individual sender, except where the sender specifically states them to be the views of the Waterloo Catholic District School Board. Page 69 of 164 Staff Report J IKgc.;i' r� R Development Services Department www.kitchener.ca REPORT TO: Planning and Strategic Initiatives Committee DATE OF MEETING: April 3, 2023 SUBMITTED BY: Garett Stevenson, Interim Director of Planning, 519-741-2200 ext. 7070 PREPARED BY: Brian Bateman, Senior Planner, 519-741-2200 ext. 7869 WARD(S) INVOLVED: Ward 2 DATE OF REPORT: March 7, 2023 REPORT NO.: DSD -2023-120 SUBJECT: 7 Morrison Road Official Plan Amendment Application OPA22/013/M/BB Zoning By-law Amendment Application ZBA22/024/M/BB Klondike Homes Ltd. RECOMMENDATION: That Official Plan Amendment Application OPA22/013/M/BB for Klondike Homes Ltd. requesting a change to the Land Use Designation on the parcel of land specified and illustrated on Schedule `A', be adopted, in the form shown in the Official Plan Amendment as Appendix "A", and accordingly forwarded to the Region of Waterloo for approval and; That Zoning By-law Amendment Application ZBA22/024/M/BB requesting to amend Zoning By-law 2019-051, for Klondike Homes Ltd. be approved in the form shown in the Proposed `Proposed By-law', and `Map No. 1' as Appendix `B'; and further That the Urban Design Brief, prepared by MHBC and attached as Appendix "C", be adopted, and that staff be directed to apply the Urban Design Report through the Site Plan Approval process. REPORT HIGHLIGHTS: • The purpose of this report is to evaluate and provide a planning recommendation regarding Official Plan and Zoning By-law Amendment Applications for the property located at 7 Morrison Road. • It is Planning staffs recommendation that these applications be approved. The proposed applications represent an opportunity to intensify land that addresses a need regarding a shortage of housing in our community. • Community engagement included: o circulation of a preliminary notice to property owners within 240 metres of the subject site; o installation of a large billboard notice sign on the property; o a neighbourhood meeting held on November 29, 2022; o follow up one-on-one correspondence with members of the public who responded to the circulation or saw the billboard sign; *** This information is available in accessible formats upon request. *** Please call 519-741-2345 or TTY 1-866-969-9994 for assistance. Page 70 of 164 o notice advising of the statutory public meeting was circulated to all property owners within 240 metres of the subject site, and those who responded to the preliminary circulation, and o notice of the public meeting was published in The Record on March 10, 2023. This report supports the delivery of core services. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: Klondike Homes Ltd. is seeking Official Plan and Zoning By-law Amendments to permit the development of multiple dwellings (stacked townhomes) containing 32 residential units. Staff recommends that the applications be approved. The subject property is identified as `Community Areas' on the City's Urban Structure (Map 2 - City of Kitchener Official Plan) and designated as `Low Rise Residential' (Map 3 - City of Kitchener Official Plan). The subject is zoned `Low Rise Residential Five (RES -5)' in Zoning By-law 2019-051. REPORT: The subject lands are located within the Centreville Chicopee neighbourhood adjacent to the Grand River Hospital — Freeport Health Centre and at the intersection of King Street East and Morrison Road. The site is bounded by a residential property to the north, the Grand River Hospital — Freeport Health Centre to the east, King Street East and rail corridor to the south, and Morrison Road to the west, as illustrated on Figure 1. The subject lands are approximately 0.35 hectares (3,500 square metres) in area with approximately 35 metres of frontage on Morrison Road. The subject lands abut a Canada Pacific Railway right-of-way to the south, sharing a lot line of approximately 85.4 metres. Currently, there is a single detached dwelling and a detached garage on the subject lands — see Figure 2. The residential building is currently vacant. These structures would be demolished as part of the proposed redevelopment. The lands on the opposite side of Morrison Road have been recently redeveloped with a stacked townhouse development. Access to the site is currently obtained via a driveway extending onto the property from Morrison Road. The surrounding neighbourhood includes a mix of land uses such as low rise residential, institutional, and open space. The development proposal provides for the establishment of two (2) stacked townhouse buildings on the subject lands. Each building would contain sixteen (16) dwelling units for a total of thirty-two (32) dwelling units on the site. Access to the property is proposed by a private road extending from Morrison Road. Parking is provided at a rate of 1.2 parking spaces per dwelling unit for a total of 39 parking spaces. Secure bicycle parking spaces are to be provided indoors, and adjacent to the common amenity area. A preliminary site plan is shown below in Figure 3. Over the course of the application, the plan has been modified to address technical comments from staff. The modified plan is shown in Figure 4. Revisions include increased interior side and rear yard setbacks and a decrease in overall number of parking spaces provided. The primary change is to increase the interior side yard setback from 3.0 metres to 4.8 metres along the northerly property limit to improve compatibility and to increase the amount of area for tree plantings. Building renderings are illustrated in Figure 5. Page 71 of 164 Figure 1 —Aerial Photo of Subject & Surrounding Lands (MHBU) Figure 2 — Existing Single Detached Dwelling 7 Morrison Road (Google Streetview) Page 72 of 164 PROJECT SITE STATISTICS AKiA Fl 1 II I PAHO } flit 04E4 I UNIT• 011 7PH1 I P,1 IRKPI 1 14 I /i Idi aI CHI S�P� fFNI IFh IMFI fBMNIN rli �d i.naf 111�r liylw EI IIL(IPtI�Vff IIrILRM1f+ISIMH� I,ICVl Ia.VAh Kif'1t:� .?1 I&IIP I. ,.: dy26:. k7 N;, WPI Figure 3 — Conceptual Site Plan (MHBC) Residenticall Residential Q / Residential o� °. j .Mw . 16 Umisw, 6 UmIs FTI, _4g aind Rwer ' Hospital .:7� tiGitirr WticrljL RtiCWzq lRe9, Rd, 8) ---------------- Figure 4 —Revised Site Plan (MHBC) Page 73 of 164 Figure 5 — Proposed Rendering (MHBC) Planning Analysis: Proposed Official Plan Amendment To accommodate the proposed development, an amendment to the Official Plan is requested to increase the permitted Floor Space Ratio (FSR) in the Low -Rise Residential land use designation. In this designation, the City's Official Plan states that the maximum permitted FSR is 0.6. Policy 15.D.3.11 states that site-specific increases to allow up to a maximum FSR of 0.75 may be considered without the need for an OPA, where it can be demonstrated that the increase is compatible and meets the general intent of the policies of the Official Plan. Given the sloping lands and grade change across the site, the redevelopment of the subject lands proposes a FSR of 0.9, thus an OPA is required. It is important to note here that the OPA is not requesting a change of land use but rather seeking a site-specific policy area to the existing Low Rise Residential designation to permit an increase in FSR to 0.9 from 0.6. Provincial Policy Statement, 2020 The Provincial Policy Statement (PPS) provides policy direction on matters of provincial interest related to land use planning and development. Section 1.4.3 (d) of the PPS promotes densities for new housing which efficiently use land, resources, infrastructure, and public service facilities. The PPS sets out a policy framework for sustainable healthy, liveable, and safe communities. The PPS promotes efficient development and land use patterns, as well as accommodating an appropriate mix of affordable and market-based residential dwelling types with other land uses, while supporting the environment, public health, and safety. Provincial policies promote the integration of land use planning, growth management, transit -supportive development, intensification, and infrastructure planning to achieve cost-effective development patterns, optimization of transit investments, and standards to minimize land consumption and servicing costs. Planning staff is of the opinion that the proposed application will contribute to an appropriate mix of housing types within the context of the surrounding neighbourhood. The subject lands are within an existing neighbourhood with adequate servicing capacity, road network capacity, and other required infrastructure and therefore represents a cost-effective infill project that minimizes land consumption Page 74 of 164 and servicing costs. There are a variety of low-rise residential uses throughout the immediate areas. Based on the above, staff is of the opinion that this proposal is in conformity with the PPS. A Place to Grow: Growth Plan for the Greater Golden Horseshoe, 2020 (Growth Plan): The Growth Plan supports the development of complete and compact communities that are designed to support healthy and active living, make efficient use of land and infrastructure, provide for a range, and mix of housing types, jobs, and services, at densities and in locations which support transit viability and active transportation. Policy 2.2.6.1(a) Municipalities will support housing choice through the achievement of the minimum intensification and targets in this plan by identifying a diverse range and mix of housing options and densities, including additional residential units and affordable housing to meet projected needs of current and future residents. Policy 2.2.1.4(c) This plan will support the achievement to provide a diverse range and mix of housing options within the city. The proposed multiple dwelling residential development will provide a greater mix of housing types in the neighbourhood and. Planning staff is of the opinion that the development proposal conforms to the Growth Plan. Regional Official Plan (ROP), 2010: Urban Area policies of the ROP identify that the focus of the Region's future growth will be within the Urban Area. The subject lands are designated Built -Up Area in the ROP. The proposed development conforms to Policy 2.D.1 of the ROP as this neighbourhood provides for the physical infrastructure and community infrastructure to support the proposed residential development, including transportation networks, municipal drinking -water supply and wastewater systems, and a broad range of social and public health services. Regional policies require the City to plan for a range of housing in terms of form, tenure, density, and affordability to satisfy the various physical, social, economic, and personal support needs of current and future residents. Regional staff have indicated that they have no objections to the proposed applications (Attachment `E'). Planning staff are of the opinion that the application conforms to the Regional Official Plan. City of Kitchener Official Plan: Urban Structure The subject lands are identified as a `Community Areas' in the City's Urban Structure (Map 2). The planned function of Community Areas is to provide residential uses as well as non-residential supporting uses intended to serve the immediate residential areas. Community Areas may have limited intensification with development being sensitive and compatible with the character, form, and planned function of the surrounding context. Page 75 of 164 Land Use Designation The subject lands are designated `Low Rise Residential' in the City's Official Plan (Map 3). Low Rise Residential areas are intended to accommodate a full range of low-density housing types including single detached, semi-detached, townhouse, and low-rise multiple dwellings. The Low -Rise Residential designation states that the City will encourage and support the mixing and integrating of innovative and different forms of housing to achieve and maintain a low-rise built form. No buildings shall exceed 3 storeys or 11 metres in height. However, policy 15D.3.12 does support an increase in building height due to unusual slopes providing it is compatible with surrounding lands. An Official Plan amendment is required to increase the permitted FSR from 0.75 to 0.9. The proposed development intends to develop a low-rise multiple dwelling building which is permitted in the Low -Rise Residential designation. and an FSR of 0.9. Moreover, the design, massing, and scale of the development is consistent with adjacent multiple dwelling and townhouse developments. Scale and massing comparisons can be made between the proposed development and similar projects on Grand River Boulevard, Morgan Avenue, the Chicopee Terrace development at 15 Hofstetter Avenue, and the Morrison Woods Development at 24 Morrison Road. The increase in FSR is attributed more to the fact that the subject lands are sloped thus exposing partially below grade ground floor area which must be calculated in the FSR calculation. If the subject lands were flat, then FSR would be closer to 0.6. The slope of the subject land exposing more floor area is a technical consideration and therefore any impact is considered negligible. As such, Planning staff is of the opinion that the requested Official Plan Amendment proposing an increase in FSR will facilitate a housing form that conforms with the Low -Rise Residential land use designation in the City's Official Plan for the reasons stated above. Transportation The City's Official Plan contains policies to develop, support, and maintain a complete, convenient, accessible, and integrated transportation system that incorporates active transportation, public transit, and accommodates vehicular traffic. In regard to alternate modes of transportation, objectives of the Official Plan include promoting land use planning and development that is integrated and conducive to the efficient and effective operation of public transit and encourages increased ridership of the public transit system. The City shall promote and encourage walking and cycling as safe and convenient modes of transportation. The proposed development aims to increase density on an existing site that is served well by public transit, with access to Grand River Transit Route 27 and Express Route 206. The proposed development concept includes provision of safe, secure indoor bicycle storage to encourage active transportation. Staff is of the opinion that the requested amendments conform with the transportation policies of the City's Official Plan. Urban Design The City is committed to achieving a high standard of urban design, architecture, and place -making to positively contribute to quality of life, environmental viability and economic vitality. Urban design is a vital component of city planning and goes beyond the visual and aesthetic character of individual buildings and considers the functionality and compatibility of development as a means of strengthening complete communities. Urban Design policies in the 2014 Official Plan support creating visually distinctive and identifiable places, structures and spaces that contribute to a strong sense of place and community pride, a distinct character and community focal points that promote and recognize excellence and innovation in architecture, urban design, sustainable building design and landscape design. Page 76 of 164 The City requires a high-quality urban design of development applications. The subject lands have been designed in accordance with the policies in the Official Plan and with the principles of the Urban Design Manual. These are outlined in the attached Urban Design Brief and will be used to direct the development through a future site plan application. Some of the key highlights are high quality design and construction, transit supportive development, positive streetscape edge and enhanced landscape design. The proposed development requires site plan approval and will be subject to further review. Housinci The City's primary objective with respect to housing in the Official Plan is to provide for an appropriate range, variety and mix of housing types and styles, densities, tenure, and affordability to satisfy the varying housing needs of our community through all stages of life. This low-rise multiple dwelling proposal is a "missing middle" housing type and provides an option that bridges the gap between high density residential towers and single detached dwellings. The proposed housing type is an important segment in Kitchener's housing continuum. Policy 4.C.1.8 states that where special zoning regulations are requested, proposed, or required to facilitate residential intensification or a redevelopment of lands, the overall impact of the special zoning regulations will be reviewed, but not limited to the following to ensure, that: a) Any new buildings and any additions and/or