Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutFCS Agenda - 2024-09-161 KiTc�ivER Finance and Corporate Services Committee Agenda Monday, September 16, 2024, 4:00 p.m. - 5:00 p.m. Council Chambers - Hybrid City of Kitchener 200 King Street W, Kitchener, ON N2G 4G7 People interested in participating in this meeting can register online using the delegation registration form at www.kitchener.ca/delegation or via email at delegation@kitchener.ca. Please refer to the delegation section on the agenda below for registration in-person and electronic participation deadlines. Written comments received will be circulated prior to the meeting and will form part of the public record. The meeting live -stream and archived videos are available at www.kitchener.ca/watchnow. *Accessible formats and communication supports are available upon request. If you require assistance to take part in a city meeting or event, please call 519-741-2345 or TTY 1-866-969-9994.* Chair: Councillor S. Davey Vice -Chair: Councillor B. loannidis Pages 1. Commencement 2. Disclosure of Pecuniary Interest and the General Nature Thereof Members of Council and members of the City's local boards/committees are required to file a written statement when they have a conflict of interest. If a conflict is declared, please visit www. kitchener. ca/conflict to submit your written form. 3. Consent The following matters are considered not to require debate and should be approved by one motion in accordance with the recommendation contained in each staff report. A majority vote is required to discuss any report listed as under this section. 4. 5. A 7. 3.1 Nominating Committee Reappointments - 2024-2026 - COR -2024-394 3 3.2 School Bus Loading Zone and Crossing Guard Adjustments DSD -2024- 16 397 3.3 Noise Exemption, VanMar Constructors On Inc, 641 King Street West, 27 CSD -2024-408 3.4 Noise Exemption - K -W OktoberPest, CSD -2024-391 125 Note: Any recommendation arising from this matter will be considered at a Special Council meeting later this date for final ratification. 3.5 Execution of Agreements with Youth Climate Action Fund (YCAF) Grant 128 Recipients, DSD -2024-395 Note: Any recommendation arising from this matter will be considered at a Special Council meeting later this date for final ratification. Delegations Pursuant to Council's Procedural By-law, delegations are permitted to address the Committee for a maximum of five (5) minutes. All Delegations where possible are encouraged to register prior to the start of the meeting. For Delegates who are attending in-person, registration is permitted up to the start of the meeting. Delegates who are interested in attending virtually must register by 2: 00 p.m. on September 16, 2024, in order to participate electronically. 4.1 None at this time. Discussion Items 5.1 2024-2025 Gas Supply and Delivery Rates, 15 m 129 INS -2024-383 (Staff will provide a 5 -minute presentation on this matter). 5.2 Belmont Business Improvement Area (BIA) 30 m 145 Boundary Expansion, DSD -2024-372 (Staff will provide a 5 -minute presentation on this matter). Information Items 6.1 Strategic Plan Update, August 2024 Implementation, CAO -2024-412 150 6.2 2024 June Variance Report - FIN -2024-404 160 6.3 Integrated Sanitary Master Plan Process Update, INS -2024-396 179 Adjournment Marilyn Mills Committee Coordinator Page 2 of 180 Staff Report Corporate Services Department www.kitchener.ca REPORT TO: Finance and Corporate Services Committee DATE OF MEETING: September 16, 2024 SUBMITTED BY: Amanda Fusco, Director of Legislated Services, 519-741-2200 ext. 7809 PREPARED BY: Amanda Fusco, Director of Legislated Services, 519-741-2200 ext. 7809 WARD(S) INVOLVED: All DATE OF REPORT: July 23, 2024 REPORT NO.: COR -2024-394 SUBJECT: Nominating Committee — Reappointments for 2024-2026 RECOMMENDATION: That representatives' or their designates from the Waterloo Region Community Foundation, Kitchener -Waterloo Multicultural Centre, the United Way Waterloo Region Communities, Capacity Canada, and the Greater Kitchener Waterloo Chamber of Commerce as outlined in Corporate Service Department report COR -2024-394, be re- appointed to the Nominating Committee for a two-year term from November 2024 to November 14, 2026; and, That the Appointment to Boards and Committees Policy, GOV-BOA-063 and Nominating Committee Terms of Reference Policy, GOV-BOA-010 attached as Appendix "A" to corporate services report COR -2024-394 be amended. REPORT HIGHLIGHTS: The purpose of this report is to re -appoint members to the Nominating Committee The financial implications are none. Community engagement includes posting this report online, and consulting with current nominating committee, and city staff This report supports the delivery of core services BACKGROUND: The Nominating Committee (the Committee) has been in place since 2008, with latest amendments in 2023 to reflect enhancements to the committee regarding equity tools to increase transparency in decision making, unconscious bias training, and improvements to the applicant review process and selection arising from a diversity lens application. The Committee's mandate is to assess applicants for the City's various Advisory Committees of Council and Quasi -Judicial Tribunals and to present Council with a list of suggested candidates for each committee/tribunal *** This information is available in accessible formats upon request. *** Please call 519-741-2345 or TTY 1-866-969-9994 for assistance. Page 3 of 180 When assessing applicants, the Committee considers the Terms of Reference for each Advisory Committee and Tribunal as well as the following criteria to determine the best fit for applicants 1) The applicant's 1st choice of committee, whenever possible; 2) The applicant's expertise and interest as outlined in the application; 3) A mix of returning members and new members to support succession planning and continuity within the Committee; and, 4) That, where possible based on citizen interest and application, committee composition reflects the diverse demographics of the City of Kitchener (e.g. diversity in terms of age, residency, race, gender identity, sexuality etc.). The following organizations were appointed to the Committee in 2022 for a term ending November 14, 2024: • Waterloo Region Community Foundation - President/Chief Executive Officer or Director of Philanthropy; • Kitchener -Waterloo Multicultural Centre (KWMC) - Chief Executive Officer; • United Way Waterloo Region Communities (UWayWRC) - Chief Executive Officer or Vice -President of Strategy and Business Development; • Capacity Canada (CC) - Chief Executive Officer; and, • Greater Kitchener Waterloo Chamber of Commerce (GKWCC) - President/Chief Executive Officer. The members of these organizations have brought their governance and recruiting experience along with their broad community perspective to the selection process for the Advisory Committee recruitments. They have consistently reviewed applications from individuals in a careful and thoughtful way ensuring their selections are in keeping with the Terms of References for the various Advisory Committees as well as the aforementioned criteria. REPORT: Over the past few cycles, Policy GOV-BOA-63 (Appointment to Boards and Committees) has not been revised with respect to Clause 2 [eligibility requirement to either reside, work or own property in the City of Kitchener]. Based on precedence and the significance that each of the community organizations identified as Nominating Committee members have in the community, it is staff's recommendation that the Appointments to Boards and Committee policy be amended to reflect that notwithstanding the eligibility requirements, Nominating Committee members shall be eligible for appointment if their offices are not located in Kitchener and/or where the representatives might not reside or own property in Kitchener, provided the organization's mandate still relates to the provisions of services and program for the broad Kitchener community. Should the organization cease to function in its current capacity or limit its scope, the composition and eligibility requirements would be amended. This provides the much needed flexibility to ensure continued functioning of the Nominating Committee while limiting the need for exemptions to established corporate policy. The Nominating Committee Terms of Reference Policy (GOV-BOA-010) were amended in September 2024 to address equity enhancements to the process including an equity toolkit, unconscious bias training, and equity staff supplementing the Nominating Committee when considering applications to the Equity and Anti -Racism Advisory Committee specifically. As Page 4 of 180 refinements have been made to processes, it recommended that the number of equity staff supplementing the review of Equity & Anti -Racism Advisory Committee applications be streamlined to include one staff member as opposed to two staff. As such the Terms of Reference, attached as Appendix B to this report are being recommended for amendment to reflect the change and minor housekeeping and formatting changes. STRATEGIC PLAN ALIGNMENT: This report supports the delivery of core services. FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS: Capital Budget – The recommendation has no impact on the Capital Budget. Operating Budget – The recommendation has no impact on the Operating Budget. COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT: INFORM – This report has been posted to the City's website with the agenda in advance of the council / committee meeting. CONSULT – This report and Nominating Committee processes have been developed in consultation with Equity, Anti -Racism and Indigenous Initiatives staff. COLLABORATE – The Nominating Committee is comprised of individuals who provide direct advice and recommendations regarding the composition of the City's advisory committees and boards. Each Nominating Committee member was consulted as to interest, availability and capacity to serve in this continued function. PREVIOUS REPORTS/AUTHORITIES: • COR -2023-377 -Nominating Committee —Reappointments for 2022-2024 Term APPROVED BY: Victoria Raab, General Manager, Corporate Services ATTACHMENTS: Appendix A: Appointment to Boards and Committees Policy, GOV-BOA-063 and Nominating Committee Terms of Reference Policy, GOV-BOA-010 Page 5 of 180 Appendix A to COR -2024-394 J POLICY APPLIES TO THE FOLLOWING: K;R ❑ POLICY Policy No: GOV-BOA-063 Policy Title: APPOINTMENT TO Approval Date: September 8, 2008 ❑ BOARDS &COMMITTEES ❑ Non Union ❑ Reviewed Date: July 2016 Policy Type: COUNCIL Next Review Date: July 2021 Category: Governance Student ❑ I.B.E.W.636 ❑ Last Amended: October 1, 2012 Sub -Category: Board & Committee ❑x Replaces: 1-063, Appointment to Boards & Committees Author: City Clerk, Director of Legislated Services Repealed: Dept/Div: Finance & Corporate Services ❑x Department, Legislated Services Replaced by: Related Policies, Procedures and/or Guidelines: To be included at next review. POLICY PURPOSE: To be included at next review. 2. DEFINITIONS: To be included at next review. 3. SCOPE: 1 of 4 Page 6 of 180 POLICY APPLIES TO THE FOLLOWING: ❑ All Employees ❑ All Full -Time Employees ❑ All Union ❑ Management ❑ C.U.P.E. 68 Civic ❑ Non Union ❑ C.U.P.E. 68 Mechanics ❑ Temporary ❑ C.U.P.E. 791 ❑ Student ❑ I.B.E.W.636 ❑ Part -Time Employees ❑ K.P.F.F.A. ❑x Specified Positions only: City Clerk ❑ Other: ❑x Council ❑x Local Boards & Advisory Committees 1 of 4 Page 6 of 180 Policy No: GOV-BOA-063 Policy Title: APPOINTMENT TO BOARDS & COMMITTEES To be included at next review. 4. POLICY CONTENT: 1. Appointments 1.1 Council may appoint members of the public to boards and committees whether the board or committee was established by Council or another agency with a request that Council make an appointment. 1.2 A special meeting of Council shall be held annually or when required to consider applications for appointments to boards and committees. 2. Eligibility Requirement 2.1. Except for boards and committees whose eligibility requirements are legislatively controlled or set by Policy, lay members appointed to boards and committees must either reside, work or own property in the City of Kitchener to be eligible for appointment. Staff shall, to the best of their ability, make this determination and where one of the above cannot be substantiated, advise Council through the appointment meeting notice or addendum. If during the term of the appointment a member of a board or committee no longer meets the eligibility requirement referenced herein, they are required to advise the City Clerk in writing of the change prior to the date Council next meets to make annual appointments, on which date that member's term will expire, if the member has not resigned in the intervening period. 2--2-2.3 Notwithstandina sections 2.1 and 2.2 members of the Nominatin Committee shall be eligible for appointment if their offices are not located in Kitchener and/or where the representatives might not reside or own property in Kitchener, provided the organizations mandate still relates to the provisions of services and program for the Kitchener community. 3. Length of Service 3.1 An individual may only be appointed to the same committee for a maximum number of 8 consecutive years. 2 of 4 Page 7 of 180 Policy No: GOV-BOA-063 Policy Title: APPOINTMENT TO BOARDS & COMMITTEES 3.2 Any appointment to fill an unexpired term shall not be considered as part of the calculation with respect to the maximum term. 3.3 Any individual will be eligible for re -appointment to the same board or committee only if a minimum period of 1 year has elapsed between the completion of an 8 -year maximum term and the commencement of the new term. 3.4 Applicants are to be appointed to only one committee at any one time. 4.1 Where a Board has established a Nominating Committee they will forward their nominations for Board vacancies to Council by the required date set by staff. Council will consider the nominations and decide whether to accept or refer the nominations back to the Board's Nominating Committee. 4.2 Where a Board has not established a Nominating Committee, staff will advertise for applications, setting deadlines for submission and present the applications for Council's consideration. 5. Advisory Committees 5.1 A Nominating Committee will be appointed by Council comprised of five community members and one City staff person. The Committee will be chaired by one of the citizen appointees. Staff does not have voting privileges but are there in a facilitative and resource role. Note: For the purposes of implementing this policy, Council will appoint a Nominating Committee to come into effect September 2008 to serve for the remainder of the current term of Council. 5.2 Citizen members of the Nominating Committee will not currently sit on any of the City's Advisory Committees and will not have sat for at least one year. 5.3 The Nominating Committee shall convene, at the call of the Chair, to fill Advisory Committee vacancies as they occur. 5.4 That following an accessible and inclusive recruitment and application process, the Nominating Committee will assess 3of4 Page 8 of 180 Policy No: GOV-BOA-063 Policy Title: APPOINTMENT TO BOARDS & COMMITTEES applicants to Advisory Committees on the basis of expertise / interest and in light of each committee's Terms of Reference and present Council with a list of qualified candidates for each committee. 5.5 Council will consider the eligible candidates and decide upon a slate of nominees for appointment to each committee for a term of 2 years with eligibility for re -appointment for a maximum of two additional terms. 5. HISTORY OF POLICY CHANGES Administrative Updates 2016-06-01 - 1-063 policy template re -formatted to new numbering system and given number GOV-BOA-063 Formal Amendments 2012-10-01 - As per Council/CLT directive. 4of4 Page 9 of 180 J K;R POLICY Policy No: GOV-BOA-010 Policy Title: NOMINATING COMMITTEE - Approval Date: June 25, 2012 TERMS OF REFERENCE Reviewed Date: OGtebe Policy Type: COUNCIL 2021 September 2023 Category: Governance Next Review Date: 2026September 2026+ Sub -Category: Board & CommitteeReviewed Date: QGtGber 2n��October Author: Council/Committee Services 2021 Last Amended: September 2023 Dept/Div: Corporate Services/Legislated Services Replaces: 1-010 - Nominating Committee - Terms of Reference Repealed: Replaced by: Related Policies, Procedures and/or Guidelines: Municipal Act, 2001, as amended 1. POLICY PURPOSE: The purpose of the Nominating Committee is to wmi 4 assess applicants to Advisory Committees of Council and Quasi -Judicial Tribunals on the basis of diverse representation of the community, expertise/interest in an issue or topic area, and in regard to each advisory committee's Terms of Reference and present Council with a list of qualified candidates for each committee. 2. DEFINITIONS: of Page 10 of 180 Policy No: GOV-BOA-010 Policy Title: NOMINATING COMMITTEE - TERMS OF REFERENCE Tri be added ed at next F.. io.ei "Advisory Committee" a committee created by Council, to report to Staff or a designated Committee on a specific subject. These Committees do not deliver municipal services. direct staff. or make decisions bindina on the Citv. "Chair" the role to facilitate and chair meetinas "Composition" the number of members approved for the composition of the Advisory Committee or Quasi-judicial Tribunal, including the balance between Members of Council and residents and other members, and identification of any organization outside the City that is invited to nominate a member. The composition of each body will vary according to specific business and citizen engagement objectives and is contained in the terms of reference for the advisory body. "Citizen Member" Kitchener residents who are not Council Members, City or agency staff, or staff of City corporations or their subsidiaries. It does not indicate Canadian citizenship and may include permanent residents, refugees, refugee claimants, and residents without homes. "Nominating Committee" the committee established by City Council that is authorized to consider and recommend to Council the appointment of citizens to various City Advisory Committees, Quasi -Judicial Tribunals and other bodies. "MFIPPA" the Municipal Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act (MFIPPA) imposes mandatory confidentiality obligations on the City of Kitchener, Members of Council, and members of advisory committees and quasi-judicial tribunals of the City to refrain from disclosing personal information and to protect the privacy of confidential information obtained in performance of their duties. "Quasi-judicial Tribunal" the legislative structures to conduct hearings to decide on individual cases. "Quorum" the number of members comprising a majority of a committee that must be present at any of its meetings to make the proceedings of that meeting valid. 3. SCOPE: 2ofo Page 11 of 180 Policy No: GOV-BOA-010 Policy Title: NOMINATING COMMITTEE - TERMS OF REFERENCE 4. POLICY CONTENT: Committee Composition and Reporting (a) The Nominating Committee will be appointed by Council and comprised of five community members, being representatives from: • Kitrat Waterloo Region Community Foundation (WRCF) President /Chief Executive Officer or Director of Philanthropy or designate) • Kitchener Waterloo Multicultural Centre (Chief Executive Officer or designate), • United Way Waterloo Region Community (UWayWRC) (Chief Executive Officer or Vice -President of Strategy and Business Development, or designate), • Capacity Waterloo Region (Chief Executive Officer or designate), • Greater Kitchener Waterloo Chamber of Commerce (President/Chief Executive Officer, o�r designate); and, at.1eact `7 `7 /;itY StQiT Staff will include: (i) Director, Legislated Services, or designate, ssist+ t/Gemmittee 4AM in ictplater,Cinonno Anrl GhcccRt��vr.�bar�crwrrrrrrrcc arra Legislative Clerk, or designate. 3 of 6 Page 12 of 180 POLICY APPLIES TO THE FOLLOWING: ❑ All Employees ❑ All Full -Time Employees ❑ All Union ❑ Management ❑ C.U.P.E. 68 Civic ❑ Non Union ❑ C.U.P.E. 68 Mechanics ❑ Temporary ❑ C.U.P.E. 791 ❑ Student ❑ I.B.E.W.636 ❑ Part -Time Employees ❑ K.P.F.F.A. ❑ Specified Positions only: ❑x Other: Nominating Committee ❑ Council ❑x Local Boards & Advisory Committees 4. POLICY CONTENT: Committee Composition and Reporting (a) The Nominating Committee will be appointed by Council and comprised of five community members, being representatives from: • Kitrat Waterloo Region Community Foundation (WRCF) President /Chief Executive Officer or Director of Philanthropy or designate) • Kitchener Waterloo Multicultural Centre (Chief Executive Officer or designate), • United Way Waterloo Region Community (UWayWRC) (Chief Executive Officer or Vice -President of Strategy and Business Development, or designate), • Capacity Waterloo Region (Chief Executive Officer or designate), • Greater Kitchener Waterloo Chamber of Commerce (President/Chief Executive Officer, o�r designate); and, at.1eact `7 `7 /;itY StQiT Staff will include: (i) Director, Legislated Services, or designate, ssist+ t/Gemmittee 4AM in ictplater,Cinonno Anrl GhcccRt��vr.�bar�crwrrrrrrrcc arra Legislative Clerk, or designate. 3 of 6 Page 12 of 180 Policy No: GOV-BOA-010 Policy Title: NOMINATING COMMITTEE - TERMS OF REFERENCE (b) Composition of the Nominating Committee shall be supplemented by tone Equity Anti -Racism staff member when considering applications to the Equity & Anti -Racism Advisory Committee. (c) Wer.m..ally TypiGallyTypically,appointments will be made to the Nominating Committee six months to one year prior to Council's usual November appointments meeting. (d) Citizen members of the Nominating Committee will not currently sit on any of the City's Advisory Committees and will not have sat on an Advisory Committee for at least one year prior to being eligible for the Nominating Committee. (d) All members will serve for a period of 2 years. (e) The Committee will be Chaired by one of the citizen appointees. (f) Meetings will be held by video or teleconference or other such communication method that allows all participants equal access to communicate with one another. (e)-Meetnng f (q) The Gern Tmitt a shall arms sally nheese a Chair 7TIS� /h\(q) NeFinallmect+p� Wil�hek-l-att#e��the Com -Frequency will L „, depend on the appointment cycle and ad hoc meetings will occur as required to meet the obligations of Council's schedule. It is eXper+ed +ha+ hi weekly meetings will be FequiFerd dwFing the artive FerF,,itment and appGintMeR} phase b it may cslew Fri,aFt r at he Chair's roll fer thp. aF'1�TTT `f-�-ra�c,�'T the year. (f) The Committee shall report directly to Council. When reporting to Council voluntary demographic data for all applicants and those recommended for selection shall be communicated to Striking Committee and Council to further support that recommended appointments are reflective of the community as a whole (diverse in terms of age, residency, race, gender identity, sexuality etc.). Quorum (a) Quorum for t#+s-the Nominating Committee is 3 members. Responsibilities 4of6 Page 13 of 180 Policy No: GOV-BOA-010 Policy Title: NOMINATING COMMITTEE - TERMS OF REFERENCE The Nominating Committee will be responsible for: /7� riooii-rnini-r �n,� i_Implementing an accessible and inclusive advisory committee lG/ recruitment and application process. () (b) {G4—Convenin�ce, as required, to fill Advisory Committee and Quasi - Judicial vacancies. --This may be at the call of the Chair or from a specific request from .;n / dyiseFy Gemmitteeof Legislated Services staff with a vacancy/vacancies. {d}Lgl Leveraging the equity toolkit provided by the Equity, Anti -Racism and Indigenous initiatives division when reviewing and considering appointments to Advisory Committees and Quasi -Judicial Tribunals. {e4 dL Participating in unconscious bias training as available and applicable. (e) Reviewing applications for Advisory Committees and Quasi -Judicial Tribunals. Making decisions by consensus, where possible. Should consensus not be reached, the Nominating Committee's decisions shall be made by a simple majority vote of the members present at a meeting of the Nominating Committee that has achieved quorum. Each member of the Nominating Committee has one (1) vote. Staff does not have voting privileges but are there in a facilitative and resource role. {4}(g) The Nominating Committee shall consider applications for the Equity, Anti - Racism and Indigenous Initiatives Advisory Committee in consultation and collaboration with the Senior Equity Advisor. (h) Proposing a suggested list of candidates to Council for consideration, ensuring a diversity lens has been applied and the matter of succession olannina has been considered. 5 of o Page 14 of 180 5 Policy No: GOV-BOA-010 Policy Title: NOMINATING COMMITTEE - TERMS OF REFERENCE Council will consider the eligible candidates and decide upon a slate of nominees for appointment to each committee f„r a term e �� with eligibility for re-aopointment for a maximum of two additional terms. HISTORY OF POLICY CHANGES Administrative Updates 2016-07-01 - 1-010 policy template re -formatted to given number GOV-BOA-010. 2021-10-18 -Administrative updates— departmenta Formal Amendments 2023-09-25 — Council approval COR -2023-377 new numbering system and name change. 11 of Page 15 of 180 Staff Report Development Services Department www.kitchener.ca REPORT TO: Finance and Corporate Services Committee DATE OF MEETING: September 16, 2024 SUBMITTED BY: Darren Kropf, Manager, Active Transportation & Development, 519- 741-2200 ext. 7314 PREPARED BY: Dean McMillan, Supervisor, Crossing Guards 519-741-2200 ext. 7232 WARD(S) INVOLVED: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 7 DATE OF REPORT: August 29, 2024 REPORT NO.: DSD -2024-397 SUBJECT: School Bus Loading Zone and Crossing Guard Adjustments RECOMMENDATION: That the School Bus Loading Zone be extended on the east side (odd -numbered) of Indian Road from a point 77 m north of McGee Avenue to a point approximately 147 m North thereof; and, That a School Bus Loading Zone be installed on the north side (even -numbered) of Block Line Road from a point 93m east of Hanover Street to a point approximately 87m east thereof; and, That the School Bus Loading Zone be extended on the west side (even -numbered) of Autumn Hill Crescent from a point 104m north of Westheights Drive to a point approximately 38m north thereof; and, That a School Bus Loading Zone be installed on the east side (even -numbered) of Vanier Drive from a point 49m south of Boniface Avenue to a point approximately 31m south thereof; and, That the School Bus Loading Zone previously established on Emerald Avenue be removed; and, That the School Bus Loading Zone be extended on the east side (odd -numbered) of Hickson Drive from a point 10m south of Secord Avenue to a point approximately 49m south thereof; and, That two Adult Crossing Guards be installed along Huron Road at Beckview Drive; and, *** This information is available in accessible formats upon request. *** Please call 519-741-2345 or TTY 1-866-969-9994 for assistance. Page 16 of 180 That an Adult Crossing Guard be installed along Thomas Slee Dr at South Creek Dr; and, That an Adult Crossing Guard be removed along Holborn Drive at Old Chicopee Drive; and, That an Adult Crossing Guard be removed along Franklin Street at Connaught Street; and, That the Adult Crossing Guard be removed along Pioneer Drive at Pioneer Park Public School stairway location; and further, That the Uniform Traffic By-law be amended accordingly. REPORT HIGHLIGHTS: • The purpose of this report is to improve street safety at multiple elementary schools within the City of Kitchener • The key finding of this report is that safety and operations can be improved with several school bus loading zone adjustments and crossing guard location changes. • The financial implications are approximately $5,000 for the school bus loading zones taken from the existing sign maintenance budget. The removal of crossing guards at underutilized locations allows resources to be redeployed at the proposed new locations, at no net cost to the city. • This report supports the delivery of core services. BACKGROUND: Transportation Services is providing an update to Council regarding recommendations to support school safety and active travel at the following schools: • Grand River Collegiate Institute: A school Bus Loading Zone extension on Indian Road; • St. Mary's High School: A School Bus Loading Zone along Block Line Road; • St. Mark Catholic Elementary School: A School Bus Loading Zone extension on Autumn Hill Crescent; • Rockway Public School: A School Bus Loading Zone installation on Vanier Drive; • Sunnyside Public School: A School Bus Loading Zone removal on Emerald Avenue • Stanley Park Senior Public School: A School Bus Loading Zone extension on Hickson Drive; • St. Josephine Bakhita Catholic Elementary School: The justification of crossing guards for Huron Road at Beckview Drive; • Groh Public School: The addition of a crossing guard for Thomas Slee Drive at South Creek Drive; • Crestview Public School and St. Daniel Catholic Elementary School: the removal of a crossing guard for Holborn Drive at Old Chicopee Drive; • Wilson Avenue Public School and St. Aloysius Catholic Elementary School: the removal of a crossing guard for Franklin Street at Connaught Street; and, • Pioneer Park Public School: the removal of a crossing guard for Pioneer Drive at stairway location. Page 17 of 180 REPORT: Grand River Collegiate Institute Student Transportation Services of Waterloo Region (STSWR) requested the extension of a School Bus Loading Zone located on Indian Road between Queenston Drive and McGee Avenue to accommodate school buses dropping -off and picking -up students. Staff have reviewed and determined that this request can be accommodated with minimal impact to the neighourhood given the existing No Parking restrictions on -street for school and general traffic operations. 60of", U his t.�, r` r X t . .' * _ . v r � �.•• it �� " +��` 1.81J.1 � i cl,ff ��, �, '�, Q 1 i Ilk 4 , f708Cnb8rg P a"T Ind Reef - ►► ' St. Mary's High School — School Bus Loading Zone STSWR requested the addition of a School Bus Loading Zone on the north side of Block Line Road (between Hanover Street and school access driveway location) to accommodate school buses dropping -off and picking -up students. Staff have reviewed and determined this request can be accommodated with minimal impact to the neighourhood given the existing No Parking restrictions on -street for school and general traffic operations. Page 18 of 180 �J-;., _- V - !#Y 1 ;F int 1- 1 , St. Mark Catholic Elementary School — School Bus Loading Zone STSWR requested the extension of a School Bus Loading Zone located on Autumn Hill Crescent between Westheights Drive and Blue Spruce Court to accommodate school buses dropping -off and picking -up students. Staff have reviewed and determined that this request can be accommodated with minimal impact to the neighourhood given the existing No Parking restrictions on -street for school and general traffic operations. AL I S r -..�4 - J,� •. '� �` � .e�°, *-ice .�.. ':.a►s � ��`- 66 Pk LU i P 41, PO gr ,) e00010, TOM ♦ ~ ° • .' 1 Rei .'.. �'ftefa Page 19 of 180 Rockway Public School — School Bus Loading Zone STSWR requested the addition of a School Bus Loading Zone on Vanier Drive between Boniface Avenue and Walton Avenue fronting Rockway Public School to accommodate school buses dropping -off and picking -up students. Staff have reviewed and determined that this request can be accommodated with minimal impact to the neighourhood given the existing No Parking restrictions on -street for school and general traffic operations. Ilk jy 41. ' h a%'` • L r � � Opt': I Page 20 of 180 Sunnyside Public School — School Bus Loading Zone STSWR requested the removal of the School Bus Loading Zone along Emerald Avenue between Weber Street East and Prospect Avenue since it will no longer be in use. w ,., pRO$ � ► J 'P a l' st 4111 Stanley Park Senior Public School — School Bus Loading Zone STSWR requested the extension of a School Bus Loading Zone located on Hickson Drive between Crosby Drive and Secord Avenue to accommodate school buses dropping -off and picking -up students. Staff have reviewed and determined that this request can be accommodated with minimal impact to the neighourhood given the existing No Parking restrictions on -street for school and general traffic operations. y 3 f� ` • 0�1 w or i• �� 4 ''; Y• � a 5 POP 7G Y r; Page 21 of 180 Groh Public School Residents have requested the establishment of an adult crossing guard to accommodate student safety to and from Groh Public School at the all -way stop intersection of Thomas Slee Drive at South Creek Drive. Data was collected to determine the number of students crossing during the arrival and dismissal periods in both the morning and afternoon. The average number of school -aged pedestrians crossing exceeds the recommendation of 40 pedestrians in the Ontario Traffic Council School Crossing Guard manual. In addition, staff observed it is difficult for school aged children to determine safe crossing opportunities due to the high volume of traffic at the all -way stop intersection during school periods. A crossing guard will provide clearer direction for both pedestrians and drivers during the busy school periods. Ats St. Josephine Bakhita Catholic Elementary School Waterloo Catholic District School Board requested the establishment of an adult crossing guard to accommodate student safety to and from St. Josephine Bakhita Catholic Elementary School, which opened in September, 2023.The new school is located on Beckview Drive roadway adjacent to arterial Huron Road, requiring students to cross Huron Road at the roundabout. Huron Road is an arterial street with high vehicle volumes and speeds and limited pedestrian crossing opportunities. The average number of school -aged pedestrians crossing exceeds the recommendation of 40 pedestrians in the Ontario Traffic Council School Crossing Guard manual. Due to operational concerns controlling both the entry and exit of the roundabout location, two crossing guards are needed to ensure a safe crossing experience. Page 22 of 180 Y x A t �P��• �J+ j, � ,� BakfM.l�� Adult Crossing Guard Holborn Drive at Old Chicopee Drive Staff are recommending the removal of the crossing guard location for Holborn Drive at Old Chicopee Drive (all -way stop control). It should be noted that this location is close to Stanley Park Mall which is likely a destination for pedestrians within the area throughout the day. Data was collected during the morning and afternoon time periods (in 5 minute increments) to determine pedestrian movements before and after school times. During the morning data collection, there were mostly adolescent students crossing-, these pedestrians are able to determine when it is safe to cross the roadway and do not need the assistance of an adult crossing guard. Also, during some of the time periods observed for the morning study there were only adults crossing, and for three of the time periods there weren't any pedestrians observed. It is likely that throughout time the neighbourhood has changed as well as student ages and pedestrian patterns. Page 23 of 180 Since the school crossing guard program is reserved for elementary aged students (kindergarten to grade 6) and due to the low number of elementary aged students accessing the intersection, staff are recommending the removal of the crossing guard for this location. Affected schools were notified and no concerns have been received. The crossing guard from this location can be redeployed to a justified crossing guard location. 4 Y' 6 j "i• � 4 W ''� IE � 6 IF 40 �' + d its• './!' `r! ^, k'"'JYrrr'OQ /54 ,y stat; Adult Crossing Guard Franklin Street at Connaught Street Staff are recommending the removal of the crossing guard location for Franklin Street at Connaught Street, an all -way stop location. In 2022, through the complete streets reconstruction program, Transportation Services added curb extensions to the intersection location, effectively narrowing the crossing distance for pedestrians accessing the location during all times of day. Once this work was completed, pedestrians began crossing themselves in all directions, choosing not to wait for the crossing guard who was crossing at another leg, as they observed the short crossing distance to be safe enough to cross without the assistance of a guard. Additionally, there are Grand River Transit (GRT) bus stops in the immediate vicinity of the crossing location; therefore, a number of pedestrians at the crossing location are adults crossing to access the bus stop locations. Given the improved safety following installation of curb extensions, and due to the low number of school related pedestrians accessing the intersection, staff are recommending the removal of the crossing guard for this location. Affected schools were notified and no concerns have been received. The crossing guard from this location can be redeployed to a justified crossing guard location. Page 24 of 180 Adult Crossing Guard Pioneer Drive at Stairway Location Staff are recommending the removal of the crossing guard location for Pioneer Drive at Pioneer Park Public School stairway location. A pedestrian refuge island was installed at this location prior to 2017, thereby creating a two-stage crossing process. Pedestrians only have to determine when there is a safe gap within one direction of traffic flow and can wait on the island (or on the street sidewalk) until there is a safe gap in traffic to proceed. Staff committed to monitoring the crossing location for the first two weeks of the 2023-2024 school year. This included a crossing guard working and advising the community that the crossing guard would be removed from this location. Further, data was collected during the morning and afternoon time periods to determine whether a crossing guard would still be justifiable for this location. During the studies conducted there were always less than 40 pedestrians (typical threshold to justify a crossing guard in the School Crossing Guard Guide from the Ontario Traffic Council) and, in most cases, the student was accompanied by an adult. For example, during the morning period time studies, 34 pedestrians were observed, however, all students were accompanied by an adult except for one student that was crossing on their own (17 students and 17 adults observed). During another study conducted during morning and rainy conditions, there were only 12 pedestrians observed altogether. During the afternoon time period, again, there were 25 pedestrians crossing with 16 students crossing and 9 adults. The number of adults crossing with students and due to the addition of the island within the roadway, a crossing guard is not suitable for this location at this time. Pioneer Park Public school was notified prior to the 2023-2024 school year. After the crossing guard had been removed, the crossing guard Supervisor continued to monitor the location periodically. During this monitoring process a concern was received from a local resident regarding crossing guard removal, however, the Supervisor was able to address the concerns to the resident's satisfaction. Page 25 of 180 so- 14W j <VLI egoism, r • „' Ak � � ['rte, -,. � STRATEGIC PLAN ALIGNMENT: This report supports the delivery of core services. FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS: Capital Budget — The recommendations will cost approximately $5,000 to make the necessary signing changes for school bus loading zones, taken from the existing sign maintenance budget. Operating Budget — The recommendations in this report has no impact on the Operating Budget given the recommendation that three crossing guards be removed which will offset the three new recommended crossing guards working at the new crossing guard locations. COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT: INFORM — This report has been posted to the City's website with the agenda in advance of the council / committee meeting. PREVIOUS REPORTS/AUTHORITIES: There are no previous reports/authorities related to this matter. APPROVED BY: Justin Readman, General Manager Development Services Department ATTACHMENTS: n/a Page 26 of 180 Staff Report Community Services Department www.kitchener.ca REPORT TO: Finance and Corporate Services Committee DATE OF MEETING: September 16, 2024 SUBMITTED BY: Gloria MacNeil, Director of Enforcement, 519-741-2200 ext. 7952 PREPARED BY: Gloria MacNeil, Director of Enforcement, 519-741-2200 ext. 7952 WARD(S) INVOLVED: 9 DATE OF REPORT: September 3, 2024 REPORT NO.: CSD -2024-408 SUBJECT: NOISE EXEMPTION -VANMAR CONSTRUCTORS ON INC 641 KING ST W RECOMMENDATION: That the noise exmeption requested by VanMar Constructors for construction work at 641 King St W to commence at 6am from October 1, 2024 to April 30th, 2025 be denied. REPORT HIGHLIGHTS: • VanMar Constructors ON Inc. is requesting a noise exemption for phase two of the Station Park development to allow them to begin construction at 6am beginning October 1, 2024 until April 30, 2025 (7 months). • Staff are not supportive of the exemption request based on the duration of time being requested. • Based on staff's experience during the pandemic when construction times were expanded, the limited number of exemptions provided to date for extended construction hours on a short-term basis, and the lack of community engagement related to this exemption request for a seven-month period, staff are unable to support the noise exemption put forward by VanMar Constructors ON Inc for a 6AM start. • There are currently a number of condo developments throughout the city and in particular the downtown, staff have concerns that allowing an early start time for one development may result in a precedent being set which will encourage others to also apply and expect the same consideration. BACKGROUND: VanMar Constructors ON Inc. is currently constructing a multi -residential housing development project at 641 King St W as part of phase two of the Station Park development and have requested an exemption to Chapter 450 to allow them to begin work one hour earlier at 6am for a seven-month period, instead of the permitted 7am start time in the by-law. REPORT: *** This information is available in accessible formats upon request. *** Please call 519-741-2345 or TTY 1-866-969-9994 for assistance. Page 27 of 180 VanMar Constructors ON Inc. have provided information outlining several reasons why they believe their request for an exemption should be considered — see Schedule A as attached to this report. Staff have summarized some of the key points included in Schedule A below, which form VanMar Constructors rationale for consideration: 1. VanMar Constructors request for an early start time will assist with accelerating the housing development which they believe aligns with the City of Kitchener's strategic priority. By starting construction at 6:00 AM, their goal is to advance their project timeline. 2. The trades and workforce working on this project travel from various locations across the Greater Toronto Area (GTA), it is believed that an earlier start time will help their tradespeople avoid peak -hour traffic, reducing commute. 3. Union regulations typically limit work hours to 3:00 PM, making an earlier start crucial for maximizing productivity and ensuring a full workday. A 6:00 AM start also allow for a staggered arrival of workers, facilitating a smoother transition into the site and avoiding congestion at 7:00 AM. 4. To mitigate potential noise impacts, they are proposing the following measures: • Restricted Hoist Operations: Limit hoist operations to a specific number of runs between 6:00 AM and 7:00 AM. • Noise Minimization Activities: they are committed to restricting certain high noise activities to later in the day. They are open to collaborating with City officials to define specific activities that can be undertaken early in the morning with minimal noise. • Noise Reduction with Construction Progress: As construction progresses, and the building becomes enclosed with the facade materials including windows and doors, the noise levels on site will be significantly reduced. Trades people will be working within an enclosed structure which should decrease the noise levels identified within the initial noise monitoring report. 5. They also engaged Englobe, an Acoustic Engineer, to monitor noise levels on-site from May 3 to May 12, 2024 the details of the report and findings are provided as part of the package in Schedule A. 6. VanMar Constructors would issue personalized notifications to residents, especially those in Station Park Building B facing the construction site. The notice will detail the adjusted construction hours and their efforts to minimize disturbances, ensuring transparency and fostering positive community relations. Staff have reviewed the entirety of Schedule A and appreciate the level of commitment and research that has been put forth by VanMar Constructors ON Inc. and their efforts to reduce the impact of noise on the surrounding residents as part of their request. However, staff have not had an opportunity to speak with nearby residents to determine if the current construction noise Page 28 of 180 has had a negative impact, or if residents would support an exemption for a 6AM start time over the next seven months. When staff have supported early start times for previous construction projects, they have typically been for concrete pours that must be completed within the same day, these have typically been infrequent over a couple of days at most, never for this length of time. During the pandemic, the provincial government paused any existing municipal noise by-laws allowing construction to take place between 6AM and 10PM daily, staff can advise that during that period we consistently received complaints from residents regarding the disturbances and impacts they experienced, including being woken up by construction noise at 6AM. Based on our experience during the pandemic, the limited number of exemptions provided for extended construction hours on a short-term basis, and the lack of community engagement related to this exemption request for a seven-month period, staff are unable to support the noise exemption request put forward by VanMar Constructors ON Inc. for a 6AM start. Lastly, there are currently a number of condo developments throughout the city and in particular the downtown, staff have concerns that allowing an early start time for one development may result in a precedent being set which will encourage others to also apply and expect the same consideration. STRATEGIC PLAN ALIGNMENT: This report supports the delivery of core services. FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS: N/A COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT: APPROVED BY: Michael May, DCAO ATTACHMENTS: Attachment A — Station Park C — Noise Exemption Justification Page 29 of 180 00 V;Nn"Mar CONSTRUCTORS ON INC. To: City of Kitchener Council, By Law Enforcement Division From: VanMar Constructors ON Inc. Date: August 30, 2024 145 Goddard Crescent Cambridge Ontario WE 0131 5197406800 Subject: Request for Noise By -Law Exemption for Construction Activity VanMar Constructors ON Inc. is currently constructing a multi -residential housing development project within the City of Kitchener. VanMar is committed to supporting the City of Kitchener's ambitious housing and environmental goals through our multi - residential housing development project and in alignment with the City's goal to address housing affordability and supply, we are seeking an exemption from the city's noise by-law, which restricts construction activities to the hours between 7:00 AM and 7:00 PM. We request permission to start construction at 6:00 AM from October 1, 2024, until April 30, 2025. Below, we present a detailed justification for this request and outline our commitment to minimizing potential impacts to the surrounding community. Justification for Early Start Time 1. Support for Accelerating Housing Targets The City of Kitchener has established a strategic priority to accelerate housing development and address community needs. By starting construction at 6:00 AM, we aim to advance our project timeline, contributing to the City's objective of addressing and increasing the housing supply while addressing affordability issues more promptly. This alignment with municipal goals underscores our commitment to advancing the City's housing agenda and tackling the housing supply shortages. 2. Mitigation of Traffic and Environmental Impacts Our trades and workforce travel from various locations across the Greater Toronto Area (GTA). An earlier start time helps our tradespeople avoid peak -hour traffic, reducing commute times and greenhouse gas emissions. This initiative supports the City & Municipal's environmental sustainability goals by contributing to lower traffic congestion and reduced carbon footprints. In support of this initiative, we have received and attached requests from our tradespeople, Davicon and Uniform. These early starts not only support efficient scheduling but also emphasize our commitment to our environmental goals. 5197406800 vanmarconstruRapIecaQ of 180 V;Nn--Mar 145 Goddard Crescent Cambridge Ontario WE 0131 CONSTRUCTORS ON INC. 5197406800 3. Optimizing Workforce Management Union regulations typically limit work hours to 3:00 PM, making an earlier start crucial for maximizing productivity and ensuring a full workday. A 6:00 AM start also allow for a staggered arrival of workers, facilitating a smoother transition into the site and avoiding congestion at 7:00 AM. The earlier start also facilitates better scheduling and efficient use of available labor, directly contributing to the rapid completion of housing units and aligning with provincial and municipal targets for housing delivery. By commencing construction at 6:00 AM, we're enable our workforce to manage their schedules more effectively, leading to an improved work -life balance. Early start times allow workers to complete tasks earlier in the day, providing them with more flexibility in their personal lives and reducing the need for extended hours or weekend work. This balance not only enhances overalljob satisfaction but also contributes to better workforce morale and productivity. 4. Proactive Noise Management Strategies To mitigate potential noise impacts, we are proposing the following measures: o Restricted Hoist Operations: Limit hoist operations to a specific number of runs between 6:00 AM and 7:00 AM. This approach will facilitate the entry of trades and materials with minimal disruption around the exterior of the building. o Noise Minimization Activities: We are committed to restricting certain high - noise activities to later in the day. We are open to collaborating with City officials to define specific activities that can be undertaken early in the morning with minimal noise. This would include deliveries, placing rebar etc. The most critical item would be the allowance of utilizing the hoist to get teams up the building so that work can be completed within the building instead of at the exterior. As we move into the taller portion of the tower, and the building becomes enclosed, most work in the earlier hours will be completed internally, which will limit the amount of noise transmission to the neighbouring community. o Noise Reduction with Construction Progress: As construction progresses, and the building becomes enclosed with the facade materials including windows and doors, the noise levels on site will be significantly reduced. Trades people will be working within an enclosed structure which should decrease the noise levels identified within the initial noise monitoring report. 