modifications to existing buildings are appropriate in massing and scale and are compatible with the built form and the community character of the established neighbourhood. b) Where front yard setback reductions are proposed for new buildings in established neighbourhoods, the requested front yard setback should be similar to adjacent properties and supports and maintain the character of the streetscape and the neighbourhood. c) New additions and modifications to existing buildings are to be directed to the rear yard and are to be discouraged in the front yard and side yard abutting a street, except where it can be demonstrated that the addition and/or modification is compatible in scale, massing, design, and character of adjacent properties and is in keeping with the character of the streetscape. d) New buildings, additions, modifications, and conversions are sensitive to the exterior areas of adjacent properties and that the appropriate screening and/or buffering is provided to mitigate any adverse impacts, particularly with respect to privacy. e) The lands can function appropriately and not create unacceptable adverse impacts for adjacent properties by providing both an appropriate number of parking spaces and an appropriate landscaped/amenity area on the site. Policy 4.C.1.9 states that residential intensification and/or redevelopment within existing neighbourhoods will be designed to respect existing character. A high degree of sensitivity to surrounding context is important in considering compatibility. Policy 4.C.1.12 notes that the City favours a land use pattern which mixes and disperses a full range of housing types and styles both across the city as a whole and within neighbourhoods. Policy 4.C.1.22 encourages the provision of a range of innovative housing types and tenures such as rental housing, freehold ownership and condominium ownership including common element condominium, phased condominium, and vacant land condominium, as a means of increasing housing choice and diversity. Staff is of the opinion that the development proposal is functional and at a scale and massing consistent with surrounding lands. Appropriate buffers to the adjacent property have been established and impacts associated with proposed special regulations for rear yard, height and FSR are considered minimal. Page 77 of 164 Cultural Heritage Resources This property is located immediately adjacent to Freeport Hospital, which is considered a Cultural Heritage Resource. As such, in accordance with policy 12.C.1.23, a Heritage Impact Assessment HIA) is required. An HIA has been submitted, reviewed, and accepted by Heritage Staff. Policy Conclusion Planning staff are of the opinion that the proposed Official Plan/Zoning By-law amendment is consistent with policies of the Provincial Policy Statement, conforms to the Growth Plan for the Greater Golden Horseshoe, the Regional Official Plan, and the City of Kitchener Official Plan, and represents good planning. Proposed Zoning By-law Amendment: The subject lands are zoned `Low Rise Residential Five Zone (RES -5)' in Zoning By-law 2019-051. This zone permits the use of a multiple dwelling subject to meeting zoning and parking regulations. The applicant has requested to change the zoning from 'Low Rise Residential Five Zone (RES -5)' to 'Low Rise Residential Five Zone (RES -5) with Site Specific Provision (361)' in Zoning By-law 2019-051. The table below illustrates the zoning, parking, and bicycle regulations and whether or not the proposal complies. Justification is provided where a regulation is not being met and why. These are highlighted in bold. Page 78 of 164 Minimum Lot Area 495 mZ 3,522 mZ Complies Minimum Lot Width 19.0 m 35.6 m Complies Minimum Front Yard Setback 4.5 m 6.4 m Complies Minimum Interior Side Yard Setbacks 3.0 m 4.8 m/20m Complies Minimum Rear Yard Setback 7.5 m 6.0 m The rear yard backs onto a treed portion of Freeport Hospital lands. Impacts are negligible. Maximum Height 11.0m 11.0 to 11.5m Due to the slope from the highest of the lands and grade and 13.5 m how height is to the lowest measured. This grade complies with policy 15.D. 3.12 of the OP that supports relief in height due unusual grade conditions. Maximum Floor Space Ratio 0.6 0.9 Due to slope of lands and how FSR is measured. Notwithstanding, the scale and massing is consistent with adjacent multiple dwellings Page 78 of 164 Maximum Number of Storeys 3 3 Complies Minimum Landscaped Area 20% 41.4% Complies Private Patio Area 8 8 Complies Minimum Parking Rate 1.0 / unit 1 / unit Complies Maximum Parking Rate 1.4 / unit 1.4 / unit Complies Total Parking Required 32-45 spaces 39 spaces Complies Visitor Parking Rate 0.15/unit 0.15/unit Complies Visitor Parking Requirements 5 spaces 5 spaces Complies Barrier Free Parking Rate 2 spaces 2 spaces Complies Class A Bicycle Parking Requirement 13 spaces 16 spaces (incl. 8 garage) Complies Class B Bicycle Parking Requirement 6 6 Complies WHAT WE HEARD 2 people provided comments ''����DJI�IIIIUIIVIIIo 1 Neighbourhood Meetings held 270 households circulated and notified Department and Agency Comments: Preliminary circulation of the Zoning By-law Amendment was undertaken in October 2022 to applicable City departments and other review authorities. No major concerns were identified by any commenting City department or agency. Copies of the comments are found in Attachment "E" of this report. The following reports and studies were considered as part of this proposed Official Plan and Zoning By-law Amendments: • Planning Justification Report; • Urban Design Report; • Tree Management Report; • Preliminary Building Elevation Drawings; • Preliminary Floor Plans; • Preliminary Grading Plan; • Functional Servicing Report; • Water Distribution Report; • Functional Stormwater Report; • Environmental Noise Study; • Truck Turning Templates; • Scoped TIS; and • Sustainability Statement Page 79 of 164 Community Input and Staff Response: Staff received written responses from two (2) residents with respect to the proposed development. These can be found in Attachment `F'. A summary of what we heard, and staff responses are noted below. What We Heard Staff Comment Traffic on Morrison Road is busy, A Traffic Study was submitted and reviewed by staff. The this development will make it worse development will generate twelve am and twelve pm peak hour trips which are considered minimal. Under the forecasted 2028 Future Total Traffic Volumes, Morrison Road at the site access point is operating with sufficient vehicle capacity, vehicle delays not exceeding criteria and no vehicle queueing concerns in either the AM or PM peak hours. Also, there are no recommendations to provide additional physical capacity near this access in response to the site generated traffic. The proposed site access location provides sufficient stopping sight distance for oncoming vehicles along Morrison Road. Also, the traffic generated by this development will have minimal impact on the surround road network. Safety Concerns As mentioned above, the site access location was assessed and deemed acceptable from a site visibility standpoint. With respect to the railway tracks, CP Railway was notified of the proposal, and it advised staff that it has no concerns (see Attachment E). A Noise and Vibration Study was prepared, and it has been reviewed and approved by the Region of Waterloo. Any design mitigation measures, and warning clauses will be implemented through the site plan and condominium approval processes, respectively. Impacts to Property Values Assessing the impacts to property values is not a planning consideration. Planning applications are reviewed based on the principles of `good planning' in the public interest which includes policy direction, serviceability, and functionality of the proposal. Future Development Plans Like the subject property, the adjacent lands addressed as 25, 33 and 41 Morrison Road, are zoned RES -5 which permits the development of single and semi-detached dwellings and low-rise multiple dwelling forms of housing such as apartments and townhomes either rental or condominium tenure. Criteria for Approval/Rejection of Staff makes a professional planning recommendation in an Application the form of a staff report to PSIC Committee, and a decision is rendered by the Committee/Council to either recommend approval or refusal of the application to Council. Council's decision is subject to an appeal process to the Ontario Land Tribunal. Sidewalks Presently, there are no sidewalks along this section of Morrison Road. However, the plan is to have sidewalk Page 80 of 164 installed for 7 Morrison Road at the time of construction. The City will evaluate future sidewalks through the Sidewalk Infill Policy and workplan. Planning Conclusions: In considering the foregoing, staff are supportive of the Zoning By-law amendment. Staff is of the opinion that the subject application is consistent with policies of the Provincial Policy Statement, conform to Growth Plan for the Greater Golden Horseshoe, the Regional Official Plan, and the City of Kitchener Official Plan and represent good planning. Staff recommends that the Zoning By-law Amendment application be approved. The proposed application represents an opportunity to provide `missing middle' housing that addresses a need in our community. STRATEGIC PLAN ALIGNMENT: The recommendation of this report supports the achievement of the City's strategic vision through the delivery of core service. FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS: There are no financial implications associated with this recommendation. COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT: INFORM — This report has been posted to the City's website with the agenda in advance of the Council / Committee meeting. A large billboard notice sign was posted on the property and information regarding the application was posted to the City's website. Following the initial circulation referenced below, an additional courtesy notice of the public meeting was circulated to all property owners within 240 metres of the subject lands, those responding to the preliminary circulation and Notice of the Public Meeting was posted in the Waterloo Region Record on March 10, 2023 (a copy of the Notice may be found in Attachment `D'). CONSULT — The proposed Zoning By-law Amendment was originally circulated to property owners within 240 metres of the subject lands on October 25, 2022. In response to this circulation, staff received written responses from 2 residents, which are included in Attachment `E'. A Neighbourhood Meeting was held on November 29, 2022, and attended by approximately 3 residents. PREVIOUS REPORTS/AUTHORITIES: • Zoning By-law 2019-051 • Official Plan, 2014 • Regional Official Plan, 2010 • Provincial Policy Statement, 2020 • Planning Act, 1990 • A Place to Grow Growth Plan, 2020 REVIEWED BY: Tina Malone -Wright— Interim Manager of Development Review, Planning Division APPROVED BY: Justin Readman - General Manager, Development Services ATTACHMENTS: Attachment A — Proposed Official Plan Amendment Attachment B — Proposed Zoning By-law Amendment Attachment C — Urban Design Brief Attachment D — Newspaper Ad Attachment E — Department & Agency Comments Attachment F Community Consultation Comments Page 81 of 164 AMENDMENT NO. XX TO THE OFFICIAL PLAN OF THE CITY OF KITCHENER CITY OF KITCHENER 7 Morrison Road Page 82 of 164 AMENDMENT NO. XX TO THE OFFICIAL PLAN OF THE CITY OF KITCHENER 7 Morrison Road 10101WV4 SECTION 1 TITLE AND COMPONENTS SECTION 2 PURPOSE OF THE AMENDMENT SECTION 3 BASIS OF THE AMENDMENT SECTION 4 THE AMENDMENT APPENDICES APPENDIX 1 Notice of the Meeting of Planning and Strategic Initiatives Committee of April 3, 2023 APPENDIX 2 Minutes of the Meeting of Planning and Strategic Initiatives Committee — April 3, 2023 APPENDIX 3 Minutes of the Meeting of City Council — April 17, 2023 Page 83 of 164 AMENDMENT NO. XX TO THE OFFICIAL PLAN OF THE CITY OF KITCHENER SECTION 1 — TITLE AND COMPONENTS This amendment shall be referred to as Amendment No. XX to the Official Plan of the City of Kitchener. This amendment is comprised of Sections 1 to 4 inclusive and Schedule `A'. SECTION 2 — PURPOSE OF THE AMENDMENT The purpose of this amendment is to add a site-specific policy and amend Map 5 of the 2014 Official Plan to increase the maximum permitted density on the subject lands to facilitate the redevelopment of the lands at 7 Morrison Road with a stacked townhouse development with 32 dwelling units. SECTION 3 — BASIS OF THE AMENDMENT The subject lands are located at 7 Morrison Road. The subject lands are designated Low Rise Residential in the 2014 City of Kitchener Official Plan. The Low Rise Residential designation encourages a range of low density housing, including street and cluster townhouse forms, at a maximum net density of 30 units per hectare over the entirety of lands designated Low Rise Residential to a maximum Floor Space Ratio (FSR) of 0.6. The Official Plan supports an increase in FSR to 0.75 without an amendment to the plan. An Official Plan Amendment is required to add a Site -Specific Policy to permit a maximum Floor Space Ratio (FSR) of 0.9 to facilitate the redevelopment of the lands with a 32 -unit stacked townhouse development and a requirement for a Holding Provision. The subject lands are located in the Centreville/Chicopee neighbourhood. The proposed development includes a low density residential development that will provide another form of low density housing within an established community. The lands are identified as a `Community Areas' on Map 2 — Urban Structure in the Official Plan. The planned function of Community Areas is to provide for residential uses as well as non-residential supporting uses intended to serve the immediate residential areas. Lands within Community Areas may be designated as Low Rise Residential, Medium Rise Residential, High Rise Residential, Open Space, Institutional and/or Major Infrastructure and Utilities. Limited intensification may be permitted within Community Areas in accordance with the applicable land use designation and the Urban Design Policies in the Official Plan. The proposed development must be sensitive to and compatible with the character, form and planned function of the surrounding context. The Official Plan Supports an appropriate range, variety and mix of housing types and styles, densities, tenure and affordability to satisfy the varying housing needs of our community through all stages of life. The City favours a land use pattern which mixes and disperses a full range of housing types and styles both across the city as a whole and within neighbourhoods. Page 84 of 164 The Official Plan contains policies to consider when a site-specific zoning regulation is proposed to facilitate residential intensification or a redevelopment of lands. The overall impact of the site-specific zoning regulations will be reviewed by the City to ensure: — That any new buildings and any additions and/or modifications to existing buildings are appropriate in massing and scale and are compatible with the built form and the community character of the established neighbourhood, — That new buildings, additions, modifications and conversions are sensitive to the exterior areas of adjacent properties, and that the appropriate screening and/or buffering is provided to mitigate any adverse impacts, particularly with respect to privacy, and — That the lands can function appropriately and not create unacceptable adverse impacts for adjacent properties by providing both an appropriate number of parking spaces and an appropriate landscaped/amenity area on the site. The design, massing, and scale of the development is consistent with adjacent multiple dwelling and townhouse developments. Density, scale, and massing comparisons can be made between the proposed development and similar nearby projects on Grand River Boulevard, Morgan Avenue, the Chicopee Terrace development at 15 Hofstetter Avenue, and the Morrison Woods Development at 24 Morrison Road. The increase in FSR is attributed more to the fact that the subject lands are sloped thus exposing more ground floor area which is counted towards the FSR calculation. If these lands were flat, then FSR would be more in line with 0.6 rather than 0.9. As such, this is more of a technical consideration and therefore any impact is considered negligible. Furthermore, the conceptual site plan has been modified to provide increased interior side and rear yard setbacks to address buffering and planting considerations. The proposal is consistent with the Provincial Policy Statement, conforms to the Growth Plan and complies with the Regional Official Plan, as it promotes intensification within the built boundary, and a development that is transit- supportive, that maximizes the use of existing and new infrastructure, and assists in development of this area as a compact and complete community through the broad range of uses. SECTION 4 — THE AMENDMENT The 2014 City of Kitchener Official Plan is hereby amended as follows: a) Part D, Section 15.D.12 Area Specific/Site Specific Policy Areas is amended by adding new 15.D.12.60 thereto as follows: 15.D.12.60. 7 Morrison Road Notwithstanding the Low Rise Residential land use designation and policies on lands municipally known as 7 Morrison Road: a) the maximum permitted Floor Space Ratio (FSR) will be 0.9. b) a Holding provision pursuant to Section 17.E.13 of the Official Plan will apply to residential uses, day care uses and other sensitive uses. The Holding provision will Ig@gfftg6 of 164 through a by-law amendment and will not be removed until such time as a Record of Site Condition has been acknowledged by the Province and an Updated Environmental Noise Study has been approved by the Region and a release has been issued by the Region for both an RSC and Updated Noise Study. c) Part F, Map 5 — Specific Policy Areas is amended by adding Site - Specific Policy Area No. 60 to the lands municipally known as 7 Morrison Road, in the Area of Amendment, as shown on the attached Schedule `A'. Page 86 of 164 APPENDIX 1 Notice of the Meeting of Planning and Strategic Initiatives Committee of April 3, 2023 NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING for a development in your Ineighbourhood lei 7 Morrison Road Curicept Drawkig Have Your Voice Heard Date. April 3. 2023 Tir-rie, 7:00 Ip.m. Location: Couniell Chambers, Kitchener City HIal 1 200, King Street West or,Virtual Zoom, Meeting, To viiew the staff report, agenda, nj'ieeting detai4s, start time of this iteriI or to appear" as a delegation, vii t. - To learn more abort this project,, inclu6ng information on YOUr appeal dghts, visit-, www.kitcheiner.ca/ PlanningAPPlications or contact: f S�D�i�:e ' e k iroti Brian Bateman, Senior Planner "dE �0 �'l E. t 1� 'E� S, S! C 519.741.2200 x 78,69 6. 0 1`1 E� t e brilaiibaternan( kitchener.ca The pity of Ochener will consider applIcations- to arijierid the it Official Plan arid Zoning , By-law to add a site-specilfic proOsion to increase the IRoor Space Patio (FSR) frorn, 0.6 to 0. 9, to permit a redUCed rear and setback of 5.5, metres instead of the required 75 metres, arid! to permit a 110 percent visitor parking rate to facilitate the developrrient of 32 stacked townhOlLlse UrlitS w,iith ark4ig spaces. Page 87 of 164 APPENDIX 2 Minutes of the Meeting of Planning and Strategic Initiatives Committee — April 3, 2023 Page 88 of 164 APPENDIX 3 Minutes of the Meeting of City Council — April 17, 2023 Page 89 of 164 Z a mm /yam m m u m a d \ O N W W Z Q Z Q O a O o Q J U \ N Q N Q z vIL H J H J N a > o 0_-O CO N L a Y Q Z O WcQ o O H ^ Z � Va Q L o Z w zO 2 OZ v V Q N = Q z W Of QW Vi d N acLL S w 0a F O Q Q LLLI a m >%W — — V O �'`I\VIIIIIIIIII \ LL LL Z J W O > SII O N o rn 0 w CO w _ 0 LO N C) N O U W p � p = tGp W 2i V) ()� �-7 (o Q r c C7 r Y 0 RNe� J LI Grad (U Q J � U W J ~ W Z Q O U0 d Y O cnJ Y CO '�`yiby 2 BY-LAW NUMBER OF THE CORPORATION OF THE CITY OF KITCHENER (Being a by-law to amend By-law No. 2019-051, as amended, known as the Zoning By-law for the City of Kitchener — Klondike Homes Ltd. — 7 Morrison Road) WHEREAS it is deemed expedient to amend By-law 2019-051 for the lands specified above; NOW THEREFORE the Council of The Corporation of the City of Kitchener enacts as follows: 1. Schedule Number 262 of Appendix "A" to By-law 2019-051 is hereby amended by changing the zoning applicable to the parcel of land specified and illustrated as Area 1 on Map No. 1, in the City of Kitchener, attached hereto, from Low Rise Residential Five Zone (RES -5) to Low Rise Residential Five Zone (RES -5) with Site Specific Provision (361) and Holding Provision 42H. 2. Section 19 of By-law 2019-051 is hereby amended by adding Section (361) thereto as follows: "361. Within the lands zoned RES -5 and shown as affected by this subsection on Zoning Grid Schedule Number 262 of Appendix'A' the following shall apply: i) The maximum Floor Space Ratio (FSR) shall be 0.9; ii) The maximum permitted building height shall be 13.5 metres from the lowest grade; iii) The minimum rear yard setback shall be 6.0 metres; iv) A prohibition on geothermal energy systems as defined in the Region of Waterloo Official Plan." 1 Page 91 of 164 3. Section 20 of By-law 2019-051 is hereby amended by adding Section (42H) thereto as follows: "42H. Notwithstanding Section 7 of this Bylaw, within the lands zoned RES -5 (361) and shown as being affected by this subsection on Zoning Grid Schedule Number 262 of Appendix "A", only those uses which lawfully existed on the date of passing of this By-law, shall be permitted to continue until such time as this Holding Provision is removed by by-law once the City of Kitchener is in receipt of a letter from the Regional Municipality of Waterloo, advising that the Region's requirements have been satisfied with respect to the submission of a Record of Site Condition and a detailed Noise Study." 4. This By-law shall become effective only if Official Plan Amendment No. XX, 7 Morrison Road comes into effect, pursuant to Section 24(2) of The Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.13, as amended. 2023. PASSED at the Council Chambers in the City of Kitchener this day of Mayor Clerk 2 Page 92 of 164 Z W z �? p a O N LU_O z W W Z W p LU _ w^ F ZOz Q O N O N J� LLN J Z� I M w w N N Lu w 0 Z o Q 0 m O Q W Z Z (n > Z W W O O r IN Q �./� W m m N r Z WO N O _Q Q Q � LU J m N D J Q> Z Q H H H Q Z w Z z z 0 Q Q Z J N O \ \ � Q w HO0 z�— U 0 W W W 'LLJ if 7: o0In W Q U } rn = U) N M C7 v) of oU> gD 2 www w O~ O� O z Q m LU u) LL O H 2 �-' �-' z LU W N- z CN O Z O H rr WUa (If Lu in �J www oU z Q fn (n Cn W L Qz WN WQ- p z o Q N Q LJ Q 3: (1) Fr� wQ Z) X�� �zXN O O o U) m Q ^+ a W H U Wz 0 F o oU O F N O Q O O O �W0W N LLL J Z w N a F z JO z LU Z O (^D2 7 IM ZQCL g`�'O�O W WO�J=0 Q N W N V J UZ dJ (n Cn W�d2 i�"� Z2QU "� W Z i� fq w QQW W O�>z �H>Q } O 20 W W W m U z ZN o' of Of 00-L: "°i" Nu)OY W � Q d p 57,,��m"�fs�`/`��Illllllir�� '� Z �w �" �y� IIII� f r r M " Q CWC G � > LU 2 � uuum "I " U) ' ��uupuuuuVuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuumumuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuui Z U / Z " Q Z ,' �q J �Lu � Z "� �" 1 0- � ♦a O pppW " I m V w 1 N 111111 "10 0 M"�"�iii'�{i��"�"�fi7 .-. m��M "I,.", ��", r" I Z > o �� VIII n .,..I�;,,,I�� �S"'y�"��,�iti� 1 _ Z _ LL NVHO uuuuuuuu r """ `' �'�� ' LL UVVV �'' ;,, "j N O Ijp o co I w �p � ��;� "tM "",�"y4 � �" , �� �, 0,0 p LO LnH W Of O O co I �F Q Q a C:) W J W Z U< Q 0� co U) 0 w I m cn w rl m rL OLU 70 ZO rl w Z O U) CO aLU o O U Q � z w� O�'� � J � umui a uii uuuuui j O O O � O i i LLJ --o m 0 w I U-) CY) (4-- (a) 0 0 0 Q) Q) Q) 4- 0 . 0 0 4- = 4- M > 0 0 0 .— - 4- (,)- m 0 Q) E m= -x Q) _0 Q u -7(D > Q) = > Q) 2 m o u 0 0 4- x _0 C) - 4 u 4- 0 co Q) M U > 4- 4- 4- -0 ra 4- 0 u _u 14- 0 0 m V) 4f 4- 0 (a) 0 4- Ln -0 o - Ln (1) 4- .4- 0 cll +- 00U Q) 0- 0 Q) m 4-- B ra �'5 -C U Ln 0 Q) u 0 LIJ m 0- x 4- 4- 0 --o Q) 4-- 0 0 u Q) V) 4- C �n Q) >, .- U� 0 0 �c -: Q) Q) - > 0 0 = > =3 V) n 0-_O Q) 0 > Q) U U u ru Q) 4-> Q) V) --0 C- M 4-% Ln Q) 4- x 0 Q) 0-) 4- Q) Q) 0 �n 0 Q) Ln (D Q) " 0 0 m n Q) Q) Q) 0 - Co 4-- "n Q) o 0 QJ o w 0 U 0 4- " 0 :�j 0 , 0 c- ra Ln �D 0 0 4- p a) Q) 10 1- -0 (D u >1 -0 m v> 0 - 0') - 140- -0 ry- Q) -0 -0 -0 0 0 L (D 4- o 4- Ln Ln 4 CO (D Vi Q) Q) Q 0 04- V) (D QJ 00 -0 .= — 0 E V) 0 CE Ln 0 14- 14- 0 = Ln u Ln E < Ln 0 O Ln 00 0 Q) 7-- c (D -0 u Cc U _0 E Ln Q) >1 U) Q) Ln Ln W vi Q) coW U M Q) -0 Ln Q) Ln rn — x 0 Q) = u E Q) m 0 4- > = 0- u 0 Cc Q) -C u .7 0- < E W u 0 4- ro co co Q) o Ln Q) Q) Ln v < Ln u 0 U 0 u Q) 0 4- 0 4•E .— Ln X 0 W 0 -T, (a) Q) M CD- -C — 0>, LLJ n N QJ --j V) co Q) 0 Q) m 4- 0 U) U 4-- 1 4- (1) >, 4f 0 (.n N 0 co m QJ E Q) U < 0 S �n 4-- W 4 - 4- m 4- m 0 0 Isom= 0 = (�n Q) M Lij 0) -§ CY) Q) 4- _ u 0 m 2 u -C (D N F— 4-1 Q) 0 4 ,f 4- � 0 O 4 Q14- D- Q) 4- ,u > q) -0 4- c (1) > 0" 4, 4- 4- 0 Q) Q) -,o Q) Q) u V ) 0 0 4- Ln M V) Q) C) Q) 4- 0 :) V) 0 =3 0 - Q) cr- 0 c- ra 0 n > Q) 0 Ln Q) CL (D CD 4L 0 Q) > < 4- 1� 0 2 4� Lr! 4- =4- =4- Q) (1) 0 C) Q) o -.0 4- u Q) Q) . u) Ln 0 0 C�: = L,) o V) V) - o D-- 4- (1) U Q) = 4 �E 4- 4- CU U E U Q) Co = 4- -0 4- 42) (1) -0 uQ Q) v- 0 Q) (1)4- (1) 4- 0 . ..... .. ..... ... Q) LLJ 0-) Q) U V 0 V C) 0 0,0- 4- -f2 4- LaJ) (2) Qn) cn M 4� 4- 2 E 76 4-- -0 0) Q) 4- > oL o ru V) 0 un 0 j� Q) _0 0 4- 'E U Q) 5 Q un E Q) WERE= 0 L -n _0 125 0 cn u E — F -0 4- 0 4-U 0 ass= 0 4- r -Cu (2) =3 r) j-0 L a)cu E CS0 4--; -0 m Q) Q) 4- cn U E (- kA .0-) 0 m (D LU 0- 4-1 0 Q) u 0 0 10- 0')-C 4- QJ V) D :Ll 0 4-- :L'- 10- 4- MomO 4L 0 Q) 4-' 0 0)v -0 >1 4- (A4 0 0 c 0 — 4t G >1 76 . 4- N- _0 V) Ln 79 *x 4- u 4- m Ln 4--; Ln — 0 Ln Q) U'u 4-- -0 E Q) 0 U) 4- .j :3 4- :D V) V) Q) Q) -C Z S 4- --o 0 (- U Q) QJ 4- 4 -LI) 4- (10 Ql _0 0 M 4-1 LU> 76 0 0 rQ) > I *;,--Q) 14- = 0 1-- 3: (a) (1) m -0 Q)0 4 - p1 >jV) o n(a)v) >, -0 4-- 0 j U �E 0 Q) E E E•Ln Q) V) m M (D E 0 4- 4- (- E - U -i m < U -i >' 4- X 0 V) M 0- 0 LLJ 4- m 0 U =0 E 0 n 0) _0 Q)uj 0 0 -0 .... .. ..... .. .. -C -f2 z ui CA M 4- 00 LLJ L/) (1) M 4- c _0 L/) Q) (1) L/) Q) (-) Q) 4- 0 c 0 4- E 0 4- 0 0 EE o o n 0 E o a 4- �i u 0-0 --o (D) G) > 4-- L/(a)� = =3 Q) QJ lJ CO Q) uo 0 = -5: E 4- 0 Ln 0 CO 0) 4- 4-- U Q) 0 4- 2! O Q� 0 u 0 -Fo E 1� 0 CD) = = u Q) -zD 4- QJ Ln J) c Ln 0 C o 0 _0 Q) �n 0 U = 0 0 0 u Q) DL X 2 (U u u Ln cr 0 Q) 4- 0 4- n F L/) m = 0 4- U V) co -1 (1) :3 M C 4-- o 0 0 (a) 0 LI) Ln 4- 0 LI) CD Q) n Ln 4- 4- 4- CN Q) co 0 Q)Q) C: QJ W 4- 0 Q) CO Q) 4 -- 0- 0 0 Ln Q) LD 0 4- E U4L- 4 - Ln u n MOM Ln 0 -LDw 4- 0 - 7C) 4- a) C)) 0 U z u (1) E Q) 4- Q) - Q) =3v_ >Q) > L/) 0 4- —.- -0 = = 1A 4Q) (1) 2! Q) < Q) 0 > H 4- m 4- cc 4- 4- > n 4 - 0 4- Q) Q) 4- u 2) 0 2 4- LI) o 14- 0 Q) 0 4-1 0 u 4- Q) 0 4- * Q) U 4L� 4Z V) 0 0 Q) n p _0 CO 4- U-) 4- 2c z -0 /) 4- 4- 4- -0 4- - co a ('U 4- m 0 4_ 0 u o4- 4-4- 4= V) 0 V) 0 (D o 7C) 0 0Q) 0 n U (o 0) u Ln -u -0 C -0 - 4 4-'-„ LI) Q) M LU 4- m (1) 0 Ll -C E 0 0 Q-) E = 4- 0 0 '7) U > 0 415) 5) -E Ln 4- 4- m 4- cc = o 4- - U4 C 0 (1) 4- 0 Q) \- m U M 4- 0 D- 0 E 0 -C) m 0 cr- 4- V) L/) u (a) o CN Q) 4 I 0 co 4- U') CL 7D m o 70-N , Q) _Q) 0 - 0 4- Q) = -0 Q) = Lf) _0 4- 0 u = 0 0 L/) 0-) - co 4- L/") 2 Q-) .> 4- 4t (a) 0 0 0 V) cy) Ln U Q� 0 ;- 4- u V� > Q) 0 4- > o 0- 5, j) Ln 4- Q) 4 Q) 7) u 0 V) Q) 0 U 0 0 (1) CU F. 0m E V) Q) Ln uj 4- 4- 0 - > (1) . U u u > Q) u — > 4� (1) (D Ln ffAVANM 0 4t L/) Ln 0 14- ro L/) 4- Q) u 4- 0 F U 0 LI) 4- U u C) V) 0 __j X V) (1) 4- (1) Co = u co 0 m E -M 0 (D U 4-- 4- u E D Q) 0 0 Q) Q) 0 CD Lo Q) = 4- 0QJ L/) 4- 0 C u L/) u U - -0 -;- 0 0 4- co 0 4- Q) 4- .('U Q) U > o -x �E > Q) 0 0 0 .§ 0 0 0 :t-_ 0 -0 (1) . ..... .. ..... .. 'n 0 2 = u 4- -0 2 m C:c " 0- 2 3: " L 0- D 4 ci mQJ 00 LLJ Q) 41 > E > vi Q) Q) 0 r Q.4-- u A-_ c: Ln 4 0 Q) u V) Q) u V) E v 0 E Ln E4- V) 4t CD- Q) > Q) Q) E 0 u Ln Q) V) -0 u Q) Z Q) �n 4- E Q) 0 IA(D > Q) V� 0 Z 4-- Q) M U Q) > I L/� V) 0- x 4-V) E Q) Ln Q) %I.- 0 4- m 0 u E V) Q) CD- CT V) C) Q) Q) (1) 0 4- 75. 4- 4 > 0 > 0 L) (13 U 4- L/) r E CL 4� CD - E 0 C) Q) 0 V) u 14- E E -40- 0 e, m o —Q) ry- 0 (1) U) 4- V) 0 u (1) V) V) 4- m Q) - +- 4-- w J 0 Q. 4A #A 0 C 0 m 4- > V) (1) m 00 1, 4� c >, OL 4- Q) -"U -0 4- u u E Ln mani= a 0 & 0 - C-) (1) Q) 2 (3) = 14- 0 Q) 0- 2) V) (A C- 0 E c 0 V) uj -a E 0 4 40 m Q) 4-c m 0 D- m = Q) c- 0) m V) .- co E -0 C- m V) C: CO LA 0 (a) u E V) AM% > 7:) -0 4= 0 0 (V 4- 14- V) Q) 0 U 4-- u Q) 4- Co 4-- V) z u -0 x (1) -= 4- E vi (2) 4- *G X 4t �n co 0 -1 4 -0 4- 75 (1) c) C) I rl (1) Cl) a U) 4-1 co0 U = Cl 4- u D M 4- ru4- u V) 4- u LU LLJ C m (1) DL .9 LIn M U U c LLJ -0 =- 4- co Ln 4- V) -C V) :.6 -i 4-Q) U) 41 V) 4- cu 4- 4- 0 4- E C) V) ca L, O u O 4- 4- E Ln � > 4 - 4-- tA 4-0 :D Ln Q) -.F,3 U) Q) E 0 pt 0 >° m -C 0 — a) - c 0 . E- ­ 4-- 0- E Q) E z cn 0 -0 0) E > Q) ;D CT 0 Q) Q) DL 0 - 0 E D +- 0) o D Q) > 4� C >, 0 0-) 0 u = E > CD- 0 (D +.# 4a Q) 0 Z E m = (10 4- 0 U 0 x 0 Q) > M Q) c 4t u Q) u 0 0 2 Rt Ln 0 E M M r� kk„d mom fr pt 47 a cl C�1 (1) (a) u un -0 00 ra -- 0 V) 0 (1) 4- 0- (a) V)aJ 0 _0 V) E ' W C) Q) U 0 m m 75 C5Q, Y 0 ca U-) E u 0 V) (D 4- V) Ln Q) 0 E 0 > 4� 0 0 C-) 1� .7 E 0 Q) 0 Ln u Ln u -1 04- CD - V) 0 6 v L/) 0 m (a) 4L 0 n u E 10 m \e - E (u 0 N CL 7)u V) .5 . - Q) E m — C Q - Y) 4J v u 0 --c (U 4-- E 0) Ln(D 4-- = =3 4- — 'E U di Ln V) 0 0 V) Q) Z) QJ > E u > 4- o < 0- 0 0 'n -0 —,- E - 0 V) 0) 0 -0 V) (D Ln 0- C6 ry� r U 0 V) -0 - +D M L . C-: 0) Q 2!- c Q) (a) 2 Q) Q) '7) E >, n Q) E4 m 4- ru �5 CD- Z-- 4- 4- CD- D 0 E -2 M u E 0 D 0 4L Ln Q) >1 a) 0 4-- 4- 0 x (D M U �n -0 (-n U-) Q) :) 0 -0 vc > 0 2! Ln Q --O Q) > u Q) V) 4- -,o S, n .- r- 0 u 4- u 0 Q) 0') Ln M -0 0 (a) E Q) Q) +- 3: �-D- = d 0 4- (3) C)- 0-) Q) V) E IL U u 0 V) -0 0 0 14- _0 0 Z3 (P 0 2 -0 4--0 14-- 0 Ln Q) 4- 0 L Q) QJ u (U Ln 0 V) 4- 0 tf 0- z u 0 0 cn u m 0 4- 73 0) 0 Q m - 0 4- -o '4- 0 Q) CD- 0- fZ 0 QJ C) vi -0 -0cu 0 m Q) 0 U Q) 0 4- (:6 0 Ln 0 ,Q 0 4-- iS Q 0- ) 0 V) 4-- U 0 Q) - N 0 0- Q� -71 0 uL7 = 0 U m 0 V) Q) LLJ 4- -0 m Q) E Q) -C +- 0 4- 0 4- Q) Ln - = Q) 0 0 m m 0 (U E V) Q) 0-- , 7, �: E > 0 4-- (U Q) 0 _0 ra 4- U E 0) �= M (a) 0 4- ,> -0 = 0 c- 4- 0 > • 0 4- j:j. 40 o n Ln LQ,)) 'n (- -0 V) 4- _0 Q) 0 0 U (1) Q) 4-v u 0 :3 0 0 > 0 z E 0 0- u Ln 0 0 U Q) I - C) -= Ln Q) 0 U V) C-'� 4- 0 u 4- V) U -0 .22, — * " 0 0- Q) w u 4- 0 u 4-- X — 0 14- 0 0 M U Q) Q) CD- Q) E a) _0 �4- u �n u Q) _0 0 0 0 '40- 0 uL/) —M Q) > 4-- 4- c E -V) 0 0) Q) V) 4 u u 0 -0 4-- - 4- , -0 3 Ln a) Q) Q) tA 0 Q) --C) 0.- o E Q) u E 0 0 0-.E Q) u 0 4- 0- 2 - +� 3: 0).9 X m m2 0') In InQ) 0 mu �_n --i< > 2 0) 0 0 E 0cn Q) -= .�2 -.0 < u CD 0 r - CD ro 77 Ln 12 uJ Ci z1LLJ <., I'll ILL 0 d^1F— LLJ LL: nl < Cc LLJ > rc I LJ 1 — ali E 0 + (1) - o 4- I,-- (a) 0- — 0 �n -0 4- -Fo E C 4- Lf) _0 = 0 (a) .- 14 E M0 4- raO M 0 (N C: '7/) C) LI) Ln �—n (a)aJ 0 Q) U V) NE 4- 4- 0 Q) > 47- Q) (1) --F 0 V) 0 �- o 4-- vo E Ln Ln o 0 E o4-1 E E (D Q) -0 E (0 2 - -) 0 v = -0 M 0 0 u U - D COLL O L-) Q) 1 (a) 0) Q) 0 u 4- (a) 0 4- c 14- � Ln 4- 0 c 0-140- V) E 0 4- Q) Q) 4- 0 > 7:) 0 U ru n co M 0 4 Q) 0 Q) V) -0 (13 > 0 V) QL u (, C) u (13 4� = — u V) -0 L,) M 4Z c x Q) :Ll Ln Q) 4- (1) 0-) 0 0) " - 0 (3) - _0 4- U 4--;' U (Z �n 0 " U 4- 4-- Cl x C) 4-- u u m 0 n -0 V) (1) 0 = 'o 0 V) V) (D 4- (2) v) V) Q) 0 (1) (2) V) 4-v (a) U V) _0 (1) oU V) 0) 4-- = = .0 4- U U 0 --ox Ln Q) V) 0 (1) -0 2) 4 -0 .- M — 0 - 0 LLJ U) - 4- 0 0 -0 '0 2 -T) w0 4- 4- 4- 4- O v=co ra Q) Q) = - C) v) 0 _0OO V) 0 NpcII 0-) 0- Q) 0 E E 4 4- -0 3: -LL) -0 Q) 4-; -0 a) =3 0 CT a) V) 4-1 0 Q) 0 0 Q) M Q) >, 4- -FD m , L 0 4- - 4- 4- E = 4- (0 -- 4- 40- E 4- L M Q) Q) > U o 0 4- 0 U V) 6 LI) 4- .- �n X 7:3 Q) C .- -r) V� 0 CD.- C) 4- 4- co Q) 4- c U-) 0) E Q) 4- Ln (D Q) -0 0 0 u 0-) 14- LD �4- 0 u a) = 0) U-) E Q) 4-- Q) CD- 0 > Q) = cy� -0 _0 0 4- 4-- U (1) -0 aLn 4- r,-) 14---0-) (3) n 4- Q) U Q) (1) C)- Q) Q) E -0 Q) C) 4--; 40- o 7D Ln CD- co Q) 0 Q) u 4-- Q) 4- (D) (U (13 0-) -0 L13 4- V)O Cn 0c) 0 > 0 ry*) E u C 4- L/) E m n n Ln 0 Q) 4- 0 V) 0 X (a) " - M — 0 Q) - - 0) 4- ra -C Q 4- ui 0 T) 0 0 V) Q) +- r) n V) 4- V) V) 0 Q) M Q) > U W Q) V) M > 4- U (0 U -i CD- .- 4- = V) co E 0-) Ln 4- CD) 0 ra 4 U) 0 Z vi 4- > m .5 0 V) 4- Q) > cu 0 0 L/) CD- (D Q) V) u 7:3 > u Ln Q) 4- m Q) - 0 0 0 T) Q) CU >, ca u (1) co > -I- n3 (1) 4- L') V) �g 4- (L) m CD- - V) m 4- V) Q) C) 0 2 CD O U > CDL >, -0 V) . (3) 4.