5197406800 vanmarconstruRapIecg14 of 180 00 V;Nn"Mar CONSTRUCTORS ON INC. 5. Noise Monitoring Data 145 Goddard Crescent Cambridge Ontario N3E 0131 5197406800 We have also engaged Englobe, an Acoustic Engineer, to monitor noise levels on-site from May 3 to May 12. Key findings in the report include the following: o Background information: The sensors installed monitor every second, with an average reading provided every hour, alongwith the loudest noise during the 1 -hour period (Lmax). Englobe confirmed that we should analyze the Leq values within the data as this is the most accurate sense of noise during the hour. The Lmax will only identify the loudest noise which may only last a second or two at maximum length. Sensor locations and distances from the existing building at Station Park building B are identified within the report provided in the attachment. Construction work did NOT over the weekends during the monitoring duration. Construction start times were from Monday to Friday, between the hours of 7:00 AM —3:00 PM —4:00 PM daily. o Average Noise Levels: Noise levels between 6:00 AM and 7:00 AM averaged 56.1-67.4 dB, with a minimal increase compared to post 7:00 AM levels (61.0-68.9 dB). The anticipated increase is relatively minor, between 1.5-4.9 dB, and we expect that the noise levels will be similar to the 7:00 AM range if the early start time is permitted. o Comparison with Ambient Noise: During the entire monitoring period, noise from the Metrolinx train horn, typically at 6:00 AM, exceeded all construction noise levels across all 3 sensors. Additionally, overnight noise levels, between the hours of 11:00 PM —1:00 AM, on average were 57dB. This noise level on average was comparable to the noise levels at the construction start time between the hours of 7:00 AM and 8:00 AM. The average variance across the entire duration of the monitoring period was only 4.08dB. o Adjacent Building Materials: For the monitoring, the sensors were mounted to posts located at the hoarding surrounding the site. One thing to note is that the existing buildings at Station Park were previously built by VanMar, and we can confirm the inclusion of double -glazed windows and doors, which provide a reduction of noise levels by +/-31 dB. In order to achieve this reduction, it would need to be assumed that this reduction would only be applied if the windows and doors are closed. As we approach the winter 5197406800 vanmarconstruRapIeca2 of 180 00 V;Nn"Mar CONSTRUCTORS ON INC. 145 Goddard Crescent Cambridge Ontario N3E 0131 5197406800 months, it would be assumed that windows and doors will be closed during the hours of 6:00 AM — 7:00 AM, which would support the minimizing of noise if we were granted an exemption to start at 6:00 AM. 6. Community Notification In line with our commitment to community consideration, we will issue personalized notifications to residents, especially those in Station Park Building B facing the construction site. This notice will detail the adjusted construction hours and our efforts to minimize disturbances, ensuring transparency and fostering positive community relations. Conclusion Granting this exemption to allow VanMar Constructors Inc. to start at 6:00 AM, will significantly enhance our ability to meet the City of Kitchener's housing supply targets and environmental goals while maintaining our commitment to noise management and community consideration. We are dedicated to supporting the City's vision for sustainable and efficiently expedited housing developments so that our community can have a place to call home sooner. We appreciate your review of this request and look forward to working with the City and Council in any capacity to build on our shared goals. Attachments: 1. Trade Letters from Davicon Forming and Uni-Form Structures 2. Englobe Noise Monitoring Summary Report (June 25, 2024) Contact Information: Catheryne McCutcheon VanMar Developments Inc. cmccutcheon@vanmardevelopments.com Thankyou for considering our request. Sincerely, Catheryne McCutcheon Design & Approvals Associate VanMar Developments Inc. 5197406800 vanmarconstruRapIecof 180 ATTACHMENTS ENCLOSED Page 34 of 180 DAViCDNFOP-MING August 26, 2424 To Whom It May Concern: Re: Noise Exemption Permit As a current sub -trade of VanMar Constructors ON Inc, currently working at the DUO condos project located at 641 Ding St., W. in Kitchener, we are asking that you consider the application request for a noise exemption permit to allow our employees to start at an earlier time. This would benefit those employees who are commuting into work from as far as the GTA to avoid lengthy traffic delays on their commute to and from work. Our steelmen already have a physically demanding job and work in inclement weather conditions daily and by approving a noise exemption permit it would significantly improve their quality of life. We would appreciate your serious consideration and thank you in advance for your time. Sincerely, Ana Ferreira President Mobile: 905-931-7662 Web: www.daviconforming.com Email: ana(aNaviconforrningxom Page 35 of 180 To whom it may concern: Please accept this short letter as a plea to adjust the start time on site from 7am to 6am. I hope those involved in the decision-making process will be able to see things from our perspective and I would like to fully thank those involved for their time and consideration, regardless of the outcome. We have multiple out of town employees from all over southern Ontario travelling into the city from places like Bluevale, Innisfil, Mississauga, Markham, Niagara Falls, St. Catherines and Dorchester, just to name a few. For these employees, a 6am start time equates to more time available with their families and loved ones as they will lose less time on highways waiting in traffic while they attempt to get to and from work. For them, a 6am start time equates to an earlier, more predictable commute. For many of them, this earlier commute is inevitable if they are to ensure they will arrive to work on time, because often a later start to their commute equates to a much longer overall commute duration once the additional traffic is factored in and an increased likelihood of highway accidents. But the 6am start time is not only beneficial to those commuting from far away. We often have long days at work (10-11+ hours) and having the crew start at 6am helps to ensure everyone gets home to their families at a decent time. Starting at 6am vs. 7am can mean the difference between sharing a meal with your family that evening or not. For the out-of-town employees, it can mean the difference between getting home at 6pm vs. 7:30-8pm. What it comes down to for everyone is work -life balance. Simply put, the 6am start time allows every one of our employees more work -life balance. In an industry that has such high demand on in-person, hands on, work -until -it's -done, day after day mentality; the work -life balance has always been a huge struggle for construction employees as a whole. Unfortunately, our industry has not been blessed with a work -from -home format. I would love nothing more than to tell all of our employees they will have more of this work -life balance while they put in their hard work, blood, sweat and tears into each day as we shape the skylines of Kitchener. Thank you again for your time and consideration. Andrew Berner Site Supervisor, Uni-Form Structures UNI -FORM STRUCTURES Page 36 of 180 eNGLOBe June 25, 2024 VanMar Constructors Inc. 145 Goddard Crescent Cambridge, Ontario N3E 0131 Attention: Catheryne McCutcheon I BA Development Design & Approvals Subject: Station Park Phase 2A - Building C - Noise Monitoring Summary Report 621 King Street West, Kitchener, Ontario Englobe Reference: 02404088.000 1 Glossary LEa(c): The Equivalent Continuous Sound Pressure Level which is an average of the sound pressure level measured over a specified time period "t". This is commonly used as the preferred parameter for all forms of environmental noise and is expressed in decibels. dBA: A -weighted decibel. The A -weighting approximates the response of the human ear. Slow Time Weighting: A measurement sampling rate of 1 measurement per second, commonly used as the preferred time weighting for steady and varying environmental noise sources. 2 Introduction Englobe Corp. ("Englobe") is pleased to produce a report summarizing the data collected during the Noise Monitoring Program ("the Program") conducted for VanMar Constructors Inc. ("the Client") for the construction activities taking place for Station Park Phase 2A - Building C ("the Project") at 621 King Street West, Kitchener, Ontario ("the Site") during the period of May 3, 2024 to May 17, 2024. The objectives of this report are as follows: • Present all 1 -hour Equivalent Continuous Sound Pressure Level (LEo(lhr)) data collected during the Project in a single document on a unified scale; • Present basic summary statistics for the collected data; This report was prepared with the purpose of summarizing the data collected during the Project in order to assist in interpretation and communication of the data and its implications for nearby receptors. Please note that the application of the above objectives to any predictive environmental noise modelling using software, additional analysis, commentary on and/or comparison of collected noise data to relevant municipal/provincial/federal regulations and/or guideline are outside the scope of this report. T 1.877.300.4800 — info(o)englobecorp.com 353 Bridge Street E - Kitchener, ON - Canada - N2K 2Y5 englobecorp.com Page 37 of 180 3 Project Background The primary goal of this Program was to measure noise levels near adjacent residential land uses in order to better understand the noise impact of the regular operation of construction activities associated with the Station Park Phase 2A Tower C project. It is understood that the Client intends to use the noise impact data to assist in its application for a noise exemption from the City of Kitchener. To achieve this, Englobe installed noise monitors as detailed in Table 1 and Appendix A. Weather data (taken for a local third -party weather station) was also analyzed to highlight any noise measurements that are invalid due to adverse weather conditions (including wind speeds above 20 km/h, precipitation events, etc.). 4 Collection of Noise Data Data collection for the Program was conducted in accordance with Englobe's corresponding project - specific quote dated April 8, 2024. Sigicom INFRA S50 Digital Sound Level Meters ("SLMs") were utilized for the data collection for the Program. The SLMs were programmed to measure A -weighted noise levels with a "Slow" Time Weighting. For the duration of the monitoring period, the equivalent sound pressure level was measured in 5 -minute intervals, which Englobe later averaged to 1- hour intervals. Three (3) monitoring stations were deployed concurrently for the Program, at the locations detailed in Table 1 below. A site map depicting the monitoring station deployment locations is included in Appendix A. Table 1: Noise Monitoring Station Deployment Location A S50: Hoarding Wall near unit B105 4.3 m May 2, 2024 May 20, 2024 14603 approx. 47m from Tower C B S50: Security Pole near unit B101 3.74 m May 2, 2024 May 20, 2024 13846 approx. 12m from Tower C C S50: Light pole above air shaft 3.5 m May 2, 2024 May 20, 2024 13649 approx. 35m from Tower C It should be noted that the locations of the monitoring stations were chosen in consultation with the Client. All monitoring stations were positioned between the prospective noise source and the receptors. No noise limits were determined for this program, since the purpose of monitoring is solely to measure the noise levels during regular construction activities. All sound level meters have valid lab calibration certificates, included in Appendix B, and were field calibrated before and after the Program using a BrOel & Kjaer Type 4231 Sound Calibrator (Serial Number: 3026798). Station Park Phase 2A - Building C - Noise Monitoring Summary Report Englobe 102404088.000 1 June 25, 2024 Page 3$ of 180 5 Summary of Collected Data The complete data record in a graphical, temporal form can be found in Appendix C. The complete data record in tabular form can be found in Appendix D. Table 3 below presents a brief summary of the full dataset collected during the monitoring period from May 3, 2024, to May 17, 2024. Table 3: Summary of Collected Data A Hoarding Wall near unit B105 approx. 47m from 71.8 Tower C [2024-05-08 / 13:00:00-14:00:00] B Security Pole near unit B101 approx. 12m from 79.7 Tower C [2024-05-06/ 10:00:00-11:00:00] C Light pole above air shaft approx. 35m from 78.1 Tower C [2024-05-06 / 15:00:00-16:00:00] 6 Closure We trust the foregoing will satisfy your present requirements. If you have any questions regarding this matter, please do not hesitate to contact us. Yours very truly, Englobe Corp. Kevin Wadia, EIT Engineering Intern, Instrumentation Appendices Martin Villeneuve, P. Eng. Acoustical Engineer Appendix A Noise Monitoring Station Deployment Locations Appendix B Sound Level Meters Calibration Records Appendix C Graphical Temporal Data Record Appendix D Tabular Data Record Appendix E Weather Data Record for Monitoring Period Station Park Phase 2A - Building C - Noise Monitoring Summary Report Englobe 102404088.000 1 June 25, 2024 Page 39 of 180 Property and Confidentiality "This report can only be used for the purposes stated therein. Any use of the report must take into consideration the object and scope of the mandate by virtue of which the report was prepared, as well as the limitations and conditions specified therein and the state of scientific knowledge at the time the report was prepared. Englobe Corp. provides no warranty and makes no representations other than those expressly contained in the report. This document is the work product of Englobe Corp. Any reproduction, distribution or adaptation, partial or total, is strictly forbidden without the prior written authorization of Englobe Corp. and its Client. For greater certainty, use of any and all extracts from the report is strictly forbidden without the written authorization of Englobe Corp. and its Client, given that the report must be read and considered in its entirety. No information contained in this report can be used by any third party without the prior written authorization of Englobe Corp. and its Client. Englobe Corp. disclaims any responsibility or liability for any unauthorized reproduction, distribution, adaptation, or use of the report. If tests have been carried out, the results of these tests are valid only for the sample described in this report. Englobe Corp.'s subcontractors who have carried out on-site or laboratory work are duly assessed according to the purchase procedure of our quality system. For further information, please contact your project manager." Station Park Phase 2A - Building C - Noise Monitoring Summary Report Englobe 102404088.000 1 June 25, 2024 Page 4Q of 180 Appendix A Noise Monitoring Station Deployment Locations eNGLOBe Page 41 of 180 Appendix B Sound Level Meters Calibration Records DocuSign Envelope ID: B814ED81-ACA9-4028-8358-1 EBFB1974439 • • Sigicom CALIBRATION DOCUMENT Document No: Print Date: Location of Calibration: Page No: Cal 114185 2024-04-15 Ottawa, Canada 1/ 1 Customer: Englobe Corporation Device under Test: INFRA S50 Sound Level Meter SN: 14603 Software Version: 1.8.1 Date of Calibration: 2024-04-15 Ambient Conditions: 23° C ± 2° C (73.4° F ± 3.6° F) Method of Measurement: Absolute gain at 94 dBA/ 1000 Hz using acoustic calibrator. Rel. gain between standards and freq. weighting using electrical signals. Equipment: Acoustic Calibrator: Svantek SV36 #116312 Signal Generator: Keysight 33521B #MY59000555 Traceability: Traceable to national and international standards. Result of Measurement: Results are within specification limits. Recommended Interval of 12 months. Calibration: Calibration performed by: Matthew Scott ~U~ 5r0-4-4� Signature: .............................. Sigicom Canada, Inc. • 350 Palladium Drive, Suite 104 • Ottawa, ON K2V 1A8, Canada • +1 613 238 3232 • www.sigicom.com Page 44 of 180 DocuSign Envelope ID: 88AF2lA1-187A-47FF-AA5B-2BFE7D2449DA • • Sigicom CALIBRATION DOCUMENT Document No: Print Date: Location of Calibration: Page No: Cal 107531 2023-09-11 Ottawa, Canada 1/ 1 Customer: Englobe Corporation Device under Test: INFRA S50 Sound Level Meter SN: 13846 Software Version: 1.8.1 Date of Calibration: 2023-09-07 Ambient Conditions: 23° C ± 2° C (73.4° F ± 3.6° F) Method of Measurement: Absolute gain at 94 dBA/ 1000 Hz using acoustic calibrator. Rel. gain between standards and freq. weighting using electrical signals. Equipment: Acoustic Calibrator: Svantek SV36 #116312 Signal Generator: Keysight 33521B #MY59000555 Traceability: Traceable to national and international standards. Result of Measurement: Results are within specification limits. Recommended Interval of 12 months. Calibration: Calibration performed by: Imran Ahmad Signature: ..... ""'.`"L ................ ,.W Sigicom Canada, Inc. • 350 Palladium Drive, Suite 104 • Ottawa, ON K2V 1A8, Canada • +1 613 238 3232 • www.sigicom.com Page 45 of 180 DocuSign Envelope ID: B814ED81-ACA9-4028-8358-1 EBFB1974439 • • Sigicom CALIBRATION DOCUMENT Document No: Print Date: Location of Calibration: Page No: Cal 114187 2024-04-15 Ottawa, Canada 1/ 1 Customer: Englobe Corporation Device under Test: INFRA S50 Sound Level Meter SN: 13649 Software Version: 1.8.1 Date of Calibration: 2024-04-15 Ambient Conditions: 23° C ± 2° C (73.4° F ± 3.6° F) Method of Measurement: Absolute gain at 94 dBA/ 1000 Hz using acoustic calibrator. Rel. gain between standards and freq. weighting using electrical signals. Equipment: Acoustic Calibrator: Svantek SV36 #116312 Signal Generator: Keysight 33521B #MY59000555 Traceability: Traceable to national and international standards. Result of Measurement: Results are within specification limits. Recommended Interval of 12 months. Calibration: Calibration performed by: Matthew Scott ~U~ 5r0-4-4� Signature: .............................. Sigicom Canada, Inc. • 350 Palladium Drive, Suite 104 • Ottawa, ON K2V 1A8, Canada • +1 613 238 3232 • www.sigicom.com Page 46 of 180 Appendix C Graphical Temporal Data Record M wv 00:00:217 N ei Wd 00:00:11 y Wd 00:00:01 y Wd 00:00:6 N Wd 00:00:8 N Wd 00:00:L N Wd 00:00:9 N � 0 N Wd 00:00:9 0 N O N r M Wd 00:00:17 N vcn c 2 `i Wd 00:00:£ N J a M I N Wd 00:00:2 N O y E O Rx M m Wd 00:00:17 v y Q) N E I L. O Wd 00:00:217 v N '= N r wu � M bb wv00:00:11 It N O z Y r- 0 0 Wtl 00:00:017 N N 0 `i y > O M E a Wtl 00:00:6 N a 0) ~ m N 0 Wtl 00:00:8 (D N Z Z f° i M m D GWtl 00:00:L N 0 M Wv 00:00:9 N S J Wtl 00:00:s N Wtl 00:00:17 ow N Wtl 00:00:£ cn w N Wtl 00:00:2 cn w N Wv 00:00:17 M v N ei wv 00:00:217 M N O NO N O N O N O N O N ei O a -I Of Of a0 a0 I� n N N N N V (ad© OZ'Iaa `Vep) lanai ainssaad punog M Wv00:00:Zti N ei Wd 00:00:11 O v O y Wd 00:00:01 y Wd 00:00:6 N Wd 00:00:8 N Wd OO:OO:L N Wd 00:00:9 N 04 N Wd OO:OO:S N cc Wd 00:00:17 w N ° 2 Q Wd 00:00:£ N G M E r— Wd OO:OO:Z N Z 0) x m Wd 00:00:1 N E c IM m Wd OO:OO:Zl N u' ~ o `y M Z wvoo:oo:titi N R i o N v WV 00:00:01 o y d 7*4 E v M a Wtl 00:00:6 N ° m Ncn> p Wtl 00:00:8 N Z Z m Wtl OO:OO:L M v N In O r cn r'I Wtl 00:00:9 w N cn s M J Wtl OO:OO:S N Wtl 00:00:17 cn w N Wtl 00:00:£ cn w N Wtl OO:OO:Z cn w N wvoo:oo:ti v cny Wv00:00:Zti M v N ei T co co n n w w N N (ad© OZ IOJ 'V8p) lanai ainssaad punog M wvoo:oo:zi N ei Wd 00:00:11 y Wd 00:00:01 y Wd 00:00:6 N Wd 00:00:8 N Wd 00:00:L N Wd 00:00:9 N M N 0 Wd 00:00:9 N N M Wd 00:00:17 v N ti 2 rr Wd 00:00:£ w Lo a �Io y Wd 00:00:Z N R Z N o f° Wd 00:00:17 o N E 4LuM c m Wd 00:00:Zl N N o wvoo:oo:titi y z a; wvoo:oo:oti N E N ~ 0 Q Wtl00:00:6 N :2 0) f° N > Zwv oo:00:8 N is i C M p Wtl00:00:L N t � wvoo:oo:s � y a3 a� J wvoo:00:s N wv 00:00:17 v N wvoo:00:£ cn w N wvoo:00:Z cn w N wvoo:oo:ti v cny wvoo:oo:zi M v N ei Of co co I, n w w N N (ad©OZ IOJ `v8p) lanai aanssaad punog M wtl00:00:ZZ N ei Wd 00:00:11 y Wd 00:00:01 y Wd 00:00:6 N Wd 00:00:8 N Wd 00:00:L N Wd 00:00:904 N _ O Wd OO:OO:S N CV Cfl o � Wd 00:00:17 v o N ° 2 cn Q Wd 00:00:£ v N M E r— Wd 00:00:Z N Z 0) x ++ Wd 00:00:1 N E O � I M u O Wd 00:00:Zl N 0)o M Z N wtl00:00:11 N 0 WV 00:00:oti v y d E v Wtl 00:00:6 ° N 0) m > O Wtl 00:00:8 (D N ° Z Z M � m Wtl00:00:L N O t 0 V Wtl 00:00:9 � 0 N s M J Wtl00:00:S N Wtl 00:00:17 w N Wtl00:00:£ cn w N Wtl00:00:Z cn w N wtloo:oo:ti v cny wtl00:00:ZZ M v N 3 T co co n n w w N N (ad©OZ IOJ `Vep) lanai ainssaad punog M wtloo:oo:ati y Wd 00:00:11 y Wd 00:00:01 y Wd 00:00:6It y li Wd 00:00:8 cn v N Wd 00:00:L cnoN Wd 00:00:9 cn N M 04 Wd 00:00:9 y C N cnn Wd 00:00:17 wN c � 2 cn Wd oo:oo:£ y a yIo °' y Wd 00:00:2 v N R Z N o f° Wd 00:00:1 v o ami N E _a IM c m Wd 00:00:ZT v N y o `y M Z wtloo:oo:titi Lo R m N d d wtl o0:00:0ti Zo in ti ~ O cn a WV 00:00:6 N 0) f° y_ > Oo Wtl 00:00:8 o N Z Z m m i C M p WV 00:00:L N t swtl oo:oo:s a y a� J M Wtl 00:00:9 v N li Wtl 00:00:17 cn v N Wtl 00:00:£ cn v y li Wtl 00:00:2 cn w N li wtl 00:00:17 cn v y li wtl 00:00:22 M N ei T co co n n w w N N (ad©OZIaa `Vep) lanai aanssaad punog wtloo:oo:ati v Lo Wd 00:00:11 oo y Wd 00:00:01 M o y N.^ c Z Wd 00:00:6 N Wd 00:00:8 M N Wd OO:OO:L N Wd 00:00:9 N _ N o N Wd 00:00:9 0 y OCT Wd 00:00:17 oN cn a Q Wd 00:00:£ � N y d £ I N O Wd 00:00:Z v N Z 0) ~ N M ami E Wd 00:00:1 v N a E H m Wd oo:oo:ati !og y u' N o N M Z wtloo:oo:titi v Lo R Y i O wtl 00:00:017 ( Loo +� Wtl 00:00:6 en a M > 0 Wtl 00:00:8 (D N Z Z m 15 Wtl OO:OO:L cn v N O tcn Wtl 00:00:9 (D N s M a� J Wtl OO:OO:s v N Wtl 00:00:17 cn v N Wtl 00:00:£ cn (D N Wtl OO:OO:Z o (D o N wtloo:oo:ti v cny wtl 00:00:ZZ M ( N ei O O a -I N O N O N O N O N Of Of a0 a0 I, n V7 V7 N (ad© OZ IOJ `Vep) lanai aanssaad punog O N N V M Wtl 00:00:22 N ei Wd 00:00:11 y Wd 00:00:01 y Wd 00:00:6 N Wd 00:00:8 N Wd 00:00:L N Wd 00:00:9 N C Wd 00:00:9 N N Wd 00:00:17 w N c � 2 rr Wd 00:00:£ w y a �I0 y N Wd 00:00:2 N R Z N o d f° Wd 00:00:1 o N E M c Wd 00:00:Zl N u' 0) o wtloo:oo:titi y •i N M d w wtl o0:00:0ti N E_ N ~ 0 Q WV 00:00:6 N 0) m N > • M O Z Wtl 00:00:8 N m is i C M 0 WV 00:00:L v N t 3 swtl 00:00:9 y a� J M Wtl 00:00:9 N Wtl 00:00:17 w N Wtl 00:00:£ cn N Wtl 00:00:2 N wtl 00:00:17 y wtl 00:00:22 M N ei T co co n n w w N N (ad© OZ IOJ `Vep) lanai ainssaad punog O co O LO LO M Wtl 00:00:22 N ei Wd 00:00:11 y Wd 00:00:oti y Wd 00:00:6 N Wd 00:00:8 N Wd 00:00:L N Wd 00:00:9 N N M N Wd 00:00:9 N M ow � Wd 00:00:17 Loo = O � � cn Wd 00:00:£ N Q N Wd 00:00:2 N Z O ~ 0) x N m Wd 00:00:1 N a N 3 I O Wd 00:00:217 S N N M O Z y � wtl 00:00:1717 w N R m cn O wtl 00:00:017 > r M ~ Q Wtl 00:00:6 N -° > Wtl 00:00:8 M (D ° Z 0 N Z m a i� O Wtl 00:00:L N O Wtl 00:00:9 N s M J Wtl 00:00:s N Wtl 00:00:17 ow N Wtl 00:00:£ cn w N Wtl 00:00:2 cn w N wtloo:oo:ti v cny wtl 00:00:22 M ow N ei ON Of O N O N O N O a0 a0 I� n f0 f0 N N (ad©OZ IOJ `VeP)lana1 aanssaad punog O co O LO LO M Wtl 00:00:217 N ei Wd 00:00:11 y Wd 00:00:01 y Wd 00:00:6 N Wd 00:00:8 N Wd 00:00:L N Wd 00:00:9 N M N Wd 00:00:9 N ei -- Wd 00:00:17 w N O cn ti Wd 00:00:£ v N rr a � M � R IL y Wd 00:00:2 N O Z Wd 00:00:1 M y E E N � O Wd 00:00:217 u' N o N M Z N wv 00:00:1717 N R L M N N WV 00:00:01 a N E_ w +0+ O WV 00:00:6 0) > N M o O Wtl 00:00:8 N Z m m i M D GWV 00:00:L N 0 `i M •� Wtl 00:00:9 N s a� J Wtl 00:00:9 N Wtl 00:00:17 w N Wtl 00:00:£ cn w N Wtl 00:00:2 N wv 00:00:17 y wv o0:oo:2ti M N ei CO I, n w w N N (ado OZ'Iaa `v8p) lanai aanssaad punog M Wtl 00:00:22 N ei Wd 00:00:11 y Wd 00:00:01 y Wd 00:00:6 N Wd 00:00:8 N Wd 00:00:L N Wd 00:00:9 N N M N Wd 00:00:9 N N -- M ow � Wd 00:00:17 Loo = O � � cn Wd 00:00:£ N Q N Wd 00:00:2 v Lo Z O ~ 0) x N m Wd 00:00:17 E N N 3 I O Wd 00:00:217 ow N u' O M Z y � wtl 00:00:1717 N R i M v% wtl 00:00:017 0 r ~ QM Wtl 00:00:6 N ° > 0 Wtl 00:00:8 M (D N ° Z Z m is i O Wtl OO:OO:L � N O !i Wtl 00:00:9 N s M a� J Wtl OO:OO:S � N Wtl 00:00:17 w N Wtl 00:00:£ cn w N Wtl 00:00:2 cn N wtloo:oo:ti v cny wtl 00:00:22 M ow N ei CO CO I, n w w N Lo (ad©OZ IOJ `VeP)lana1 aanssaad punog M Wv 00:00:Zti N ei Wd 00:00:11 y Wd 00:00:01 y Wd 00:00:6 N Wd 00:00:8 N Wd OO:OO:L N Wd 00:00:9 N M N Wd 00:00:s N M -- Wd 00:00:17 w en M 1- Wd 00:00:£ v Lo rr a � M � R IL y Wd OO:OO:Z N O Z 0) m M Wd 00:00:1 y E N � O Wd OO:OO:Zti N o N M Z w wv 00:00:1717 N R i M N v Wv 00:00:OT y £ v > O Wtl 00:00:6N :2 0) > N M o O Wtl 00:00:8 N Z Z is i M C O Wtl OO:OO:L N O t � � M •� Wtl 00:00:9 N s a� J Wtl 00:00:6 c� N Wtl 00:00:17 w N Wtl 00:00:£ cn w N Wtl OO:OO:Z cn w N wvoo:oo:ti v cny Wv 00:00:Zti M v N ei OGf N co co n n w w N N N (ad© OZ IOJ `v8p) lanai ainssaad punog O co O O LO M wv 00:00:zi N ei Wd 00:00:11 y Wd 00:00:01 y Wd 00:00:6 N Wd 00:00:8 N Wd 00:00:L N Wd 00:00:9 N N M N Wd 00:00:9 N M � Wd 00:00:17 N = O � � Wd 00:00:£ N Q N Wd 00:00:2 N Z O ~ 0) x N m Wd 00:00:1 E N N 3 I O Wd 00:00:217 u' M O Z y � wv 00:00:1717 N R m O wv 00:00:017 > r M ~ Q WV 00:00:6 N a > Wtl 00:00:8 M Z 0 N Z m is i� O WV 00:00:L N O Wtl 00:00:9 N s M J Wtl 00:00:9 N WV 00:00:17 w N Wtl 00:00:£ cn w N Wtl 00:00:2 N wv 00:00:17 y wv 00:00:zi M N ei N Of O N O N O N O N O N O Of a0 a0 I, n f0 f0 N N It It (ad©OZ'Iaa `v8p) lanai ainssaad punog O co O O LO M Wtloo:oo:zi N ei Wd 00:00:11 y Wd 00:00:01 y Wd 00:00:6 N Wd 00:00:8 N Wd 00:00:L N Wd 00:00:9 N N M o 0 N Wd 00:00:9 N N ^ Wd 00:00:17 N vcn O ti Wd 00:00:£ N a � M � IL y Wd 00:00:2 N O Z M fxG Wd 00:00:17en E _a 3 cr IN O Wd 00:00:Zl Lu N N o N M Z N ow wvoo:oo:ii N R 15 L M N N Wtl 00:00:017 N £ y +O+ > ~ F O M a Wtl 00:00:6 N :2 0) > N M o O Wtl 00:00:8 Z m Z m D O Wtl 00:00:L N O t � � M .-. Wtl 00:00:9 N s a� J Wtl 00:00:s N Wtl 00:00:17 ow N Wtl 00:00:£ cn N Wtl 00:00:2 cn w N wvoo:oo:ti v cny Wtl 00:00Zti M a N ei (L'dJ O2 •}aa `Vgp) lanai aanssaad punog M Wtl 00:00:22 N ei Wd 00:00:11 y Wd 00:00:01 y Wd 00:00:6 N Wd 00:00:8 N Wd 00:00:L N Wd 00:00:9 N N M N Wd 00:00:9 N M � Wd 00:00:17 v Lo = O � � Wd 00:00:£ v N Q N Wd 00:00:2 v Lo Z O ~x 0) N m Wd 00:00:1 E N a' I O Wd 00:00:2ti S N V} r M O Z y wtloo:oo:titi woN R m O wtloo:oo:oti > r M ~ Q WV 00:00:6 N -° > Wtl 00:00:8 M (D ° Z 0 N Z m is i� O WV 00:00:L N O Wtl 00:00:9 N s M J Wtl 00:00:9 N Wtl 00:00:17 w N Wtl 00:00:£ N Wtl 00:00:2 N wtl 00:00:1 y wtl 00:00:22 M N ei ON Of O N O N O N O a0 a0 I� n f0 f0 N N (ad© OZ IOJ `Vep) lanai ainssaad punog M wvoo:oo:Zti y Wd 00:00:11 y Wd 00:00:01 y Wd 00:00:6 N Wd 00:00:8 N Wd 00:00:L N Wd 00:00:9 N M N Wd 00:00:9 N 1- ^ Wd 00:00:17 m L en � M � Wd 00:00:£ N rr2 a � L M R I y Wd 00:00:Z N O Z 0) M m Wd 00:00:17 y E _a N � I O Wd 00:00:Zl LLI N N o N M Z w wvoo:oo:titi en R L M N y Wv 00:00:02 v N +O+ O Wtl 00:00:6 N:2 0) > N M 0 O Wtl 00:00:8 c� N Z is 0 O Wtl00:00:L N O t � M o .