- 0 4 14-v n3 u 0 C3) "o 0 0-) (o o 42 -0 4- _0 4--0 0 �5 CD- �42) C) 4 U V) 4- (13 (o 0 0 14- 0 4- < Q) Ln Ql 4-O 4- -C 4- 0 0 Q) 0 C) Q) CD- - W 0 C) Sn- o - (10 0 c cl 0 0') 0 o - D 3: - Q) C: m C) Q) (-u C 4- C: 0 (1) Q) u Q) 2 r) (Y-) Q) n u +,f 0 r) V) (1) M (1) 0 �n 0 E >, Q) Q) Q) U Ln Q) V) :3 V) C u 0 Q) cc 0- 0 --o Q) 0 n m ra U ra M 14 0 C U Q) Q) 4-� u 2 0 m 'n 0 4- CD- m o 4- Ln Q) -C 4- L,n ru > 0 0 4-1 cn u V) 0 4-1 4- ra — Q) Ln (U 4- Q) 0 -0 0 +- co a) 4- U > u u o CC V) a) 0 co Q) (1) CD) > :3 (D mQ 0) 0 V) LD CY) =4- Itf 0 4- I�n Q) E u) 0 a) Q) 4- 0 LL 0 LL 4-0 . (Z 4- = . - (1) 0 0 >, 0 4-- 00 .5; (D W - - — -- = :2 > o 3� U-) Lu CQ7 0 u 0 c Q) c V) 4- V) < LWJ (1) Q) -0 Q) -73 Q) = Q) -0 L/ -i (1) >, 0 4- 4- 4- 4- 4- 4- 0 4- U) V) lJ (1) 0 0 un 4- 0 0 Ln 0 E �E ru 14- r, 4- 4- 4 0 4- 0 Q) L/) — 0 (1) 0 Q) Cl) 4- M Q) -0 -0 > LQJ u U) -0 4- 4- u (13O :L� w Ln c Q - cu u =3 Q) 4- 0 4- 4- = 4- u0 Lf) 0 0 — M 4- m L/) Ln m Q) x u E 0 QJ 0 V) ru u Q) (a) Q) 0 14- 0 C- 0 C V) U 4_ 4- Ln 2 �n o C: Q) co (o Q) (1) Q) > (1) (10 c (1) =3 - = (L) (T u u E V) 0 E �n — -Fz ()) 0 4L/') ci _0 V) 4- 4- M ';:; =3 0 (D w = 0 (1) 0 0 C) 140- Q) 4- M -0 E 4- 4- 0 v (/) 4- U -9 Z , 0- 2 co 2 U '4- 2 17, n -0 4-1 0 4-- Q) E m Q) m Ew0 m 0 4--j o Q) 0 X > 0 4-Q) Q) 4- 0 > M v c 0 Q) U o V) Ln > 4-- 0-0 Q) m > U 0 Ln >, �- ;- c 0--- Q) 4- 4- Q) 0 (10 0) ru =3 CD_ 4- 1 0 0 4-1 E immmm F 0 0- C w 4-1 0 u 4- -�= E Ln E 0 -0 Co C LU o Q) ru 4-- 4- V) X 0 Q) (U C- m Q) U U ru 4 - Ln 4- 076 Q) Ln 4-- W> C -0 L/) Ln 4- ui CD- - CD .0 /i 4- T- +- - -I- ;-- Q) 0- V� 0 C Q) Q (U c 0 -0 co E o E Q) 0DL 4- 0 u Q) O> Q) 0 Q) C)) Q) 0 U c 4 CU 4- -.0 m 0 4- (Z E -C 0 U) m LLJ u -0 0 0 Q) Q) E 4- --o -I-, 4- - ru _0 7) 0 uQ) 2 u 4- 4- Ln 0 Ln C Ln 4- 0u n -0 0 Ln -0 4- 'n ) m Q(D D 4-- Ltf -0 Ln 0 L/) n Q)i-- u 0 V) 0 4-1 0 Q) D_ -0 C) Ln 4- 0 7C) 4t 4- 0 4- m n tf 0 0 7j- u E --T) 0 > Q) Q) 4 E 0 > 0 _0 0- > V) cU -0 u CC 0 = m '4- 0 L! (D V) . L 0 .1 -0 4- 4 3: 0 E 4- 0 m �n - t . Q) 4-- Ln Q) Q) a) V) Q) 0 -1 v) E 0 4 m Ln 0 0- 0 4- G) = Ln 0 0-0 — — 0 0- Ln W E 0 Q) 0 > 0-,5: 0 _0 > 0 Ln (D Q) Q) Q) Ln E 0 U — >1 0 > W _0 R 0) D- D- Q) :E o Q� a) 4- 0� 0- 4- V) W 0 0 > 0) o-0 -0 a) 0 E Q) Q) Q) .0--) E -= - Q) Q) 0 = 0- �-n -0 -= m > cn 0-- L, 0- u 4 - �-- 0 It Q0 0 0 00 LLJ n 4- V) L/) 14- 0 n Q- Q) 0 4- n V) 4- 76 c - Q) = C- Q) Q) Q) E 0 4- co n 4-m E V) 4-1 > 0 Ln 0 v 0 0 0 > Ln Q) +- m U 0 4 - _0 Ln oU Ln 4t Q) Q) N 4-- QJ 4- 4- 0 E 00 Q) =5 V) 14- 0 N Ln cu E V) 0 0 Ln Q) -0 Ln m sa W 0 0 o n E Q) >1 U — o u E Q) 75 2 En 0 -5 3: = .X m W 0 = > 4- 0 4- 0 L/) < E 4_ 4- 4- 0 4 '40 0 W (D N Q) E L/) 0 c 0Ln — —v C x 0 0 0 v v 0 u D- (1) 0 -0 - (1) 4- m OV u u 4- 0 0 4- 0 E O 0 (a) > 0 QJ > co 4- V Q) -0 o- 0 Ln 0- 0 E E5) o 11) z > Q (1) Q) 4- (1) 4- 0 Q) = 4- 4 -0 14- -0 v F- Q) Ln co Q) LLJ Q) -0 E 0 D-0 0- L/) 0 n M 0 4-- 5) 2 n (1) Q) -0 0 n o > -0 4- m Q) 0-n Q) ro 0 4- L/) c- 0 Q) (�n (1 .- = 0 = 0 u %F-- 4- Ln 14- 0 0) G) c > U rU M 4- 0 4- n Q) _0 Q)L/) C- 0 0 0- 4- V) n z 0 . 4- 4- 0 0 0 n L/) DL 0 n D L/) 4- . U CU — rac 4- Co �n 4- 4- D u V) ra V) 0- 4- m Q ) -a () E 0 4- < E U 7-0 M (a) (a) (1) vi -0 L /) 4- -0 .�n 14- u 4- F- V) cu Q) Q) 0 4- M LI) u 04-- 'Z�: 14- 0) M ' (Y ) 0 W 4- 4- u C7) Fu = 0 4- 4- 0 U cn4- 00 LLJ 7z- L') (1) V) 4- ::) Q) E 0 75 0 U cu E 4-1 V) u T Q) U 0- E 0 Co (D M m v 0 _0 u E 4- 4- E 0 > 0 0 Ln Q) E Ln +-, Q) U) LU u Q) \- 4- U4- Ln Q) V) '4- 4- Ln Q) (U > M Z) 0 \' = Q) -ucs 0 0 2 n 2!- 0 4- V) V) Ln t-- U 4- M 3: E (a) Q) 0 (a) u E -C (1) C) Q) > I-- Ln (a) = Q) C) 0 U Ln u cu 0 0 Q) = E = 0- o- n Q) L/) Q) n M D E NL/) 0 u 2? 0- L/) 4- M Q) 4- um En Q) m 07 0 E 14- > CU m 4- D Q) 4- M 4- > 0 0- U 0 L') +- 0 U.J m 14- Q) V) 4- uq m 0 C) m 4- 14- 0 4- Q) 0 a: U (1) (- = U --o (D) 4- 4- 4-- C) ±:� — Q) c 0 Q) 0 vn 0 M "n E V) 4- 1 - z Ul 0 > 0 4- 0 0 (1) m > 4-Ol U a --, Q) ro 4 V) C M Ln -) Q) 0 o 4 0 0) E L, u u E0 z > Ln (D M M Q) 4- Q- u 0 o V) 0 = 0 u m (1) — (i) . - OU Q) ru CDL Q) 4- (a) Q) 4- U u 0 >, +- M -0 m 4- 4- CD) 4- Q) 0 01-0 u c Q) u U 0 (1) M (1) = 4- Q- > 0- (1) V) -0 (1) ) V) — c 0- (a) m Q) 0 0 0 Ln -0 (a) 0 0) M u 4- 0 u 0- = 4- L/0) Q) Q) o 4-- U 14- v ONE= V) 0 3: (1) () > U " .> .— u - Q) — > V) Q) u 0 0 =5 .-L-- 4- Ln V) > z", u V) Q) Q) Q - 0z Qu o C 0 C) (1) 4- �E 0 LU U Q) 0 Q) 0 Q) (10 L/I > Lf) -C c: V) cc L/) > cc r" o 4- (1) 4- 75 4- -0 X -a QJ z Q) (D Q) 0 0 > L/) E 4- Q) (o E (a) 0 Q) V) V) 4- n u -y(1) (1) V) LU 0 L/) § x 0 u �: M 0 (a) > 4- (1) UJ Ln 4 o 4- Q) U 0 U) < U .�z 0 4- 4- 4 - LI) 0) 0) (a) V) . .................... i -0 0 > 0- 0) 0 U 0 0 4- x - - 0 L) U U V) (Y) = (1) [-- Q I ........... 0 .................... ............................... ........................................ c ....................... � -0 Q) = 4- (a) (a) (1) Q) Co >Q) U 0 m Q) u m > Q) 4- -0 QJ Q) Q) c - M 4- F- 14- E Q) Q) 0 Q) 4- 0 4- Q) Ln > u Q) U 4- (3) n 0 = 4- 4- 4t Q) 0 V, N 0 O 0 O Q) Ln Q) Q) Q) L/") 0 QJ c Q) Q .0 o u 4- 4- `,j(- co Q) >' 0 4- n 0 4- Ln +- E 0 U 4- E 4-- 0 4t QJ E C: 0 Q) 0 Q) c- c = Q)Q) CD) 0 E 4-- E A 0 > Q) = Q) F- ra 0 0 4-1 u Q) > U 0 > Q) u Q) CD- L, Q) 0 .- -= >1 4- 4- 4 0 4- 4-0 V) Q) (1) ru — U F- 4- -C = .- yu 4- 0- Q o Q) L/) >' Q) L.Lj - Q) - () > -- D- Ln(D 4- n Cl- Q) 4- 7DC, C- = 4- = �= E o al. E 0 U m0 01 4-1O Q)Q) OC y " (1) 4- Q) V) '4- m -0 M n3 n3 W > Q) < �o E 22 Q) CC Q) 4- QJ c m co Vwwww v0 4 - Ln E E 4eb ............................ ■ 1 It Q0 0 u E (1) E 0 > Q) 4-1 QJ Ln Qj C- z W 4Ln E 76 LLJ Qj VAN&= Qj Q1 C) In CS Qj - = V) O Ln 4-- Q) co L/) Qj Qj(- (1) Qj co 4- CL m (�j coQJ ra >1 Qj07 =O -S = =3 U Cj -Z C�L r_n m 4- 4- =3 cic Lf) PQa 4 - (ID ugz 7z� 14- Ln QJ 14- U.j C) -Z) Q) zQ) Qj 0 (1) +E- N LLJ Qj �5 z mu -Z Q) > > ru >1 Qj 4-1 Qj (2) 4- 0 = 0) = 0 0 > 14- 4- 0 Q Ln Qj Q-) Ln E2! 4- .T Q) 7C)0 QJ Z U> o Ln Q) -Z Q: 4-1 Qj Ln ry- QN Q) a) = - 1� Q) m Ln u -9 LE 4-o 0 U -Z) 0 (u 4 4- Qj 0 Q) QU) Qj Qj 0 ki E QJ 0- = 4- LLJ co LA z < QJ < Q- 4-1 u z Qj 0 C)) 0 4- 2 QJ Ln 0 Qj [2 - Q) o uj u Q) Q (a) -Z:z mj EL QL U- 4- U 4 - was%= 0 u Z cc 4- uimm u LLJ Ln 75 Q) QJ Qj — (3) z 0 0 — MOMM LLJ 4- D U > X u Qj ro > Qu 14- E 4- .— t V) Q) QJ 4- Qj E VI I c kn 4-1 U- U Qj o Cr. -T5 oc Ln r- Q) 0 0 L/) QJ Z). 2 vi tA x ui c 0 O Q) 7D (1) 4- 4- -0 cn Q) 4- 0 _0 C: (10 Q) 7D 0 u U) ry') O Cu 4- c M C 0 0-) 0 C: 4— 0 Z_- > 12 — Z _Z5 79 C C5 Cal C) 0 Ln Ln QO 47DN 0 -cZ- N C)4-1 CS cn U Zr 6 D 0 4t c (a) Zz 4—= Q) M :t -- 4 C5 Q - E v) QJ O Ln -t") CS O o Qj Qn C: 0 0 4— Ln D Q Ts Q) N CS v v 0 iZ3 Q: Qj U QJ Cll cn Ln N > 4— 4— Q) In Q) 0- Ln Ln 4- -C Qj CD 2) 0) Ln QJ 0 Qj Ln > Z/ -i E �, Qj QJ QL (D Q) Q) Q) D 0 S, 0 _0 Q QJ C) Z5 z Qu 0 Q) 0 0 --o V cs( Qj Q)OU 0 4-1 0 -"D 'o E QJX Qj O. k-) Qj > 0 0Q OC) QJ aj O O Qj-0 0 Q) QU > QJ 0 ID -0 Ul (o to > u (- -Z) Qj Qj N QJ cl) -0 0 QJ Q) kn 0) O4-- Q.) Qj rt3 Q Vv Qj Qj 0 -2 :::3 -Z-- Q, u 4-- -0 QJ Qj 14— ti Q) Z_- is F= M (a) o c) QJ ;N (D c) o ru zz u Iz .(3 .2 Qj (1) Qj ZZ > 0 -Q) 0 u Si v w a) c Qj 4— Qu r') (D) 4- Q-) �4— 03 C 4.- Qj Qj Qj QL) U m u (1) -Z LI) — (1) Q) M o C:) Qj Q: M V) 14 Q) V, VI 14 CS 0 0 0 = 'A Qu =0) Q) 0 cc -Z z CE. cc Q3 M cr. z Qj X QJ ZI c) Qu vi vi VI .,n -73 vi Qj Q Q It Q0 0 It Q0 0 r— O 4— .N c- V) (1) Ln Ln Lj) E QJ 0- Q) 0 C- —0 Q) x 2: 4— 0 > 0 Ln N Ln Q) Ln Q) C- E NM = Ln E 0 Q) .7, > 0) 5 Q)12 0 Ln 4— c) Ln �E Ln Ln • U 0 (1) 0) (U Q- 4— - 3: V) - o 0 4— Q >, 7) Q) 0 Q) u C O :t-- .: Ln , ( Cl) C u L/) C 'n = 4— 6 = C u Q) 0-) > 4— > 4- 0 — 4 41 > E > 0 (U n n o L/) O E m Q>) V) Q 0 Q) ro �5) 0 LI) 4- 0 n vi 6� 4— 0 76 0 > Ln 0 0' > 0 Ln 0 0 4— -F n 0 Q n Q> 14-- 0 - Q) Q) -) 0 un -C 4- 0 n +- u Ln 4__ 4-1 Q) L C-- Q) 75 W L -L Ln 0 Q) u > c) 2)m 4- W 0 rr n n 0 u > Q n m QJ +- C 730 4- L/) m wUl) , > - 0 E Li 4— LJ m W g Q) 0 C-) 0- -Fu 0 '4- Ln -C —i 4- C -0 0 cu 0 cc u Q) m 0 = Ln m � 0 0) Z5 (A u Q "o - r Ln 4— Ln Q) (1) =5 -0 >(a) (1) = 4- C C) :3 Q) U') (1 ) C r) 4- 0 M 4— C) n 0 c 0 E Q) 4— U Q) > cc 1 (D 4— M u E v W G j _.. 4— Q) 2- Q) > (a) V)O u Q) U-) Q) U-) It Q0 0 r— 0 4- V) 0- x 2: 0 N u V) -0 Ln E NM = Ln E 0 Q) .7, 0) 5 Q)12 0 Ln 4— c) �E U 0 (1) 0) (U Q- 4— - 3: V) - o 0 Q >, 7) Q) u X 4— C C u 0- 0 Ql C E > > 4— un co aJ V) cn V) Q) ro �5) 0 LI) 4- 0 4— 6� 4— C) 0' Q) C 4- 0 4— -F --C) >_0 14— 0 u L -L c) 2)m 4- L/) Q) = , Q) C V) 0) wUl) , > - 0 U') 4— LJ Q) 0 C-) 0- 4— Q) -0 0 cu Q) m 0 = Ln m � Ln Ln (A U- Q "o - r Ln 4— Ln Q) (1) =5 -0 4- C C) :3 Q) U') (1 ) C r) 4- 0 C) 0 c 0 Q) 4— E Q) > Q) :3 M u E v c- 0 Q) 2- Q) > (a) V)O (a) Ln 0 Q) -E O 1-- D- :3 4— (LID) 0 2 01 00 LI) V) Q) = Uv 0- 2 c o 5n) -0 DL 4-0v :u LZ o (D 0 4— It Q0 0 r— 0 00 2- vz 0 14- QJ 4- 0 0 c -Q ��-\•I-) , o- c) -Z E QJ 0 u -0 Q) Q) 0 4- LI) 7 � ().) C) C) 0 0 ") Qj In (a) V) 411 0 4- N 4- Ln Qj -Z 4 L/) (1) 4- (a) LI) c 0 0 Q) v 4--; u cu 0z 4- U Qj Q-) C) 4- 0 v) E -- 1- 0 4- L/) v) O Q5 QJ C- Qj Q) 4- 4- c Ln 0 > n 4- m p 2 In cAj Qj 0) 0 (1) qj QJ L� -c3 QJ cz v) Q) v), > Q) 4- v) 0 QJ �-z Z) z QJ -Z) ti .4 Q) 4- (1) QJ Ln Q) U o 0 U v) Qj 4.,Q) U Q) E u 0 u N E o 0- 4- Ts v Ln u v) Q) > O 1) -C) E4- U 0Ln 0 4- U 4- Qj -r3 4- 'F Q) -0 -0 0) ��: m =-C E = (3) v) v) m U n Q) Ln > 0 E-0 = C) 22 8, :S? 4- QJ 2 '4- L/) 4- L/) 4-Q- or -p 0 73 cS U E Q) c 0 z Q) - Q) = m Q) -0 0 (.n > -0 0 — 4- C. 2-- 0 0 Qj Z5 c- o Qj Q: Qj > M 4- V) E Q) M Q 4- m 0 =3 .- 4- o-) L,) .- Q) >1 -F LL) Q) n cy) , 7) 4-- C- 0) -Z g) 0 ox _0 (1) = 4- 7) — m Q) 0 E u Q) ul = z 0 o 0 Q) ma= (1) m 3: 7D v) 5 C 4-- — ()0 C: Q) Q-) 0 0 2 0 0 4- V) > 4- — > 0 Q) u oC) 7z:: 0 ca 4- 0- m 0 Z3 -FE E Q) 0 Ln 4- Ln M Ln E 4- Ln Qj N Z QJ 4- 0 -10 4- > Ln 0 = m r_ Ln = 0 — QO - Q) Q) 0 -0 0 L/) Ln Ln 0 F > 0 - Q) Q) tA Up Ln v) Q) -IZ5 QJ Qj > 4 ra U 0 (3) (1) -0 .= oj Z -(:-- , Qj - -TI3 Q) un > Q) -0 v) Q) 0 cu '3 '4) QL) L� C) u D- 0 0 u Q) C) o'0 > (a) 4- -C) z -Z C) u Q) Q) Qj v) v) 0 V) 0) To -0 .- 40 - = -0 --E-) p T) 4- — v) 0 m 0 > 0 4-1 -0 -Q) Z-) Z 4-- 0 0 D �n - 0- cF .- -0 :3 > Qu 6 a Ln 4- rn , o cu (2) z 4s_-:) �3 (Ij z Q) 4- -0 4- Ln = 0• �;� (-,� ') Qj -Q) QJ Qj < LI) v) u v) Z - _0 0 0 a-' Q) (- Q = m tA Z Z Z - - Z- Q)- -Z Qj 0 Ln 4- mO Q3) c5 D 0 4- > -Z- C7) 0 Q) _0 E Q) I 0- vi Z3 0 (1) -0 n 0 Q) 0) (3) = - Q) 4- U 4- �= E 0 zn cc L, 0-) Q) L/) (D c- 0 D -Z Qu 0 ;-- E L/) = 7u- S21 0 Z Qj Cq -Z LU 4- 0 U — Q) 0 > r4 �: Qj Z .�3) (�u Qu (D 4 4- -jV7 W -0 T-- E Q -5 Q -z Qu 0 00 LLJ Qu C) _73 cz Qj QJ QJ QJ C) -Z Qj Qj4-1 -C3 Qj I- -G IW QJ Q50 Qj Cl- [2 Q j 1- -z -Iz� ° Q5 Qj 0-) — z Qj >— Qj QJ s1 4-1 Qj -d - . Z-- In QJ QJ Qj C-) 'z3 CD Ln Qj Qj QJ Qj -Z C --L Qj . Ln v 0 c5 Qj -z: 0 0 0 Q) Q) Co QJ 12 o Qj a v o (D Qj QJ QL) 4— 'E Qj LES' UnQj z — -z: Qj — CD o 'Z z Ln Z2 Z- 0 -Z m L/; -Z 0 QL) Ln — ru 73 QJ Qj Ln QJ QJ QJ Qj QJ Qj QJ Qj -QD CY Qj QL) QL, Qj -2) C) 4-.; Ln Qu Ln Qj r) 4a Ci c) s z 7ZE - 2 Qj >, cz)Qj Qj -r-5 Q3) -� y C)- -zz Qj C-) tA o o o co Qj ��� N Qu QJ C) C) Z- -0 -sp QJ C) LE UC) QJU C) C5 Qu LLJ It Q0 0 0 v QJ Qu U 0 75 4- C) Qj P v Qu Qj Qj Qj -11-3 C) :-�� E 0 E - -Z 7� 1�1 Ln Qj C 7C3 Qj Qj QJ 4� co (1) QJ QL) cs 0 L, u Q) 4- L/) 0 0 v) 4 -QJ 4- QJ In Qj C) +- QL) CS CD - QL) 0 C) Z Z z ,07 m 0 u o CD - E- C) Qj Qj 'Qu QJ Qj 4 4- 0 Qj SJ S QJ QjLn 11) zzz , — o Z-� CS cll 43 6j Qj QJ o Qj Ln 0 Q, Z2 4 - Ln Qj Qj Qj Qj Ln QJ Ln (1) 0 0 Qj TS O QJ QJ O -r3 QJ C) Q i7 O CS C: 4- Lq 4- 4- C) QJ FS) �S Q) E Qj (Ij 75- _0 Qj Qj ru >1O Qj o QJ Ci 05 L/) .a QJ QL, Qj Qj C5 0 4- 4-1 vL/) QJ C) Ln QJ C3 zzz-3 C) QJ -Z > Qj Qj Q-) Ln Ln I- - --C3 - 0 -C3 O 0 QJ cjj Ln 4 - Ln Lnc- 0 14- o C) e n 0. Q4) 0 QJ QL) z 0 mO 0- CS C) QL) �-j c- z Q: Qj -zz 7D- > v) Qj 4- .0 0 - Q, �j Z: QJ QJ Qn �j O CS Cg Q Z� Qj QJ Q: Qj Qu (10 0 t C) QJ 0 Q2 Q-) Qj kA (1) -0 L Z5 >z, z 12) Qj 0 vi �j z Q) Q) Qj FSJ -tz, z QL) z QC) r 1�5 Q 14- QL) QL) Qj Z im Q) Q. 0 Qj QL) Z3 --t3 (�u -T::5 C m cic Qu CC -T::5 Qj 0 �j r-4 2 cu Z- 2 QJ ryi Ln w 2 QL) z �:, - '= 1 .2 Q) 'n C�- F,- -) r-: '. (U _0 Q z QJ C�- -,::3 Ez QL) LE -73 2 QL) It Q0 0 0 00 N LLJ It cc) 0 N 0) 0) M 0— C) 0- �: 4- .N Tj- Q) >1 -�3 0 -Z� (1) Qj C) _0 u Qj 4-- COQJ 4- 0 Q) 0 co 7) CU a 0 Qj u Qjco CY) U = _QCS L/) -7) = Q) Qj cn Q3) Q) Q5 oj U (T 4- V) o UQj Q) Q) V) Qj Z5 z: 14- C- 0 Q) Q O z 0 co 0 c) U 4- Q) Qj QL) CS > Ln Ln Qj S? -Z �Z5 - . o) -o E� C) :5 Q) CO o- Q:5) Z Qj U L/) Q) I > V) C) 75 co 0- QJ 0 4- Q) Qj • C)LI) 0 C) 4- 0 -0 4- 4- Qj Qj 4- Q) C,-) C) m C) Ln Q) 0 D CO Qj E 0 Qj . U \,- Q) 1) :c Qj �j �j �.j Q3 QJ CD- 0 — �j u 0 > Q) V) -0 �z QJ Qu -Z$ Dv C, 1 2 u 0 CS Qj Q5 E .9) Q) Z- V) QJ Qv') Q) C) Q) Qj QL) 0 0 4-- Q) Q-) Q) -cz 0lS 7� Ln Ln 0 QJ C) C) 4-Q) Ln _Z3 Q) 4- 4-- u 14- 0 Ln Q) -2 2 Q) Q) 0 0 C, I�j -T::5 -0 Q) C: LJ > O — �5 Q) 0 Qj Z - ZZ -c- Z =) = n L/) QJ -0 0 E Q3 -r3 -C3 0 z = 0 0" -0 -Q-I� 0 (Y� 4- 0 QL) C� -Z3 Q �z Q:n 4- 0 'A QJ cc -Z) 1- Q:5) Qj Q-) Q-) ZS Q) CDZ: Q01 0 -z' QJ Ln 14- 0 1� QO Q-) Q) .2 In 0 =3 C) Qu Z- Ln Q) -0 --Z u > 0 Zf • 0 14- 0 n v).Cl 4- -17) u E QQ) Q) Q-) Qj Lo u Q) Q) Qj F- Z)- Ln C) :,� (Y) --o 4- C) cu QJ - 4- 0 12il E 0 Q o .2 — O �)- CS z > -��< Z U -Q) Q) c 0) cs E Qj QJ Qj Ln 1) v4- Qj c- IZ -11�5 — O- z 7::z z 0 14- 0 Qn C3) CD 0 Q) Ln 4-1 C) Q, 4 Q) CD. -g Qj CS Z, M 0 QJ E u Qj QL) Qj — Z5 o V� 0 (D — -Z P Q) Qj c2 (5) .— .— 0 1 2 -0 co V, QD L, -Z� p C Lit >j cs vi C'n Q) LL ru 2! E Qj c) QO fl - cc •14— m kn QL) -Q3 ::3) -ZN CD �lj -Z Q 0 Q) 0- u m cr. C Qu Qu Q:3 Ln CC Z rn rvi r.7) c) vi r- 14- QJ Q3 r- 0 Q) 2- - Qu Qu zzz T--0 C) La- z C) 00 N LLJ It cc) 0 N 0) 0) M 0— It cc) 0 CN M n CL o D M ru 14- O 0 o C) < 0 V) 0 Q) 7u- aj SOU Q) 0 0 C-: v > Q) -0 >,z 0 4- Q) >1 C- 0 0 -F Ln Q) M C: 4-4-o Q) Q) _0 0 0) Ln 0 0 Q) u Q) E C: -0 0 E2 0 Q) U L/) 4- 0- L/) N 4- aj Q) > E 4-- 4-1 4- V) (10 O o 4x Zi QJ U 0 > u Ln > '4- Q) Q) M 4-- Co +- 0> m m Q) Ln Q QJ4- 0 u 0 -0 V) 0 Q) QJ C) +- 3: 0 u E QJ (-r-- CC —u LQ) E W 0 4-1 0 Q) (1) co 0 0 C� u Ln Ln — cz C , U In Q) +- Q) Q 0 u 0 Q) 0 0 (o co �E 4- U Q) 4- = V) 0 L" >1 LLJ LI) m V) 4- 0 E Q) V) (a) 76 co -F) 0 0 (a) o -0 0 Q) V) -Fo A- = - m> (a) V) E Q) -0 0- 4- 4- m= — 0 0 (a) (1) 4 Q) m V) , 2 (a) (1) .f �2 E 4- (a) 0 0 01 3: 4- > C) 4-4 > > 0 0 N (A - (1) E 4- 4- 4- = _0 Q) �n z OL -7) 0 4- U 0 (1) Q) 0 C Q) 0 .�n 0 Q) Q) Q) E ECDL ru Q1 O - 0 Ln C n3 c- 0 Q) '4QJ QJ - m 4- x V) 0 Q) 0 4-1 (u 0 4- c (D 14- Q) f) 4- m m 0 co u 0 E --o L,- L = . u 0 C 0 CT (D 0 > Q) (1) Q) 4- CDL L Q) > Q) > Q) 0 > E Q) -Ln 0 QJ 4- U (1) ('0 4-- = 0 140- 4- Ln 4- _0 0 4-- Q) Q) (D 0 > E W Ln 0 a) 0 E Q) 4-- Q Q) �.n Ln 4- U') C) 4- CU 0 0- Q) m u 0 Ln U 0 L/) u 0 ajowo E ut-- — a)u — -0 < 0 u -.0 ) CDL > E 0- > cy� -0 u ul (D -u Q) = Q) Q) I— n3. E = C- 0 ,It co 0 CY) N ca 0- NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING � for a development in your neighbourhood 7 Morrison Road I TCT 11,"NER Have Your Voice Heard! Concept Drawing Date: April 3, 2023 Time: 7:00 p.m. Location: Council Marn eirs,, Kitchener City Hall 200, King Street West orVirtual Zoom Meeting To view the staff report, agenda, meeting details, start time of this item or to appear as a delegation, visit: kitchener.ca/meetings To learn more about this project, including information on your appeal rights, visit: www.kitchenenca/ Plan n i ngAppl ications or contact: 0 r IS p a c e i .......... i i gi of ai °11u11°Fai Brian Bateman, Senior Planner 1:1a tIiio o f 3.5Metre 11, l�b a c III 519.741.2200 x 7869 III'Aeti e s brian.bateman@kitchener.ca The City of Kitchener will consider applications to amend the City's Official Plan and Zoning By-law to add a site-specific provision to increase the Floor Space Ratio (FSR) from 0.6 to 0.9, to permit a reduced rear yard setback of 5.5 metres instead of the required 7.5 metres, and to permit a 10 percent visitor parking rate to facilitate the development of 32 stacked townhouse units with 45 parking spaces. Page 125 of 164 From: Mike Seiling Sent: Tuesday, October 25, 2022 12:26 PM To: Brian Bateman Subject: FW: Circulation for Comment - 7 Morrison Road (OPA/ZBA) Attachments: 7 Morrison Road Agency Letter.pdf Building; No concerns From: Christine Kompter <CIhiristi_rn_e. IKarrn er( Sent: Tuesday, October 25, 2022 10:07 AM To: CPR(atil{....._¢rpirmit.Y:::m.troa..@r)<c.12.......12!rp�rvnit.X:::ptrl_p_@Ir>; MTO -Allan Hodgins ( Vll n Ilirsdgiins@o taruq_ca) <aV.l_aon lhpd ins. cantarup ca>, 'clerks@cambridge.ca' <cllerks@cairmbridge c�>, _DL # DSD Planning <DSQ.::II II_g_rn_rnfingMvision.0 ..�:�c�_ !n_ .rr c�.>; Bell - c/o WSP — — — .. <circullatioins@ws.p.,ce rmn>; Carlos Reyes < a_irll ........s.....f.e IkV.tclh_e!n_e.rr,.c >; Darren Kropf y:@ <I ffI,[n�@.Ik tclherner.ca>: Dave Seller <,D ye.Selll_er.@_K�tc_�ener.ca>; David Paetz .................................................... <I[) yu . .tZ..L t Vr r r >; Ellen Straus <IFID rn.S ra s@V<it h ro r:_c >; Enova Power Corp. -Greig Cameron <grcugmeraaop@rrrrpaver cornu>; Enova Power Corp. - Shaun Wang <Shaun.wang.@rrr.lfpr.:.rrarn>; Feds <vp_ ...@...tsc>; GRCA - Planning (Ip .Or�r�irrg.�'.grrurive.r.::ca.) <p annin@ randriver.ca>; Greg Reitzel <G.reB.ReutzeV@kutchener,ca>; Hydro One - Dennis DeRango <�arq.d.. u.,s plann'un @hydroone.com>; Jim Edmondson <puI.......................... spr_@.I<o....................................................O>; Justin Readman .....................F <Ju.stun.Read rmarn_@_kiitch rn ir.ca>; Katherine Hughes <IKatlher.n_a ..II..Nnuglhcs..@_kii.tc_in rnerr.ca>; Mike Seiling ....................................................................... <Miilke.Seilliiing@Ikii.tc.lhener:.ca>; Ontario Power Generation<IE::xecutiivevrn.I�nrrne_d_vllcirnrnt.@_a.ta,.crm>; Park Planning (SM) <P irI .Pll rnrniim @Ikiiac ener._c >; Region - Planning < Il irflirfliiing > Iliic .tu rns..@_r .giiP..rn�rf. a.te.rr-o-o c. >; Property Data Administrator (SM) < n.r Ip t i.rr girn@Ikirtclh inr~rr >; Robert Morgan <,Clic?bdrt. ..M irgarn@Ikiitclhen r.ca>; Steven Ryder <Steven..Ifty air@Ilii ..........1h_ rner..ca>; Sylvie Eastman <S.yll rir ._Fps.tm rn@II<iitclhe ner.c >; WCDSB -Planning .......................................... <.IEIIh nniing@ sVa c >; WRDSB - Board Secretary (g.11_ iiln_ < Il iirn_ ....._ uainns@ irdsl ac >; WRDSB - Planning <pII_ !2.!2J_r4g.@ Cc: Brian Bateman <Birii_arn.._B t rn in@.I itclh en_er ca> Subject: Circulation for Comment - 7 Morrison Road (OPA/ZBA) Please see attached. Additional documentation can be found in AMANDA folders 22-124797 & 22- 124799 (City staff) and Slh_L_FV.I_e. (external agencies). Comments or questions should be directed to Brian Bateman, Senior Planner (copied on this email). Christine Kompter Administrative Assistant I Planning Division I City of Kitchener 200 King Street West, 6t" Floor I P.O. Box 1118 Kitchener ON N2G 4G7 519-741-2200 ext. 7425 1 TTY 1-866-969-9994 christine.kompter@kitchener.ca Page 126 of 164 Page 127 of 164 City of Kitchener COMMENT FORM Project Address: 7 Morrison Road Application Type: Official Plan Amendment OPA22/013/M/BB Zoning By-law Amendment ZBA22/024/M/BB Comments of: Environmental Planning — City of Kitchener Commenter's Name: Carrie Musselman Email: carrie.mussel man@kitchener.ca Phone: 519-741-2200 X 7068 Date of Comments: January 17, 2023 1. Plans, Studies and Reports submitted as part of a complete Planning Act Application: • Arborist Report, 7 Morrison Road Kitchener ON, prepared by WSP Canada Inc., dated November 2022. 2. Site Specific Comments & Issues: I have reviewed the study noted above to support an official plan and zoning bylaw amendment to permit a development that includes two stacked townhouse buildings with 16 units each (total of 32 units) with amenity areas and a private access road, and note: 1) An Arborist Report was submitted in support of the application. In summary, the report noted: 1.1. No trees on applicant land will be preserved. • Of the trees being removed on the subject property, there are nineteen (19) in good condition, twelve (12) in fair condition, one (1) in poor condition, and two (2) are dead. 1.2. Some trees on adjacent properties may be injured or require removal, they are: 1.2.1.Canadian Pacific Railway Property • (16) sixteen of these trees will require permission to injure and/or remove as their driplines will be impacted by the proposed site grading. Generally, permission has been granted. 1.2.2. Hospital property • (2) two trees will require permission to injure as their driplines will be impacted by the proposed site grading. Permission has been granted, the letter notes if the trees die within 5 years, they will be replaced at a 2:1 ratio. • (8) eight trees will require permission to remove. (6) six of the (8) eight trees are dead from Emerald Ash Borer. Permission has been granted; the letter notes the replacement of (2) two trees at a 2:1 replacement ratio. 1.2.3. 25 Morrison Road, Kitchener ON (7) seven trees will require permission to injure as their driplines will be impacted by the proposed site grading. Permission has been granted, the letter notes if the trees die within 5 years, they will be replaced at a 2:1 ratio. (1) one tree will require permission to remove. Permission has been granted; the letter notes the replacement of two trees at a 2:1 replacement ratio. A City for Everyone Working Together — Growing Thoughtfully — Building Community Page 128 of 164 2) In summary, the proposed new development and related grading works will require the removal of (44) forty-four individual trees. 3) Tree protection fencing is recommended to be installed around trees noted for retention. An extensive landscape planting plan is proposed as part of the site plan process. The planting plan should aim to exceed the number of trees removed from site and so the Zoning By Law Amendment can be supported. 3. Conditions of Approval in Principal (AIP) and/or Full Site Plan Approval: City Environmental Planning supports Approval -In -Principle (AIP) provided the following custom and/or modified conditions are incorporated into the AIP and/or Section 41 Development Agreement. • The proposed development is in accordance with the Arborist Report, prepared by WSP Canada Inc., dated November 22, 2022. 4. Policies, Standards and Resources: Tree Management • As per Section 8.C.2.16. of the Official Plan, the City will require the preparation and submission of a tree management plan in accordance with the City's Tree Management Policy (available on the City's Website), where applicable, as a condition of a development application. o Any tree management plan must identify the trees proposed to be removed, justify the need for removal, identify the methods of removal and specify an ecologically sound tree replacement scheme and any mitigative measures to be taken to prevent detrimental impacts on remaining trees. • policy 8.C.2.6., the City will incorporate existing and/or new trees into the streetscape or road rights- of-way and encourage new development or redevelopment to incorporate, protect and conserve existing healthy trees and woodlands in accordance with the Urban Design Policies in Section 13 (Landscape and Natural Features) of the Urban Design Manual and the Development Manual. V,.. ;IFIT0 As per Section 8.C.2.17. of the Official Plan, the City will consider the importance of woodlands, not classified as significant, during the development review process by considering the following: a) the potential impact of the proposed development, redevelopment or site alteration on the ecological functions of the woodland; b) the impact of the proposed development, redevelopment or site alteration on the extent and distribution of woodland cover in the watershed, the city and the local planning community; and, c) opportunities to restore or re-establish productive forest habitats consisting of native species following the completion of the proposed development. As per Section 8.C.2.18. of the Official Plan, the City will minimize the impact of development, redevelopment or site alteration on woodlands, not classified as significant through the implementation of appropriate mitigation measures, which may include compensation. Hedgerows • As per Section 8.C.2.19. of the Official Plan, when considering development, redevelopment or site alteration proposals, the City may require the protection and enhancement of hedgerows, especially where: a) they link other elements of the Natural Heritage System; A City for Everyone Working Together — Growing Thoughtfully — Building Community Page 129 of 164 b) wildlife regularly use them as habitat or movement corridors; c) they are composed of mature, healthy trees; d) they contain trees that are rare, unique, culturally important or over 100 years in age; or, e) they contribute to the aesthetics of the landscape. Natural Heritage Features • The mapping and criteria for identifying individual natural heritage features is included in the Kitchener Natural Heritage System Technical Background Report (rev. June 2014). A City for Everyone Working Together — Growing Thoughtfully — Building Community Page 130 of 164 City of Kitchener - Comment Form Project Address: 7 Morrison Road Application Type: OPA and ZBA Comments of: Environmental Planning (Sustainability) — City of Kitchener Commenter's name: Gaurang Khandelwal Email: gaurang.khandelwal@kitchener.ca Phone: 519-741-2200 x 7611 Written Comments Due: November 18, 2022 Date of comments: November 14, 2022 1. Plans, Studies and/or Reports submitted and reviewed as part of a complete application: • Sustainability Statement — Official Plan and Zoning By-law Amendment, 7 Morrison Road, Kitchener, prepared by MHBC, dated September 26, 2022 2. Comments & Issues: I have reviewed the documentation (as listed above) to support an Official Plan Amendment and a Zoning By-law Amendment to develop the subject lands with two stacked townhouse buildings with 16 units each, regarding sustainability and energy conservation and provide the following: • Based on my review of the supporting documentation, some sustainability elements are being proposed and the development is contemplated to meet or exceed the Ontario Building Code. • Although the Ontario Building Code (OBC) is advanced, going forward all developments will need to include robust energy conservation measures as the City (and Region of Waterloo) strive to achieve our greenhouse gas reduction target. • It is strongly suggested that the proposed development achieve more efficient standards than the minimum OBC requirements. • A Sustainability Statement (as per the City's Terms of Reference) will be required as part of a complete Site Plan Application. • As the project evolves through the detailed design process, more progressive energy conservation and efficient design elements should be incorporated. Potential items for consideration: o Electric vehicle charging stations o Community/ common gardens and urban agriculture o On-site composting o Green roofs 11 Ifsage Page 131 of 164 o Use of alternative water supply and demand management systems such as rainwater harvesting and grey water reuse o Use of alternative or renewable energy systems or the capacity to incorporate such systems in the future 3. Policies, Standards and Resources: • Kitchener Official Plan Policy 7.C.4.4. Development applications will be required to demonstrate to the satisfaction of the City, through the completion of a Sustainability Report/Checklist in accordance with the Complete Application Requirements Policies in Section 17.E.10, that the proposal meets the sustainable development policies of the Plan and that sustainable development design standards are achieved. • Kitchener Official Plan Policy 7.C.4.5. The City will encourage and support, where feasible and appropriate, alternative energy systems, renewable energy systems and district energy in accordance with Section 7.C.6 to accommodate current and projected needs of energy consumption. • Kitchener Official Plan Policy 7.C.6.4. In areas of new development, the City will encourage orientation of streets and/or lot design/building design with optimum southerly exposures. Such orientation will optimize opportunities for active or passive solar space heating and water heating. • Kitchener Official Plan Policy 7.C.6.8. Development applications will be required to demonstrate, to the satisfaction of the City, energy is being conserved or low energy generated. Such studies may include, but not limited to an Energy Conservation Efficiency Study, a Feasibility Study for Renewable or Alternative Energy Systems, District Heating Feasibility Study, and the completion of a Sustainability Report/Checklist in accordance with the Complete Application Requirements Policies in Section 17.E.10. • Kitchener Official Plan Policy 7.C.6.27. The City will encourage developments to incorporate the necessary infrastructure for district energy in the detailed engineering designs where the potential for implementing district energy exists. 4. Advice: ➢ As part of the Kitchener Great Places Award program every several years there is a Sustainable Development category. Also, there are community-based programs to help with and celebrate and recognize businesses and sustainable development stewards (Regional Sustainability Initiative - http://www.sustainablewaterlooregion.ca/our-programs/regional-sustainability- initiative and TravelWise - http://www.sustainablewaterlooregion.ca/our-programs/travelwise). ➢ The 'Sustainability Statement Terms of Reference' can be found on the City's website under 'Planning Resources' at ... https://www.kitchener.ca/SustainabilityStatement 21Ifsage Page 132 of 164 From: Real Estate Canada <Rea|_Estate[anada@cpr.ca> Sent: Tuesday, December 3U'2UZ31Z:01PK4 To: Brian Bateman Subject: RE: Circulation for Comment - 7 Morrison Road (CPA/ZBA) You don't often get email from Good Afternoon, and welfare of residents can be adversely affected by rail operations and CP is not in favour of residential uses that are not compatible with rail operations. CP freight trains operate 24/7 and schedules/volumes are subject to change. CP's approach to development in the vicinity of rail operations is encapsulated by the recommended guidelines developed through collaboration between the Railway Association of Canada and the Federation of Canadian Municipalities. The 2013 Proximity Guidelines can be found at the following website address: http://www.proximityissues.ca . CP recommends that the below condition be inserted in all property and tenancy agreements and offers of purchase and sale for all dwelling units in the proposed building(s): 7anallian 'acii ic I ai7w—ay ancl/or its assigns or successors in interest nas or nave a railway rignt-OT-way and/or yard located adjacent to the subject land hereof with operations conducted 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, including the shunting of trains and the idling of locomotives. There may be alterations to, or expansions of, the railway facilities and/or operations in the future, which alterations or expansions may affect the living environment of the residents in the vicinity. Notwithstanding the inclusion of any noise and/or vibration attenua"q measures in- C, i - n of the develAo.ment and individual dwellings, Canadian Pacific Railway will not be responsible for complaints or claims arising from the use of its facilities and/or its operations on, over, or under the aforesaid right-of-way and/or yard." Should the captioned development proposal receive approval, CP respectfully requests that the recommended guidelines befollowed. MOB, Real EstateCanada@cpr.ca 7550 Ogden Dale Road SE, Building z Calgary xaT2c4X9 CP ** Please beadvised that will bedeactivated asofJmnuary31,2O23' Page 133 of 164 Real EstateCanada@cpr.ca to ensure your communication is received and replied to in a timely manner ** From: Brian Bateman <,Briiarn_._Fla.teirin_a_rn..@IKitchener._ca> Sent: December 9, 2022 12:22 PM To: CP Proximity -Ontario <CVS....._C roxiim.iity..-.!21r.t�!rlie..�$_c r ca> Subject: FW: Circulation for Comment - 7 Morrison Road (OPA/ZBA) This email did not originate from Canadian Pacific. Please exercise caution with any links or attachments. To Whom it May Concern, Just following up on correspondence sent to CPR asking for comments regarding a development application located at 7 Morrison Road, Kitchener Ontario. Can you please advise when these comments will be forthcoming as the commenting period ended on November 18. Your comments are important to us as this proposal is adjacent to your railway line. Thank you. Brian Bateman, MCIP, RPP Senior Planner City of Kitchener 519-741-2200 x7869 From: Christine Kompter <Ihir.st.rne IKaio> Sent: Tuesday, October 25, 2022 10:07 AM To: CPR(atil{....._¢rpirrn_i.Y:::m.tUoa..r)<c.12.......12!rp�rrnllt.X:::prnr.1_p_IFr>; MTO -Allan Hodgins ( VllanIlipdgiins@o tarip_ca)<aVII_an.Ihod ins.C. nta!lcoca>,'clerks@cambridge.ca' «Darks@cambridge ca>, _DL <[)S[_�:._!jguru%in. l(�uyusi_orti V<otchene_ir.ca>; Bell - c/o WSP ................................................................ .... <avp'_Ucu.u_Va.tura s sr�.cr%m>; Carlos Reyes <CarVo.s...I eYese Htch_e_ine�r ca>; Darren Kropf <I[Jarren Kro.pf@k tchener.ca>; Dave Seller <Il)ave Seller kitchener.ca>; David Paetz ........ ....._.......... <[)avu ,Ra_e.t. _@ki cV,ener._ca>; Ellen Straus<11:.Heru_.,Straus@_kitcVneruer.c�>; Enova Power Corp. -Greig Cameron <grcuuame�raaru..@errevaaveU Enova Power Corp. - Shaun Wang <slh_au.in.wain8..'�_e.in ur 1pp air.:: r�i >; Feds «e e ..'�:fe .:s.:: a>; GRCA -Planning (.la.11a_ru_ru.iing.'�.gira.in _river.::ca.) <Iplla ... randriver.ca>; Greg Reitzel <.ire.Reiitzell@kiitcheiner.ca>; Hydro One - Dennis DeRango <Ia_rurj_ sgpllaininiiin In dirooine.com>; Jim Edmondson <.J_ii_m_._Ed mon.ds rg_.@ t lhein_e.ir ea.>; Justin Readman <J_ru.,s.tii_ru_._Cie_adrnaru_@_kiitchern. ir.._ca>; Katherine Hughes<IKa.tlh_er.i_in_e_..II.:Nughes@kiitcherneir.ca>; Mike Seiling <In/n_ii.ke.Se.i_Iliiin Iftir�clheiner.ca>; Ontario Power Generation <IE;,xeautiivev .lawainddevello rrnernt o .corma; Park Planning (SM) <Cha.irlk._PlIa.in.in.iiln.g.@.II<iltchueineir.._ca>; Region - Planning <II1II_ainin.ii_in A Iliicatiions re iionol�waterlloo.ca>; Property Data Administrator (SM) <Illrolp_ a.ta d.in_i.in..@.IKirtclheineir.aa>; Robert Morgan <.Rolbert..l@/or ain@Ilcirtclhener,ca>; Steven Ryder <Steven.If y eir.@.IkirtcIn ner..ca.>; Sylvie Eastman <S.yllviie.Fas.trrain@II<iitalheineir.ca>; WCDSB -Planning .......................................... <II_a_E_E.1_lmg.�$ cslbca>; WRDSB - Board Secretary (ell_aiiine Iburrns@yrrs.ca) <Iliiineuairins@rdslbaa>; WRDSB - Planning <pllaininJ_9.g.�� vrrslb.ca> Cc: Brian Bateman<13rV_a.in.._Batemain�I.!<itdhene_r :ca.