-. Wtl 00:00:9 N s J M wvoo:00:s N Wtl 00:00:17 w o N wvoo:00:£ (D o N wvoo:00:Z (D N wvoo:oo:ti 0 0 y Wv00:00:Zti M v N ei T co co n n w w N N (ad©OZ IOJ `v8p) lanai ainssaad punog It 0 wtl oo:oo:ati co y li Wd 00:00:11 co y li Wd 00:00:017 o y li Wd 00:00:6 It co o N M vi Wd 00:00:8 M N vi Wd 00:00:L It o N M m Wd 00:00:9 co N li m N Wd 00:00:9 co y M N Wd 00:00:17 co N M J Wd 00:00:£ D (It co o N I m L N v 't o £ Wd 00:00:Z Ln N ei Z 2 ei N Wd 00:00:1 w LO £ m N a N � I 0 Wd 00:00:ZT M N N o `w Z WV 00:00:11 o y 0 WV 00:00:01 o y E v ~ o a N a WV 00:00:6 � N m > N 0 Z Wtl 00:00:8 M N is i C 0 WV 00:00:L It co o N t M s wtl 00:00:9 o y Wtl 00:00:9 It co o N M li Wtl 00:00:17 M N li Wtl 00:00:£ M N li Wtl 00:00:2 M N li wtl 00:00:17 m o y li wtl oo:oorti o y N Of o N o N o N o N o N Of co co I, n f0 f0 N N � (ad©OZ'Iaa `Vep) lanai ainssaad punog wtl oo:oo:ati ' y Wd 00:00:11 ' y Wd 00:00:017 ' y Wd 00:00:6 co N m Wd 00:00:8 co N m N O Wd 00:00:L N Wd 00:00:9 co N m N N Wd 00:00:9 N NN Wd 00:00:17 M N E J Wd 00:00:£ co N I m M L O v O £ N Wd 00:00:Z co N R o O aM-i N Z 2 � N +� Wd 00:00:1 co N E rr O m a N � I LLI O Wd 00:00:Zl M N N o wtl 00:00:1717 y i Q) N co w Wtl 00:00:02 co N E ~ O Q Wtl 00:00:6 co NLo m > N o Z Wtl 00:00:8 co N M m i O O Wtl 00:00:L v co o N t M s wtloo:oo:9 co y a� M Wtl 00:00:6 co N M Wtl 00:00:17 co N M Wtl 00:00:£ co N M Wtl 00:00:2 M N wtloo:oo:ti It co o y wtl oo:oorti 9 N y 14 co co n n w w N N (ad© OZ IOJ `Vep) lanai ainssaad punog w wtloo:oo:Zti ' y Wd 00:00:11 co y Wd 00:00:01 co y Wd 00:00:6 co N m Wd 00:00:8 co N m Wd 00:00:L N M Wd 00:00:9 m N N a -I Wd 00:00:9 M N O N Wd 00:00:17 N M Wd 00:00:£ N I m M L 0 N o d £ N Wd 00:00:ZN R o M N Z 2 c N Wd 00:00:17 co a J NLO � � IN u' m Wd 00:00:Zl M N N o wtloo:oo:titi M y •i N co w Wtl 00:00:02 co N E N ~ 0 Q Wtl 00:00:6 co M N m > N • o Z Wtl 00:00:8 co N m 0 Wtl00:00:L v o co N t M a3 wtl o0:00:9 co y a� M J Wtl00:00:s co N M Wtl 00:00:17 co N M Wtl00:00:£ co N M Wtl00:00:Z co N M wtloo:oo:ti co y M wtloo:oo:zl co y co co n n w w N N (ad©OZ'Iaa `Vep) lanai ainssaad punog N N wtloo:oo:Zti ' y Wd 00:00:11 ' y Wd 00:00:01 co y Wd 00:00:6 co N m Wd 00:00:8 co N m Wd OO:OO:L N cco m Wd 00:00:9 co N m Wd OO:OO:$ M N O N Wd 00:00:17 co N E J Wd OO:OO:£ � M N Im L y N Wd 00:00:Z co N R m Z O 2 N v o d Wd 00:00:17 en £ m _m N � I O Wd OO:OO:Zti M N od N o N m Z y wtloo:oo:titi co y •i Q) N v O wtloo:00:01 coM y E +, r> O a Wtl 00:00:6 M Lo a 0) m N 0 Wtl 00:00:8 coN 0 Z m is 0 Wtl00:00:L co N wtloo:oo:s co y a3 M J m wtl00:00:s co N M WV 00:00:17 co N wtl00:00:£ M N wtl00:00:Z M N wtloo:oo:ti co y wtloo:oo:zl It co o y O o N O N O N O N O N O N Of Of a0 a0 I, n f0 f0 N N It (ad©OZ IOJ `Vep) lanai ainssaad punog wtl oo:oo:zi ' y w o Wd 00:00:11 y Wd 00:00:01 co y Wd 00:00:6 co N m Wd 00:00:8 co N m Wd 00:00:L co N M m Wd 00:00:9 co N m N Wd 00:00:9 co y M N Wd 00:00:17 N m E J V Wd 00:00:£ co N M L Wd 00:00:2 � co N d O M z 2 r ei N rr Wd 00:00:1 co N E r _a H �I Wd oo:oo:ati M y N ~ o m Z y y� WV 00:00:ti1 9 c y y (D Q) N v 0 }+ Wtl 00:00:02 M N E y r- 0 0 �p Q Wtl00:00:6 co N M m N � Wtl 00:00:8 co o Z N m is i C 0 Wtl00:00:L co N t M Wtl00:00:9 N s N a� J Wtl00:00:s co N M Wtl00:00:ti co N M Wtl00:00:£ co N M Wtl00:00:Z co N M wtloo:oo:ti co y M wtl oo:oo:Zti co y O N N ONE T co co n n w w N N N (ad© OZ'Iaa `Vep) lanai ainssaad punog w wvoo:oo:Zti 9 a -I N y Wd 00:00:11 co N Wd 00:00:01 ' y Wd 00:00:6 co N m Wd 00:00:8 co N m Wd 00:00:L N M m Wd 00:00:9 co N m N C Wd 00:00:9 N N 04OCTx Wd 00:00:17 co N m I Wd 00:00:£ co N m M L O co N E N Wd 00:00:Z Lo R o O ei N Z 2 � N � a Wd 00:00:1 M N d E _a I 4 m c O Wd 00:00:Zl N ~ o wvoo:oo:titi co en •i N co w Wv 00:00:02 co N E N ~ O Q Wtl 00:00:6 M N � N m o Z Wtl 00:00:8 M N Is i C O � O Wtl00:00:L m N N S Wv 00:00:9 co N M J wvoo:00:s co N M Wtl 00:00:17 co N wvoo:00:£ co N M wvoo:00:Z co N wvoo:oo:ti co y M wvoo:oo:zl N y a -I T N T co co n n w w N N N (ad© OZ IOJ `v8p) lanai ainssaad punog wtloo:oo:Zti co y Wd 00:00:11 co y O Wd 00:00:01 y Wd 00:00:6 co N m N O Wd 00:00:8 N Wd 00:00:L co N M m Wd 00:00:9 m N N a -I co O NO Wd OO:OO:S N m N Wd 00:00:17 M N E J Wd 00:00:£ It M o N I m L O It o N £ N Wd 00:00:Z w N R o O M N Z 2 � N Wd 00:00:1 M N E J N .� I O Wd 00:00:ZT M N N m o wtloo:oo:titi M y •i N v co Wtl 00:00:02 co N £ N ~ O Q Wtl 00:00:6 M N m � > N o Z Wtl 00:00:8 M N m m i O O Wtl00:00:L v co o N t M Wtl 00:00:9 co N M J Wtl00:00:S co N M Wtl 00:00:17 co N M Wtl00:00:£ co N M Wtl00:00:Z co N M wtloo:oo:ti y M wtloo:oo:Zti co y T N T co co n n w w N N N (ad©OZ IOJ `Vep) lanai ainssaad punog wtl oo:oo:Zti co y Wd 00:00:11 co y Wd 00:00:01 co y Wd 00:00:6 co N m Wd 00:00:8 co N m Wd 00:00:L co N m Wd 00:00:9 co N m 0 Wd 00:00:9 co N N M O !� Wd 00:00:17 co m N m J c� IV Wd 00:00:£ M N L H Wd DD:DD:ZM � N d R O ei Z 2 a d a +N, Wd 00:00:1 co N E a N � I Wd 00:00:Zl co N Lu N o � Z `w wtl 00:00:11 co Lo Wtl 00:00:02 M N E N +O+ a Wtl 00:00:6 co en M N_ 0 Wtl00:00:8 co Z Z Lo is 0 0 Wtl 00:00:L co N M wtloo:oo:s co y a3 M a� J Wtl00:00:s co N M Wtl 00:00:17 co N M Wtl00:00:£ co N M Wtl00:00:Z co N M wtloo:oo:ti co y M wtl oo:oo:Zti co y T T co co n n w w N N (ad© OZ IOJ `Vep) lanai ainssaad punog wvoo:oo:zl 00 y Wd 00:00:11 ' y Wd 00:00:01 co y Wd 00:00:6 co N m Wd 00:00:8 co N m � Wd OO:OO:L NO Wd 00:00:9 co N m _ 0 Wd 00:00:$ co N N Wd 00:00:17 co N m a E 00:00:£ IWd c* N i H Wd 00:00:Z � d co N R O m Z 2 Wd 00:00:1 co y E .2- m Wd OO:OO:Zti co N N o � Z `w Wvoo:00:11 co y i N WVDD:DD:Dti co M N £ w `y +0+ a 0 WVOO:00:6 o co N M > N o 0 WVOO:00:8 co m Z N 15 0 WVOO:00:L co N t M sWvoo:00:9 co ' y a� J �p WVOO:00:9 co N M wv 00:00:17 co N M WVOO:00:£ co N M wvOO:00:Z co N M Wvoo:00:1 co Ln ' wvoo:oo:zl co y coLn N W n Ln n Ln o w w N N N (ad©OZ'Iaa `Vep)lana1 ainssaad punog w wtloo:oo:Zti 9 a -I N y Wd 00:00:11 co N Wd 00:00:017 ' y Wd 00:00:6 co N m Wd 00:00:8 co N m Wd 00:00:L N M m Wd 00:00:9 co N m _ N 0 :: Wd OOOOS m O N N OF ei Wd 00:00:17 co N Lo E c� IV Wd 00:00:£ M N 0 H Wd 00:00:Z coM N R 7 O 0 2 Z 2 d Wd 00:00:17 M N £ J ++ N m � Wd OO:OO:Zti N N o m Z `w wtloo:oo:titi M y i m N wtloo:oo:oti y E v v > Wtl 00:00:6 M N 0) r m N_ 0 Wtl 00:00:8 co Lo Z N Z m m 0 Wtl00:00:L m N N 1 �r wtloo:oo:s y s M wtl00:00:S M N wtl 00:00:17 co N wtl00:00:£ co N M wtl00:00:Z co N wtloo:oo:ti co y M wtloo:oo:Zti N y a -I ONE T N co co n n w w N N N (ad©OZ'Iaa `tl8p)l8n8j ainssaad punog wvoo:oo:Zti co y Wd 00:00:11 ' y Wd 00:00:01 co y Wd 00:00:6 co N m Wd 00:00:8 co N m Wd 00:00:L co N M m Wd 00:00:9 co N m N 0 Wd 00:00:$ co N N aMi Wd 00:00:17 co NLo E m J V Wd 00:00:£ M N L 0It H Wd DD:DD:Z (p co o N N O ei R Z 2 a d a Wd 00:00:1 co N E +N, m ? N � I Wd 00:00:Zl M N Lu N o � Z `w wvoo:oo:titi co cn N i Wv 00:00:017 co M N £_ w +0+ 0 Wtl 00:00:6 co N 0) M r > N o O Wtl 00:00:8 co N m Z m G Wtl00:00:L co N 0 wvoo:oo:s co y a3 M a� J wvoo:00:s co N Wtl 00:00:17 co N M wvoo:00:£ co N M wvoo:00:Z co N M wvoo:oo:ti co y M wvoo:oo:Zti co y Of Of a0 a0 I, n f0 f0 N N � (ad©OZ IOJ `v8p) lanai ainssaad punog wtloo:oo:Zti co y Wd 00:00:11 co y Wd 00:00:01 co y Wd 00:00:6 co N m Wd 00:00:8 co N m Wd OO:OO:L co N M m Wd 00:00:9 co N m _ 04 Wd 00:00:9 co O N N Wd 00:00:17 co N � m J c� Wd 00:00:£ M N IV m � H Wd OO:OO:ZM N d R ati Z O 2 � f0 C ei NE Wd OO:OO:ti M N £ rr a 3 N a I Wd OO:OO:Zl i N ~ N o 0) <o Z wtloo:oo:titi M cn R N O WtlOO:OO:oi co o`y ++ my F O (D p a Wtl 00:00:6 N $ 0) ~ > _ o O Wtl 00:00:8 co Lo Z M 'i m O Wtl00:00:L co N O r t� o V s Wtl 00:00:9 m N a� J Wtl00:00:s co N M wtl 00:00:17 co N m Wtl00:00:£ co N M Wtl00:00:Z co N M wtloo:oo:ti co y ' wtloo:oo:Zti ' y O O a -I NO N O N O N O N O N Of Of a0 a0 I� n f0 f0 N N V (ad©OZ'Iaa `tl8p) lana] ainssaad punog wvoo:oo:Zti co y Wd 00:00:11 co y M Wd 00:00:01 co y Wd 00:00:6 co N m � O Wd 00:00:8 N Wd 00:00:L N M m Wd 00:00:9 co N m CV Wd 00:00:9 co N O N Wd 00:00:17 co m yen � J V Wd 00:00:£ M N m � d O Wd OO:OO:Zco Lo R y O m N Z o ? N Wd 00:00:1 c E v +, O m en a J N m c I Wd 00:00:Zl M N u' ~ N o 0) m Z `w wvoo:oo:titi ' y v N o wvoo:oo:oti com N E_ r ~ > 'a O p a Wv 00:00:6 co N 0) > N m o O wv 00:00:8 N Z N is O Wtl00:00:L co N M O t � •� wtl 00:00:9 m co N s M a� J wvoo:00:s co N M wtl 00:00:17 co N M wvoo:00:£ co N M wvoo:00:Z co N M wvoo:oo:ti co y M wvoo:oo:Zti co y O � N O N O N O N O N O Of Of a0 a0 I, n f0 f0 N N (ad© OZ IOJ `v8p) lanai ainssaad punog wv oo:oo:Zti co y Wd 00:00:11 co y Wd 00:00:01 N y a -I Wd 00:00:6 co N m Wd 00:00:8 co N m Wd 00:00:L N cco m Wd 00:00:9 co N m _ N 0 Wd 00:00:$ co N N !� Wd 00:00:17 co N m m J V Wd 00:00:£ M N H Wd 00:00:Z co Lo R O N ei Z 2 a +N, Wd 00:00:1 co N d E a .2- m Wd 00:00:Zl co N Lu N o � y� Wv 00:00:titi y m N i wv DD:DD:Dti co E w N +O+ M N > r ~ F G Q Wtl00:00:6 co N 0) M r > N o O wv oo:00:8 co N Z is 0 Wtl00:00:L co N t M wvoo:oo:s co y a3 M a� J wvoo:00:s co N M wv 00:00:17 co N M wvoo:00:£ co N M wvoo:00:Z co N M wvoo:oo:ti co y M wv oo:oo:Zti N y a -I N Of O N O N O N O N O N Of a0 a0 I, n f0 f0 N N � (ad© OZ IOJ `v8p) lanai ainssaad punog w wvoo:oo:zl ' y Wd 00:00:11 ' y Wd 00:00:01 ' y Wd 00:00:6 N N a -I Wd 00:00:8 co N m Wd 00:00:L co N M m Wd 00:00:9 co N m 04 Wd 00:00:9 co O N N Wd 00:00:17 M Lo m N cO Wd 00:00:£ M N IV m � Q) O Wd OO:OO:Z co Lo R m y m N Z o Wd OO:OO:ti m N E rr O 'ia y m c I Wd OO:OO:Zti co N 0 ~ y o 0) m Z `w wvoo:oo:titi ' y m �p N O Wv00:00:01 M N `w ++ E F > O p a WV 00:00:6 M N a 0) ~ > y m o O wv 00:00:8 N Z N 2 O WV 00:00:L co N M � O t .-. wv 00:00:9 co N s M a� J fO o wv 00:00:9 N wv 00:00:17 co N M wv 00:00:£ co N M wv 00:00:Z co N M wv 00:00:1 co y M wvoo:oo:zl m N y l O � N O N O N O N O N O N Of Of a0 a0 I, n N N N N It (ad© OZ IOJ `v8p) lanai ainssaad punog wtloo:oo:z1 M y Wd 00:00:11 M y Wd 00:00:01 M y Wd 00:00:6 M N ei Wd 00:00:8 M N ei Wd 00:00:L Of N N a -I Wd 00:00:9 M N ei N Wd 00:00:9 N y N Wd 00:00:17 M N .-. 2 c L � Wd 00:00:£ N J U m � IN i Wd 00:00:Z ti R N Z N x y m ++ Wd 00:00:1£ E O N _ O Wd 00:00:ZT M N N N o y� wtl o0:00:11 d i N rn w Wtl 00:00:01 M N £ `y F O Q T Wtl 00:00:6 M N m > N o Z Wtl 00:00:8 M N m i C O O Wtl00:00:L v M o N t � a3 wtl o0:00:9 y a� J wtl00:00:s M N WV 00:00:17 N m wtl00:00:£ M N wtl00:00:Z M N wtl o0:00:1 rn M y wtloo:oo:z1 M y N Of O N O N O N O N O N Of a0 a0 I, n N N N N It (ad© OZ'Iaa `Vep) lanai ainssaad punog rn wtloo:oo:Zti y Wd 00:00:11 ° y Wd 00:00:01 ° y Wd 00:00:6 M N ei Wd 00:00:8 M N ei Wd 00:00:L M N Wd 00:00:904 M N Of Q Wd 00:00:9 M N N 0 Wd 00:00:17 M N O 2 c L ti a U Wd 00:00:£ M � N N J y Wd 00:00:2 M N y IO Z C m ++ Wd 00:00:2 M N � a uj O Wd 00:00:Zl M N N � o y� wtloo:oo:titi y •i N 0 wtl oo:00:0ti v y r- 0 a Wtl 00:00:6 M o N a 0) m N 0 Wtl 00:00:8 N 0 Z ti is i rn GWtl00:00:L M 0 N rn .� Wtl 00:00:9 N s a� Wtl00:00:s N °f Wtl 00:00:17 No °f o Wtl00:00:£ N °f o Wtl00:00:Z N °f o wtloo:oo:ti y wtloo:oo:Zti N y a -I co co n n w w N N (ad© OZ'Iaa `Vep) lanai ainssaad punog wtloo:oo:Zti y ° Wd 00:00:11 ° y Wd 00:00:01 ° y Wd 00:00:6 M N ei Wd 00:00:8 M N ei Wd 00:00:L M N Wd 00:00:9 M N ei N O Wd 00:00:9 y � N N Wd 00:00:17 M y --. L Wd 00:00:£ M N � J U N Wd 00:00:Z E I i m ti N Z c x N ++ Wd 00:00:1 E c 4 rn 0 Wd 00:00:ZT N N o `w � Z wtl00:00:11 y i N rn w Wtl 00:00:02 M N £ `y F � 0 Q T Wtl 00:00:6 M N m > N o Z Wtl 00:00:8 M N m i 0 Wtl00:00:L M N t S Wtl 00:00:9 M N J � Wtl00:00:s M N Wtl 00:00:17 N M Wtl00:00:£ M N Wtl00:00:Z M N wtloo:oo:ti ° y wtloo:oo:Zti ° y co co n n w w N N It (ad© OZ'Iaa `Vep) lanai ainssaad punog rn wtloo:oo:Z1 M y Wd 00:00:11 M y Wd 00:00:01 M y Wd 00:00:6 M N ei Wd 00:00:8 M N ei Wd 00:00:L M N Wd 00:00:904 M N Of Q Wd 00:00:9 M N N (D 3 Wd 00:00:17 M N Lo O 2 c L ti a U Wd 00:00:£ M N � N J y Wd 00:00:2 N M y IO Z C d m Wd 00:00:1 M N J � N _E � I Wd 00:00:Z1 y N � o y� wtl 00:00:11 y 2 15 •i N Wtloo:oo:01 d v y r- 0 a Wtl00:00:6 o M N 'a 0) > N O Wtl00:00:8 cn o Z ti co m G Wtl00:00:L M N rn .� Wtl00:00:9 N s a� Wtl00:00:s N °f Wtl00:00:17 No °f o Wtl00:00:£ N °f o Wtl00:00:Z N °f o wtl oo:oo:1 y wtloo:oo:Z1 N y a -I T T co co n n w w N Lo (ad© OZ'Iaa `Vep) lanai ainssaad punog rn wtl oo:oo:Zti ° y Wd 00:00:11 ° y Wd 00:00:01 ° y Wd 00:00:6 M N ei Wd 00:00:8 M N ei Wd 00:00:L M N Wd 00:00:9 M N ei N Wd 00:00:9 M y N Wd 00:00:17 Lo .-. M O L Wd 00:00:£ M N ti S U � J y N T m CC � G I i Wd 00:00:Z ti R N Z c x N ++ Wd 00:00:1 M N E N � 0 Wd 00:00:ZT M N N o `w � Z wtl 00:00:titi N d N •i N rn v wtl oo:oo:oti y E 0 a Wtl00:00:6 M N m > N • o Z Wtl00:00:8 M N m rn 0 Wtl00:00:L 0 N t c7 a3 wtl o0:00:9 y a� J Wtl00:00:s M N Wtl00:00:17 N M Wtl00:00:£ M N Wtl00:00:Z N wtloo:oo:ti ° y wtl oo:oo:Zti ° y N O Of Of N O N O N O N O N a0 a0 I, n f0 f0 N N � (ad© OZ'Iaa `Vep) lanai ainssaad punog rn wv oo:oo:Zti ° y Wd 00:00:11 ° y o Wd 00:00:01 y Wd 00:00:6 N N a -I Wd 00:00:8 M N ei Wd 00:00:L M N Wd 00:00:9 M N Of N Wd 00:00:9 M y OC , Wd DD:DD:ti M N p 2 c L ti a V Wd 00:00:£ M � N y O Wd 00:00:2 M E y I Z Nm Wd 00:00:1 M N J _E u' Wd 00:00:Zti y N N o y� Wv 00:00:titi y •i � N 0 wv 00:00:01 v " M N £ N r- 0 O a Wtl00:00:6 M G N $ 0) m N 0 wv oo:00:8 N 0 Z ti i rn GWtl00:00:L It oC 0 M N `i •� wv oo:00:9 rn M N s a� J wvoo:00:s M N wv 00:00:17 M N wvoo:00:£ M N wvoo:00:Z M N wvoo:oo:ti ° y wv oo:oo:Zti ° y N Of O N O N O N O N O N Of a0 a0 I, n N N N N � (ad© OZ'Iaa `v8p) lanai ainssaad punog wtloo:oo:z1 M y Wd 00:00:11 N y a -I Wd 00:00:01 M N ei Wd 00:00:6 M N ei Wd 00:00:8 M N ei Wd 00:00:L M N Wd 00:00:9 M N ei N Wd 00:00:9 M y N Wd 00:00:17 M N .-. 7 O 2 � c L Wd 00:00:£ M N J U N Q) E I i Wd 00:00:Z (D ti L, R N Z c x N ++ Wd 00:00:1 M N E a � IN 0 Wd 00:00:Z1o M N N `w Z y� wtl 00:00:11 y i N rn w Wtl 00:00:01 M y £ `y F > 0 Q Wtl 00:00:6 M N m > N It oo Z Wtl 00:00:8 M N m i 0 Wtl00:00:L It M o N t � s wtl o0:00:9 w y a� J Wtl00:00:s M N Wtl 00:00:17 N M Wtl00:00:£ M N Wtl00:00:Z N wtl oo:oo:1 M y wtloo:oo:z1 M y N Of O N O N O N O N O N Of a0 a0 I, n N N N N � (ad© OZ IOJ `Vep) lanai ainssaad punog wvoo:oo:z1 M y Wd 00:00:11 M y Wd 00:00:01 M y Wd 00:00:6 M N ei Wd 00:00:8 M N ei Wd 00:00:L M N Wd 00:00:904 M N C Wd 00:00:9 M N N ei Wd 00:00:17 M N p ei Wd 00:00:£ M N a N Wd 00:00:Z M N R ei Z X m Wd 00:00:1 M N E }.I N � O Wd 00:00:Z1 Lu M N N 0 rn Z `w wv oo:oo:11 y N 0 Wv00:00:01 M N £ N F Of > a Wtl00:00:6 M N 'a 0) ~ > N p O wv oo:00:8 a°i Z N � is rn C i O Wtl00:00:L M N O t V wv oo:00:9 M N J wvoo:00:s M N wv 00:00:17 M N wvoo:00:£ M N wvoo:00:Z M N wv oo:oo:1 ° y wvoo:oo:Z1 ° y N Of O N O N O N O N O N O Of a0 a0 I, n f0 f0 N N (ad© OZ IOJ `v8p) lanai ainssaad punog rn It wvoo:oo:zl y Wd 00:00:11 y Wd 00:00:01 y Wd 00:00:6 M N ei Wd 00:00:8 M N ei Wd 00:00:L M N Wd 00:00:9 M N ei Of O Wd 00:00:9 M N N rn Wd 00:00:17 N j >� m 0 c� V Wd 00:00:£ M N S N U H Wd 00:00:Z Q) o R I M ei N Z N m Wd 00:00:2 M N O a c Irn O Wd 00:00:ZT M N N o N � Zcc `w wvoo:oo:titi y N i Wt/ 00:00:02 rn M £ w `y +O+ N r- 0 O Of Wtl 00:00:6 M N N > N o Oz Wtl 00:00:8 M Z N m i rn p Wtl00:00:L N t � ei rn s wv o0:00:9 y Q) J wvoo:00:s M N WV 00:00:17 N M wvoo:00:£ M N wvoo:00:Z N wvoo:oo:ti ° y wvoo:oo:zl ° y W Ln o W n n w Ln w N N It It (ad©OZ IOJ `v8p) lanai ainssaad punog wtloo:oo:Zti ° y Wd 00:00:11 ° y Wd 00:00:01 ° y Wd 00:00:6 M N ei Wd 00:00:8 M N ei Wd 00:00:L M N Wd 00:00:9 M N 04 N Wd 00:00:9OF M y ei Wd 00:00:17 M N O ei Wd 00:00:£ M N a J U R I y Wd 00:00:Z N O Z 0) c m d +N, Wd 00:00:1 M N E N � a Wd 00:00:Zl N u' N 0 rn Z `w wtloo:oo:titi y N o wtloo:oo:oti }I M N E N Of a WV 00:00:6 M N a m 0) N O Wtl 00:00:8 M N o z Z m rn C i O WV 00:00:L M N O t V Wtl00:00:9 N a� J Wtl00:00:9 N N a -I Wtl00:00:ti N M Wtl00:00:£ M N Wtl00:00:Z M N wtl 00:00:1 ° y wtloo:oo:Zti N y a -I co co n n w w N Lo (ad© OZ IOJ `Vep) lanai aanssaad punog rn WV 00:00:z1 M y Wd 00:00:11 M y Wd 00:00:01 M y Wd 00:00:6 M N ei Wd 00:00:8 M N ei Wd 00:00:L M N Wd 00:00:9 M N ei Of O Wd 00:00:9 M N N rn Wd 00:00:17 N j M c� V Wd 00:00:£ M N S N U H Wd 00:00:2 Q) I M ei N Z N m Wd 00:00:1 M N rn c O Wd OO:OO:Z1 M N N o N � Z `w wv 00:00:11 y N i Wv 00:00:01 rn M £ w `y +O+ N r- 0 O Of Wtl 00:00:6 M N N > N o Oz Wtl 00:00:8 M Z N m i rn p Wtl00:00:L N t � ei rn s wv o0:00:9 y a� J wvoo:00:s M N Wtl 00:00:17 N M wvoo:00:£ M N wvoo:00:Z N wv o0:00:1 M y WV 00:00:z1 M y T co co n n w w N N (ad© OZ IOJ `v8p) lanai ainssaad punog It 0 wtloo:oo:Zti ° y Wd 00:00:11 y Wd 00:00:01 y Wd 00:00:6 M N ei Wd 00:00:8 M N ei Wd 00:00:L M N Wd 00:00:9 M N 04 N Wd 00:00:9 M y ei Wd 00:00:17 M N O ei Wd 00:00:£ M N a J U R I y Wd 00:00:Z N O Z 0) c x d +N, Wd 00:00:1 M N E N � a Wd 00:00:Zl N u' N 0 rn Z `w wtloo:oo:titi y N o wtloo:oo:oti }I M N E N r Of F a Wtl 00:00:6 M N 'a m 0) N O Wtl 00:00:8 M N o z Z m rn C i O Wtl00:00:L M N O t V Wtl 00:00:9 N a� J wtl00:00:s N N a -I wtl 00:00:17 M N wtl00:00:£ M N wtl00:00:Z M N wtloo:oo:ti ° y wtloo:oo:Zti N y a -I N O N O N O N O N O Of Of a0 a0 I, n f0 f0 N N N O (ad©OZ'Iaa `Vep)lana1 ainssaadpunog wvoo:00:Zi y Wd 00:00:11 ° y Wd 00:00:01 ° y Wd 00:00:6 N cn Wd 00:00:8 N cn Wd 00:00:L w N cn Wd 00:00:9 N cn _ Of 0 Wd 00:00:9 M N N rn !'I Wd 00:00:17 N j >� cn = c� L Wd 00:00:£ rrtn M N H Wd 00:00:2 M ei N R Z N c m Wd 00:00:2 M N N rn c mWd 00:00:Zl M N u' N o � Z `w wvoo:oo:titin cn i N wvoo:oo:oti rn w y Ecn v v r- 0 Wtl 00:00:6 N M li > N o O Wtl 00:00:8 rn N z Z M yv 15 i p Wtl00:00:L rn N t M wvoo:oo:s y a3 n a� J � Wtl 00:00:9 N M wv 00:00:17 N cn Wtl00:00:£ N M wtl00:00:Z N M wvoo:00:1 y ° wvoo:oo:zl N y cn a -I N M O N O N O N O N O M CO CO I, n w w N N (ad©OZ IOJ `v8p) lanai ainssaad punog wvoo:oo:Zti ° y Wd 00:00:11 ° y Wd 00:00:01 y Wd 00:00:6 N Wd 00:00:8 M N ei Wd 00:00:L M N Wd 00:00:9 M N N rn 0 Wd 00:00:9 N N ei0 Wd 00:00:17M N p ei c L Wd 00:00:£ M N S N J U I H Wd 00:00:Z M N R y Z N x Wd 00:00:1 y E N rn c Wd OO:OO:Zti M N No rn Z y wvoo:oo:titi en � N o wvoo:oo:oti ++ M N E > F Of 'p Q Wtl00:00:6 M N a m 0) > N O wv oo:00:8M N Z Z2 m rn C O Wtl00:00:L M N O t V wv oo:00:9 M N a� J wvoo:00:s M N wv 00:00:17 N M wvoo:00:£ M N wvoo:00:Z M N wvoo:oo:ti ° y wvoo:oo:zl ° y N o)N p N p N N Lo Of Of a0 a0 I� n f0 w f0 N N N p It It (adTi OZ 'Iaa `v8p) lanai aanssaad punog rn It 0 wvoo:oo:Zti ° y Wd 00:00:11 ° y Wd 00:00:01 ° y Wd 00:00:6 N Wd 00:00:8 M N ei Wd 00:00:L M N Wd 00:00:9 M N ei N 0 Wd 00:00:$ M N N rn Wd DD:DD:ti N M ei � c� L Wd 00:00:£ M N N J H Wd 00:00:Z M o Q) R ei N Z 0) rn m Wd 00:00:2M N y £ N � m Wd OO:OO:Zti M N u' N o � Z `w wv00:00:11 y i N wvoo:oo:oti rn y E v v WV 00:00:6 M N li > N rn o 0wv 00:00:8 M m Z N i 0 WV 00:00:L rn M N s wv 00:00:9 N a� J wv 00:00:9 M N wv 00:00:17 N M wv 00:00:£ M N wv 00:00:2 M N wv 00:00:17 ° y wvoo:oo:zl ° y N Of O N O N O N O N O N Of a0 a0 I, n f0 f0 N N � (ad© OZ IOJ `v8p) lanai aanssaad punog Appendix D Tabular Data Record eNGLoBe Table D-1 Noise Level and Weather Data Measured for Sensor A Sensor Type Serial No. MMIDD/YYYY HH:MM L.. (dBA) (IA) 11-hourAverageAlr Temperature CC) 1 -hour Average Wind i -hour Speed (km/h) Precipitation Cumulative Comments (mm) S50 14603 5/3/20240:00 9.9 4 0 S50 14603 5/3/20241:00 81.50 51.80 7.8 5 0 S50 14603 5/3/20242:00 61.70 47.30 8.3 8 0 S50 14603 5/3/20243:00 62.00 45.00 9.3 13 0 S50 14603 5/3/20244:00 65.10 46.30 8.9 8 0 S50 14603 5/3/20245:00 74.20 52.30 8.6 5 0 S50 14603 5/3/20246:00 71.40 53.10 10.2 4 0 S50 14603 5/3/20247:00 73.60 57.001 12.4 4 0 S50 14603 5/3/20248:00 85.20 66.20 12.5 17 0 Offloading Noise (1 Sec) S50 14603 5/3/20249:00 80.70 63.30 13.9 9 0.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/3/202410:00 88.40 64.70 12.9 9 1.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/3/202411:00 85.80 65.07 13.1 17 1.5 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/3/202412:00 81.20 62.24 12.5 4 2.5 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/3/202413:00 73.20 61.77 13.1 17 1 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/3/202414:00 77.60 61.60 14.6 17 0 S50 14603 5/3/202415:00 95.40 65.251 14 9 0.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/3/202416:00 72.40 58.44 13.1 13 0.8 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/3/202417:00 80.40 60.24 12.6 11 0 S50 14603 5/3/202418:00 75.20 59.55 12.8 0 0.5 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/3/202419:00 69.40 57.69 12.4 8 0 S50 14603 5/3/202420:00 69.00 56.78 12.4 5 0.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/3/202421:00 65.40 54.04 12.2 4 0 S50 14603 5/3/202422:00 68.90 52.99 12 0 0 S50 S50 1 14603 14603 5/3/202423:00 5/4/20240:00 77.301 73.00 54.641 51.60 11.2 10.6 8 5 0 0 S50 14603 5/4/20241:00 64.30 49.06 10.8 11 0 S50 14603 5/4/20242:00 63.10 46.75 11.7 8 0 S50 14603 5/4/20243:00 62.80 46.65 10.4 5 0 S50 14603 5/4/20244:00 59.20 45.12 10.2 9 0 S50 14603 5/4/20245:00 58.10 45.44 11.6 8 0 S50 14603 5/4/20246:00 61.90 47.171 11.8 8 0 S50 14603 5/4/20247:00 64.70 51.17 13.3 13 0 S50 14603 5/4/20248:00 69.20 51.62 15.4 17 0 S50 14603 5/4/20249:00 66.40 53.02 17.6 17 0 S50 14603 5/4/202410:00 65.30 54.71 18.9 21 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/4/202411:00 73.90 55.33 19.5 21 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/4/202412:00 78.20 56.49 21.2 22 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/4/202413:00 83.00 58.25 20.6 21 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/4/202414:00 77.40 57.621 19.3 21 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/4/202415:00 84.00 57.77 20.6 21 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/4/202416:00 76.20 56.00 20.4 21 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/4/202417:00 70.40 55.43 20.1 17 0 S50 14603 5/4/202418:00 86.30 59.30 18 18 0 Noise from a Pedestrian vehicle S50 14603 5/4/2024 19:001 69.60 55.46 17 24 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/4/2024 20:001 75.70 55.45 15.7 17 0 S50 14603 5/4/202421:00 73.50 54.66 14.5 15 0 S50 14603 5/4/202422:00 79.30 54.591 14 17 0 S50 14603 5/4/2024 23:001 65.70 51.21 13.11 15 0 Sunday, May 5, 2024 S50 14603 5/5/20240:00 67.30 53.30 13.2 15 0 S50 14603 5/5/20241:00 85.90 55.29 12.9 15 0 Noise from a Pedestrian vehicle S50 14603 5/5/20242:00 61.40 48.43 12.1 13 0.5 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/5/20243:00 62.60 49.09 11.5 13 0 S50 14603 5/5/20244:00 62.40 46.86 11.4 11 0 S50 14603 5/5/20245:00 69.60 48.25 11.4 13 0 S50 14603 5/5/20246:00 64.10 47.12 11.4 9 0 S50 14603 5/5/20247:00 73.60 55.53 11.7 9 0 S50 14603 5/5/20248:00 88.70 59.12 12.3 11 0.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/5/20249:00 68.70 53.021 13.2 8 0 S50 14603 5/5/202410:00 66.90 53.74 14.1 15 0 S50 14603 5/5/202411:00 71.10 54.64 15.9 11 0 S50 14603 5/5/202412:00 67.30 54.38 17.3 13 0 S50 14603 5/5/202413:00 71.20 55.15 18.2 13 0 S50 14603 5/5/202414:00 74.60 54.85 17.6 22 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/5/202415:00 70.10 54.58 17.2 15 0 S50 14603 5/5/202416:00 67.70 55.04 15.5 15 0 S50 14603 5/5/202417:00 68.90 56.921 15.6 11 0 S50 14603 5/5/202418:00 78.90 55.17 16.2 13 0 S50 14603 5/5/202419:00 74.00 54.00 14.6 11 0 S50 14603 5/5/202420:00 78.40 55.77 12.4 9 0 S50 14603 5/5/202421:00 69.10 52.93 11 11 0 S50 14603 5/5/202422:00 74.00 53.52 9.7 9 0 S50 14603 5/5/202423:00 75.80 51.47 9.5 8 0 Page 94 of 180 eNGLoee Table D-1 Noise Level and Weather Data Measured for Sensor A Sonso, Serial No. MMIDD/YYYY L.. (dBA) 11-hourAverageAlr Type HH:MM (IA) Temperature CC) S50 14603 5/6/20240:00 70.40 52.30 7.2 1 -hour Average Wind Speed (km/h) 9 i -hour Cumulative Precipitation (mm) 0 Comments S50 14603 5/6/20241:00 60.70 49.18 7.2 9 0 S50 14603 5/6/20242:00 57.80 46.11 7.2 11 0 S50 14603 5/6/20243:00 74.90 50.01 7.2 8 0 S50 14603 5/6/20244:00 58.80 45.97 6.5 9 0 S50 14603 5/6/20245:00 60.40 48.76 6.3 5 0 S50 14603 5/6/20246:00 71.70 54.12 6.2 4 0 S50 14603 5/6/20247:00 79.80 60.851 9.3 11 0 S50 14603 5/6/20248:00 80.30 63.98 11 8 0 S50 14603 5/6/20249:00 81.70 63.64 12.6 9 0 S50 14603 5/6/202410:00 81.70 68.79 14.5 4 0 S50 14603 5/6/202411:00 86.40 68.52 16 17 0 Cutting noise - Quick Cut: rebar/concrete(0.5 sec) S50 14603 5/6/202412:00 81.00 63.91 17.1 11 0 S50 14603 5/6/202413:00 81.30 63.74 17.6 9 0 Hammering noise- Concrete Chipping (0.5 Sec) S50 14603 5/6/202414:00 84.20 64.24 18.3 8 0 S50 14603 5/6/202415:00 88.40 64.011 18.4 11 0 S50 14603 5/6/202416:00 75.60 60.29 18.1 9 0 S50 14603 5/6/202417:00 81.80 57.91 17.9 9 0 S50 14603 5/6/202418:00 78.30 57.50 17.6 13 0 S50 14603 5/6/202419:00 82.80 58.44 16.2 9 0 S50 14603 5/6/202420:00 85.60 60.65 12.5 5 0 Noise from a Pedestrian vehicle S50 14603 5/6/202421:00 66.30 53.45 9.7 0 0 S50 14603 5/6/202422:00 80.70 54.15 7.9 5 0 S50 Tuesday, May S50 1 14603 5/6/2024 23:001 71.60 52.1516.2 7, 2024 14603 5/7/20240:00 73.40 50.16 5.1 5 0 0 0 S50 14603 5/7/2024100 69.60 50.92 5.3 0 0 S50 14603 5/7/20242:00 66.20 45.91 4.6 5 0 S50 14603 5/7/20243:00 63.80 45.64 3.4 4 0 S50 14603 5/7/20244:00 61.30 45.53 4 8 0 S50 14603 5/7/20245:00 74.80 51.41 3.1 8 0 S50 14603 5/7/20246:00 74.60 54.301 3.4 5 0 S50 14603 5/7/20247:00 70.90 58.61 9.1 0 0 S50 14603 5/7/20248:00 80.30 64.03 13.1 9 0 S50 14603 5/7/20249:00 85.40 66.22 16.5 17 0 Grinding noise S50 14603 5/7/202410:00 86.70 61.44 18.2 13 0 Unloadingn Oise (1 Sec) S50 14603 5/7/20241100 86.40 64.01 19 11 0 1 Unloading noises (2 Sec) S50 14603 5/7/202412:00 79.30 64.42 19.6 21 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/7/202413:00 81.70 64.37 20.5 22 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/7/202414:00 83.80 65.931 20.2 18 0 S50 14603 5/7/202415:00 83.50 67.04 20.3 21 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/7/202416:00 86.50 63.62 19.7 21 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/7/202417:00 79.80 60.40 18.5 13 0 S50 14603 5/7/202418:00 75.40 57.59 17.3 15 0 S50 14603 5/7/2024 19:001 79.10 57.80 16 13 0 S50 14603 5/7/2024 20:001 78.40 56.35 15.1 15 0 S50 14603 5/7/202421:00 85.70 58.71 11.6 15 4.1 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/7/202422:00 81.50 57.63 10.4 9 12.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/7/202423:00 71.80 55.39 9.919 3.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) Wednesday, May 8, 2024 S50 14603 5/8/20240:00 73.90 55.73 9.8 21 7.3 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/8/20241:00 73.50 58.27 9.6 11 0.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/8/20242:00 64.00 48.84 10.4 9 0 S50 14603 5/8/20243:00 64.70 46.45 10.6 4 0 S50 14603 5/8/20244:00 77.20 50.50 10.9 5 0 S50 14603 5/8/20245:00 64.90 47.17 11.3 8 0 S50 14603 5/8/20246:00 63.70 53.32 11.4 9 0 S50 14603 5/8/20247:00 75.90 61.121 14.7 24 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/8/20248:00 82.80 64.89 16.5 30 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/8/20249:00 96.00 70.34 17.3 46 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/8/202410:00 81.40 63.62 18.3 43 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/8/202411:00 89.40 70.28 18.9 43 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/8/202412:00 89.60 68.25 19.1 43 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/8/202413:00 82.20 63.18 15.7 37 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/8/202414:00 88.80 71.80 15.6 35 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/8/202415:00 87.40 67.471 15.2 37 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/8/202416:00 80.40 63.98 15.1 41 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/8/202417:00 78.60 62.65 13.5 32 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/8/202418:00 76.60 61.12 13.1 24 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/8/202419:00 73.80 60.62 11.6 22 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/8/202420:00 78.70 57.50 13 0 S50 14603 5/8/202421:00 70.10 0.00 9 0 S50 14603 5/8/202422:00 75.70 53.48 4 0 S50 14603 5/8/202423:00 76.80155.27P4 9 0 Page 95 of 180 eNGLoBe Table D-1 Noise Level and Weather Data Measured for Sensor A Sonso, Type S50 Serial No. May 9, 2024 14603 MMIDD/YYYY HH:MM 5/9/20240:00 L.. (dBA) 71.30 11-hourAverageAlr (IA) Temperature 52.52 CC) 6.9 1 -hour Average Wind Speed (km/h) 0 i -hour Cumulative Precipitation (mm) 0 Comments S50 14603 5/9/20241:00 64.70 48.08 5.9 4 0 S50 14603 5/9/20242:00 64.40 46.59 6.8 9 0 S50 14603 5/9/20243:00 60.20 45.77 6.8 11 0 S50 14603 5/9/20244:00 81.50 51.89 6 4 0 S50 14603 5/9/20245:00 62.40 46.16 5.2 4 0 S50 1 14603 5/9/20246:00 63.60 52.93 6.7 4 0 S50 14603 5/9/20247:00 70.00 64.09 9.5 9 0 S50 14603 5/9/20248:00 79.30 66.05 11.9 11 0 S50 14603 5/9/20249:00 84.60 66.77 13.6 17 0 S50 14603 5/9/202410:00 84.30 66.49 15.1 22 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/9/202411:00 84.80 68.41 15.4 13 0 S50 14603 5/9/202412:00 88.90 67.93 16.3 22 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/9/202413:00 79.80 65.91 15.6 11 0 S50 14603 5/9/202414:00 86.50 68.331 15.3 11 0 1 Offloading Noise (0.5 See) S50 14603 5/9/202415:00 79.80 67.44 14.2 13 0 S50 14603 5/9/202416:00 80.00 65.19 13.8 13 0 S50 14603 5/9/202417:00 77.00 64.28 13.3 13 0 S50 14603 5/9/202418:00 78.30 64.39 12.1 9 0 S50 14603 5/9/2024 19:001 80.90 64.78 11 5 0 S50 14603 5/9/2024 20:001 75.80 64.18 11.1 5 0 S50 14603 5/9/202421:00 68.70 63.66 10.7 5 0 S50 14603 5/9/202422:00 72.90 63.491 9.1 5 0 S50 1 14603 5/9/2024 23:001 70.60 63.43 9.2 4 0 S50 May 9 0, 2024 14603 5/10/20240:00 74.30 63.44 9.6 8 0 S50 14603 5/10/20241:00 76.50 63.35 8.9 8 0 S50 14603 5/10/20242:00 66.40 63.03 8.7 11 0 S50 14603 5/10/20243:00 69.40 63.03 8.1 5 0 S50 14603 5/10/20244:00 80.70 63.28 5.6 5 0 S50 14603 5/10/20245:00 65.00 63.20 4.4 4 0 S50 14603 5/10/20246:00 68.40 63.60 7.4 4 0 S50 14603 5/10/20247:00 74.00 65.031 9.1 8 0 S50 14603 5/10/20248:00 86.70 66.17 10 5 0 Ha mmering Noise (0.5 See) S50 14603 5/10/20249:00 81.40 66.76 11.3 4 0 S50 14603 5/10/202410:00 88.90 66.56 12.5 11 0 Ha mmering Noise (0.5 See) S50 14603 5/10/20241100 85.00 69.35 13.7 13 0 Ha mmering Noise (0.5 See) S50 14603 5/10/202412:00 83.00 66.74 15.4 4 0 S50 14603 5/10/202413:00 82.00 64.32 14.3 9 0 S50 14603 5/10/202414:00 82.40 66.53 14.3 11 0 S50 14603 5/10/202415:00 81.00 65.731 15.3 9 0 S50 14603 5/10/202416:00 74.50 59.48 13.5 24 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/10/202417:00 80.50 58.57 14.9 11 0 S50 14603 5/10/202418:00 72.60 57.41 14.2 9 0 S50 14603 5/10/202419:00 72.70 58.61 13 9 0 S50 14603 5/10/202420:00 73.40 56.68 10.3 9 0 S50 14603 5/10/202421:00 72.90 53.35 10.8 9 0 S50 14603 5/10/202422:00 66.90 52.46 11 8 0 S50 1 14603 5/10/202423:00 83.80 55.171 8.6 4 0 11priday, S50 May 99,'•- 14603 5/11/20240:00 66.40 53.69 7 5 0 S50 14603 5/11/20241:00 63.60 52.47 6.8 0 0 S50 14603 5/11/20242:00 82.00 52.52 3.5 0 0 S50 14603 5/11/20243:00 69.70 49.44 4 4 0 S50 14603 5/11/20244:00 62.80 51.97 3.6 5 0 S50 14603 5/11/20245:00 73.10 50.87 4.3 8 0 S50 14603 5/11/20246:00 64.00 47.49 6.4 8 0 S50 14603 5/11/20247:00 66.10 51.64 9.9 11 0 S50 14603 5/11/20248:00 67.40 53.13 12.3 17 0 S50 14603 5/11/20249:00 71.60 54.74 12.2 18 0 S50 14603 5/11/202410:00 72.50 57.57 12.4 26 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/11/202411:00 70.70 57.24 11.7 22 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/11/202412:00 78.20 58.90 12.2 28 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/11/202413:00 67.80 57.91 10.6 28 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/11/202414:00 75.70 57.90 10.7 21 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/11/202415:00 73.00 56.66 12 18 0 S50 14603 5/11/202416:00 72.30 56.41 11.2 11 0 S50 14603 5/11/202417:00 74.20 57.461 10.6 15 0 S50 14603 5/11/202418:00 75.20 57.81 10.6 15 0 S50 14603 5/11/202419:00 79.60 56.90 "9.8 4 2.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/11/202420:00 71.10 54.55 9.5 81 0.8 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/11/202421:00 77.80 54.11 9.3 15 2.3 Adverse Weather (Dat a not valid) S50 14603 5/11/202422:00 68.40 52.60 8.8 13 3.8 Adverse Weather(Data not valid) S50 14603 5/11/202423:00 72.40 52.06 8.9 131 0 Page 96 of 180 eNGLoee Table D-1 Noise Level and Weather Data Measured for Sensor A Sonso, Serial No. Type Un�iyy�Asy�3;-iO3$ MMIDD/YYYY HH:MM L.. (dBA) (IA) 11-hourAverageAlr Temperature CC) 1 -hour Average Wind Speed (km/h) i -hour Cumulative Comments Precipitation (mm) S50 14603 5/12/20240:00 68.70 53.92 9 9 0.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/12/20241:00 65.80 50.95 9 9 0 S50 14603 5/12/20242:00 60.30 48.10 8.8 13 0 S50 14603 5/12/20243:00 61.20 46.48 8.5 9 0 S50 14603 5/12/20244:00 60.90 45.63 7.8 5 0 S50 14603 5/12/20245:00 56.40 44.55 7.8 13 0 S50 14603 5/12/20246:00 63.40 45.431 7.9 11 0 S50 14603 5/12/20247:00 68.70 49.80 9.7 13 0 S50 14603 5/12/20248:00 66.50 49.95 10.7 18 0 S50 14603 5/12/20249:00 63.30 51.08 10.8 21 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/12/202410:00 75.20 54.39 12 15 0 S50 14603 5/12/202411:00 74.50 54.90 13.9 13 0 S50 14603 5/12/202412:00 69.60 55.24 14.1 11 0 S50 14603 5/12/202413:00 65.70 55.73 15.5 17 0 S50 14603 5/12/202414:00 79.40 56.341 16.3 8 0 S50 14603 5/12/202415:00 69.50 54.62 16.3 9 0 S50 14603 5/12/202416:00 71.70 58.82 16.6 17 0 S50 14603 5/12/202417:00 82.90 56.24 17.1 18 0 S50 14603 5/12/202418:00 75.50 56.03 16 18 0 S50 14603 5/12/202419:00 79.20 55.76 15 15 0 S50 14603 5/12/202420:00 75.20 53.87 13.9 18 0 S50 14603 5/12/202421:00 75.40 54.76 12.5 17 0 S50 1 14603 5/12/202422:00 72.20 52.931 11.2 15 0 S50 14603 5/12/202423:00 67.60 51.83 9.8 11 0 S50 May13, 2024 14603 5/13/20240:00 76.20 55.50 9.4 13 0 S50 14603 5/13/2024100 67.20 49.33 9.3 13 0 S50 14603 5/13/20242:00 61.70 46.96 9.5 11 0 S50 14603 5/13/20243:00 70.70 47.61 9.6 13 0.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/13/20244:00 74.60 52.49 9.6 11 0 S50 14603 5/13/20245:00 70.60 49.78 10.4 18 0 S50 14603 5/13/20246:00 66.80 53.23 10.8 11 0 S50 14603 5/13/20247:00 76.50 60.251 11.6 0 0 S50 14603 5/13/20248:00 84.40 68.79 14.3 17 0 S50 14603 5/13/20249:00 82.60 66.67 18 18 0 S50 14603 5/13/202410:00 85.40 65.29 15.6 13 0.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/13/20241100 78.70 65.88 17.8 17 0 S50 14603 5/13/202412:00 82.10 66.87 19.9 15 0 S50 14603 5/13/202413:00 76.00 64.51 21.3 17 0 S50 14603 5/13/202414:00 77.80 67.60 21.8 26 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/13/202415:00 83.10 68.351 23 17 0 S50 14603 5/13/202416:00 84.20 65.48 24.4 30 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/13/202417:00 78.30 58.89 23.3 34 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/13/202418:00 74.00 58.93 23 32 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/13/202419:00 73.50 61.06 21.8 22 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/13/202420:00 79.10 59.66 17.6 8 0 S50 14603 5/13/202421:00 68.10 53.65 15.8 0 0 S50 14603 5/13/202422:00 71.40 52.34 13.5 8 0 S50 14603 5/13/202423:00 77.101 52.471 13.41 5 0 S50 14603 5/14/20240:00 76.70 51.62 13.8 0 0 S50 14603 5/14/20241:00 66.20 49.24 13 4 0 S50 14603 5/14/20242:00 57.90 44.88 12.6 4 0 S50 14603 5/14/20243:00 74.80 48.67 12.8 4 0 S50 14603 5/14/20244:00 56.30 43.97 12.9 4 0 S50 14603 5/14/20245:00 59.30 45.78 13.3 0 0 S50 14603 5/14/20246:00 75.20 52.99 13.8 9 0 S50 14603 5/14/20247:00 73.50 56.77 14.8 5 0 S50 1 14603 5/14/20248:00 81.60 66.521 15.8 8 0 S50 14603 5/14/20249:00 81.70 67.46 16.6 8 0 S50 14603 5/14/202410:00 85.50 67.87 17.9 5 0 Hammering Noise(1 Sec) S50 14603 5/14/202411:00 89.80 69.11 18.3 13 0 Concrete truck noise (5 Sec) S50 14603 5/14/202412:00 86.70 68.74 19.6 15 0 Grinding Noise(4Sec) S50 14603 5/14/202413:00 79.20 65.62 19.4 13 0 S50 14603 5/14/202414:00 89.40 67.28 20.3 15 0 Offloading Noise(1 Sec) S50 14603 5/14/202415:00 90.30 69.39 20 18 0 Hammering Noise(2 Sec) S50 14603 5/14/202416:00 78.601 65.801 20.2 15 0 S50 14603 5/14/202417:00 73.60 64.341 20 15 0 S50 14603 5/14/202418:00 73.80 64.13 18.5 13 0 S50 14603 5/14/202419:00 70.00 64.37 18 15 0 S50 14603 5/14/202420:00 70.80 64.08 15.8 13 0 S50 14603 5/14/202421:00 79.90 64.25 14 8 0 S50 14603 5/14/202422:00 74.00 63.86 12.7 5 0 S50 14603 5/14/202423:00 81.10 63.97 11.9 8 0 Page 97 of 180 eNGLoBe Table D-1 Noise Level and Weather Data Measured for Sensor A Sonso, Type S50 Serial No. sday, May 95; 14603 MMIDD/YYYY HH:MM 5/15/20240:00 L.. (dBA) 82.50 (IA) 63.94 11-hourAverageAlr 1 -hour Average Wind Temperature CC) Speed (km/h) 11.2 9 i -hour Cumulative Precipitation (mm) 0 Comments S50 14603 5/15/20241:00 69.80 63.65 11 5 0 S50 14603 5/15/20242:00 77.60 63.74 10.7 5 0 S50 14603 5/15/20243:00 79.10 63.67 9.7 4 0 S50 14603 5/15/20244:00 65.00 63.48 9.4 4 0 S50 14603 5/15/20245:00 70.40 63.53 10.6 5 0 S50 1 14603 5/15/20246:00 74.80 63.701 11.2 4 0 S50 14603 5/15/20247:00 76.90 64.84 13.4 11 0 S50 14603 5/15/20248:00 83.10 66.66 14.6 11 0 S50 14603 5/15/20249:00 84.20 69.19 15.8 15 0 S50 14603 5/15/202410:00 85.00 66.45 17.1 15 0 S50 14603 5/15/202411:00 84.10 67.43 17.6 17 0 S50 14603 5/15/202412:00 77.90 66.13 19 18 0 S50 14603 5/15/202413:00 80.80 66.08 19 15 0 S50 14603 5/15/202414:00 77.10 65.771 20 15 0 S50 14603 5/15/202415:00 86.30 70.24 21.2 15 0 Equipment noise (4 Sec) S50 14603 5/15/202416:00 82.20 65.08 20.1 17 0 S50 14603 5/15/202417:00 74.40 64.17 20.2 18 0 S50 14603 5/15/202418:00 7200. 64.30 19.4 21 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/15/202419:00 75.40 64.66 17.8 13 0 S50 14603 5/15/202420:00 78.70 64.33 15.4 8 0 S50 14603 5/15/202421:00 71.50 63.99 14.4 0 0 S50 1 14603 5/15/202422:00 67.90 63.79 12.4 4 0 S50 14603 5/15/202423:00 70.80 63.82 12.6 8 0 S50 May 16, 20Y 14603 5/16/20240:00 71.10 63.68 11.6 8 0 S50 14603 5/16/2024100 72.50 63.72 10 4 0 S50 14603 5/16/20242:00 67.60 63.43 10.3 4 0 S50 14603 5/16/20243:00 65.00 63.41 9.5 5 0 S50 14603 5/16/20244:00 69.80 63.44 8 4 0 S50 14603 5/16/20245:00 76.20 63.48 8 4 0 S50 14603 5/16/20246:00 80.10 63.941 9.3 5 0 S50 14603 5/16/20247:00 82.50 64.97 13 5 0 S50 14603 5/16/20248:00 77.20 63.61 16.5 13 0 S50 14603 5/16/20249:00 84.10 65.12 18.1 4 0 S50 14603 5/16/202410:00 77.70 63.84 19.5 8 0 S50 14603 5/16/20241100 77.60 64.06 20.4 4 0 S50 14603 5/16/202412:00 81.10 65.40 20.3 8 0 S50 14603 5/16/202413:00 81.00 63.03 21.1 4 0 S50 14603 5/16/202414:00 86.30 64.811 23 9 0 Unloading Noise (2 Sec) S50 14603 5/16/202415:00 81.50 61.53 22.9 9 0 S50 14603 5/16/202416:00 82.30 60.52 22.7 24 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/16/202417:00 77.20 59.09 21.7 15 0 S50 14603 5/16/202418:00 73.50 57.94 20.6 18 0 S50 14603 5/16/202419:00 82.80 59.55 17.9 13 0 S50 14603 5/16/202420:00 79.00 58.27 17 13 0 S50 14603 5/16/202421:00 79.00 55.54 16.1 8 0 S50 14603 5/16/202422:00 83.10 55.791 14.3 5 0 S50 14603 5/16/202423:00 70.20 53.29 13.1 5 0 S50 ',, May 17, 2024 14603 5/17/20240:00 70.40 53.15 12.9 9 0 S50 14603 5/17/20241:00 60.10 47.40 13.4 4 0 S50 14603 5/17/20242:00 68.20 47.59 12.2 0 0 S50 14603 5/17/20243:00 59.90 45.34 11.2 5 0 S50 14603 5/17/20244:00 61.80 45.10 11.3 4 0 S50 14603 5/17/20245:00 79.40 50.17 11.4 0 0 S50 14603 5/17/20246:00 72.30 52.63 12.7 0 0 S50 14603 5/17/20247:00 74.10 58.38 14.4 5 0 S50 14603 5/17/20248:00 81.20 64.651 15.1 5 0 S50 14603 5/17/20249:00 89.80 64.79 15.8 8 0 Combination of unloading and Air Horn noise (4 Sec) S50 14603 5/17/202410:00 75.80 59.73 16.1 4 0 S50 14603 5/17/202411:00 87.40 65.31 16 11 0.8 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) SIMON S50 14603 5/17/202412:00 80.50 65.20 15.9 8 1.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/17/202413:00 77.10 60.64 15.9 8 1.5 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/17/202414:00 77.70 61.79 16 22 1 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/17/202415:00 86.90 61.12 17.1 4 0.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 14603 5/17/202416:00 78.90 58.781 18.4 ill 0 S50 14603 5/17/202417:00 69.60 57.201 17.9 11 0 S50 14603 5/17/202418:00 68.70 55.97 17.5 15 0 S50 14603 5/17/2024 19:001 72.90 57.92 16.3 15 0 S50 14603 5/17/2024 20:001 69.80 56.56 15.3 13 0 S50 14603 5/17/2024 21:001 73.30 53.78 15.2 11 0 S50 14603 5/17/202422:00 71.40 53.36 14.8 9 0 S50 14603 5/17/202423:00 73.50 52.36 13.6 11 0 S50 14603 5/17/202423:59 67.10 50.90 14.2 9 0 Page 98 of 180 eNGLoBe Table D-2 Noise Level and Weather Data Measured for Sensor B ...... We S50 ..Ii.1 No. S, 2024 13846 .[W)DD/YYYY I-_ 5/3/20240:00 (dBA) ( L, 1-h ... dBA) Temperature Average Air 1 -hour Average (*C) Wind Speed (km/h) 9.9 4 u mulative Comments Pr cipitation 0 S50 13846 5/3/20241:00 71.80 49.40 7.8 5 0 S50 13846 5/3/20242:00 62.10 47.90 8.3 8 0 S50 13846 5/3/20243:00 58.70 47.50 9.3 13 0 S50 13846 5/3/20244:00 55.10 47.60 8.9 8 0 S50 13846 5/3/20245:00 60.80 48.10 8.6 5 0 S50 13846 5/3/20246:00 85.00 61.001 10.2 4 0 S50 13846 5/3/20247:00 81.10 63.30 12.4 4 0 S50 13846 5/3/20248:00 92.60 71.20 12.5 17 0 Top layer install or rebar install on L4 P#1 S50 13846 5/3/20249:00 91.60 72.40 13.9 9 0.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/3/202410:00 90.00 71.10 12.9 9 1.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/3/202411:00 92.60 74.33 13.1 17 1.5 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/3/202412:00 84.80 69.00 12.5 4 2.5 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/3/202413:00 87.60 66.66 13.1 17 1 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/3/202414:00 82.80 63.971 14.6 17 0 S50 13846 5/3/202415:00 85.00 65.82 14 9 0.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/3/202416:00 77.70 61.51 13.1 13 0.8 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/3/202417:00 73.10 56.12 12.6 11 0 S50 13846 5/3/202418:00 69.00 54.93 12.8 0 0.5 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/3/202419:00 62.00 53.73 12.4 8 0 S50 13846 5/3/202420:00 72.60 58.58 12.4 5 0.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/3/202421:00 67.10 51.80 12.2 40 S50 13846 5/3/202422:00 76.90 51.84 12 0 0 S50 13846 5/3/202423:00 76.80 52.24 11.21 8 0 Saturday, May 4, 2024 S50 13846 5/4/20240:00 70.50 50.61 10.6 5 0 S50 13846 5/4/20241:00 61.40 49.34 10.8 11 0 S50 13846 5/4/20242:00 60.70 48.59 11.7 8 0 S50 13846 5/4/20243:00 62.00 47.98 10.4 5 0 S50 13846 5/4/20244:00 53.50 47.56 10.2 9 0 S50 13846 5/4/20245:00 53.10 47.75 11.6 8 0 S50 13846 5/4/20246:00 65.80 48.86 11.8 8 0 S50 13846 5/4/20247:00 60.80 50.19 13.3 13 0 S50 13846 5/4/20248:00 60.20 50.56 15.4 17 0 S50 13846 5/4/20249:00 62.70 51.59 17.6 17 0 S50 13846 5/4/202410:00 65.10 51.70 18.9 21 0 Adverse Weather (Data not va lid) S50 13846 5/4/202411:00 68.50 51.90 19.5 21 0 Adverse Weather (Data not va lid) S50 13846 5/4/202412:00 68.50 53.06 21.2 22 0 Adverse Weather (Data not va lid) S50 13846 5/4/202413:00 75.00 54.71 20.6 21 0 Adverse Weather (Data not va lid) S50 13846 5/4/202414:00 77.40 55.75 19.3 21 O 1 Adverse Weather (Data not va lid) S50 13846 5/4/202415:00 74.90 54.46 20.6 21 0 Adverse Weather (Data not va lid) S50 13846 5/4/202416:00 74.70 54.69 20.4 21 0 Adverse Weather (Data not va lid) S50 13846 5/4/202417:00 66.50 51.94 20.1 17 0 S50 13846 5/4/202418:00 75.80 52.26 18 18 0 S50 13846 5/4/202419:00 70.70 52.95 17 24 0 Adverse Weather (Data not va lid) S50 13846 5/4/202420:00 81.30 54.71 15.7 17 0 S50 13846 5/4/202421:00 63.40 51.25 14.5 15 0 S50 13846 5/4/202422:00 75.50 51.99 14 171 0 S50 1 13846 5/4/2024 23:001 76.401 51.221 13.1 15 0 Sunday, May 5, 2024 S50 13846 5/5/20240:00 72.90 50.60 13.2 15 0 S50 13846 5/5/20241:00 72.10 49.66 12.9 15 0 S50 13846 5/5/20242:00 58.00 48.06 12.1 13 0.5 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/5/20243:00 60.20 48.76 11.5 13 0 S50 13846 5/5/20244:00 52.50 47.53 11.4 11 0 S50 13846 5/5/20245:00 56.30 48.18 11.4 13 0 S50 13846 5/5/20246:00 52.50 47.56 11.4 9 0 S50 13846 5/5/20247:00 72.30 54.811 11.7 9 0 S50 13846 5/5/20248:00 81.20 53.73 12.3 11 0.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/5/20249:00 73.50 50.46 13.2 8 0 S50 13846 5/5/202410:00 63.90 50.38 14.1 15 0 S50 13846 5/5/202411:00 74.40 54.56 15.9 11 0 S50 13846 5/5/202412:00 64.30 50.42 17.3 13 0 S50 13846 5/5/202413:00 62.90 53.21 18.2 13 0 S50 13848 5/5/202414:00 57.50 50.11 17.6 22 0 Adverse Weather(Data notvalid) S50 13846 5/5/202415:00 63.60 51.091 17.2 15 0 S50 13846 5/5/202416:00 66.00 52.36 15.5 15 0 S50 13846 5/5/202417:00 62.90 50.61 15.6 11 0 S50 13846 5/5/202418:00 67.50 50.08 16.2 13 0 S50 13846 5/5/202419:00 66.10 50.22 14.6 11 0 S50 13846 5/5/202420:00 66.20 50.74 12.4 9 0 S50 13846 5/5/202421:00 65.20 49.34 11 11 0 S50 13846 5/5/202422:00 76.40 50.911 9.71 9 0 S50 13846 5/5/202423:00 76.50 50.29 9.5 8 0 Page 99 of 180 eNGLose Table D-2 Noise Level and Weather Data Measured for Sensor B ...... We ..n.1 No. .[W)DD/YYYY I-_ HH:MIVI (dBA) L, 1-h ... dBA) Temperature Average Air (*C) 1 -hour Average Wind Speed (km/h) u mulative Pr cipitation (mm) Comments S50 13846 5/6/20240:00 71.70 52.77 7.2 9 0 S50 13846 5/6/20241:00 58.80 49.48 7.2 9 0 S50 13846 5/6/20242:00 59.60 47.51 7.2 11 0 S50 13846 5/6/20243:00 58.60 47.40 7.2 8 0 S50 13846 5/6/20244:00 51.30 46.86 6.5 9 0 S50 13846 5/6/20245:00 65.10 57.04 6.3 5 0 S50 1 13846 5/6/20246:00 64.30 61.47 6.2 4 0 S50 13846 5/6/20247:00 77.101 64.26 9.3 11 0 S50 13846 5/6/20248:00 89.40 73.13 11 8 0 Hammering Noise -Concrete Chipping S50 13846 5/6/20249:00 87.70 72.79 12.6 9 0 Hammering Noise -Concrete Chipping S50 13846 5/6/202410:00 89.50 72.77 14.5 4 0 Hammering Noise -Concrete Chipping S50 13846 5/6/202411:00 98.20 79.72 16 17 0 Combination of hammering and grinding noise -Concrete Chipping S50 13846 5/6/202412:00 88.30 73.79 17.1 11 0 Hammering Noise -Concrete Chipping S50 13846 5/6/202413:00 86.40 71.73 17.6 9 0 Combination of hammering and grinding noise -Concrete Chipping S50 13846 5/6/202414:00 89.30 72.40 18.3 8 0 Hammering Noise -Concrete Chipping S50 13846 5/6/202415:00 88.00 72.50 18.4 11 0 Combination of hammering and grinding noise -Concrete Chipping S50 13846 5/6/202416:00 89.10 68.26 18.1 9 0 Hammering Noise -Concrete Chipping S50 13846 5/6/202417:00 81.50 54.86 17.9 9 0 S50 13846 5/6/202418:00 70.20 51.761 17.6 13 0 S50 13846 5/6/202419:00 74.40 59.57 16.2 9 0 S50 13846 5/6/202420:00 80.70 59.38 12.5 5 0 S50 13846 5/6/202421:00 76.10 55.17 9.7 0 0 S50 13846 5/6/202422:00 76.40 51.51 7.9 5 0 S50 13846 5/6/202423:00 76.60 50.32 6.2 5 0 ..,Ma 7,.2024 S50 13846 5/7/20240:00 63.80 47.89 5.1 0 0 S50 13846 5/7/20241:00 70.40 52.59 5.3 0 0 S50 13846 5/7/20242:00 53.40 46.62 4.6 5 0 S50 13846 5/7/20243:00 58.00 46.72 3.4 4 0 S50 13846 5/7/20244:00 51.50 47.21 4 8 0 S50 13846 5/7/20245:00 73.50 55.52 3.1 8 0 S50 13846 5/7/20246:00 93.80 67.89 3.4 5 0 Noisefrom site security speaker S50 13846 5/7/20247:00 88.00 68.041 9.1 0 0 Hammering Noise -Concrete Chipping S50 13846 5/7/20248:00 86.30 69.74 13.1 9 0 Hammering Noise(1Sec) S50 13846 5/7/20249:00 96.20 74.48 16.5 17 0 Grinding Noise S50 13846 5/7/202410:00 89.70 65.68 18.2 13 0 Grinding Noise (1 Sec) S50 13846 5/7/202411:00 90.90 72.72 19 11 0 Hammering Noise S50 13846 5/7/202412:00 90.00 73.60 19.6 21 0 Adverse Weather (Data notvalid) S50 13846 5/7/202413:00 88.70 73.56 20.5 22 0 Adverse Weather(Data notvalid) S50 13846 5/7/202414:00 92.40 74.34 20.2 18 0 Hammering Noise S50 13846 5/7/202415:00 91.60 74.051 20.3 21 0 Adverse Weather(Data notvalid) S50 13846 5/7/202416:00 87.40 67.97 19.7 21 0 Adverse Weather(Data notvalid) S50 13846 5/7/202417:00 75.00 62.19 18.5 13 0 S50 13846 5/7/202418:00 71.30 51.68 17.3 15 0 S50 13846 5/7/202419:00 82.40 59.71 16 13 0 S50 13846 5/7/202420:00 73.40 56.03 15.1 15 0 S50 13846 5/7/202421:00 77.10 52.15 11.6 15 4.1Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/7/202422:00 1 76.30 56.20 10.4 9 12.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/7/202423:00 94.00 67.06 9.9 91 3.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) W.dnastlay, May 8, 2024 S50 13846 5/8/20240:00 73.80 55.96 9.8 21 7.3 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/8/20241:00 74.20 59.70 9.6 11 0.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/8/20242:00 58.10 50.63 10.4 9 0 S50 13846 5/8/20243:00 58.30 48.51 10.6 4 0 S50 13846 5/8/20244:00 60.40 47.88 10.9 5 0 S50 13846 5/8/20245:00 69.20 52.40 11.3 8 0 S50 13846 5/8/20246:00 74.80 60.91 11.4 9 0 S50 13846 5/8/20247:00 79.70 65.85 14.7 24 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/8/20248:00 86.40 74.27 16.5 30 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/8/20249:00 92.80 76.68 17.3 46 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/8/202410:00 85.20 71.77 18.3 43 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/8/202411:00 94.00 75.98 18.9 43 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/8/202412:00 94.30 76.79 19.1 43 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/8/202413:00 84.40 72.51 15.7 37 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/8/202414:00 92.80 75.79 15.6 35 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/8/202415:00 89.20 72.57 15.2 37 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/8/202416:00 86.10 68.01 15.1 41 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/8/202417:00 80.80 60.12 13.5 32 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/8/202418:00 73.10 56.85 13.1 24 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/8/202419:00 80.00 58.86 11.6 22 OAdverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/8/2024 20:001 70.40 54.63 10.51 13 0 S50 13846 5/8/202421:00 61.70 50.32 10 9 0 S50 13846 5/8/202422:00 77.10 51.67 9.2 4 0 S50 13846 5/8/2024 23:001 77.101 54.481 7.51 9 0 Page 100 of 180 eNGLOBe Table D-2 Noise Level and Weather Data Measured for Sensor B ...... We Thum ..n.1 No. .[W)DD/YYYY HH:MIVI I-_ (dBA) ( L, 1-h ... dBA) Temperature Average Air (*C) 1 -hour Average Wind Speed (km/h) u mulative Comments Pr cipitation (mm) S50 13846 5/9/20240:00 71.40 53.55 6.9 0 0 S50 13846 5/9/20241:00 56.30 47.65 5.9 4 0 S50 13846 5/9/20242:00 54.00 47.02 6.8 9 0 S50 13846 5/9/20243:00 52.50 47.00 6.8 11 0 S50 13846 5/9/20244:00 62.20 47.28 6 4 0 S50 13846 5/9/20245:00 52.00 47.50 5.2 4 0 S50 13846 5/9/20246:00 73.70 60.301 6.7 4 0 S50 13846 5/9/20247:00 76.70 62.72 9.5 9 0 S50 13846 5/9/20248:00 88.00 69.78 11.9 11 0 S50 13846 5/9/20249:00 90.50 72.33 13.6 17 0 Hammering Noise(1Sec) S50 13846 5/9/202410:00 88.70 71.81 15.1 22 0 Adverse Weather (Data notvalid) S50 13846 5/9/202411:00 89.90 75.53 15.4 13 0 S50 13846 5/9/202412:00 94.30 74.96 16.3 22 0 Adverse Weather (Data notvalid) S50 13846 5/9/202413:00 86.30 69.86 15.6 11 0 S50 13846 5/9/202414:00 88.50 72.551 15.3 11 0 S50 13846 5/9/202415:00 87.10 69.61 14.2 13 0 S50 13846 5/9/202416:00 81.30 64.32 13.8 13 0 S50 13846 5/9/202417:00 65.00 52.57 13.3 13 0 S50 13846 5/9/202418:00 75.70 53.62 12.1 9 0 S50 13846 5/9/202419:00 75.00 59.72 11 5 0 S50 13846 5/9/202420:00 84.00 56.18 11.1 5 0 S50 13846 5/9/202421:00 62.80 50.52 10.7 5 0 S50 13846 5/9/202422:00 76.101 51.33 9.1 5 0 S50 1 13846 5/9/2024 23:001 76.101 51.661 9.2 4 0 May 10, 2024 S50 13846 5/10/20240:00 90.00 57.12 9.6 8 0 Noise from train horn (1 Sec) S50 13846 5/10/20241:00 67.20 48.65 8.9 8 0 S50 13846 5/10/20242:00 57.10 47.68 8.7 11 0 S50 13846 5/10/20243:00 57.70 47.34 8.1 5 0 S50 13846 5/10/20244:00 61.80 47.67 5.6 5 0 S50 13846 5/10/20245:00 61.20 49.09 4.4 4 0 S50 13846 5/10/20246:00 93.80 67.54 7.4 4 0 Noise from site secu rity speaker S50 13846 5/10/20247:00 79.80 64.321 9.1 8 0 S50 13846 5/10/20248:00 86.10 66.53 10 5 0 S50 13846 5/10/20249:00 89.50 68.72 11.3 4 0 S50 13846 5/10/202410:00 94.70 68.12 12.5 11 0 Ha m mering Noise (4 Secs) S50 13846 5/10/202411:00 88.90 72.52 13.7 13 0 S50 13846 5/10/202412:00 94.20 72.81 15.4 4 0 Ha m mering Noise (1 Sec) S50 13846 5/10/202413:00 91.00 73.52 14.3 9 0 Hammering Noise S50 13846 5/10/202414:00 92.80 77.89 14.3 11 0 Hammering Noise S50 13846 5/10/202415:00 92.70 73.09 15.3 9 0 Hammering Noise S50 13846 5/10/202416:00 81.40 60.09 13.5 24 O Adverse Weather (Data notvalid) S50 13846 5/10/202417:00 84.60 55.27 14.9 11 0 S50 13846 5/10/202418:00 74.10 54.57 14.2 9 0 S50 13846 5/10/202419:00 70.70 59.95 13 9 0 S50 13846 5/10/2024 20:001 72.50 56.23 10.3 9 0 S50 13846 5/10/202421:00 63.90 49.64 10.8 9 0 S50 13846 5/10/202422:00 1 76.00 50.58 ill 8 0 S50 1 13846 5/10/2024 23.001 76.10 53.20 8.61 4 0 Saturday, May 11, 2024 S50 13846 5/11/20240:00 66.00 53.64 7 5 0 S50 13846 5/11/20241:00 60.10 50.41 6.8 0 0 S50 13846 5/11/20242:00 82.80 52.02 3.5 0 0 S50 13846 5/11/20243:00 63.10 48.55 4 4 0 S50 13846 5/11/20244:00 59.60 47.62 3.6 5 0 S50 13846 5/11/20245:00 58.80 47.32 4.3 8 0 S50 13846 5/11/20246:00 53.10 47.291 6.4 8 0 S50 13846 5/11/20247:00 62.00 51.75 9.9 11 0 S50 13846 5/11/20248:00 66.20 52.86 12.3 17 0 S50 13846 5/11/20249:00 71.00 52.73 12.2 18 0 S50 13846 5/11/202410:00 70.80 54.08 12.4 26 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/11/202411:00 77.20 55.34 11.7 22 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/11/202412:00 70.90 56.87 12.2 28 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/11/202413:00 70.00 55.29 10.6 28 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/11/202414:00 66.101 52.61 10.7 21 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/11/202415:00 81.80 55.12 12 18 0 S50 13846 5/11/202416:00 62.10 50.43 11.2 11 0 S50 13846 5/11/202417:00 67.00 52.30 10.6 15 0 S50 13846 5/11/202418:00 60.10 52.22 10.6 15 0 S50 13846 5/11/202419:00 77.70 53.89 9.8 4 2.2Adverse Weather(Data notvalid) S50 13846 5/11/202420:00 62.10 50.37 9.5 8 0.8 Adverse Weather (Data notvalid) S50 13846 5/11/202421:00 58.90 50.34 9.3 152.3 Adverse Weather (Data notvalid) S50 13846 5/11/20242200 77.40 51.70 8.8 13 3.8 Adverse Weather (Data notvalid) S50 13846 5/11/202423:00 77.301 52.001 8.9 13 0 Page 101 of 180 eNGLOBe Table D-2 Noise Level and Weather Data Measured for Sensor B We un • , S50 13846 HH:MIVI 5/12/20240:00 68.70 dBA) Temperature 54.17 (*C) Wind Speed (km/h) 9 9 Pr cipitation Commerds 0.