> Subject: Circulation for Comment - 7 Morrison Road (OPA/ZBA) Page 134 of 164 Please see attached. Additional documentation can be found in AMANDA folders 22-124797 & 22- 124799 (City staff) and Slha_L _ .J.l_e. (external agencies). Comments or questions should be directed to Brian Bateman, Senior Planner (copied on this email). Christine Kompter Administrative Assistant I Planning Division I City of Kitchener 200 King Street West, 6th Floor I P.O. Box 1118 Kitchener ON N2G 4G7 519-741-2200 ext. 7425 1 TTY 1-866-969-9994 christine.l<ompter@I<itchener.ca ------------------------------ IMPORTANT NOTICE - AVIS IMPORTANT ------------------------------ Computer viruses can be transmitted via email. Recipient should check this email and any attachments for the presence of viruses. Sender and sender company accept no liability for any damage caused by any virus transmitted by this email. This email transmission and any accompanying attachments contain confidential information intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. Any dissemination, distribution, copying or action taken in reliance on the contents of this email by anyone other than the intended recipient is strictly prohibited. If you have received this email in error please immediately delete it and notify sender at the above email address. Le courrier electronique peut etre porteur de virus informatiques. Le destinataire doit donc passer le present courriel et les pieces qui y sont jointes au detecteur de virus. L' expediteur et son employeur declinent toute responsabilite pour les dommages causes par un virus contenu dans le courriel. Le present message et les pieces qui y sont jointes contiennent des renseignements confidentiels destines uniquement a la personne ou a I' organisme nomme ci-dessus. Toute diffusion, distribution, reproduction ou utilisation comme reference du contenu du message par une autre personne que Ie destinataire est formellement interdite. Si vous avez recu ce courriel par erreur, veuillez le detruire immediatement et en informer I' expediteur a I' adresse ci-dessus.------------------------------ IMPORTANT NOTICE - AVIS IMPORTANT ------------------------------ Page 135 of 164 From: Trevor Heywood <theywood@grandriver.ca> Sent: Tuesday, October 25, 2022 11:00 AM To: Brian Bateman Subject: RE: Circulation for Comment - 7 Morrison Road (OPA/ZBA) Hey Brian, This is not regulated by the GRCA and we have no comment. Thanks, i,,,irevoir III°ieywood, IB„Cc„(Il::::.:rnv„) Resource IRainineir I irfi irmn: IRiveir Conservation Authority 400 Clyde Road, PO Box 729 Cambridge, ON N1 R 5W6 Phone: 519-621-2763 ext. 2292 Email: tlheywood c iraindiriiveir..ca y✓ .:. iraindiriiveir..ca , ,irn„ln a ...wiitlh......u'...... !C:�.....sociiall......imed.Ii . From: Christine Kompter<hru_s.tp_on_.a.V<a_rtnlpter@kitcheneraca> Sent: Tuesday, October 25, 2022 10:07 AM To: CPR (t i'rox'imity-Ontario@claroca) <cpproxiuuluity-aB.ri_p.@_.>; MTO - Allan Hodgins ( i.is_rn_._V..N_gdgiiins@ontario.ca) < .o.l_aon.ho.dg ns@ontario.ca>; 'clerks@cambridge.ca' <cI_e_rks.. ca_rn. Lii_d ca>; _DL_#_DSD_Planning <[ [ ::� V_ roru.%rr. l[�uv'a_s.i_on_@kr tuhene_roca.>; Bell - c/o WSP u_rCL.V_Iado_rB.s_ ” .s.l2.oc ruff>; Carlos Reyes < r0c s it y se Vcu.tc0r rr ro >; Darren Kropf <i)arren IKro.pf@k tcherner.ca>; Dave Seller <1D ve S tier( ko_tcherner.ca>; David Paetz ........ <(�aviid.Paetz_ Ikiitclhener:_ca>; Ellen Straus <1E:;.1ll rn_.,St.ra_u.us@ Ikitclhener:_ca>; Enova Power Corp. - Greig .......... .......... . Cameron <graf.Z...ca.irm irpin@gin �r Ipa it cu Im>; Enova Power Corp. - Shaun Wang <slhaun.wain.g..@cinanringgra girn>; Feds <vfru?(!:fs:c>; Planning <�Inlniirn@rinviri'irrr c>; Greg ................................................. ......... Reitzel <G�ira~ iitzgl@Ikii:tclh incur.. >; Hydro One -Dennis DeRango <Il rnc9 s .pl in iniiing@hy .irpr2ina c im>; Jim Edmondson <Jiinn_.Ed mo.irdso �a lCirtclha?in r:q >; Justin Readman <�ua_s.tiiin.I r inn in Ikitcheiner.ca>; .............. ....._ .._ .........@.......................................................... Katherine Hughes<IKatlherine:_Huglh_gs_@I�irtclhener ca>; Mike Seiling <Milke S_efi.li ng.@Ikiitclheiner.ca>; Ontario Power Generation < c tii�r nr n:I in er llrnpim! ija @cup cion>; Park Planning (SM) <Ilia_rlk.,Pllaininii.in (kiitcheineir.ca>; Region - Planning <.PII_aininii:in. ppllicatiioin.s@ire iionofwateirlloo.ca>; Property Data Administrator (SM)<”rq.[ataA..inn.V.in..@.Ikiiaclhinrca>; Robert Morgan <Il cslb .irt. I.M.p.irgain@Ikitclheiner.ca>; Steven Ryder <St2v m.,_Ryder@kitclneneir.ca>; Sylvie Eastman <2 Ivie.Eastman@kitcheineir.ca>; WCDSB - Planning <iaV_a_un_un.uongC mrcdsb.ca>; WRDSB - Board Secretary ( lai.nn_ burns@wrd.sb.ca) <e a_I_rne burns a wirdsb.ca>; WRDSB - Planning <planning�@wrdslb.ca> Cc: Brian Bateman <Bri_a_un.,.B t m In..@.1Si.tclhenne_r:ca.> Subject: Circulation for Comment - 7 Morrison Road (OPA/ZBA) Please see attached. Additional documentation can be found in AMANDA folders 22-124797 & 22- 124799 (City staff) and S.ha.I _ .J.l_a (external agencies). Comments or questions should be directed to Brian Bateman, Senior Planner (copied on this email). Page 136 of 164 Christine Kompter Administrative Assistant I Planning Division I City of Kitchener 200 King Street West, 6th Floor I P.O. Box 1118 Kitchener ON N2G 4G7 519-741-2200 ext. 7425 1 TTY 1-866-969-9994 christine.kompter@kitchener.ca i IN n9u," I Page 137 of 164 From: Sent: To: Subject: Attachments: Good afternoon 1Biriialn, '7 MorrisonRoad P ,I Johnston, Jeremiah (MTO) <Jeremiah.Johnston@ontario.ca> Monday, December 12, 2022 10:24 AM Brian Bateman RE: Circulation for Comment - 7 Morrison Road (OPA/ZBA) 7 Morrison Road Agency Letter.pdf; 16218E - Site Plan - July 18 2022 Plan.pdf Phe I iilrnii tlry of Firarnspolrtatiion Ihas no objection to t1hiis alplplliioatiion, iinollusiive of 2 stacked town Ihouse structures, 32 unfits totall„ ..Rhe subject property Cr Morrison (Road) its Ilooated (beyond our Iliiinmiits of Ipelrinmiit oontiroll and therefore Ilii FO Ireviiew, alplplrovall and 1peirimiits wiillll (mot Ibe Irequiilred„ Phalnik you, .Ilelreirnia [i Johnston Corridor Management Planner Corridor Management Section Ministry of Transportation Operations Branch West 659 Exeter Road, London, ON N6E 11-3 M: (226)-980-6407 From: Brian Bateman <,Briie9_:_Fla.teir�r�_arn.( !Kit lhern ir.ca> Sent: December 9, 2022 3:08 PM To: Johnston, Jeremiah MTO <Jeiremialh.Jolhinston ointainlo.ca> ......................................................................................................................................... Subject: FW: Circulation for Comment - 7 Morrison Road (OPA/ZBA) CAUTION -- EXTERNAL E-MAIL - Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender. Hello Jeremiah, Just following up on attached correspondence sent to Allan regarding a development application at 7 Morrison Road. I presume you are taking this one over? If so, can you provide MTO comments at your earliest convenience. Thanks. Brian From: Christine Kompter <Ihril_sail.in_.:.IICr.inn.�pteir@kirtcheneir.ca> Sent: Tuesday, October 25, 2022 10:07 AM To: CPR (o l{? IProxiirnity Oirntarilo@c inr.ca) <.c.I2 piroxiirnity oirvtario cir.ca>; MTO - Allan Hodgins ( (III iro.Il::Nr dgiins o_rn.t _6 ::c ) <aIIIIain (hod fins@ arn.t iriip >; 'clerks@cambridge.ca' <.c.!9rks@g1mbrid,ge e2>, _DL_#_DSD_Planning <[)SI[ {>Ilanrailn �.ivisioin@.II<iitclheine.ir.ca>; Bell - c/o WSP ... <circullatioins@As.p:e�nirm>; Carlos Reyes <�aalrllos.lf e es Ikirtclheineir.ee>; Darren Kropf y:_@ <[7 Irlre1n:IKirp @Ik elh_erneir.ee>; Dave Seller <Dave.Selller@_kirtc_ einie1r.ca>; David Paetz ................. < � nr( I etz@.Ik tcheiner._e >; Ellen Straus <1�:..Il�en...St.ra.us.@..!�itclhen.er.,ca>; Enova Power Corp. - Greig .......... ............ Cameron <8i� ee.ireircm@ernvreir.epi >; Enova Power Corp. - Shaun Wang Page 138 of 164 <slhauin.wang"invalppir,.cai >; Feds <vh_..s.,.a a>; GRCA - Planning (Ip .Ilarnrningramriver,.ca.) ................................................. <Ip.Va_rn_rn.iraji andriver.ca>; Greg Reitzel <.GD! . eVtzeV kotchener,ca>; Hydro One - Dennis DeRango ................. <oa_nd_r�u.,se lannun "hydroone.com>; Jim Edmondson <,p_'u_m_ IFclinno_n.clsaro_@.I<ut h u�_ _r ca.>; Justin Readman <Justin.Readma__n.@..kit h _roer,.ca>: Katherine Hughes <.Ka.tlheri.�no- o11u..lhes@I<o cherue�r.ca>; Mike Selling < oke.Se.:i:fi g. _kp:tC_��ro�r...�a>; Ontario Power Generation <IE.: ecutuv yp.lawarrddeveVolauvuerut@ogg._�g_rn>; Park Planning (SM) <Pa.irk...Pja_n n.oin ftitchener.ca>; Region - Planning <PV_annin.g Vucatuon.s re Voncfwatedoo.ca>; Property Data Administrator (SM) <Eq.plp at .irmiin�lkirtclh in it a>; Robert Morgan <,R lk�.�ir�t..l@,��irgain Ikii��.lh�in�r �a>; Steven Ryder <Steven,.Ifty it 1ki .1h_ iner.,ca>; Sylvie Eastman <S.yllviie.Fas.tm in kiitclheiner:_ca>; WCDSB -Planning .......................................... < IIa_!n_!n.i.ing.sl ca>; WRDSB - Board Secretary (SII_gi.n_e.._lb urrn.s yrr slp: a) «Ilaiiin bvairins.° ..�....._.__. WRDSB - Planning <�aininiirggonrirslaca> ...... _.... Cc: Brian Bateman <iriiain:Bat main kiirclheneir.ca> .......................................................... Subject: Circulation for Comment - 7 Morrison Road (OPA/ZBA) Please see attached. Additional documentation can be found in AMANDA folders 22-124797 & 22- 124799 (City staff) and Slhaire_FVI_e. (external agencies). Comments or questions should be directed to Brian Bateman, Senior Planner (copied on this email). Christine Kompter Administrative Assistant I Planning Division I City of Kitchener 200 King Street West, 6t" Floor I P.O. Box 1118 Kitchener ON N2G 4G7 519-741-2200 ext. 7425 1 TTY 1-866-969-9994 christine.kompter@kitchener.ca Page 139 of 164 From: Lenore Ross Sent: Wednesday, February 8'2O235:06PM To: Brian Bateman Subject: RE: Staff & Agency Comments Thanks Brian, The revised TPEPbacceptable and P&Chave noadditional concerns orcomments forOPA2Z/013/M/BB and ZBA22/024/M/BB. From: Brian Bateman Sent: Friday, January 27'20232:57PK4 To: Lenore Ross Subject: FW: Staff & Agency Comments Hi Lenore, Happy Friday! Please see attached being sent from MHBCtnaddress your comments. Please let me know if this is satisfactory. Brian From: Luisa Vacondiu Sent: Thursday, January 19'202211:33AM To: Brian Bateman Cc: Pierre Chauvin Subject: FW: Staff & Agency Comments Thanks for accommodating aquick meeting with usyesterday — hopefully tonight's meeting goes off smoothly. As I mentioned yesterday, please find attached the revised Arborist Report and TMP that we've received from the client to address the comments from Park and Cemeteries. With regards to the urban design comments that Katey has provided, it seems that many of these comments are more specific to building design and/or site plan details. Can you discuss with Katey and advise if you would be comfortable with deferring these matters to the future site plan application? It I I gmymoj LI 11101 --1 as IV Page 140 of 164 E • Urban Design + Landscape Architecture 540 Bingernans Centre Drive, Suite 200 1 Kitchener I ON I N213 3X9 I T 519 576 365 • 576 Follow : . ,I�, ry I !l::::ii....................................l1 nI E.2.c, tg.g;h I ..�..vvii:tle.r I YC rn o I !!.!2�g iraim C t %i E A S MHBC .. A N N � N G LAN .:I. This communication is intended solely for the named addressee(s) and may contain information that is privileged, confidential, protected or otherwise exempt from disclosure. No waiver of confidence, privilege, protection or otherwise is made. If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, please advise us immediately and delete this email without reading, copying or forwarding it to anyone. From: Brian Bateman <,1_!rian._13ate �_a_rro.. V.:itc_herer.ca> Sent: December 21, 2022 4:05 PM To: Luisa Vacondio<Ovacorrdp_cn(+�_!D.b.L!.pVan.com> Cc: Pierre Chauvin <clhuvilrnmlhl... Iin.caairm> Subject: RE: Staff & Agency Comments Please see attached comments received to date. I still require comments from the Region, CP and Environmental Planning -Carrie will be sending hers soon — before I can recommend this for approval. In addition, UD has raised some concerns to be addressed. Please contact me should you have any comments or questions. Brian From: Brian Bateman Sent: Wednesday, December 21, 2022 9:31 AM To:'Luisa Vacondio' <0vac nd� h.!?. !p.0�u�.,.co ru> Subject: RE: Staff & Agency Comments This is perfect... thank you! I will be sending you staff/agency comments I have received so far by weeks end. Brian From: Luisa Vacondio <1I c.ind'.is!_ ! _ _ _cln_V _In_._ca _m.> Sent: Wednesday, December 21, 2022 9:15 AM To: Brian Bateman <Bo"ia .._B t m !n.C.!<itcheu�_e ca> Subject: RE: Staff & Agency Comments Page 141 of 164 Just seeing this now — attaching the Word version of the PJR for 7 Morrison. Please confirm receipt and if this is what you were looking for. From: Brian Bateman <,Briia_r�_.Bateiriri_a_r�.. _Ikitc.lhener._ca> Sent: December 20, 2022 9:33 AM To: Luisa Vacondio <1lvandi.�I Ir.!kp.lgn..corn> _ Subject: RE: Staff & Agency Comments Hi Luisa, Favour to ask: Could you please send me the Word document of your planning report. I want to get started on the report. Thanks. Brian From: Brian Bateman Sent: Friday, December 9, 2022 3:00 PM To: Pierre Chauvin <pchauviin 2mhbcplan.corn>; Luisa Vacondio <1lvaco.ind.iir_@.M1h1kn pJl !jq.._ce_m.> Subject: Staff & Agency Comments Hi Pierre & Luisa, Just want to let you know the commenting period was over but I am still waiting for comments from the Region and CPR and I guess MTO — but unsure if they will have anything to major to say here In any event, I have sent follow up emails to the Region and CPR and will send over what I have received to date very shortly. Brian Bateman, MCIP, RPP Senior Planner City of Kitchener 519-741-2200 x7869 Page 142 of 164 City of Kitchener OPA/ZBA Comment Form Project Address: 7 Morrison Road File Number: OPA22/013/M/BB and ZBA22/024/M/BB Comments Of: Policy Planning Commenter's Name: John Zunic Email: john.zunic@kitchener.ca Phone: 519.741.2200 ext. 7685 Date of Comments: December 1, 2021 ❑ I plan to attend the meeting (questions/concerns/comments for discussion) ❑ I do NOT plan to attend the meeting. 0 No meeting to be held 1. Planning Context: • The site is located within a "Community Area" on the Urban Structure map of the Official Plan (Map 2) and has a "Low Rise Residential" land use designation on Map 3: Land Use. • Policy 3.C.2.50 of the Official Plan notes that the planned function of Community Areas is to provide for residential uses as well as non-residential supporting uses intended to serve the immediate residential areas. • Policy 3.C.2.52 of the Official Plan states "Limited intensification may be permitted within Community Areas in accordance with the applicable land use designation on Map 3 and the Urban Design Policies in Section 11. The proposed development must be sensitive to and compatible with the character, form and planned function of the surrounding context." • Policy 15.D.3.10 of the Official Plan indicates that the net residential density for lands which are designated Low Rise Residential will be a maximum of 30 units per hectare. Further, Policv 15.D.3.11 of the Official Plan indicates that the maximum FSR for Low Rise Residential lands is 0.6. • The property is currently zoned RR=6 in Zoning By-law 85-1 and RES -5 in Zoning By-law 2019-051. Special Use Provision 201U as part of Zoning By-law 85-1 applies to the property and indicates that "...a craftsman shop only for a sign making business shall also be permitted in accordance with the regulations set out in Section 12.2." A City for Everyone Working Together — Growing Thoughtfully — Building Community Page 143 of 164 • Section 40.6 of the City of Kitchener Zoning By-law 85-1 indicates that the Maximum Floor Space Ratio for properties zoned R-6 is 0.6. • "Table 7-5: For Cluster Townhouse Dwelling Units" in Zoning By-law 2019-051 indicates that the Maximum Floor Space Ratio for Cluster Townhouse Dwelling Units on lands zoned RES -5 is 0.6 • This process recognizes that there is a housing crisis and climate emergency currently impacting Kitchener. • Based on the policy framework identified above and policy analysis contained within the Planning Justification Report prepared as part of this application, Policy Planning staff are supportive of the proposed Official Plan Amendment and Zoning By-law Amendment for 7 Morrison Road. • Policy Planning staff encourage a reduction in the drive aisle width as a site plan consideration, in keeping with requirements for fire access and truck turning movements, in an effort to reduce the amount of impermeable surface on the site. A City for Everyone Working Together — Growing Thoughtfully — Building Community Page 144 of 164 Brian Bateman, MCIP. RPP Senior Planner DSD — Planning Division City of Kitchener 200 King Street W. Kitchener, ON N2G 4G7 Dear Mr. Bateman: Post Circulation Comments OPA 22/013/M/BB ZBA 22/024/M/BB Klondike Homes Ltd. 7 Morrison Road CITY OF KITCHENER PLANNING, DEVELOPMENT AND LEGISLATIVE SERVICES Community Planning 150 Frederick Street 8th Floor Kitchener Ontario N2G 4,13 Canada Telephone: 519-575-4400 TTY: 519-575-4608 Fax: 519-575-4466 www.reedionofwaterloo.ca Shilling Yip (226) 753-1064 (C) Files: D17-40/2/22013 C14-60/2/22024 February 8, 2023 Region staff has reviewed the above -noted applications and provides the following comments for your consideration at this time. The applicant is proposing Official Plan Amendment and Zoning By-law Amendment for the development of two (2) stacked