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/12/20241:00 56.30 49.63 9 9 0 S50 13846 5/12/20242:00 55.20 48.31 8.8 13 0 S50 13846 5/12/20243:00 56.60 47.70 8.5 9 0 S50 13846 5/12/20244:00 58.30 47.30 7.8 5 0 S50 13846 5/12/20245:00 52.10 46.92 7.8 13 0 S50 13846 5/12/20246:00 52.30 47.12 7.9 11 0 S50 13846 5/12/20247:00 59.10 48.421 9.7 13 0 S50 13846 5/12/20248:00 59.80 48.26 10.7 18 0 S50 13846 5/12/20249:00 65.60 48.87 10.821 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/12/202410:00 65.60 50.29 12 15 0 S50 13846 5/12/202411:00 60.20 49.78 13.9 13 0 S50 13846 5/12/202412:00 62.80 49.93 14.1 11 0 S50 13846 5/12/202413:00 65.50 50.78 15.5 17 0 S50 13846 5/12/202414:00 69.00 51.47 16.3 8 0 S50 13846 5/12/202415:00 93.80 66.61 16.3 9 0 Noise from site security speaker S50 13846 5/12/202416:00 66.70 51.63 16.6 17 0 S50 13846 5/12/202417:00 67.00 53.00 17.1 18 0 S50 13846 5/12/202418:00 68.60 52.07 16 18 0 S50 13846 5/12/202419:00 69.00 51.85 15 15 0 S50 13846 5/12/202420:00 63.40 50.12 13.9 18 0 S50 13846 5/12/202421:00 70.20 51.96 12.5 17 0 S50 13846 5/12/202422:00 76.60 51.61 11.2 15 0 S50 1 13846 24 5/12/2024 23:001 76.201 51.501 9.8 11 0 S50 13846 5/13/20240:00 78.00 57.50 9.4 13 0 S50 13846 5/13/20241:00 61.20 48.57 9.3 13 0 S50 13846 5/13/20242:00 52.30 47.20 9.5 11 0 S50 13846 5/13/20243:00 61.00 47.18 9.6 13 0.2 Adverse Weather (Data not va lid) S50 13846 5/13/20244:00 94.00 66.71 9.6 11 0 Noise from site secu rity speaker S50 13846 5/13/20245:00 83.10 58.40 10.4 18 0 S50 13846 5/13/20246:00 78.60 61.63 10.8 11 0 S50 13846 5/13/20247:00 69.00 61.99 11.6 0 0 S50 13846 5/13/20248:00 94.00 72.87 14.3 17 0 Grinding Noise S50 13846 5/13/20249:00 92.60 70.32 18 18 0 Combination of hammering and grinding noise S50 13846 5/13/202410:00 91.80 71.12 15.6 13 0.2 Adverse Weather(Data notvalid) S50 13846 5/13/202411:00 87.20 73.09 17.8 17 0 S50 13846 5/13/202412:00 93.70 73.89 19.9 15 0 Offloading noise (0.5 Sec) S50 13846 5/13/202413:00 83.20 69.66 21.3 17 0 S50 13846 5/13/202414:00 92.00 77.101 21.8 26 0 Adverse Weather(Data notvalid) S50 13846 5/13/202415:00 94.50 75.32 23 17 0 Hammering Noise S50 13846 5/13/202416:00 86.70 69.18 24.4 30 0 Adverse Weather(Data notvalid) S50 13846 5/13/202417:00 77.00 59.60 23.3 34 0 Adverse Weather(Data notvalid) S50 13846 5/13/202418:00 72.00 59.82 23 32 0 Adverse Weather(Data notvalid) S50 13846 5/13/202419:00 80.60 66.70 21.8 22 O 1 Adverse Weather (Data notvalid) S50 13846 5/13/202420:00 77.30 63.61 17.6 8 0 S50 13846 5/13/202421:00 65.10 51.19 15.8 0 0 S50 13846 5/13/202422:00 74.70 51.56 13.5 8 0 S50 13846 5/13/202423:00 76.00 50.90 13.4 5 0 Tuaatlay, May 14, 2024 IL S50 13846 5/14/20240:00 73.10 49.05 13.8 0 0 S50 13846 5/14/20241:00 93.50 66.33 13 4 0 Noisefrom site securityspeaker S50 13846 5/14/20242:00 51.50 46.58 12.6 4 0 S50 13846 5/14/20243:00 58.60 46.69 12.8 4 0 S50 13846 5/14/20244:00 51.30 46.47 12.9 4 0 S50 13846 5/14/20245:00 54.20 46.79 13.3 0 0 S50 13846 5/14/20246:00 84.30 59.88 13.8 9 0 S50 13846 5/14/20247:00 78.40 67.941 14.8 5 0 S50 13846 5/14/20248:00 86.80 72.03 15.8 8 0 S50 13846 5/14/20249:00 92.60 74.25 16.6 8 0 Hammering noise S50 13846 5/14/202410:00 87.20 72.21 17.9 5 0 S50 13846 5/14/202411:00 88.00 70.99 18.3 13 0 S50 13846 5/14/202412:00 96.30 76.73 19.6 15 0 Combination of Hammeringand griding noise S50 13846 5/14/202413:00 86.40 69.41 19.4 13 0 S50 13846 5/14/202414:00 90.90 73.43 20.3 15 0 Offloading noise (0.5 Sec) S50 13846 5/14/202415:00 93.50 76.211 20 18 0 Hammering noise S50 13846 5/14/202416:00 88.70 68.32 20.2 15 0 S50 13846 5/14/202417:00 74.20 56.09 20 15 0 S50 13846 5/14/202418:00 64.70 53.30 18.5 13 0 S50 13846 5/14/2024 19:001 77.10 58.61 18 15 0 S50 13846 5/14/2024 20:001 74.40 59.33 15.8 13 0 S50 13846 5/14/202421:00 68.00 58.60 14 8 0 S50 13846 5/14/202422:00 76.80 58.66 12.7 5 0 S50 13846 5/14/2024 23:001 82.801 59.271 11.9 8 0 Page 102 of 180 eNGLOBe Table D-2 Noise Level and Weather Data Measured for Sensor B ...... ..Ii.1 No. We .[W)DD/YYYY I-_ (dBA) L, 1-h ... dBA) Temperature Average Air (*C) 1 -hour Average Wind Speed (km/h) u mulative Comments Pr cipitation S50 13846 5/15/20240:00 64.70 58.45 11.2 9 0 S50 13846 5/15/20241:00 66.50 58.82 11 5 0 S50 13846 5/15/20242:00 75.50 58.56 10.7 5 0 S50 13846 5/15/20243:00 62.00 58.43 9.7 4 0 S50 13846 5/15/20244:00 67.90 58.72 9.4 4 0 S50 13846 5/15/20245:00 59.70 58.67 10.6 5 0 S50 1 13846 5/15/20246:00 85.40 60.56 11.2 4 0 S50 13846 5/15/20247:00 88.101 67.72 13.4 11 0 S50 13846 5/15/20248:00 89.00 72.25 14.6 11 0 S50 13846 5/15/20249:00 97.80 71.95 15.8 15 0 Offloading noise (1 Sec) S50 13846 5/15/202410:00 89.70 71.90 17.1 15 0 S50 13846 5/15/202411:00 80.90 71.48 17.6 17 0 S50 13846 5/15/202412:00 84.90 71.15 19 18 0 S50 13846 5/15/202413:00 83.90 69.84 19 15 0 S50 13846 5/15/202414:00 89.20 72.111 20 15 0 S50 13846 5/15/202415:00 85.20 71.10 21.2 15 0 S50 13846 5/15/202416:00 83.10 62.64 20.1 17 0 S50 13846 5/15/202417:00 66.90 53.85 20.2 18 0 S50 13846 5/15/202418:00 63.50 53.76 19.4 21 0 Adverse Weather(Data notvalid) S50 13846 5/15/202419:00 72.30 60.93 17.8 13 0 S50 13846 5/15/202420:00 79.00 55.00 15.4 8 0 S50 13846 5/15/202421:00 69.30 51.78 14.4 0 0 S50 13846 5/15/202422:00 75.90 51.52 12.4 4 0 S50 1 13846 5/15/2024 23:001 76.301 51.051 12.6 8 0 S50 ay, May 16, 2024 13846 5/16/20240:00 66.60 50.43 11.6 8 0 S50 13846 5/16/20241:00 93.70 66.45 10 4 0 Noise from site secu rity speaker S50 13846 5/16/20242:00 54.90 47.67 10.3 4 0 S50 13846 5/16/20243:00 61.10 47.53 9.5 5 0 S50 13846 5/16/20244:00 53.30 47.26 8 4 0 S50 13846 5/16/20245:00 61.70 47.80 8 4 0 S50 13846 5/16/20246:00 83.80 58.771 9.3 5 0 S50 13846 5/16/20247:00 81.70 65.97 13 5 0 S50 13846 5/16/20248:00 86.50 68.91 16.5 13 0 S50 13846 5/16/20249:00 84.90 72.02 18.1 4 0 S50 13846 5/16/202410:00 81.80 69.32 19.5 8 0 S50 13846 5/16/202411:00 85.90 70.64 20.4 4 0 S50 13846 5/16/202412:00 83.40 70.63 20.3 8 0 S50 13846 5/16/202413:00 84.80 66.571 21.1 4 0 S50 13846 5/16/202414:00 84.80 68.70 23 9 0 S50 13846 5/16/202415:00 91.00 68.00 22.9 9 0 Offloading Noise (0.5 Sec) S50 13846 5/16/202416:00 85.60 66.20 22.7 24 0 Adverse Weather(Data notvalid) S50 13846 5/16/202417:00 77.00 59.59 21.7 15 0 S50 13846 5/16/202418:00 70.20 54.62 20.6 18 0 S50 13846 5/16/202419:00 71.601 61.74 17.9 13 0 S50 13846 5/16/202420:00 78.101 58.85 17 13 0 S50 13846 5/16/202421:0071.20 52.64 16.1 8 0 S50 13846 5/16/202422:00 74.70 53.30 14.3 5 0 S50 1 13846 5/16/202423:00 75.401 52.951 13.11 51 0 Friday, May 17, 2024 S50 13846 5/17/20240:00 72.60 52.33 12.9 9 0 S50 13846 5/17/20241:00 63.00 49.45 13.4 4 0 S50 13846 5/17/20242:00 65.70 50.25 12.2 0 0 S50 13846 5/17/20243:00 54.90 48.94 11.2 5 0 S50 13846 5/17/20244:00 51.70 49.01 11.3 4 0 S50 13846 5/17/20245:00 62.60 49.41 11.4 0 0 S50 13846 5/17/20246:00 83.301 59.76 12.7 0 0 S50 13846 5/17/20247:00 79.10 63.34 14.4 5 0 S50 13846 5/17/20248:00 93.50 69.00 15.1 5 0 Offloading Noise (1 Sec) S50 13846 5/17/20249:00 88.70 70.22 15.8 8 0 S50 13846 5/17/202410:00 85.20 66.80 16.1 4 0 S50 13846 5117/202411:00 95.70 72.82 16 11 0.8 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/17/202412:00 89.60 70.30 15.9 8 1.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/17/202413:00 86.20 65.531 15.9 8 1.5 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/17/202414:00 83.50 72.34 16 22 lAdverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/17/202415:00 79.20 60.99 17.1 4 0.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13846 5/17/202416:00 69.90 54.31 18.4 11 0 S50 13846 5/17/202417:00 65.00 53.01 17.9 11 0 S50 13846 5/17/202418:00 71.40 53.85 17.5 15 0 S50 13846 5/17/202419:00 71.101 60.26 16.31 15 0 S50 13846 5/17/202420:00 79.80 57.51 15.3 13 0 S50 13846 5/17/202421:00 67.80 52.65 15.2 11 0 S50 13846 5/17/202422:00 77.90 53.24 14.8 9 0 S50 13846 5/17/202423:00 77.90 52.98 13.6 11 0 S50 13846 5/17/202423:59 62.10 50.80 14.2 9 0 Page 103 of 180 eNGLoee Table D-3 Noise Level and Weather Data Measured for Sensor C Sensor Type S50 Serial No. 13649 MM/DD/YYYY HH:MM 5/3/20240:00 L_ (dBA) I-— (dBA) I -hour Average Air I -hour Temperature CC) Wind Speed 9.9 Average 1 -hour (kmth) Precipitation 4 Cumulative Comments (mm) 0 S50 13649 5/3/20241:00 64.7 50.9 7.8 5 0 S50 13649 5/3/20242:00 65.6 47.5 8.3 8 0 S50 13649 5/3/20243:00 53.4 46.7 9.3 13 0 S50 13649 5/3/20244:00 54.7 46.2 8.9 8 0 S50 13649 5/3/20245:00 56.5 47.4 8.6 5 0 S50 13649 5/3/20246:00 91 67 10.2 4 0 Noisefrom train horn S50 13649 5/3/20247:00 86.9 68.6 12.4 4 0 Noisefrom train horn S50 13649 5/3/20248:00 77.1 65.1 12.5 17 0 S50 13649 5/3/20249:00 80.9 66.5 13.9 9 0.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/3/202410:00 79.5 63.3 12.9 9 1.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/3/202411:00 86.7 68.72 13.1 17 1.5 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/3/202412:00 83.2 69.64 12.5 4 2.5 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/3/202413:00 82.6 62.881 13.1 17 1 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/3/202414:00 86.6 60.53 14.6 17 0 Offloading Noise (1 Sec) S50 13649 5/3/202415:00 75.1 59.76 14 9 0.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/3/202416:00 68.8 56.93 13.1 13 0.8 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/3/202417:00 74 57.00 12.6 11 0 S50 13649 5/3/202418:00 77.1 56.95 12.8 0 0.5 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/3/202419:00 65.4 54.87 12.4 8 0 S50 13649 5/3/202420:00 77.6 63.79 12.4 5 0.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/3/202421:00 72.2 53.41 12.2 4 0 S50 13649 5/3/202422:00 66.9 51.43 12 0 0 S50 1 13649 5/3/202423:00 75.9r.52.71 11.2 8 0 S50 13649 5/4/20240:00 74.2 52.25 10.6 5 0 S50 13649 5/4/20241:00 65.7 50.27 10.8 11 0 S50 13649 5/4/20242:00 61 48.63 11.7 8 0 S50 13649 5/4/20243:00 64.7 47.15 10.4 5 0 S50 13649 5/4/20244:00 55.8 46.09 10.2 9 0 S50 13649 5/4/20245:00 53.4 46.64 11.6 8 0 S50 13649 5/4/20246:00 68.6 49.001 11.8 8 0 S50 13649 5/4/20247:00 63.4 50.52 13.3 13 0 S50 13649 5/4/20248:00 59.6 51.25 15.4 17 0 S50 13649 5/4/20249:00 68.8 53.30 17.6 17 0 S50 13649 5/4/202410:00 71.1 53.32 18.9 21 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/4/202411:00 70.5 52.62 19.5 21 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/4/202412:00 68.6 53.66 21.2 22 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/4/202413:00 76.1 55.49 20.6 21 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/4/202414:00 84.5 57.921 19.3 21 0 lAdverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/4/202415:00 82.5 55.73 20.6 21 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/4/202416:00 80.5 56.47 20.4 21 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/4/202417:00 69.5 52.96 20.1 17 0 S50 13649 5/4/202418:00 65.2 51.86 18 18 0 S50 13649 5/4/202419:00 80.2 55.37 17 24 0 Adverse Weather(Data not valid) S50 13649 5/4/202420:00 79 56.49 15.7 17 0 S50 13649 5/4/202421:00 66.6 52.60 14.5 15 0 S50 13649 5/4/202422:00 70.6 52.63 14 17 0 S50 13649 5/4/202423:00 79.8 52.22 13.1 15 0 Sunday, May 5, 2024 S50 13649 5/5/20240:00 81.3 53.22 13.2 15 0 S50 13649 5/5/20241:00 77.3 51.42 12.9 15 0 S50 13649 5/5/20242:00 62.2 47.97 12.1 13 0.5 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/5/20243:00 64.2 47.84 11.5 13 0 S50 13649 5/5/20244:00 57.6 45.92 11.4 11 0 S50 13649 5/5/20245:00 58.6 49.11 11.4 13 0 S50 13649 5/5/20246:00 58.2 45.431 11.4 9 0 S50 13649 5/5/20247:00 66.4 50.831 11.7 9 0 S50 13649 5/5/20248:00 69 48.91 12.3 11 0.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/5/20249:00 57.4 48.24 13.2 8 0 S50 13649 5/5/202410:00 54.8 48.25 14.1 15 0 S50 13649 5/5/202411:00 68.6 58.16 15.9 11 0 S50 13649 5/5/202412:00 56.5 48.84 17.3 13 0 S50 13649 5/5/202413:00 68.4 57.07 18.2 13 0 S50 13649 5/5/202414:00 57.8 48.38 17.6 22 0 Adverse Weather(Data not valid) S50 13649 5/5/202415:00 66.3 48.771 17.2 15 0 S50 13649 5/5/202416:00 72.2 52.61 15.5 15 0 S50 13649 5/5/202417:00 63 49.16 15.6 11 0 S50 13649 5/5/202418:00 64.1 48.78 16.2 13 0 S50 13649 5/5/202419:00 69.1 50.05 14.6 11 0 S50 13649 5/5/202420:00 69.5 49.85 12.4 9 0 S50 13649 5/5/202421:00 70.9 49.05 11 11 0 S50 13649 5/5/202422:00 68.8 48.56 9.7 9 0 S50 13649 5/5/202423:00 54.1 46.24 9.5 8 0 Page 104 of 180 eNGLoee Table D-3 Noise Level and Weather Data Measured for Sensor C Sensor Type Serial No. MM/DD/YYYY L_ (dBA) I-— I -hour Average Air HH:MM (dBA) Temperature CC) I -hour Average 1 -hour Cumulative Wind Speed (kmth) Precipitation (mm) S50 13649 5/6/20240:00 76.1 55.18 7.2 9 0 S50 13649 5/6/20241:00 61.5 46.99 7.2 9 0 S50 13649 5/6/20242:00 52.8 42.98 7.2 11 0 S50 13649 5/6/20243:00 54.1 42.89 7.2 8 0 S50 13649 5/6/20244:00 53.5 42.14 6.5 9 0 S50 13649 5/6/20245:00 72 62.14 6.3 5 0 S50 1 13649 5/6/20246:00 69.9 66.711 6.2 41 0 S50 13649 5/6/20247:00 75.5 66.80 9.3 11 0 S50 13649 5/6/20248:00 84.7 65.96 11 8 0 S50 13649 5/6/20249:00 79.3 66.21 12.6 9 0 S50 13649 5/6/202410:00 80.7 67.76 14.5 4 0 S50 13649 5/6/202411:00 89.9 72.93 16 17 0 Grinding Noise -Concrete Chipping S50 13649 5/6/202412:00 85.3 71.90 17.1 11 0 Grinding Noise -Concrete Chipping S50 13649 5/6/202413:00 86.4 69.20 17.6 9 0 Grinding Noise -Concrete Chipping S50 13649 5/6/202414:00 80.3 67.801 18.3 8 0 S50 13649 5/6/202415:00 81.8 68.36 18.4 11 0 S50 13649 5/6/202416:00 92.1 78.11 18.1 9 0 Grinding Noise -Concrete Chipping S50 13649 5/6/202417:00 67.2 51.01 17.9 9 0 S50 13649 5/6/202418:00 68.2 49.84 17.6 13 0 S50 13649 5/6/202419:00 69.9 65.38 16.2 9 0 S50 13649 5/6/202420:00 72.3 64.26 12.5 5 0 S50 13649 5/6/202421:00 65.1 50.66 9.7 0 0 S50 1 13649 5/6/202422:00 66.9 51.571 7.9 5 0 S50 Tuesday, May S50 1 13649 7, 2024 13649 5/6/202423:00 60.5 5/7/20240:00 58.2 48.41 6.2 48.14 5.1 5 0 0 0 S50 13649 5/7/2024100 73 54.50 5.3 0 0 S50 13649 5/7/20242:00 55 45.41 4.6 5 0 S50 13649 5/7/20243:00 60.2 46.39 3.4 4 0 S50 13649 5/7/20244:00 56.2 47.22 4 8 0 S50 13649 5/7/20245:00 80.9 61.04 3.1 8 0 S50 13649 5/7/20246:00 75 68.35 3.4 5 0 S50 13649 5/7/20247:00 83.1 69.441 9.1 0 0 S50 13649 5/7/20248:00 83.2 70.10 13.1 9 0 S50 13649 5/7/20249:00 87.3 68.24 16.5 17 0 Gri nd in Noise S50 13649 5/7/202410:00 82.9 62.29 18.2 13 0 S50 13649 5/7/20241100 83.1 67.07 19 11 0 S50 13649 5/7/202412:00 79.1 67.05 19.6 21 0 Adverse Weat her (Data n of va lid) S50 13649 5/7/202413:00 82.7 64.56 20.5 22 0 Adverse Weat her (Data n of va lid) S50 13649 5/7/202414:00 81.5 66.18 20.2 18 0 S50 13649 5/7/202415:00 91.5 67.541 20.3 21 0 Adverse Weat her (Data n of va lid) S50 13649 5/7/202416:00 76.9 65.52 19.7 21 0 Adverse Weat her (Data n of va lid) S50 13649 5/7/202417:00 77.2 62.87 18.5 13 0 S50 13649 5/7/202418:00 64.9 52.44 17.3 15 0 S50 13649 5/7/202419:00 71.5 68.06 16 13 0 S50 13649 5/7/202420:00 81.7 63.27 15.1 151 0 S50 13649 5/7/202421:00 75 52.27 11.6 15 4.1 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/7/202422:00 66.853.58 10.4 91 12.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/7/202423:00 69.2 53.93 9.9 9 3.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) Wednesday, May 8, 2024 S50 13649 5/8/20240:00 73.8 57.18 9.8 21 7.3 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/8/20241:00 73.1 55.55 9.6 J111iff 11 0.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/8/20242:00 57.4 48.91 10.4 9 0 S50 13649 5/8/20243:00 58.7 47.99 10.6 4 0 S50 13649 5/8/20244:00 63.9 46.80 10.9 5 0 S50 13649 5/8/20245:00 77.1 59.80 11.3 8 0 S50 13649 5/8/20246:00 80.7 69.87 11.4 91 0 S50 13649 5/8/20247:00 84.2 71.261 14.7 24 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/8/20248:00 79.7 69.07 16.5 30 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/8/20249:00 92.7 69.74 17.3 46 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/8/202410:00 83.1 65.63 18.3 43 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/8/202411:00 87.1 68.58 18.9 43 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/8/202412:00 83.9 70.20 19.1 43 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/8/202413:00 81 65.07 15.7 37 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/8/202414:00 81.3 66.21 15.6 351 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/8/202415:00 87.4 67.05 15.2 371 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/8/202416:00 87 58.26 15.1 41 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/8/202417:00 65.8 51.92 13.5 32 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/8/202418:00 66.5 50.35 13.1 24 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/8/202419:00 69.2 64.03 11.6 22 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/8/202420:00 75.5 58.41 10.5 13 0 S50 13649 5/8/202421:00 66.7 49.90 10 9 0 S50 13649 5/8/202422:00 67.3 50.96 9.2 4 0 S50 13649 5/8/202423:00 76.3 55.94 7.5 9 0 Page 105 of 180 eNGLoBe Table D-3 Noise Level and Weather Data Measured for Sensor C Sensor Type S50 Serial No. ,May 9,'2024 13649 MM/DD/YYYY L_ HH:MM 5/9/20240:00 (dBA) 76.8 I-— (dBA) 56.53 I -hour Average Air Temperature CC) 6.9 I -hour Average 1 -hour Wind Speed (kmth) Precipitation 0 Cumulative (mm) 000** 0 S50 13649 5/9/20241:00 56.1 47.35 5.9 4 0 S50 13649 5/9/20242:00 55 45.64 6.8 9 0 S50 13649 5/9/20243:00 54.2 46.16 6.8 11 0 S50 13649 5/9/20244:00 52.9 45.55 6 4 0 S50 13649 5/9/20245:00 55.9 47.66 5.2 4 0 S50 13649 5/9/20246:00 79.5 66.94 6.7 4 0 S50 1 13649 5/9/20247:00 80.4 67.911 9.5 9 0 S50 13649 5/9/20248:00 81.7 67.04 11.9 11 0 S50 13649 5/9/20249:00 84.8 68.40 13.6 17 0 S50 13649 5/9/202410:00 79.2 64.83 15.1 22 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/9/202411:00 80.6 68.10 15.4 13 0 S50 13649 5/9/202412:00 84.7 67.60 16.3 22 0 Adverse Weather(Data not valid) S50 13649 5/9/202413:00 79.6 66.38 15.6 11 0 S50 13649 5/9/202414:00 85.2 70.55 15.3 11 0 Combination of Machinery and hammering noise S50 13649 5/9/202415:00 80.4 69.351 14.2 13 0 S50 13649 5/9/202416:00 84.1 64.66 13.8 13 0 S50 13649 5/9/202417:00 71.3 54.02 13.3 13 0 S50 13649 5/9/202418:00 71.4 54.60 12.1 9 0 S50 13649 5/9/202419:00 72.9 66.02 11 5 0 S50 13649 5/9/202420:00 77.5 60.32 11.1 5 0 S50 13649 5/9/202421:00 69.8 51.63 10.7 5 0 S50 13649 5/9/202422:00 72.7 50.68 9.1 5 0 S50 1 13649 5/9/202423:00 69.8 51.361 9.2 4 0 May 10, 2024 S50 13649 5/10/20240:00 93.8 60.19 9.6 8 0 Noisefrom train horn S50 13649 5/10/2024100 58.4 45.37 8.9 8 0 S50 13649 5/10/20242:00 61.3 47.24 8.7 11 0 S50 13649 5/10/20243:00 54.7 44.86 8.1 5 0 S50 13649 5/10/20244:00 53.1 46.00 5.6 5 0 S50 13649 5/10/20245:00 67.2 50.92 4.4 4 0 S50 13649 5/10/20246:00 76.3 67.42 7.4 4 0 S50 13649 5/10/20247:00 78.5 67.841 9.1 8 0 S50 13649 5/10/20248:00 76.8 65.37 10 5 0 S50 13649 5/10/20249:00 80.9 62.86 11.3 4 0 S50 13649 5/10/202410:00 73.8 61.52 12.5 11 0 S50 13649 5/10/202411:00 80 64.72 13.7 13 0 S50 13649 5/10/202412:00 82 65.40 15.4 4 0 S50 13649 5/10/202413:00 92.8 66.62 14.3 9 0 Noisefrom train horn S50 13649 5/10/202414:00 82.5 68.80 14.3 11 0 S50 13649 5/10/202415:00 82 64.54 15.3 9 0 S50 13649 5/10/202416:00 84.6 60.07 13.5 24 0 Adverse Weather(Data not valid) S50 13649 5/10/202417:00 70.2 55.32 14.9 11 0 S50 13649 5/10/202418:00 69 55.51 14.2 9 0 S50 13649 5/10/202419:00 72.8 66.68 13 9 0 S50 13649 5/10/202420:00 78.8 61.92 10.3 9 0 S50 13649 5/10/202421:00 70.3 51.21 10.8 9 0 S50 13649 5/10/202422:00 67.3 50.13 11 8 0 S50 1 13649 5/10/202423:00 81.3 52.951 8.6 4 0 Er S50 may, May 99,'•- 13649 5/11/20240:00 70.9 54.131 7 5 0 S50 13649 5/11/20241:00 62.7 47.58 6.8 0 0 S50 13649 5/11/20242:00 75.2 48.58 3.5 0 0 S50 13649 5/11/20243:00 67.7 48.58 4 4 0 S50 13649 5/11/20244:00 63 47.06 3.6 5 0 S50 13649 5/11/20245:00 54.4 44.71 4.3 8 0 S50 13649 5/11/20246:00 56.4 47.27 6.4 8 0 S50 13649 5/11/20247:00 62.2 52.49 9.9 11 0 S50 13649 5/11/20248:00 67.61 53.22 12.3 17 0 S50 13649 5/11/20249:00 67.4 53.00 12.2 18 0 S50 13649 5/11/202410:00 72.1 56.23 12.4 26 0 Adverse Weather(Data not valid) S50 13649 5/11/202411:00 68.4 54.95 11.7 22 0 Adverse Weather(Data not valid) S50 13649 5/11/202412:00 72.1 57.30 12.2 28 0 Adverse Weather(Data not valid) S50 13649 5/11/202413:00 68.7 52.92 10.6 28 0 Adverse Weather(Data not valid) S50 13649 5/11/202414:00 63.7 52.40 10.7 21 0 Adverse Weather(Data not valid) S50 13649 5/11/202415:00 80.1 55.021 12 18 0 S50 13649 5/11/202416:00 65.9 51.29 11.2 11 0 S50 13649 5/11/202417:00 59.4 51.70 10.6 15 0 S50 13649 5/11/202418:00 62.3 52.26 10.6 15 0 S50 13649 5/11/202419:00 79.5 55.49 9.8 4 2.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/11/202420:00 60.3 51.46 9.5 8 0.8 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/11/202421:00 65.4 51.71 9.3 15 2.3 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 136495/11/202422:00 64.1 50.87 8.8 13 3.8 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/11/202423:00 67.4 51.30 8.9 13 0 Page 106 of 180 eNGLoBe Table D-3 Noise Level and Weather Data Measured for Sensor C Sensor Serial No. Type SunE9y, May12; 2034 MM/DD/YYYY HH:MM L_ (dBA) I-— (dBA) I -hour Average Air I -hour Temperature CC) Wind Speed Average 1 -hour (kmth) Precipitation Cumulative Comments (mm) S50 13649 5/12/20240:00 64.1 52.12 9 9 0.2 Adverse Weat her(Dat a n of va lid) S50 13649 5/12/20241:00 56.4 48.97 9 9 0 S50 13649 5/12/20242:00 57.5 46.93 8.8 13 0 S50 13649 5/12/20243:00 59.8 45.49 8.5 9 0 S50 13649 5/12/20244:00 61 44.70 7.8 5 0 S50 13649 5/12/20245:00 55.3 43.07 7.8 13 0 S50 1 13649 5/12/20246:00 52.9 43.33 7.9 11 0 S50 13649 5/12/20247:00 62.5 46.60 9.7 131 0 S50 13649 5/12/20248:00 58.7 46.20 10.7 18 0 S50 13649 5/12/20249:00 69.9 47.73 10.821 0 Adverse Weat her(Dat a n of va lid) S50 13649 5/12/202410:00 68.9 49.51 12 15 0 S50 13649 5/12/202411:00 57.5 48.16 13.9 13 0 S50 13649 5/12/202412:00 63.5 48.52 14.1 11 0 S50 13649 5/12/202413:00 70.1 51.71 15.5 17 0 S50 13649 5/12/202414:00 68.8 50.261 16.3 8 0 S50 13649 5/12/202415:00 69.8 50.34 16.3 9 0 S50 13649 5/12/202416:00 74.6 50.71 16.6 17 0 S50 13649 5/12/202417:00 73.2 53.29 17.1 18 0 S50 13649 5/12/202418:00 64.1 49.71 16 18 0 S50 13649 5/12/202419:00 66.2 49.90 15 15 0 S50 13649 5/12/202420:00 61.3 48.19 13.9 18 0 S50 13649 5/12/202421:00 66 49.25 12.5 17 0 S50 1 13649 5/12/202422:00 68 48.61 11.2 15 0 S50 S50 13649 ME 13649 5/12/202423:00 5/13/20240:00 65.2 80.6 48.87 60.65 9.8 9.4 11 13 0 0 S50 13649 5/13/2024100 66.5 48.59 9.3 13 0 S50 13649 5/13/20242:00 54 45.52 9.5 11 0 S50 13649 5/13/20243:00 64.1 44.98 9.6 13 0.