townhouse buildings with 16 units each, for a total of 32 units. The proposed residential development also includes amenity areas, a private access road, 45 parking spaces and secure indoor bicycle storage spaces. The OPA is to add a special policy area to the Low Rise Residential designation in order to permit a maximum floor area ratio (FSR) of 0.9 and a density exceeding 30 units per hectare. The ZBA is to re -zone the lands from R-6 to RES -5 with site specific for FSR, building height, parking, visitor parking and rear yard relief. The lands are designated Urban Area "Built -Up Area" and within the "Central Transit Corridor" on Map 3a in the Regional Official Plan (ROP). Lands included within the Built -Up Area are intended to accommodate the majority of the Region's growth within Document Number: 4304692 Version: 1 Page 145 of 164 the time horizon of the ROP. This development will contribute to the intensification target within the Built -Up Area. Water Services Water Services Engineering and Planning staff has reviewed the Functioning Servicing and SWM Report and have the following comment: In detailed design, the applicant must vacuum excavate the regional waterman, in daylight, to confirm the depth and horizontal/vertical alignment to ensure there is no conflict with the proposed sanitary servicing. Please submit engineering drawings for review. Hydrogeology & Water Programs (Source Water Protection) Hydrogeology and Water Program (HWP) staff has indicated the proposed development falls within the WHPA D for the Fountain Street wellfield and the Hidden Valley Intake (I PZ 3). Staff has requested that a prohibition on geothermal energy systems as defined in the Regional Official Plan be included in the Zoning By-law amendment for the subject property. Proposed wording, "Geothermal Wells are prohibited on site. A geothermal well is defined as a vertical well, borehole or pipe installation used for geothermal systems, ground -source heat pump systems, geo-exchange systems or earth energy systems for heating or cooling; including open -loop and closed-loop vertical borehole systems. A geothermal well does not include a horizontal system where construction or excavation occurs to depths less than five metres unless the protective geologic layers overlaying a vulnerable aquifer have been removed through construction or excavation." Salt Management Plan A Salt Management Plan (SMP) will be required as part of site plan for private parking lots and/or private roadways. Implementation of the SMP may be secured through future Planning Act applications. As part of the SMP, HWP would encourage the proponent to incorporate design considerations with respect to salt management, including: • Ensure that cold weather stormwater flows are considered in the site design. Consideration should be given to minimize the transport of meltwater across the parking lots or driveway. This also has the potential to decrease the formation of ice and thereby the need for de-icing. • Directing downspouts towards pervious (i.e. grassy) surfaces to prevent runoff from freezing on parking lots and walkways. • Locating snow storage areas on impervious (i.e. paved) surfaces. • Locating snow storage areas in close proximity to catchbasins. • Using winter maintenance contractors that are Smart About SaItTM certified. • Using alternative de-icers (i.e. pickled sand) in favour of road salt. Document Number: 4304692 Version: 1 Page 146 of 164 -3 - The proponent is eligible for certification under the Smart About Sal tTM program for this property. Completion of the SMP is one part of the program. To learn more about the program and to find accredited contractors please refer to: http://www.smartaboutsait.com/. Benefits of designation under the program include cost savings through more efficient use of salt, safe winter conditions by preventing the formation of ice, and potential reductions in insurance premiums. Corridor Planning Functional Servicing and Stormwater Management (SWM) Report The subject lands do not abut directly King Street East (Regional Road 08), but the CPR/Grand River Railway Company (GRR) lands abutting these lands directly abut the Regional road. The Functional Servicing & SWM Report dated September 21, 2022 prepared by JPE Engineering has concluded that the required services are available for the proposed development. With respect to storm water management, the report has found that currently the side sheet flows into the King Street right-of-way through swales/ditches, ultimately to a creak on the south side of the road. The report confirms that under developed conditions the flows will be attenuated to pre-existing levels and will be discharged into road side ditch along Morrison Road. The report indicates a detailed SWM report will be prepared at the Site Plan stage when more details are available. The following points need to be clarified/noted further: a) The report mentioned that the soils are non conductive and a cash -in -lieu will be the option for the SWM drainage. Clarification is required, whether there will be any concentrated storm flow or a storm connection directly within the King Street right-of-way from the SWM management system. b) Will there be more than the current flows than under the existing conditions as a result of this cash -in -lieu option? c) If yes for the above, is there sufficient capacity to take the discharge in the existing system? More details must be provided in this regard. d) A Sanitary connection is proposed within the King Street right-of-way. Please note that this will require Regional approval through a separate process of Municipal Consent. Additional comments, if any, will follow. Environmental Noise The Environmental Noise Study dated August 3, 2022 prepared by JPE Engineering is currently under review. The following clarifications are required: a) The proposed development is within a 75m vibration influence zone as per Railway Proximity Guidelines. No assessment of vibration is included in the report. A vibration study will be required to confirm that railway vibration from the Document Number: 4304692 Version: 1 Page 147 of 164 -4 - CPR is not a concern, and does not require any mitigation measures in the building design. This may be secured through the use of a holding provision. b) It appears that the railway noise is based on the 2015 railway data. Please confirm that the data used in this regard will remain valid for future 10 years rail traffic forecasts. Alternatively, a conservative approach be used to calculate the future rail traffic. c) Please confirm that the noise levels from road and rail noise are combined together for reaching the ultimate noise levels at the assessment points. This is unclear in the report. d) The OLA location appears to be analysed very close to the proposed noise barrier. A central location should be analysed to assess the noise impacts for the OLA. e) The proposed noise barrier is only few metres from the railway. Please confirm that any specific vibration design is not required, a typical design detail for the proposed noise barrier be added in the report. f) Maintenance arrangements for the proposed noise barrier be confirmed by City of Kitchener staff and be detailed in the report. The above matters may be addressed prior to adoption of the ZBL amendment or secured through the use of a holding provision. Conditions for Site Plan Application Site Grading & Stormwater Management Storm sewers within the Regional road right-of-way are generally sized and designed to only accommodate stormwater from the right-of-way and in some instances off road surface drainage under existing conditions. A private stormwater connection to any storm sewer on King Street East (RR #08) will be discouraged where an alternate stormwater connection is available, including infiltration if soil conditions and Source Protection under the Clean Water Act permit, or if it is determined that the King Street East storm sewer does not have the sufficiency (condition and capacity) to accommodate private stormwater flows from this site. It is the responsibility of the applicant' s engineering consultant to determine an appropriate stormwater outlet from this site and the sufficiency of the receiving storm system if there is no other option available and to include this information in the stormwater management report. The applicant or their consultant should contact Mr. Malcolm Lister, Manager, Technical Services for the Region of Waterloo at 519-575-4432 or mlister@regionofwaterloo.ca to determine if any engineering plans and/or further technical information for King Street East (RR #08) is available which may be of assistance. Document Number: 4304692 Version: 1 Page 148 of 164 -5 - The applicant must submit electronic copies of detailed Site Grading & Drainage Control Plan(s) and Site Servicing Plan(s) along with a SWM report for Regional review and approval. This should include drainage details for the subject property, abutting properties and the public road allowance so as to ensure compatible drainage and to show thereon all existing and proposed connections to the municipal storm sewers, sanitary sewers and water mains and all detailed erosion and siltation control features, all to the satisfaction of the Regional Municipality of Waterloo. The site grading must be compatible with the existing road grades and any future project of King Street East (RR #08). The site must be graded in accordance with the approved plan and the Regional Road allowance must be restored to the satisfaction of the Regional Municipality of Waterloo. Transit Plannina There will be no transit requirements for the proposed development. However, staff note the following points: This area is well -served by Routes 204 iXpress (two-way) and Route 27. Beginning in May 2022, Route 27 will be revised to operate in a one-way loop northbound on Morrison. • Pedestrian infrastructure along Morrison Road is lacking in this vicinity. The City undertook some underground works in this area last year, and the sidewalk on the west side of Morrison may have been constructed as part of this project. The City should consider a sidewalk on east side of Morrison Road and pedestrian connections from the proposed development to help use of transit service in the area. Airport Zoning (Advisory Comments) The subject lands are located within the 6 km Development Regulation Area (Transport Canada). For further information in this regard please contact: Jordan Vander Veen, Senior Engineer, Design and Construction (Airport) 519.648.2256 ext. 8514 Email: jvanderveenCa�regionofwaterloo.ca Site Servicing / Work Permit / Municipal Consent A Municipal Consent will be required for the installation of any new/update to / removal of the existing services within the King Street right-of-way. Also, a Region of Waterloo Work Permit must be obtained from the Region of Waterloo prior to commencing construction within the Region's right of way. For further information in this regard, please visit https://rmow.permitcentral.ca/ Document Number: 4304692 Version: 1 Page 149 of 164 -6 - Conditions for Condominium / Consent ADDlication Staae Detailed Environmental Noise Stud Pending acceptance of the above-mentioned Noise Study, the recommendations of the above noised study will be implemented through a registered agreement with the Region of Waterloo; as a regional condition for any future Plan of Condominium/Consent application(s) as may be required for the proposed development. Although, the requirement of a detailed noise study may not be a condition of Site Plan application, it is strongly recommended that the proponent undertake a detailed noise study and construct the site/buildings/units accordingly to avoid any retrofit at a later stage. It's the proponents' responsibility to ensure that there are no environmental noise impacts from/on the proposed development. Land Use Compatibility The subject property is immediately adjacent to the Grand River Hospital Freeport site. Staff recommends a warning clause (Type E) pursuant to NPC -300 be included in all offers to purchase and/or lease agreements. Proposed wording for the warning clause reads, "Purchasers/tenants are advised that due to the proximity of the adjacent hospital facility/Freeport Hospital, noise from Freeport Hospital may at times be audible." This requirement should be secured through a registered agreement with the City of Kitchener as part of any future Planning Act application, including consent or plan of condominium. Record of Site Condition (RSC) A RSC is required according to the Region's guideline on site contamination. There are high and medium threats in the Region's Threats Inventory Database for the adjacent property to the west at 3570 King St E (Grand River Hospital — Freeport Campus). There is also a rail line to the south of the site which would be considered a medium threat. The RSC requirement was noted in the pre -submission comments, but it does not appear that an RSC has been filed in the interim. The RSC along with the MECP Acknowledgement will be required prior to adoption of the ZBL amendment, or secured through the use of a holding provision. Environmental Planning No comments. Archaeology No comments. Document Number: 4304692 Version: 1 Page 150 of 164 -7 - Housing General The following Regional policies and initiatives support the development and maintenance of affordable housing: • Regional Strategic Plan o Objective 4.2 requires the Region to make affordable housing more available to individuals and families. • 10 -Year Housing and Homelessness Plan o contains an affordable housing target which is that 30% of all new residential development between 2019 and 2041 in Waterloo Region is to be affordable to low and moderate income households. • Building Better Futures Framework o shows how the Region plans to create 2,500 units of housing affordable to people with low to moderate incomes by 2025. • Region of Waterloo Official Plan o Section 3.A (range and Mix of Housing) contains land use policies that ensure the provision of a full and diverse range and mix of permanent housing that is safe, affordable, of adequate size, and meets the accessibility requirements of all residents. The Region supports the provision of a full range of housing options, including affordable housing. Rent levels and house prices that are considered affordable according to the Regional Official Plan are provided below in the section on affordability. Should this development application move forward, staff recommend that the applicant consider providing a number of affordable housing units on the site, as defined in the Regional Official Plan. In order for affordable housing to fulfill its purpose of being affordable to those who require rents or purchase prices lower than the regular market provides, a mechanism should be in place to ensure the units remain affordable and establish income levels of the households who can rent or own the homes. Affordability For the purposes of evaluating the affordability of an ownership unit, based on the definition in the Regional Official Plan, the purchase price is compared to the least expensive of: Housing for which the purchase price results in annual accommodation costs $385,500 which do not exceed 30 percent of gross Document Number: 4304692 Version: 1 Page 151 of 164 annual household income for low and moderate income households $1,470 Housing for which the purchase price is at least 10 percent below the average $576,347 purchase price of a resale unit in the Bachelor: $950 regional market area 1 -Bedroom: $1,134 *Based on the most recent information available from the PPS Housing Tables (2021). In order for an owned unit to be deemed affordable, the maximum affordable house price is $385,500. For the purposes of evaluating the affordability of a rental unit, based on the definition of affordable housing in the Regional Official Plan, the average rent is compared to the least expensive of: A unit for which the rent does not exceed 30 per cent of the gross annual $1,470 household income for low and moderate income renter households A unit for which the rent is at or below the Bachelor: $950 average market rent (AMR) in the 1 -Bedroom: $1,134 regional market area 2 -Bedroom: $1,356 3 -Bedroom: $1,538 4+ Bedroom: $3,997 *Based on the most recent information available from the PPS Housing Tables (2021) In order for a rental unit to be deemed affordable, the average rent for the proposed units which have fewer than 3 bedrooms must be at or below the average market rent in the regional market area as shown above. For proposed units with three or more bedrooms, the average rent for the units must be below $1,470. Please do not hesitate to contact Judy Maan Miedema directly by email at JMaanMiedemaCa�regionofwaterloo.ca should you have any questions or wish to discuss in more detail. Proposed Zoning By-law Amendment As noted above under HWP comments, staff has requested that a prohibition on geothermal energy systems as defined in the Regional Official Plan be included in the Zoning By-law amendment for the subject property. Proposed wording provided above. Document Number: 4304692 Version: 1 Page 152 of 164 Staff recommends the use of a holding provision to secure the completion of a railway vibration study, Record of Site Condition (if not completed and MECP acknowledged prior to adoption of ZBL amendment), and final acceptance of the environmental noise study noted above. Regional Development Charges Any future development on the subject lands will be subject to provisions of Regional Development Charges By-law 19-037 or any successor thereof. Other Staff acknowledges the Region's required review fees for the OPA and ZBA applications were received November 3, 2022. Region staff has no objection to proceeding with a City staff recommendation to Kitchener Council subject to the above -noted comments. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me (226) 753-1064 (c). Yours truly, Shilling Yip, MCIP, RPP Senior Planner cc. Pierre Chauvin, MHBC Planning Document Number: 4304692 Version: 1 Page 153 of 164 City of Kitchener Application Type: Official Plan and Zoning By-law Amendments Application: Official Plan Amendment OPA22/013/M/BB Zoning By-law Amendment ZBA22/024/M/BB Project Address: 7 Morrison Road Comments of: Transportation Services Commenter's Name: Dave Seller Email: dave.seller@kitchener.ca Phone: 519-741-2200 ext. 7369 Date of Comments: November 17, 2022 a. After reviewing the Scoped Traffic Impact Study (August 25, 2022) submitted by R.V. Anderson Associates Limited (RVA), Transportation Services offer the following comments. The applicant is proposing to development 32 stacked townhouse units, with one full move vehicular access provided along Morrison Road. The development is estimated to generate 12 AM and 12 PM peak hour vehicle trips. Under the forecasted 2028 Future Total Traffic Volumes, Morrison Road at the site access point is operating with sufficient vehicle capacity, vehicle delays not exceeding LOS B and no vehicle queueing concerns in either the AM or PM peak hours. Also, there are no recommendations to provide additional physical capacity near this access in response to the site generated traffic. The forecasted 2028 Future Total Traffic Volumes at the intersection of King Street East and Morrison Road is currently operating with reserve capacity, minimal delays, and no queuing issues for most vehicle movements. The one movement experiencing delay is the southbound movement along Morrison Road at King Street East, in the PM peak hour. This is due to the higher traffic volumes on King Street East, where fewer gaps are provided for southbound vehicles along Morrison Road. This results in the southbound movement experiencing delays of approximately two minutes in the 2028 horizon year, without the subject development traffic. However, despite the delay, the low volumes result in reserve capacity for the movement (v/c ratio does not exceed 0.44) and minimal queuing (approximately two (2) vehicles). With the inclusion of site generated traffic, delays increase marginally by approximately 10 seconds, but the movement is still operating with reserve capacity and queues are not impeding on the proposed site access. A stopping sight distance (SSD) analysis was competed along Morrison Road at the site access utilizing the Transportation Association of Canada (TAC) Geometric Design Guide for Canadian Roads. Based on a 40km/h speed limit, a 50km/h design speed, where a 65m SSD is recommended. However, Morrison Road has an approximate 8% downgrade while travelling south towards King Street East. To account for the slope along Morrison Road, RVA utilized TAC methodologies yielding A City for Everyone Working Together — Growing Thoughtfully — Building Community Page 154 of 164 an increased SSD of 73m from the recommended 65m. Based on RVA field observations, a SSD of 74m was achieved along Morrison Road, exceeding the recommended SSD. Therefore, based on the field analysis completed by RVA, the proposed site access location should provide sufficient stopping sight distance for oncoming vehicles along Morrison Road. Also, the traffic generated by this development will have minimal impact on the surround road network. b. The Garbage Truck Turning Movement 1 plan submitted by MHBC for the "Wayne Titan" design vehicle illustrates a conflict with the concrete curbing noted below in red. Transportation Services recommends correcting this conflict. a.. c. As part of the City of Kitchener's Official Plan, Morrison Road is designated for a road widening, with an ultimate road width between King Street East and Manor Drive of 20 metres. Therefore, a conveyance of a portion of lands along the Morrison Road frontage is required. The approximate location of the widening is noted below in red hatching, A reference plan be submitted noting the road widening. Not to scage A City for Everyone Working Together — Growing Thoughtfully — Building Community Page 155 of 164 From: Katey Crawford Sent: Friday, March 10, 2023 9:16 AM To: Brian Bateman Subject: RE: 7 Morrison - Updated Urban Design Brief Hi Brian, The last page of the brief includes the previous outdated rendering. That page will need to be updated with the new rendering concept. I have no other concerns besides that. Thanks, Katey From: Brian Bateman <,B_iruan. ateman k'itchener,ca> ........................................................................................ Sent: Thursday, March 9, 2023 5:56 PM To: Katey Crawford <K t y U nrFa U kitchener._ca> Subject: FW: 7 Morrison - Updated Urban Design Brief Hello Katey, Can you please confirm this is acceptable. Thanks. Brian From: Luisa Vacondio <V c.ind'.pcln_Vp_In_._ca_mn.> Sent: Thursday, March 9, 2023 3:11 PM To: Brian Bateman <Bcp_ai.._B t m in.C.!<itcheu�_e a> Cc: Pierre Chauvin < clh prirn mlhl ul .cgM>; Paul Florica <12 Id. ldond l<ehpm s c.o..irm> Subject: 7 Morrison - Updated Urban Design Brief Good Afternoon Brian, Please find attached the revised Urban Design Brief for inclusion in your final staff report package, which reflects the changes to the site plan and elevations. Let us know if there is anything else you'll need from us to complete your report. Thanks, Luisa MHBCPlanning, Urban Design & Landscape Architecture N Bingemans Centre Drive, Suite 200 1 KitchenerON : 9 I T 519 576 365 • Page 156 of 164 E L. A N N U N G URBAN DES�GN a w I- w UE This communication is intended solely for the named addressee(s) and may contain information that is privileged, confidential, protected or otherwise exempt from disclosure. No waiver of confidence, privilege, protection or otherwise is made. If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, please advise us immediately and delete this email without reading, copying or forwarding it to anyone. Page 157 of 164 From: Planning <planning@wcdsb.ca> Sent: Thursday, November 17, 2022 5:24 PM To: Brian Bateman Subject: RE: Circulation for Comment - 7 Morrison Road (OPA/ZBA) Attachments: RE: Notice of (OPA/ZBA/SP) Pre -submission Consultation Meeting - 7 Morrison Road Good Afternoon Brian, The Waterloo Catholic District School Board has reviewed the subject application and based on our development circulation criteria have no new comments beyond those submitted for the presubmission consultation. Those comments are attached to this email. If you require any further information, please contact me by e-mail at Jordan. Neale@wcdsb.ca. Thank you, Jordan Neale Planning Technician, WCDSB 480 Dutton Dr, Waterloo, ON N2L 4C6 519-578-3660 ext. 2355 From: Christine Kompter <CIhlristi n_e.a.lKr.ir�ro.pter@kVtchener.ca> Sent: Tuesday, October 25, 2022 10:07 AM To: CPR (Cly Eroxirirnity-Ontario _ cpr.ca) <.c.p piroximity-ontario _ cpr.ca>; MTO - Allan Hodgins (VIla9_:_V.:Iegiinse g_rn.tgirig:g) <g.VIIam lhodirns@an.taruc gg>; 'clerks@cambridge.ca' «Narks@cambridge >, _DL_#_DSD _Planning <[)S[_ P g.9.9i_in ID v.si_o n V<ot V rgro >; Bell - c/o WSP <&cu✓u_Da.r.uo s@ sp gu ro>; Carlos Reyes < r0�as VY y se kc tcVn_e_iner.ca>; Darren Kropf <I[)arren Kro.pfC k tchener.ca>; Dave Seller <1D ve SelVer@kitchener.ca>; David Paetz ........ ................. ....... <I avud, a_e:t _@V<utcVnern r.c >; Ellen Straus <If.IVeru::S rauus@_k.itch n r._ca>; Enova Power Corp. -Greig Cameron <reuainnoircin..@e.inva.iipir coi>m>; Enova Power Corp. -Shaun Wang <slhaua.in Ging. _ .in vale rr c�im>; Feds <v;n. d..'�:f .:s.:: a>; GRCA -Planning (.I .Ila_rnrn..ing. .girain v r. a.) <1p.llainrniing@.gra_!nd_rivar.ca>; Greg Reitzel <G.ircZ,_Rj!J z ll.@_kiitcheneir.ca>; Hydro One - Dennis DeRango <wind_ us laininiiing@Ih .irpginc cpm>; Jim Edmondson <J_iim.Edirnonds rn_@_kiitclhein_e.ir.ca.>; Justin Readman <J_u_s.tii_n._Re_adlnma_n@_kiitclne_rn.elr._ca>; Katherine Hughes<.Ka.tlh_cri_In_p_..II..N_u,ugjbes@kiitcheneir.ca>; Mike Seiling <I _Vrkc..Se.i.11ir..... Ikirtclhelner._ca>; Ontario Power Generation <l::xeC ut Vev .lawainddevello ment o .corm>; Park Planning (SM) <Pa.irlk...Plla.in.in.irin .@.II<irtclnein ir.._ca>; Region - Planning <Ihll_aininV_in. A Iliicatiions re iioinofwaterlloo.ca>; Property Data Administrator (SM) <Illirolp_ a.tgAdj _i.in.. .lkirtclh in_ it ca>; Robert Morgan <.Rra.lk.�.Birt..Moi.r elkirtclheiner.ca>; Steven Ryder <Steve.n,........Iit)deir a)1 tclhener.ca>• Sylvie Eastman <S, llviie.Eastmain@II<iitclheiner.ca>; Planning .................................. <pVannin. @wcdsb.ca>; WRDSB - Board Secretary ( tgjn_e burns@nnrrd.sb.ca) «II_ u_ine buirins@wrdsb.ca>; WRDSB - Planning <p anninf@wrdsb.ca> Cc: Brian Bateman<IE3riain.BatemanC@V<Vtchener.ca> Subject: Circulation for Comment - 7 Morrison Road (OPA/ZBA) Caution - External Email - This Message comes from an external organization. Do NOT click on unrecognized links or provide your username and/or password. Page 158 of 164 Please see attached. Additional documentation can be found in AMANDA folders 22-124797 & 22- 124799 (City staff) and Slha reFill_e. (external agencies). Comments or questions should be directed to Brian Bateman, Senior Planner (copied on this email). Christine Kompter Administrative Assistant I Planning Division I City of Kitchener 200 King Street West, 6t" Floor I P.O. Box 1118 Kitchener ON N2G 4G7 519-741-2200 ext. 7425 1 TTY 1-866-969-9994 christine.l<ompter@I<itchener.ca Disclaimer - This email and any files transmitted with it are confidential and contain privileged or copyright information. You must not present this message to another party without gaining permission from the sender. If you are not the intended recipient you must not copy, distribute or use this email or the information contained in it for any purpose other than to notify us. If you have received this message in error, please notify the sender immediately, and delete this email from your system. We do not guarantee that this material is free from viruses or any other defects although due care has been taken to minimize the risk. Any views expressed in this message are those of the individual sender, except where the sender specifically states them to be the views of the Waterloo Catholic District School Board. Page 159 of 164 From: Kashels Sent: Tuesday, November 22, 2022 11:40 AM To: Brian Bateman Cc: Dave Schnider Subject: Fw: 7 Morrison Road Proposed Development Feedback You don't often get email from From: Kashels Sent: Wednesday, November 16, 2022 8:16 PM Subject: 7 Morrison Road Proposed Development Feedback Dear Mr. Bateman, My name is Baldev (Roger) Lubhaya, living at Our family recently received your feedback notice for a proposed development in our neighborhood at the intersection of King St. E & Morrison Rd. I am quite concerned and question the appropriateness of this new high density development. I am sure you are aware a similar high density development was built a couple of years ago near our house. Since that development was completed, our neighbourhood has experienced a fundamental negative impact on its safety, serenity, and flavour. Now you wish to double -down with a second high-density development right across the road from the first! This is most outrageous and uncalled for. We can see no benefits or justification for this imposition. What was once a relatively peaceful and quiet road has become a busy, noisy, and dangerous throughway due to the drastic number of new tenets and drivers that have flooded the area. Morrison Road was not designed for such heavy vehicle and pedestrian traffic. The noise and air pollution have gotten noticeably worse given the increase in traffic. There is also the matter of speeding and unsafe driving. Cars squeal their tires and accelerate dangerously fast by our house almost daily. This was rarely the case beforehand. As well, numerous pedestrians are walking directly on the road at all hours of the day, including young kids, joggers, pets, people pushing their strollers, etc. This creates high-risk situations for both drivers and pedestrians as there are no sidewalks in the area and the road is just too narrow. During the summer we have cars speeding past the curve near our house and in the winter we have traffic jams. This is due to the hazardous conditions prevalent especially after a snowfall. Not just due to the slippery conditions but because city buses are too large to safely navigate the sharp curve near our house because the snow banks pile up too high and are not cleared properly. This ultimately leads to even narrower roads, traffic jams, and near misses of on- coming vehicles. Finally, the bus is also prone to cancellation during slippery conditions as it is unable to navigate up the sharp hill at the intersection. As such, placing hundreds of new people unable to access public transportation in this location may not be the wisest plan. Page 160 of 164 Next, there is the train tracks adjacent to the intersection of King and Morrison. I would question the ethics of placing another high density development near these tracks that are travelled daily by cargo trains. I am sure there will be many young families with children that could play on the tracks, as well numerous new cars crossing these tracks. This formula can only lead to a tragedy over time. As such, I see no benefits of placing a second high-density development right next to train tracks. There is also the noise pollution as the train passes by every night and blows its horn. It's not too loud by our house, but I can imagine future tenets finding the the daily noise of both the horn and the train passing -by a major nuisance. Unfortunately, before this development was built two years ago, we went through the same process of neighbourhood feedback. At the time we voiced our strong opposition to the development but all these objections fell on deaf ears. Will we be going through deja vu with this new development feedback process where the families living here have no say? Enough damage has already been done by building these 64 units on our street, we do not want or need anymore! From my last experience, it seems the planning department and builder had all come to an agreement beforehand and the neighbourhood feedback was just a formality. I hope this time, all parties are listening in good faith and giving serious consideration to our concerns, including cancelling this project. Please provide this following information before the scheduled meeting: 1. Name of the developer. 2. Was this developer the same as the previous one, or have any relation to the previous one? 3. Is the developer waiting for your department's consent? 4. What is the criteria for consent? 5. What is the criteria for rejection? 6. If this development were to proceed against all opposition, what would be intangible and tangible benefits to the neighbourhood? 7. How will near -by property prices be impacted in the short, medium and long-term given the higher air pollution, vehicle traffic, noise, unsafe conditions, etc.? 8. Are there any future plans to create more high-density developments in the surrounding area? Thank you for your time and please feel free to contact me if you wish to discuss. Sincerely, Roger Lubhaya CC: dave.schnider(@kitchener.ca Page 161 of 164 I am copy this to my councilmen and our mayor also a petition signed by the neighbors Page 162 of 164 From Kashels Family Place Ltd Roger Lubhaya GM Page 163 of 164 From: Sent: To: Subject: You don't often get email from Donald E. Lougheed Wednesday, November 2, 2022 10:43 AM Brian Bateman 7 Morrison Road Learn why this is important Hi Brian further to our discussion this morning, I am interested in the intersection of Morrison Road and King Street and the proposal near that intersection. Don Lougheed P.S. Are you related to Carl Bateman? Page 164 of 164