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/13/20244:00 68.9 48.12 9.6 11 0 S50 13649 5/13/20245:00 89 63.40 10.4 18 0 Noisefrom train horn S50 13649 5/13/20246:00 84.1 68.321 10.8 11 0 S50 13649 5/13/20247:00 78.7 69.12 11.6 0 0 S50 13649 5/13/20248:00 83.6 70.44 14.3 17 0 S50 13649 5/13/20249:00 79.3 64.69 18 18 0 S50 13649 5/13/202410:00 76.6 61.41 15.6 13 02 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/13/20241100 78 65.64 17.8 17 0 S50 13649 5/13/202412:00 81.1 65.96 19.9 15 0 S50 13649 5/13/202413:00 77.8 63.01 21.3 17 0 S50 13649 5/13/202414:00 79.5 65.721 21.8 26 0 lAdverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/13/202415:00 80.4 67.47 23 17 0 S50 13649 5/13/202416:00 82.6 63.49 24.4 30 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/13/202417:00 72.5 55.43 23.3 34 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/13/202418:00 69 52.82 23 32 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/13/202419:00 74 66.98 21.8 22 0 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/13/202420:00 77.8 65.91 17.6 8 0 S50 13649 5/13/202421:00 66.7 50.54 15.8 0 0 S50 13649 5/13/202422:00 70.1 51.951 13.5 8 0 S50 13649 5/13/202423:00 66.9 48.72 13.4 5 0 S50 13649 5/14/20240:00 77.6 49.17 13.8 0 0 S50 13649 5/14/20241:00 68.5 49.37 13 4 0 S50 1 13649 5/14/20242:00 55.5 44.47 12.6 4 0 S50 13649 5/14/20243:00 61 44.34 12.8 41 0 S50 13649 5/14/20244:00 53.2 44.13 12.9 4 0 S50 13649 5/14/20245:00 54.2 44.88 13.3 0 0 S50 13649 5/14/20246:00 92 67.10 13.8 9 0 Noisefrom train horn S50 13649 5/14/20247:00 78.3 69.051 14.8 5 0 S50 13649 5/14/20248:00 82.3 70.14 15.8 8 0 S50 13649 5/14/20249:00 81.7 69.48 16.6 8 0 S50 13649 5/14/202410:00 86 65.17 17.9 5 0 Hammering Noise (2 sec) S50 13649 5/14/202411:00 79.4 63.87 18.3 13 0 S50 13649 5/14/202412:00 83.1 68.13 19.6 15 0 S50 13649 5/14/202413:00 78.8 63.57 19.4 13 0 S50 13649 5/14/202414:00 85.8 66.36 20.3 15 0 S50 13649 5/14/202415:00 81.8 67.071 20 18 0 S50 13649 5/14/202416:00 76 63.47 20.2 15 0 S50 13649 5/14/202417:00 69.8 53.84 20 15 0 S50 13649 5/14/202418:00 65.3 52.13 18.5 13 0 S50 13649 5/14/202419:00 70.8 64.31 18 15 0 S50 13649 5/14/202420:00 81.1 65.87 15.8 13 0 S50 13649 5/14/202421:00 72 65.24 14 8 0 S50 13649 5/14/202422:00 69.4 64.98 12.7 5 0 S50 13649 5/14/202423:00 75.8 65.06 11.9 81 0 Page 107 of 180 eNGLoee Table D-3 Noise Level and Weather Data Measured for Sensor C Sensor Type Serial No. MM/DD/YYYY L_ (dBA) I-— I -hour Average Air I -hour Average 1 -hour Cumulative HH:MM (dBA) Temperature CC) Wind Speed (kmth) PrecipRation (mm) 000** S50 13649 5/15/20240:00 67 65.00 11.2 9 0 S50 13649 5/15/20241:00 71.8 65.38 11 5 0 S50 13649 5/15/20242:00 71.2 65.08 10.7 5 0 S50 13649 5/15/20243:00 67.6 65.13 9.7 4 0 S50 13649 5/15/20244:00 69 65.07 9.4 4 0 S50 13649 5/15/20245:00 67.4 65.11 10.6 5 0 S50 1 13649 5/15/20246:00 92.5 67.291 11.2 4 0 Noisefrom train horn S50 13649 5/15/20247:00 78.8 0 70.12 13.4]17 S50 13649 5/15/20248:00 73.1 64.39 14.6 0 S50 13649 5/15/20249:00 82.1 66.52 15.8 0 S50 13649 5/15/202410:00 80.5 66.52 17.1 0 S50 13649 5/15/202411:00 78.8 68.14 17.6 0 S50 13649 5/15/202412:00 79 6954 19 0 S50 13649 5/15/202413:00 86.8 68.14 19 0 Combination of Hammering and grinding noise S50 13649 5/15/202414:00 89.1 68.551 20 15 0 Grinding noise S50 13649 5/15/202415:00 91.3 69.45 21.2 15 0 Offloading Noises S50 13649 5/15/202416:00 81.7 63.55 20.1 17 0 S50 13649 5/15/202417:00 76.4 56.1620.2 18 0 S50 13649 5/15/202418:00 72.9 57.35 19.4 21 0 Adverse Weather(Data not valid) S50 13649 5/15/202419:00 73.1 66.49 17.8 13 0 S50 13649 5/15/202420:00 85.9 59.01 15.4 8 0 S50 13649 5/15/202421:00 70.1 53.21 14.4 0 0 S50 13649 5/15/202422:00 66 51.39 12.4 4 0 S50 13649 5/15/202423:00 ay, May 16, 2024 S50 13649 5/16/20240:00 69.5 71 49.66 12.6 8 0 51.63 11.6 8 0 S50 13649 5/16/2024100 71.6 53.32 10 4 0 S50 13649 5/16/20242:00 64.7 47.08 10.3 4 0 S50 13649 5/16/20243:00 61.6 46.93 9.5 51 0 S50 13649 5/16/20244:00 52 44.07 8 4 0 S50 13649 5/16/20245:00 53.7 45.53 8 4 0 S50 13649 5/16/20246:00 90.5 64.701 9.3 5 0 Noisefrom train horn S50 13649 5/16/20247:00 78.5 68.85 13 5 0 S50 13649 5/16/20248:00 79.1 67.14 16.5 13 0 S50 13649 5/16/20249:00 84.4 66.61 18.1 4 0 S50 13649 5/16/202410:00 78.8 63.23 19.5 8 0 S50 13649 5/16/20241100 79.8 65.04 20.4 4 0 S50 13649 5/16/202412:00 77.9 64.30 20.3 8 0 S50 13649 5/16/202413:00 75.9 62.24 21.1 4 0 S50 13649 5/16/202414:00 80.2 64.501 23 9 0 S50 13649 5/16/202415:00 83.7 65.75 22.9 9 0 S50 13649 5/16/202416:00 80.7 64.33 NONE 24 0 Adverse Weather(Data not valid) S50 13649 5/16/202417:00 73.9 59.15 21.7 15 0 S50 13649 5/16/202418:00 73.3 55.40 20.6 18 0 S50 13649 5/16/202419:00 74.6 69.30 17.9 13 0 S50 13649 5/16/202420:00 1 82.9 65.00 17 13 0 S50 136495/16/202421:00 74 53.59 16.1 8 0 S50 13649 5/16/202422:00 78.3 54.821 14.3 5 0 S50 13649 5/16/202423:00 70.5 53.29 13.1 5 0 May 17, 2024 S50 13649 5/17/20240:00 74.9 52.19 12.9 9 0 S50 13649 5/17/20241:00 58 47.89 13.4 4 0 S50 13649 5/17/20242:00 64.1 50.31 12.2 0 0 S50 13649 5/17/20243:00 54.7 47.03 11.2 5 0 S50 13649 5/17/20244:00 53.2 47.04 11.3 4 0 S50 13649 5/17/20245:00 58.8 47.67 11.4 0 0 S50 13649 5/17/20246:00 91.3 66.74 12.7 0 0 Noisefrom train horn S50 13649 5/17/20247:00 72.7 69.831 14.4 5 0 S50 13649 5/17/20248:00 82.7 66.62 15.1 5 0 S50 13649 5/17/20249:00 87.1 65.32 15.8 8 0 Noise from Air Horn S50 13649 5/17/202410:00 83.4 60.02 16.1 4 0 S50 13649 5/17/202411:00 89.4 67.42 16 11 0.8 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/17/202412:00 83.1 64.84 15.9 8 1.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/17/202413:00 77.3 60.35 15.9 8 1.5 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/17/202414:00 94.6 72.56 16 22 1 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/17/202415:00 82.6 57.351 17.1 4 0.2 Adverse Weather (Data not valid) S50 13649 5/17/202416:00 76.5 55.61 18.4 11 0 S50 13649 5/17/202417:00 71.7 53.24 17.9 11 0 S50 13649 5/17/202418:00 72 54.57 17.5 15 0 S50 13649 5/17/202419:00 72.5 66.97 16.3 15 0 S50 13649 5/17/202420:00 87.3 61.94 15.3 13 0 Siren noisefrom an emergencyvehicle S50 13649 5/17/202421:00 70.5 53.80 15.2 11 0 S50 13649 5/17/202422:00 74.6 54.35 14.8 9 0 S50 13649 5/17/202423:00 72.7 55.19 13.6 11 0 S50 13649 5/17/202423:59 66.3 51.31 14.2 9 0 Page 108 of 180 Appendix E Weather Data Record for Monitoring Period Government Gouvernement of Canada du Canada Home > Environment and natural resources > Weather. Climate and Hazard > Past weather and climate > Historical Data Hourly Data Report for May 03, 2024 it:1-d 0.sT1.add i nog.t 3dl tro, oayuynr sn�i�,y mgrwnr.r n�,dwnr�i�is o�:rryrd. KITCHEN E R/WATERLOO ONTARIO Current Station Operator: NAVCAN Latitude: C imate ID: 4327-39.000".N 6144239 Longitude: WMo ID: 80"22'43.000" W 71368 Elevation: TC ID: 321.60 m YKF Precip. Amount Temp Dew Paint Rel Hum mm Wind Dir Wind Sud Visibility Stn Press Hmdx Wind Chill Weather TIME °C °C k 10'sdeg km/h km kP,a LST L L L L L L L 00:00 9.9 7.7 86 0.0 7 4 16.1 97.89 NA 01:00 7.8 6.6 92 0.0 5 5 16.1 97.84 NA 02:00 8.3 6.9 91 0.0 9 8 16.1 97.79 NA 03:00 9.3 7.4 88 0.0 8 13 16.1 97.75 NA 04:00 8.9 6.9 87 0.0 7 8 16.1 97.80 NA 05:00 8.6 7.1 90 0.0 5 5 16.1 97.82 NA 06:00 10.2 8.5 89 0.0 35 4 16.1 97.94 NA 07:00 12.4 8.6 77 0.0 M 4 16.1 97.99 NA 08:00 12.S 9.6 82 0.0 7 17 12.9 97.90 Moderate Rain 09:00 13.9 10.1 77 0.2 7 9 16.1 97.93 Rain 10:00 12.9 10.5 85 1.2 4 9 11.3 97.89 Rain 11:00 13.1 11.7 91 1.5 8 17 9.7 97.89 Rain, Fag 12:00 12.5 11.0 90 2.5 M 4 2.8 98.08 Heavy Rain, Fog, 13:00 13.1 11.7 91 1.0 9 17 16.1 97.94 Rain 14:00 14.6 11.7 83 0.0 9 17 16.1 97.91 NA 15:00 14.0 11.S 85 0.2 13 9 16.1 97.99 Rain 16:00 13.1 12.1 94 0.8 8 13 16.1 97.91 Rain 17:00 12.6 11.s 93 0.0 8 11 16.1 97.91 NA 18:00 12.8 11.5 92 O.S 0 16.1 97.96 Rain 19:00 12.4 11.8 96 0.0 33 8 16.1 98.02 NA 20:00 12.4 11.5 94 0.2 36 5 16.1 98.02 NA 21:00 12.2 11.6 96 0.0 1 4 16.1 98.07 NA 22:00 12.0 11.7 98 0.0 0 16.1 98.07 NA 23:00 11.2 11.2 100 0.0 35 8 11.3 98.08 NA Legend • E = Estimated NA= Nat Available* • M = Missing [empty] =Indicates an unobserved value Date modified: 2024-03-27 Page 110 of 180 Government Gouvernement of Canada du Canada Home > Environment and natural resources > Weather. Climate and Hazard > Past weather and climate > Historical Data Hourly Data Report for May 04, 2024 1-1-d 0.sr1. Baa i noir m 3al�n m� oayuyn� sn�i�,y mgr wnrrr n�,d wnr� i� is o�:rrurd. KITCHEN E R/WATERLOO ONTARIO Current Station Operator: NAVCAN Latitude: 4327-39.000".N Longitude: 80"22'43.000" W Elevation: 321.60 m C imate ID: 6144239 WMo ID: 71368 TC ID: YKF PreciP. Amount Temu Dew Point Rel Hum MM Wind Dir Wind Sod Visibility, Stn Press Hmdz Wind Chill Weather TIME ,°C °C ^k 10;s_d,eg km�h km, kPa LST L L L L L L L 00:00 10.6 10.2 97 0.0 34 5 16.1 98.12 NA 01:00 10.8 10.8 100 0.0 36 11 9.7 98.08 Fog 02:00 11.7 10.8 94 0.0 1 8 16.1 98.07 NA 03:00 10.4 10.3 99 0.0 36 5 14.5 98.10 NA 04:00 10.2 10.1 99 0.0 36 9 16.1 98.11 NA 05:00 11.6 9.9 89 0.0 4 8 16.1 98.11 NA 06:00 11.8 11.0 95 0.0 6 8 16.1 98.13 NA 07:00 13.3 11.5 89 0.0 4 13 16.1 98.19 NA 08:00 15.4 12.4 82 0.0 8 17 16.1 98.21 NA 09:00 17.6 13.6 77 0.0 8 17 16.1 98.18 NA 10:00 18.9 13.9 72 0.0 11 21 16.1 98.11 NA 11:00 19.5 13.5 68 0.0 10 21 16.1 98.09 NA 12:00 21.2 13.5 61 0.0 10 22 16.1 98.04 NA 13:00 20.6 13.1 62 0.0 11 21 16.1 98.01 NA 14:00 19.3 13.3 68 0.0 8 21 16.1 97.97 NA 15:00 20.6 13.9 65 0.0 9 21 16.1 97.90 NA 16:00 20.4 13.4 64 0.0 11 21 16.1 97.84 NA 17:00 20.1 14.0 68 0.0 10 17 16.1 97.81 NA 18:00 18.0 13.6 75 0.0 10 18 16.1 97.79 NA 19:00 17.0 13.0 77 0.0 10 24 16.1 9779 NA 20:00 15.7 12.9 83 0.0 9 17 16.1 97.77 NA 21:00 14.5 12.9 90 0.0 12 15 16.1 97.81 NA 22:00 14.0 11.7 86 0.0 15 17 16.1 97.80 NA 23:00 13.1 11.4 89 0.0 15 15 16.1 97.73 NA Legend • E = Estimated NA= Nat Available* • M = Missing [empty] =Indicates an unobserved value Date modified: 2024-03-27 Page 111 of 180 Government Gouvernement of Canada du Canada Home > Environment and natural resources > Weather. Climate and Hazard > Past weather and climate > Historical Data Hourly Data Report for May 05, 2024 1-1-d 0.sr1. Baa i noir m 3al�n m� oayuyn� sn�i�,y mgr wnrrr n�,d wnr� i� is o�:rrurd. KITCHEN E R/WATERLOO ONTARIO Current Station Operator: NAVCAN Latitude: C imate ID: 4327-39.000".N 6144239 Longitude: WMo ID: 80"22'43.000" W 71368 Elevation: TC ID: 321.60 m YKF PreciP. Amount Temu Dew Point Rel Hum MM Wind Dir Wind Sod Visibility, Stn Press Hmdz Wind Chill Weather TIME ,°C °C ^k 10;s_d,eg km�h km, kPa LST L L L L L L L 00:00 13.2 10.8 85 0.0 17 15 16.1 97.71 NA 01:00 12.9 10.6 86 0.0 16 15 16.1 97.64 NA 02:00 12.1 11.3 95 0.5 15 13 16.1 97.60 NA 03:00 11.5 11.2 98 0.0 16 13 16.1 97.59 Rain 04:00 11.4 11.1 98 0.0 13 11 16.1 97.55 NA 05:00 11.4 11.4 100 0.0 14 13 16.1 97.53 Rain 06:00 11.4 11.4 100 0.0 14 9 4.8 97.54 Fag, 07:00 11.7 11.7 100 0.0 17 9 4.8 97.60 Fag, 08:00 12.3 12.3 100 0.2 18 11 3.6 97.64 Fog 09:00 13.2 13.2 100 0.0 21 8 4.0 97.65 Fag, 10:00 14.1 14.1 100 0.0 19 15 4.8 97.68 Fag 11:00 15.9 15.4 97 0.0 20 11 14.5 97.67 NA 12:00 17.3 16.0 92 0.0 19 13 16.1 97.65 NA 13:00 18.2 16.2 88 0.0 24 13 16.1 97.65 NA 14:00 17.6 15.7 88 0.0 30 22 16.1 97.67 Rain 15:00 17.2 15.3 88 0.0 30 15 16.1 97.70 NA 16:00 15.5 13.2 86 0.0 32 15 16.1 97.75 NA 17:00 15.6 123 80 0.0 32 11 16.1 97.78 NA 18:00 16.2 11.5 74 0.0 31 13 16.1 97.80 NA 19:00 14.6 10.5 76 0.0 32 11 16.1 97.84 NA 20:00 12.4 7.5 72 0.0 32 9 16.1 97.87 NA 21:00 11.0 6.6 74 0.0 31 11 16.1 97.90 NA 22:00 9.7 6.8 82 0.0 32 9 16.1 97.91 NA 23:00 9.5 6.8 83 0.0 32 8 16.1 97.94 NA Legend • E = Estimated NA= Nat Available* • M = Missing [empty] =Indicates an unobserved value Date modified: 2024-03-27 Page 112 of 180 Government Gouvernement of Canada du Canada Home > Environment and natural resources > Weather. Climate and Hazard > Past weather and climate > Historical Data Hourly Data Report for May 06, 2024 1-1-d 0.sr1. Baa i noir m 3al�n m� oayuyn� sn�i�,y mgr wnrrr n�,d wnr� i� is o�:rrurd. KITCHEN E R/WATERLOO ONTARIO Current Station Operator: NAVCAN Latitude: 4327-39.000".N Longitude: 80"22'43.000" W Elevation: 321.60 m C imate ID: 6144239 WMo ID: 71368 TC ID: YKF PreciP. Amount Temu Dew Point Rel Hum MM Wind Dir Wind Sod Visibility, Stn Press Hmdz Wind Chill Weather TIME ,°C °C ^k 10;s_d,eg km�h km, kPa LST L L L L L L L 00:00 7.2 6.0 92 0.0 31 9 16.1 97.98 NA 01:00 7.2 5.4 88 0.0 32 9 16.1 97.97 NA 02:00 7.2 2.9 74 0.0 33 11 16.1 97.98 NA 03:00 7.2 1.8 68 0.0 33 8 16.1 97.99 NA 04:00 6.S 1.0 68 0.0 33 9 16.1 97.99 NA 05:00 6.3 0.8 68 0.0 32 5 16.1 97.98 NA 06:00 6.2 3.7 84 0.0 27 4 16.1 98.01 NA 07:00 9.3 2.3 61 0.0 35 11 16.1 98.00 NA 08:00 11.0 2.4 S5 0.0 1 8 16.1 98.05 NA 09:00 12.6 3.8 S5 0.0 36 9 16.1 98.05 NA 10:00 14.5 4.8 52 0.0 M 4 16.1 98.04 NA 11:00 16.0 4.1 45 0.0 34 17 16.1 97.99 NA 12:00 17.1 4.8 44 0.0 M 11 16.1 97.94 NA 13:00 17.6 53 44 0.0 M 9 16.1 97.91 NA 14:00 18.3 5.2 42 0.0 M 8 16.1 97.86 NA 15:00 18.4 4.9 41 0.0 36 11 16.1 97.79 NA 16:00 18.1 4.5 40 0.0 35 9 16.1 97.73 NA 17:00 17.9 43 40 0.0 33 9 16.1 97.68 NA 18:00 17.6 3.8 40 0.0 33 13 16.1 97.66 NA 19:00 16.2 2.4 39 0.0 36 9 16.1 97.61 NA 20:00 12.5 4.4 S8 0.0 35 5 16.1 97.59 NA 21:00 9.7 6.6 81 0.0 0 16.1 97.61 NA 22:00 7.9 4.0 76 0.0 5 5 16.1 97.59 NA 23:00 6.2 4.9 92 0.0 34 5 16.1 97.61 NA Legend • E = Estimated NA= Nat Available* • M = Missing [empty] =Indicates an unobserved value Date modified: 2024-03-27 Page 113 of 180 Government Gouvernement of Canada du Canada Home > Environment and natural resources > Weather. Climate and Hazard > Past weather and climate > Historical Data Hourly Data Report for May 07, 2024 it:1-d 0.sT1.add i nog.t 3dl t., oayuyn�sn�i�,y mgrwnr.r n�,dwnr�i�is o�:rryrd. KITCHEN E R/WATERLOO ONTARIO Current Station Operator: NAVCAN Latitude: C imate ID: 4327-39.000".N 6144239 Longitude: WMo ID: 80"22'43.000" W 71368 Elevation: TC ID: 321.60 m YKF P-ip. Amount Temp Dew Point Rel Hum mm Wind Dir Wind Sod Visibility, Stn Press Hmdx Wind Chill Weather TIME �C *. C °;6 10 ;s d,eg km(h km kPa LST L L L L L L L 00:00 5.1 4.8 98 0.0 0 16.1 97.59 NA 01:00 5.3 4.0 91 0.0 0 16.1 97.58 NA 02:00 4.6 4.6 100 0.0 36 5 16.1 97.52 NA 03:00 3.4 3.4 100 0.0 33 4 16.1 97.49 NA 04:00 4.0 4.0 100 0.0 35 8 16.1 97.44 NA 05:00 3.1 3.1 100 0.0 30 8 16.1 97.44 NA 06:00 3.4 3.4 100 0.0 34 5 16.1 97.45 NA 07:00 9.1 5.3 77 0.0 0 16.1 97.47 NA 08:00 13.1 5.3 59 0.0 8 9 16.1 97.45 NA 09:00 16.5 6.4 51 0.0 11 17 16.1 97.38 NA 10:00 18.2 8.1 51 0.0 11 13 16.1 97.36 NA 11:00 19.0 7.5 47 0.0 13 11 16.1 97.29 NA 12:00 19.6 6.2 41 0.0 10 21 16.1 97.15 NA 13:00 20.5 7.6 43 0.0 10 22 16.1 97.05 NA 14:00 20.2 4.5 35 0.0 12 18 16.1 97.02 NA 15:00 203 5.7 38 0.0 13 21 16.1 96.95 NA 16:00 19.7 3.5 34 0.0 11 21 16.1 96.91 NA 17:00 18.5 4.5 39 0.0 10 13 16.1 96.85 NA 18:00 17.3 6.5 49 0.0 11 1s 16.1 96.76 NA 19:00 16.0 5.5 49 0.0 10 13 16.1 96.75 NA 20:00 15.1 5.1 51 0.0 9 15 16.1 96.71 Rain 21:00 11.6 7.4 75 4.1 3 1s 4.8 96.71 Thunderstorms,Heavy Rain 22:00 10.4 8.7 89 12.2 8 9 16.1 96.61 NA 23:00 9.9 9.1 95 3.2 4 9 6.4 96.59 Moderate Rain, Fag Legend • E = Estimated NA= Nat Available* • M = Missing [empty] =Indicates an unobserved value Date modified: 2024-03-27 Page 114 of 180 Government Gouvernement of Canada du Canada Home > Environment and natural resources > Weather. Climate and Hazard > Past weather and climate > Historical Data Hourly Data Report for May 08, 2024 1-1-d 0.sr1. Baa i nog. m 3al�n m� oayuynr sn�i�,y mgr wnr.r n�,d wnr� i� is o�:rrurd. KITCHEN E R/WATERLOO ONTARIO Current Station Operator: NAVCAN Latitude: 4327-39.000".N Longitude: 80"22'43.000" W Elevation: 321.60 m C imate ID: 6144239 WMo ID: 71368 TC ID: YKF Precis. Amount Tema Dew Paint Rel Hum mm Wind Dir Wind Sud Visibility Stn Press Hmdx Wind Chill Weather TIME °,C °C °6 Mk41g km/h km, kP,d LST L L L L L L L 00:00 9.8 9.0 95 7.3 7 21 9.7 96.48 Rain, Foy 01:00 9.6 9.2 97 0.2 8 11 16.1 9635 NA 02:00 10.4 9.5 94 0.0 10 9 16.1 96.31 NA 03:00 10.6 9.7 94 0.0 13 4 16.1 96.29 NA 04:00 10.9 9.8 93 0.0 23 5 16.1 96.32 NA 05:00 11.3 11.1 98 0.0 21. 8 16.1 96.26 NA 06:00 11.4 11.4 100 0.0 25 9 16.1 9630 NA 07:00 14.7 12.5 87 0.0 26 24 16.1 96.34 NA 08:00 16.5 11.3 71 0.0 25 30 16.1 96.32 NA 09:00 17.3 9.9 61 0.0 27 46 16.1 9633 NA 10:00 18.3 9.9 58 0.0 26 43 16.1 96.33 NA 11:00 18.9 10.4 57 0.0 26 43 16.1 96.34 NA 12:00 19.1 10.5 57 0.0 26 43 16.1 96.38 Rain 13:00 15.7 10.6 71 0.0 28 37 16.1 96.46 NA 14:00 15.6 10.5 71 0.0 26 35 16.1 96.59 NA 15:00 15.2 9.8 70 0.0 29 37 16.1 96.66 NA 16:00 15.1 9.0 67 0.0 30 41 16.1 96.73 NA 17:00 13.5 8.2 70 0.0 30 32 16.1 96.84 NA 18:00 13.1 8.0 71 0.0 30 24 16.1 96.95 NA 19:00 11.6 7.9 78 0.0 34 22 16.1 97.00 NA 20:00 10.5 8.6 88 0.0 33 13 16.1 97.06 NA 21:00 10.0 8.0 87 0.0 36 9 16.1 97.15 NA 22:00 9.2 7.8 91 0.0 35 4 16.1 97.20 NA 23:00 7.5 7.5 100 0.0 36 9 16.1 97.24 NA Legend • E = Estimated NA= Nat Available* • M = Missing [empty] =Indicates an unobserved value Date modified: 2024-03-27 Page 115 of 180 Government Gouvernement of Canada du Canada Home > Environment and natural resources > Weather. Climate and Hazard > Past weather and climate > Historical Data Hourly Data Report for May 09, 2024 1-1-d 0.sr1. Baa i noir m 3al�n m� oayuyn� sn�i�,y mgr wnrrr n�,d wnr� i� is o�:rrurd. KITCHEN E R/WATERLOO ONTARIO Current Station Operator: NAVCAN Latitude: 4327-39.000".N Longitude: 80"22'43.000" W Elevation: 321.60 m C imate ID: 6144239 WMo ID: 71368 TC ID: YKF PreciP. Amount Temu Dew Point Rel Hum MM Wind Dir Wind Sod Visibility, Stn Press Hmdz Wind Chill Weather TIME ,°C °C ^k 10;sdeg kmi.h km kPa LST L L L L L L L 00:00 6.9 6.9 100 0.0 0 16.1 97.27 NA 01:00 5.9 5.9 100 0.0 35 4 9.7 97.28 Fog 02:00 6.8 6.8 100 0.0 1 9 16.1 97.19 NA 03:00 6.8 6.8 100 0.0 1 11 16.1 97.16 NA 04:00 6.0 6.0 100 0.0 2 4 16.1 97.23 NA 05:00 5.2 5.2 100 0.0 1 4 16.1 97.25 NA 06:00 6.7 6.7 100 0.0 3 4 16.1 97.26 NA 07:00 9.5 8.1 91 0.0 6 9 16.1 97.32 NA 08:00 11.9 8.2 78 0.0 6 11 16.1 97.32 NA 09:00 13.6 6.6 62 0.0 8 17 16.1 97.27 NA 10:00 15.1 5.7 53 0.0 5 22 16.1 97.25 NA 11:00 15.4 5.5 51 0.0 5 13 16.1 9721 Rain 12:00 16.3 3.8 43 0.0 3 22 16.1 97.18 NA 13:00 15.6 4.2 46 0.0 7 11 16.1 97.19 NA 14:00 15.3 5.2 51 0.0 6 11 16.1 97.11 NA 15:00 14.2 6.8 61 0.0 11 13 16.1 97.12 NA 16:00 13.8 5.7 58 0.0 11 13 16.1 97.10 NA 17:00 133 4.7 56 0.0 11 13 16.1 97.12 NA 18:00 12.1 5.6 64 0.0 10 9 16.1 97.11 NA 19:00 11.0 6.1 72 0.0 7 5 16.1 97.11 NA 20:00 11.1 4.2 62 0.0 4 5 16.1 97.18 NA 21:00 10.7 43 64 0.0 36 5 16.1 97.22 NA 22:00 9.1 6.7 85 0.0 36 5 16.1 97.19 NA 23:00 9.2 7.1 87 0.0 M 4 16.1 97.21 NA Legend • E = Estimated NA= Nat Available* • M = Missing [empty] =Indicates an unobserved value Date modified: 2024-03-27 Page 116 of 180 Government Gouvernement of Canada du Canada Home > Environment and natural resources > Weather. Climate and Hazard > Past weather and climate > Historical Data Hourly Data Report for May 10, 2024 1-1-d 0.sr1. Baa i noir m 3al�n m� oayuyn� sn�i�,y mgr wnrrr n�,d wnr� i� is o�:rrurd. KITCHEN E R/WATERLOO ONTARIO Current Station Operator: NAVCAN Latitude: 4327-39.000".N Longitude: 80"22'43.000" W Elevation: 321.60 m C imate ID: 6144239 WMo ID: 71368 TC ID: YKF PreciP. Amount Temu Dew Point Rel Hum MM Wind Dir Wind Sod Visibility, Stn Press Hmdz Wind Chill Weather TIME ,°C °C ^k 10;s_d,eg km�h km, kPa LST L L L L L L L 00:00 9.6 6.5 81 0.0 34 8 16.1 97.18 NA 01:00 8.9 5.4 79 0.0 34 8 16.1 97.16 NA 02:00 8.7 4.7 76 0.0 36 11 16.1 97.14 NA 03:00 8.1 4.8 80 0.0 1 5 16.1 97.11 NA 04:00 5.6 5.0 96 0.0 34 5 16.1 97.09 NA 05:00 4.4 3.8 96 0.0 35 4 16.1 97.10 NA 06:00 7.4 53 86 0.0 4 4 16.1 97.15 NA 07:00 9.1 6.1 82 0.0 35 8 16.1 97.14 NA 08:00 10.0 6.2 77 0.0 34 5 16.1 97.14 NA 09:00 11.3 6.6 72 0.0 M 4 16.1 97.18 NA 10:00 12.5 53 61 0.0 7 11 16.1 97.20 NA 11:00 13.7 5.7 58 0.0 6 13 16.1 97.21 NA 12:00 15.4 6.6 56 0.0 M 4 16.1 97.19 NA 13:00 143 5.7 56 0.0 34 9 16.1 97.18 NA 14:00 14.3 5.6 55 0.0 34 11 16.1 97.15 NA 15:00 15.3 5.3 Si 0.0 14 9 16.1 97.13 NA 16:00 13.5 5.6 58 0.0 14 24 16.1 97.14 NA 17:00 14.9 6.0 55 0.0 14 11 16.1 97.14 NA 18:00 14.2 5.0 54 0.0 16 9 16.1 97.14 NA 19:00 13.0 4.2 S5 0.0 14 9 16.1 97.15 NA 20:00 10.3 5.3 71 0.0 15 9 16.1 97.16 NA 21:00 10.8 73 79 0.0 17 9 16.1 97.17 NA 22:00 11.0 6.4 73 0.0 19 8 16.1 97.13 NA 23:00 8.6 5.7 82 0.0 22 4 16.1 97.10 NA Legend • E = Estimated NA= Nat Available* • M = Missing [empty] =Indicates an unobserved value Date modified: 2024-03-27 Page 117 of 180 Government Gouvernement of Canada du Canada Home > Environment and natural resources > Weather. Climate and Hazard > Past weather and climate > Historical Data Hourly Data Report for May 11, 2024 it:1-d 0.sT1.add i nog.t 3dl tro, oayuynr sn�i�,y mgrwnr.r n�,dwnr�i�is o�:rryrd. KITCHEN E R/WATERLOO ONTARIO Current Station Operator: NAVCAN Latitude: 4327-39.000".N Longitude: 80"22'43.000" W Elevation: 321.60 m C imate ID: 6144239 WMo ID: 71368 TC ID: YKF Precip. Amount Temp Dew Paint Rel Hum mm Wind Dir Wind Sud Visibility Stn Press Hmdx Wind Chill Weather TIME °C °C k 10's_deg km/h km kP,a LST L L L L L L L 00:00 7.0 4.3 83 0.0 13 5 16.1 97.09 NA 01:00 6.8 4.5 85 0.0 0 16.1 97.06 NA 02:00 3.5 2.2 91 0.0 0 16.1 97.01 NA 03:00 4.0 4.0 100 0.0 9 4 12.9 96.97 NA 04:00 3.6 3.6 100 0.0 8 5 4.8 96.94 Fog 05:00 4.3 4.3 100 0.0 8 8 16.1 96.91 NA 06:00 6.4 6.4 100 0.0 13 8 16.1 96.88 NA 07:00 9.9 8.0 88 0.0 15 11 16.1 96.83 NA 08:00 12.3 73 71 0.0 16 17 16.1 96.81 NA 09:00 12.2 7.3 72 0.0 14 18 16.1 96.75 NA 10:00 12.4 5.2 61 0.0 18 26 16.1 96.76 NA 11:00 11.7 5.7 66 0.0 16 22 16.1 96.71 NA 12:00 12.2 6.0 66 0.0 17 28 16.1 96.64 NA 13:00 10.6 6.6 76 0.0 17 28 16.1 96.65 Rain 14:00 10.7 8.1 84 0.0 17 21 16.1 96.65 NA 15:00 12.0 8.0 76 0.0 18 18 16.1 96.61 NA 16:00 11.2 8.2 82 0.0 16 11 16.1 96.58 Rain 17:00 10.6 8.s 87 0.0 15 15 16.1 96.60 Rain 18:00 10.6 9.2 91 0.0 15 15 14.5 96.59 NA 19:00 9.8 9.s 98 2.2 10 4 4.8 96.60 Rain, Fog, 20:00 9.5 9.4 99 0.8 5 8 16.1 96.61 NA 21:00 93 9.2 99 2.3 5 15 3.6 96.67 Heavy Rain, Fog, 22:00 8.8 8.7 99 3.8 6 13 16.1 96.70 NA 23:00 8.9 8.6 98 0.0 5 13 12.9 96.74 Rain Legend • E = Estimated NA= Nat Available* • M = Missing [empty] =Indicates an unobserved value Date modified: 2024-03-27 Page 118 of 180 Government Gouvernement of Canada du Canada Home > Environment and natural resources > Weather. Climate and Hazard > Past weather and climate > Historical Data Hourly Data Report for May 12, 2024 1-1-d 0.sr1. Baa i nog. m 3al�n m� oayuynr sn�i�,y mgr wnr.r n�,d wnr� i� is o�:rrurd. KITCHEN E R/WATERLOO ONTARIO Current Station Operator: NAVCAN Latitude: 4327-39.000".N Longitude: 80"22'43.000" W Elevation: 321.60 m C imate ID: 6144239 WMo ID: 71368 TC ID: YKF Precis. Amount Tema Dew Paint Rel Hum mm Wind Dir Wind Sud Visibility Stn Press Hmdx Wind Chill Weather TIME °C °C 96 Mk41g km/h km, kP,d LST L L L L L L L 00:00 9.0 8.7 98 0.2 2 9 16.1 96.78 NA 01:00 9.0 8.7 98 0.0 1 9 9.7 96.80 Rain, Fog 02:00 8.8 8.5 98 0.0 36 13 16.1 96.87 NA 03:00 8.5 8.2 98 0.0 35 9 16.1 96.96 Rain 04:00 7.8 7.4 97 0.0 36 5 16.1 97.00 NA 05:00 7.8 7.8 100 0.0 31 13 16.1 97.10 NA 06:00 7.9 7.6 98 0.0 31 11 16.1 97.19 NA 07:00 9.7 8.1 90 0.0 34 13 16.1 97.24 NA 08:00 10.7 8.4 86 0.0 32 18 16.1 9731 NA 09:00 10.8 7.8 82 0.0 32 21 16.1 9737 NA 10:00 12.0 8.5 79 0.0 34 15 16.1 97.40 NA 11:00 13.9 8.1 68 0.0 31 13 16.1 97.42 NA 12:00 14.1 73 64 0.0 31 11 16.1 97.41 NA 13:00 15.5 73 58 0.0 32 17 16.1 97.41 NA 14:00 16.3 6.6 52 0.0 35 8 16.1 97.41 NA 15:00 16.3 7.9 S7 0.0 26 9 16.1 9738 NA 16:00 16.6 73 54 0.0 26 17 16.1 9738 NA 17:00 17.1 6.8 s0 0.0 28 18 16.1 97.39 NA 18:00 16.0 6.9 55 0.0 24 18 16.1 97.37 NA 19:00 15.0 73 60 0.0 24 15 16.1 9736 NA 20:00 13.9 9.0 72 0.0 22 18 16.1 97.40 NA 21:00 12.5 8.6 77 0.0 19 17 16.1 97.44 NA 22:00 11.2 7.5 78 0.0 20 15 16.1 97.47 NA 23:00 9.8 6.9 82 0.0 19 11 16.1 97.46 NA Legend • E = Estimated NA= Nat Available* • M = Missing [empty] =Indicates an unobserved value Date modified: 2024-03-27 Page 119 of 180 Government Gouvernement of Canada du Canada Home > Environment and natural resources > Weather. Climate and Hazard > Past weather and climate > Historical Data Hourly Data Report for May 13, 2024 1-1-d 0.sr1. Baa i noir m 3al�n m� oayuyn� sn�i�,y mgr wnrrr n�,d wnr� i� is o�:rrurd. KITCHEN E R/WATERLOO ONTARIO Current Station Operator: NAVCAN Latitude: 4327-39.000".N Longitude: 80"22'43.000" W Elevation: 321.60 m C imate ID: 6144239 WMo ID: 71368 TC ID: YKF PreciP. Amount Temu Dew Point Rel Hum MM Wind Dir Wind Sod Visibility, Stn Press Hmdz Wind Chill Weather TIME ,°C °C ^k 10;sdeg kmi.h km kPa LST L L L L L L L 00:00 9.4 6.0 79 0.0 18 13 16.1 97.43 NA 01:00 9.3 5.0 74 0.0 17 13 16.1 97.35 NA 02:00 9.5 5.4 75 0.0 20 11 16.1 97.36 NA 03:00 9.6 6.6 81 0.2 18 13 16.1 97.28 NA 04:00 9.6 7.4 86 0.0 17 11 16.1 97.24 Rain 05:00 10.4 8.0 85 0.0 19 18 16.1 97.23 NA 06:00 10.8 8.4 85 0.0 21 11 16.1 97.28 NA 07:00 11.6 8.7 82 0.0 0 16.1 97.23 NA 08:00 14.3 10.0 75 0.0 18 17 16.1 97.22 NA 09:00 18.0 12.2 68 0.0 22 18 16.1 97.21 NA 10:00 15.6 12.6 82 0.2 20 13 16.1 97.21 Rain 11:00 17.8 13.9 78 0.0 20 17 16.1 97.20 NA 12:00 19.9 13.4 66 0.0 20 15 16.1 97.20 NA 13:00 213 14.7 66 0.0 21 17 16.1 97.17 25 NA 14:00 21.8 14.2 62 0.0 17 26 16.1 97.12 25 NA 15:00 23.0 15.1 61 0.0 19 17 16.1 97.07 27 NA 16:00 24.4 14.6 54 0.0 19 30 16.1 96.99 28 NA 17:00 233 10.9 45 0.0 19 34 16.1 96.98 25 NA 18:00 23.0 10.9 46 0.0 20 32 16.1 97.00 25 NA 19:00 21.8 10.5 48 0.0 22 22 16.1 97.06 NA 20:00 17.6 12.8 73 0.0 33 8 16.1 97.16 NA 21:00 15.8 110 83 0.0 0 16.1 97.20 Rain 22:00 13.5 12.4 93 0.0 36 8 16.1 97.21 NA 23:00 13.4 12.7 96 0.0 33 5 16.1 97.22 NA Legend • E = Estimated NA= Nat Available* • M = Missing [empty] =Indicates an unobserved value Date modified: 2024-03-27 Page 120 of 180 Government Gouvernement of Canada du Canada Home > Environment and natural resources > Weather. Climate and Hazard > Past weather and climate > Historical Data Hourly Data Report for May 14, 2024 1-1-d 0.sr1. Baa i noir m 3al�n m� oayuyn� sn�i�,y mgr wnrrr n�,d wnr� i� is o�:rrurd. KITCHEN E R/WATERLOO ONTARIO Current Station Operator: NAVCAN Latitude: 4327-39.000".N Longitude: 80"22'43.000" W Elevation: 321.60 m C imate ID: 6144239 WMo ID: 71368 TC ID: YKF PreciP. Amount Temu Dew Point Rel Hum MM Wind Dir Wind Sod Visibility, Stn Press Hmdz Wind Chill Weather TIME ,°C °C ^k 10;s_d,eg km�h km, kPa LST L L L L L L L 00:00 13.8 12.8 94 0.0 0 16.1 97.25 NA 01:00 13.0 12.9 99 0.0 M 4 16.1 97.25 NA 02:00 12.6 12.5 99 0.0 7 4 16.1 97.20 NA 03:00 12.8 12.8 100 0.0 M 4 16.1 97.17 NA 04:00 12.9 12.9 100 0.0 M 4 16.1 97.13 NA 05:00 13.3 13.2 99 0.0 0 16.1 97.19 NA 06:00 13.8 13.7 99 0.0 35 9 16.1 97.23 NA 07:00 14.8 14.5 98 0.0 31 5 16.1 97.30 NA 08:00 15.8 14.5 92 0.0 36 8 16.1 97.32 NA 09:00 16.6 14.8 89 0.0 35 8 16.1 97.33 NA 10:00 17.9 14.8 82 0.0 6 5 16.1 97.34 NA 11:00 18.3 14.8 80 0.0 34 13 16.1 97.34 NA 12:00 19.6 15.1 75 0.0 33 15 16.1 97.32 NA 13:00 19.4 12.8 65 0.0 35 13 16.1 97.29 NA 14:00 20.3 12.9 62 0.0 34 15 16.1 97.25 NA 15:00 20.0 10.5 54 0.0 35 18 16.1 97.20 NA 16:00 20.2 10.7 54 0.0 36 15 16.1 97.19 NA 17:00 20.0 10.9 55 0.0 35 15 16.1 97.19 NA 18:00 18.5 10.4 59 0.0 36 13 16.1 9720 NA 19:00 18.0 10.5 61 0.0 36 15 16.1 97.22 NA 20:00 15.8 9.8 67 0.0 8 13 16.1 97.27 NA 21:00 14.0 9.9 76 0.0 3 8 16.1 97.31 NA 22:00 12.7 9.2 79 0.0 4 5 16.1 97.29 NA 23:00 11.9 8.8 81 0.0 36 8 16.1 97.27 NA Legend • E = Estimated NA= Nat Available* • M = Missing [empty] =Indicates an unobserved value Date modified: 2024-03-27 Page 121 of 180 Government Gouvernement of Canada du Canada Home > Environment and natural resources > Weather. Climate and Hazard > Past weather and climate > Historical Data Hourly Data Report for May 15, 2024 1-1-d 0.sr1. Baa i noir m 3al�n m� oayuyn� sn�i�,y mgr wnrrr n�,d wnr� i� is o�:rrurd. KITCHEN E R/WATERLOO ONTARIO Current Station Operator: NAVCAN Latitude: 4327-39.000".N Longitude: 80"22'43.000" W Elevation: 321.60 m C imate ID: 6144239 WMo ID: 71368 TC ID: YKF PreciP. Amount Temu Dew Point Rel Hum MM Wind Dir Wind Sod Visibility, Stn Press Hmdz Wind Chill Weather TIME ,°C °C ^k 10;s_d,eg km�h km, kPa LST L L L L L L L 00:00 11.2 8.1 81 0.0 36 9 16.1 97.25 NA 01:00 11.0 7.0 76 0.0 1 5 16.1 97.23 NA 02:00 10.7 6.2 74 0.0 36 5 16.1 97.22 NA 03:00 9.7 6.4 80 0.0 M 4 16.1 97.18 NA 04:00 9.4 7.5 88 0.0 30 4 16.1 97.16 NA 05:00 10.6 7.5 81 0.0 35 5 16.1 97.15 NA 06:00 11.2 7.4 77 0.0 M 4 16.1 97.18 NA 07:00 13.4 8.1 70 0.0 6 11 16.1 97.20 NA 08:00 14.6 10.0 74 0.0 7 11 16.1 97.22 NA 09:00 15.8 10.8 72 0.0 5 15 16.1 97.24 NA 10:00 17.1 11.7 70 0.0 9 15 16.1 97.26 NA 11:00 17.6 12.8 73 0.0 9 17 16.1 97.25 NA 12:00 19.0 13.9 72 0.0 8 18 16.1 97.23 NA 13:00 19.0 14.0 72 0.0 8 15 16.1 97.22 NA 14:00 20.0 13.4 65 0.0 4 15 16.1 97.20 NA 15:00 21.2 15.4 69 0.0 6 15 16.1 97.17 25 NA 16:00 20.1 14.1 68 0.0 7 17 16.1 97.12 NA 17:00 20.2 13.8 66 0.0 7 18 16.1 97.13 NA 18:00 19.4 14.1 71 0.0 10 21 16.1 97.15 NA 19:00 17.8 13.8 77 0.0 11 13 16.1 97.21 NA 20:00 15.4 13.1 86 0.0 8 8 16.1 97.24 NA 21:00 14.4 11'3 93 0.0 0 16.1 97.29 NA 22:00 12.4 12.3 99 0.0 1 4 16.1 97.34 NA 23:00 12.6 12.3 98 0.0 4 8 16.1 97.32 NA Legend • E = Estimated NA= Nat Available* • M = Missing [empty] =Indicates an unobserved value Date modified: 2024-03-27 Page 122 of 180 Government Gouvernement of Canada du Canada Home > Environment and natural resources > Weather. Climate and Hazard > Past weather and climate > Historical Data Hourly Data Report for May 16, 2024 1-1-d 0.sr1. Baa i noir m 3al�n m� oayuyn� sn�i�,y mgr wnrrr n�,d wnr� i� is o�:rrurd. KITCHEN E R/WATERLOO ONTARIO Current Station Operator: NAVCAN Latitude: 4327-39.000".N Longitude: 80"22'43.000" W Elevation: 321.60 m C imate ID: 6144239 WMo ID: 71368 TC ID: YKF PreciP. Amount Temu Dew Point Rel Hum MM Wind Dir Wind Sod Visibility, Stn Press Hmdz Wind Chill Weather TIME ,°C °C ^k 10;s_d,eg km�h km, kPa LST L L L L L L L 00:00 11.6 11.5 99 0.0 7 8 14.5 97.30 NA 01:00 10.0 10.0 100 0.0 34 4 8.1 97.31 Fog 02:00 10.3 10.3 100 0.0 35 4 9.7 97.32 Fag, 03:00 9.5 9.5 100 0.0 35 5 1.6 97.31 Fag 04:00 8.0 8.0 100 0.0 32 4 0.4 97.30 Fag, 05:00 8.0 8.0 100 0.0 36 4 0.8 97.31 Fag 06:00 9.3 93 100 0.0 29 5 11.3 97.38 NA 07:00 13.0 11.1 88 0.0 5 5 16.1 97.39 NA 08:00 16.5 10.6 68 0.0 5 13 16.1 97.40 NA 09:00 18.1 11.5 65 0.0 M 4 16.1 97.47 NA 10:00 19.5 12.1 62 0.0 6 8 16.1 97.46 NA 11:00 20.4 12.5 60 0.0 M 4 16.1 97.41 NA 12:00 20.3 13.0 63 0.0 8 8 16.1 97.35 NA 13:00 21.1 12.8 59 0.0 M 4 16.1 97.35 NA 14:00 23.0 14.3 58 0.0 13 9 16.1 97.35 27 NA 15:00 22.9 13.1 S4 0.0 14 9 16.1 97.33 26 NA 16:00 22.7 13.7 56 0.0 11 24 16.1 97.29 26 NA 17:00 21.7 13.1 58 0.0 11 15 16.1 97.31 25 NA 18:00 20.6 13.0 61 0.0 13 18 16.1 97.33 NA 19:00 17.9 12.7 71 0.0 12 13 16.1 97.36 NA 20:00 17.0 12.8 76 0.0 13 13 16.1 97.37 NA 21:00 16.1 13.1 82 0.0 13 8 16.1 97.38 NA 22:00 14.3 12.5 89 0.0 6 5 16.1 97.34 NA 23:00 13.1 12.6 97 0.0 1 5 16.1 97.35 NA Legend • E = Estimated NA= Nat Available* • M = Missing [empty] =Indicates an unobserved value Date modified: 2024-03-27 Page 123 of 180 Government Gouvernement of Canada du Canada Home > Environment and natural resources > Weather. Climate and Hazard > Past weather and climate > Historical Data Hourly Data Report for May 17, 2024 1-1-d 0.sr1. Baa i nog. m 3al�n ro, oayuynr sn�i�,y mgr wnr.r n�,d wnr� i� is o�:rrurd. KITCHEN E R/WATERLOO ONTARIO Current Station Operator: NAVCAN Latitude: 4327-39.000".N Longitude: 80"22'43.000" W Elevation: 321.60 m C imate ID: 6144239 WMo ID: 71368 TC ID: YKF P-io. Amount Tema Dew Paint Rel Hum mm Wind Dir Wind Sod Visibility Stn Press Hmdx Wind Chill Weather TIME °,C °C 96 Mk41g km/h km, kP,d LST L L L L L L L 00:00 12.9 12.6 98 0.0 8 9 16.1 97.29 NA 01:00 13.4 12.8 96 0.0 10 4 16.1 97.29 NA 02:00 12.2 12.2 100 0.0 0 16.1 97.32 NA 03:00 11.2 11.2 100 0.0 2 5 11.3 97.32 NA 04:00 11.3 113 100 0.0 M 4 6.4 9730 Fog 05:00 11.4 11.4 100 0.0 0 0.2 9730 Fog, 06:00 12.7 12.7 100 0.0 0 4.8 9734 Fog 07:00 14.4 14.4 100 0.0 10 5 8.1 97.33 Fog, 08:00 15.1 14.5 96 0.0 32 5 113 97.41 NA 09:00 15.8 14.5 92 0.0 11 8 9.7 97.40 Fog, 10:00 16.1 14.5 90 0.0 M 4 9.7 97.44 Fog, 11:00 16.0 15.4 96 0.8 33 11 4.8 97.45 Rain, Fag, 12:00 15.9 15.2 95 1.2 35 8 8.1 97.45 Rain, Fog, 13:00 15.9 15.4 97 1.5 4 8 8.1 97.41 Rain, Fog, 14:00 16.0 15.7 98 1.0 12 22 8.1 97.29 Rain, Fog, 15:00 17.1 14.9 87 0.2 M 4 16.1 9732 NA 16:00 18.4 15.9 85 0.0 10 11 16.1 9732 NA 17:00 17.9 15.4 85 0.0 11 11 16.1 97.31 NA 18:00 17.5 15.4 87 0.0 9 15 16.1 97.30 NA 19:00 16.3 15.4 94 0.0 10 15 12.9 97.33 NA 20:00 15.3 14.7 96 0.0 10 13 16.1 9738 NA 21:00 15.2 14.7 97 0.0 9 11 16.1 97.41 NA 22:00 14.8 14.5 98 0.0 7 9 16.1 97.42 NA 23:00 13.6 13.6 100 0.0 9 11 16.1 9736 NA Legend • E = Estimated NA= Nat Available* • M = Missing [empty] =Indicates an unobserved value Date modified: 2024-03-27 Page 124 of 180 Staff Report Community Services Department www.kitchener.ca REPORT TO: Finance and Corporate Services Committee DATE OF MEETING: September 16, 2024 SUBMITTED BY: Gloria MacNeil, Director of Enforcement, 519-741-2200 ext. 7952 PREPARED BY: Gloria MacNeil, Director of Enforcement, 519-741-2200 ext. 7952 WARD(S) INVOLVED: All DATE OF REPORT: August 29, 2024 REPORT NO.: CSD -2024-391 SUBJECT: NOISE EXEMPTION — K -W OKTOBERFEST RECOMMENDATION: That an exemption to Chapter 450 (Noise) of the City of Kitchener Municipal Code be granted to K -W Oktoberfest Inc. for a series of events being held at various clubs between September 27 through October 19, 2024, as outlined in the letter from K -W Oktoberfest Inc., dated August 9, 2024 attached to Report CSD -2024-391 REPORT HIGHLIGHTS: • The purpose of this report is to seek a blanket noise exemption for K -W Oktoberfest which will be held at various club locations throughout the city. • Oktoberfest celebrations will take place over a three-week span from September 27 thru October 19, 2024 • This report supports the delivery of core services. BACKGROUND: K -W Oktoberfest Inc. is requesting an exemption to Chapter 450 (Noise) of the City's Municipal Code for a series of Oktoberfest events being held during the 2024 Oktoberfest festivities. A copy of their request is attached. REPORT: The number of noise complaints relating to these events over the past several years has been minimal. Typically, there appears to be a large degree of acceptance by City residents to these events, given their vast popularity and broad community benefits. The level of cooperation that staff has received from event organizers has been positive. STRATEGIC PLAN ALIGNMENT: This report supports the delivery of core services. *** This information is available in accessible formats upon request. *** Please call 519-741-2345 or TTY 1-866-969-9994 for assistance. Page 125 of 180 FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS: N/A COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT: Oktoberfest events are widely advertised throughout the entire community. APPROVED BY: Michael May, DCAO ATTACHMENTS: Attachment A — Request Letter from K -W Oktoberfest Inc. Page 126 of 180 2 King Street West, Kitchener, ON N2G 1A3 Tel (519) 570-4267 infoCa)oktoberfest.ca www.oktoberfest.ca City of Kitchener PO Box 1118, 200 King Street West Kitchener, ON N2G 4G7 ATTENTION: Gloria MacNeil, Director of Enforcement SUBJECT: Blanket Noise By -Law Exemption aliffGHERFEST. TCHENER • WATERLOO Canada's Greatest Bavarian Festival August 9, 2024 As per our request for the 2024 Festival, we are herewith requesting a blanket exemption from the Municipal By Law governing noise for the duration of K -W Oktoberfest which officially runs from September 27 to October 19, 2024. K -W Oktoberfest has been designated an event of "municipal significance" and as such would respectfully request a little latitude in the enforcement of municipal law on certain days involving a limited number of festival facilities. This is our best guess at what the schedule may look like for this upcoming Festival: Alpine Club (Habsburg Haus), 464 Maple Avenue Bingemans, 425 Bingemans Centre Drive Concordia Club, 429 Ottawa St. Schwaben Club, 50 Scheifele Place Willkommen Platz in downtown Kitchener Oct 11, 12, 14, 16, 18, 19 Sept. 27, 28 & Oct. 4, 5, 11, 12 Oct. 11, 12, 13, 14, 16, 17, 18, 19 Tent & Indoor Oct. 4, 5, 6, 11 ,12, 13, 18, 19 October 11, 12, 13 Tent & Outdoor We trust that this request will meet with the approval of the Council of the City of Kitchener and that we will be advised of this consideration accordingly. Respectfully, K -W OKTOBERFEST INC. �j ( vo-A(�� Tracy Van Kalsbeek Executive Director Page 127 of 180 Staff Report r NJ :R Development Services Department www.kitchener.ca REPORT TO: Finance and Corporate Services Committee DATE OF MEETING: September 16, 2024 SUBMITTED BY: Anna Marie Cipriani, Corporate Sustainability Officer, 519-741-2200 ext. 7322 PREPARED BY: Anna Marie Cipriani, Corporate Sustainability Officer, 519-741-2200 ext. 7322 WARD(S) INVOLVED: ALL DATE OF REPORT: August 27, 2024 REPORT NO.: DSD -2024-395 SUBJECT: Execution of Agreements with Youth Climate Action Fund (YCAF) Grant Recipients RECOMMENDATION: That the City's Chief Administrative Officer and General Managers be authorized to execute agreements with recipients of grants under the Youth Climate Action Fund, said agreements to be to the satisfaction of the City Solicitor. BACKGROUND/REPORT: The City received funding in the amount of $50,000 USD from the Rockefeller Philanthropy Advisors, on behalf of its sponsored project the Youth Climate Action Fund (YCAF), to administer microgrants (each valued between $1,000 and $5,000 USD) to youth aged 15 to 24 in respect of designing, producing, and overseeing urgent climate solutions. The City must now enter agreements with the successful YCAF microgrant applicants, for which delegated authority is being sought. STRATEGIC PLAN ALIGNMENT: This report supports Cultivating a Green City Together: Focuses a sustainable path to a greener, healthier city; enhancing & protecting parks & natural environment while transitioning to a low -carbon future; supporting businesses & residents to make climate -positive choices. FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS: None COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT: INFORM — This report has been posted to the City's website with the agenda in advance of the council / committee meeting. PREVIOUS REPORTS/AUTHORITIES: None APPROVED BY: Justin Readman, General Manager, Development Services *** This information is available in accessible formats upon request. *** Please call 519-741-2345 or TTY 1-866-969-9994 for assistance. Page 128 of 180 J Staff Report I T iE F -R Finance and Corporate Services Department www kitchener ca REPORT TO: Finance and Corporate Services Committee DATE OF MEETING: September 16, 2024 SUBMITTED BY: Greg St. Louis, Director, Gas & Water Utilities, 519-741-2600 ext. 4538 PREPARED BY: Khaled Abu-Eseifan, Manager, Gas Supply and Engineering, 519-741- 2600 ext. 4826 WARD(S) INVOLVED: Ward(s) DATE OF REPORT: September 2, 2024 REPORT NO.: INS -2024-383 SUBJECT: 2024/2025 Natural Gas Rates RECOMMENDATION: That the supply component of the natural gas rate be increased to 13.13 cents per cubic meter from 11.63 cents per cubic meter for system gas customers of Kitchener Utilities effective November 1, 2024; and, That the proposed Supply Rate Policy as detailed in report INS -2024-383 — Attachment A to change supply rates quarterly starting from January 1, 2025, through council delegated authority be approved; and further; That Kitchener Utilities' natural gas variable and fixed delivery rates be approved as proposed in report INS -2024-383 - Attachment B, for all Kitchener delivery customers effective January 1, 2025. REPORT HIGHLIGHTS: • The purpose of this report is to provide an update and recommendations for the natural gas supply and delivery rates of Kitchener Utilities for the remainder of 2024 and 2025 and to propose a new process to quarterly change the supply rate in 2025 and beyond. • The key finding of this report is that the supply rate is recommended to increase from 11.63 cents per cubic meter to 13.13 cents per cubic meter stating November 1, 2024. The report also recommends changing the supply rate quarterly starting from January 1, 2025, by following the proposed Supply Rate Policy in Attachment A. The delivery rates are recommended to change as per Attachment B with effect from January 1, 2025. • The financial implications of the delivery rates change to Kitchener Utilities residential customers will be an increase of approximately $10.30 annually or 2.1 %. The supply rate increase will have an impact of $30 annually or 13% to Kitchener Utilities system gas average residential customer. • This report supports the delivery of core services. *** This information is available in accessible formats upon request. *** Please call 519-741-2345 or TTY 1-866-969-9994 for assistance. Page 129 of 180 BACKGROUND: Kitchener Utilities (KU) is committed to delivering natural gas using a rate setting approach that focuses on supply rate stability for our customers. We follow the Council endorsed Gas Purchase Policy for the procurement of natural gas. The policy outlines how much of our natural gas portfolio can be purchased in advance and on the spot market. It provides the ability to blend our natural gas rate with fixed and market price natural gas. The blending of fixed and market price natural gas is used to reduce volatility in prices to keep rates stable for customers. It is also used to respond to significant changes in market prices within a reasonable time frame. Although this feature is designed to soften spikes in market prices and provide longer range rate stability, it does not protect against rate shocks that usually follows a delayed response to changing market conditions. Other natural gas utilities, regulated by the Ontario Energy Board, purchase natural gas on the market and adjust rates quarterly, due to the volatility of natural gas. This strategy provides rates that are more reflective of market prices, but also includes more frequent rate fluctuations. In this report, Kitchener Utilities proposes changes to optimise supply rate adjustment process along with changes to supply and delivery rates based on updated market conditions and 2025 budget requirements. The last natural gas supply rate change was in May 2024. At that time, the supply rate was decreased with a plan to review the prices more frequently due to the anticipated volatility in forward market prices. Kitchener Utilities is in a very good storage position and the proposed changes aim to timely adjust rates to benefit customers, avoid significant rate spikes and support rate stability. REPORT: Kitchener Utilities natural gas rates have two components: gas supply, and gas delivery. The gas supply program is responsible for the purchase of the gas commodity and transportation of natural gas to Kitchener customers and is a pass-through cost program. The delivery program is responsible for delivery of natural gas to customers. This includes billing, meter reading, capital, maintenance, and operating costs of the distribution system. The following are key highlights of this natural gas rate change report: • Natural gas supply rate increases for system gas customers. • A proposal for a new process to change the supply rate in the future to increase market responsiveness, reduce rate shock, and mitigate rate spikes. • Delivery rate increases as proposed in Attachment B. Gas Supply Rate: The natural gas supply program is a pass-through program. The rules around what is included in the supply rate are governed by Ontario Energy Board (OEB). Although Kitchener Utilities are not required to seek OEB approval to change their rates, they are required to abide by OEB rules and regulations about how to allocate costs and how to manage distribution services. Only the cost of gas commodity, transportation and related costs can be included in the supply rate. These costs have to be reviewed frequently and savings, or losses have to be passed directly to customers as the program operates as non-profit. The supply rate is calculated based on costs required to acquire the gas and the forecasted gas volumes to be delivered to customers. The gas volumes are weather dependant and the natural gas commodity market prices usually fluctuate with supply, demand, and weather factors. Page 130 of 180 To mitigate market price fluctuations, Kitchener Utilities relies on its purchasing policy to create a blended portfolio of hedging (fixed price contracts) and market price purchases. Kitchener Utilities sets limits on the percentage of hedging within the portfolio to minimize the risks of, "out of the money", contracts and maintain market responsiveness. Along with the purchase policy, KU also uses the stabilization reserve to absorb sudden market price increases and soften rate spikes. However, with increased volatility in market prices and consecutive mild winters, Kitchener Utilities made frequent supply rate adjustments in the last couple of years to ensure that stabilization reserve balance remains within policy threshold without the need to increase the hedging percentage of the portfolio. In 2024, supply rates were set based on normal winter consumption and average market prices forecasts. The 2024 winter was very mild resulting in high storage balances and actual market prices dropped significantly. Kitchener Utilities staff managed to secure very low-priced deals for considerable amount of gas; however, the high storage levels reduced the ability to buy more lower priced gas. Kitchener Utilities was able to reduce the supply rate in May 2024 by more than 30% to pass back the saving to customers. However, assuming normal weather conditions for the coming winter of 2024/2025, and average forward market prices indicate the need to increase the supply rate significantly in 2025. To reduce rate shock to customers, implementing smaller more frequent changes to rates will help support delivering rate stability to customers compared to one or two large rate adjustments per year. This approach provides the following benefits: • Reduces rate shock: The impact of each rate change would be smaller as more frequent rate changes improve overall rate stability and support affordability for customers. • Increases market responsiveness: frequent rate changes allow rates to follow market prices more closely and reduce the need for hedging. Although hedging provides price stability, it comes with a premium and the risk of, "out of the money", deals in decreasing market conditions. • Improves financial planning: external factors such as weather conditions or market prices can be addressed quicker with frequent rate changes reducing the impact of uncertainty on closing balances and future budgets. • Aligns with OEB policies and practices followed by rate regulated gas utilities as will as the approach followed by Utilities Kingston. Following a planned supply rate adjustment in November 2024, KU staff plan to follow a defined quarterly supply rate adjustment schedule. The supply rates will be changed if needed at the following dates of each year: • January 1St • April 1st • July 1st, and, • October 1 st Kitchener Utilities staff is also proposing modifications to the supply rate change process to streamline the process and allow the quarterly rate changes to be completed on schedule with reasonable efficiency and oversight. Page 131 of 180 Supply Rate Change Process: Enbridge Gas follows the OEB process to review and change their supply rate quarterly. The OEB have created a mechanistic process that allows for oversight and provides approvals in timely manner with minimal intervention. In addition, Utilities Kingston utilizes a similar process to obtain automatic approval from City of Kingston council to change their supply rate quarterly through delegated authority of staff to adjust supply rates quarterly. Kitchener Utilities is proposing a similar approach to delegate authority to staff to adjust the gas supply rate quarterly. In the event of a supply rate change, Kitchener Utilities staff will notify council members by e-mail at least 2 weeks before the implementation date of the supply rate change. The new delegated authority process would: • Authorize CFO or their designate to approve rate change. • Ensure that supply gas rates are reviewed and updated quarterly inline with industry practices. • Provide more timely benefit to customers in decreasing prices conditions and avoid rate shock during increasing times. • Maintain transparency and timely communications with customers, stakeholders, and Council members. KU staff are proposing a new policy that details the new process. The proposed policy is available in Attachment A. In summary, staff recommend the following: • Increase the supply rate from 11.63 cents per cubic meter to 13.13 cents per cubic meter effective November 1St, 2024; • Adopt a quarterly supply rate change approach starting from January 1St, 2025, and; • Implement a delegated authority policy to approve future supply rate changes as detailed in the proposed policy in Attachment A. Figure 1 below shows historical and forecasted supply rate changes for Kitchener Utilities compared with market prices and Enbridge rates. The forward market prices are provided by KU's consultants. These consultants are natural gas subject matter experts who are hired to provide natural gas market analysis, forecasts forward market price, gas models and assist in purchasing KU's natural gas portfolio. Page 132 of 180 30.0 45.D 40.0 35.0 30.0 E 25.0 � zD.D 15.0 10.0 5.0 0.0 NG Market Price vs KU Gas Rate vs Enbridge Gas Rate Kt! Gas Rate - tents per m3 ----Enbridge Gas rate - tents per m3 -Market Figure 1: Natural gas supply rates comparison. Gas Delivery: There are two components to the delivery charges: a daily fixed charge, and a variable rate. There are four Delivery Rate Groups: M1, M2, M4 and M5, (complete definitions are in Appendix B). These rates service customers of different volumetric requirements. The gas delivery revenues fund all Kitchener Utilities operating and capital programs in addition to the cost of Enbridge's T3 contract with KU. However, these revenues are weather dependant as mild winters reduces gas sales. Kitchener Utilities relies on delivery stabilization reserve to mitigate the impacts of weather on gas revenues. Changes to delivery rates are typically required at least once a year to absorb cost inflation and to fund new programs or requirements. For 2025, the new programs costs are offset by savings resulting from the successful intervening by KU staff in the Enbridge rate application before the OEB. That rate application proposed significant rate increases to Kitchener Utilities T3 contract which were denied by the OEB. KU staff is recommending a small increase to all delivery rate components in all rate groups starting January 1St, 2025. The changes vary between 2% to 3% for the majority of customers (M1 and M2 customers). These changes are needed to maintain the delivery stabilization reserve at a reasonable balance to mitigate the impacts of mild winters. The proposed fixed and variable rates for all rate groups are available in Attachment B. Comparison with Enbridge: Comparison to Enbridge rates cannot be completed at this time as Enbridge supply and delivery rates for 2025 have not been announced yet. Historically, Kitchener Utilities considered Enbridge rates during the rate setting process as it relates to competitiveness and affordability Page 133 of 180 considerations. Kitchener Utilities is expected to continue to do so even with moving to a more frequent supply rate setting approach. STRATEGIC PLAN ALIGNMENT: This report supports the delivery of core services. FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS: The planned delivery rate increase will bring the stabilization reserve to a reasonable balance within the thresholds to mitigate weather factors on revenues. The delivery rate increase will also increase the capital stabilization reserve. However, the capital stabilization reserve remains significantly below the minimum threshold. The 5 -year operating budget projection (as of August 23, 2024), for gas delivery is presented in Attachment C. The planned delivery rate increase will have an impact of $10.30 per year or 2.1 % on Kitchener Utilities average M1 residential customer. The planned increase to supply rate is forecasted to grow the supply stabilization reserve over the maximum threshold in 2024; however, it still required to mitigate rate shock to customers in 2025. The plan is to maintain the supply stabilization reserve within the thresholds by the end of 2025 using quarterly adjustments, as required. The 5 -year operating budget projection (as of August 23, 2024), for gas supply is presented in Attachment D. The impact of the planned increase to the supply rate to Kitchener Utilities system gas average residential customers will be around $30 per year or 13%. Kitchener Utilities supports the Waterloo Region Energy Assistance Program. This program offers support to customers facing challenges paying their utility bills. The program is administered by the Region of Waterloo and offers support for both electricity and natural gas bills. COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT: INFORM — This report has been posted to the City's website with the agenda in advance of the council / committee meeting. Kitchener Utilities will work with the Corporate Communications and Marketing Division to ensure that the rate change details are included in the Council Key Decisions media brief. A bill insert will be distributed with utility bills along with posting information about the change on the Kitchener Utilities' and City websites. Future supply rate changes will be posted on the Kitchener Utilities' and City websites along with bill message on the utility bills. A public notice will also be placed in the paper. PREVIOUS REPORTS/AUTHORITIES: • INS 2023-247 Natural gas Purchase Policy Review -2023 • INS -2023-334 2023-2024 Natural gas Supply and Delivery Rates • INS -2024-168 2024 Natural gas Supply rate Change 1 Page 134 of 180 APPROVED BY: Denise McGoldrick, General Manager Infrastructure Services. ATTACHMENTS: Attachment A — Gas Supply Rates Policy Attachment B — Natural Gas Rates Attachment C — 5 -year operating budget projection — Gas Delivery Attachment D — 5 -year operating budget projection — Gas Supply Page 135 of 180 1 POLICY Policy No: XX Policy Title: GAS SUPPLY RATES Approval Date: Click here to enter a date. Policy Type: COUNCIL Reviewed Date: September 2024 Category: FinanceNext Review Date: September 2029 Sub -Category: Acquisitions & Dispositions Reviewed Date: Ack here to enter text. Last Amended: Click hereto enter a Author: Manager, Gas Supply and Engineering date. Replaces: Click here to enter text. Dept/Div: Infrastructure Services/Gas and Water Utilities Repealed: Click here to enter a date. Replaced by: Click here to enter text. Related Policies, Procedures and/or Guidelines: FIN-ACQ-560 and FIN -RES -770 1. POLICY PURPOSE: The purpose of this policy is to define the process to review and approve the change to natural gas supply rates for Kitchener Utilities System Gas customers. 2. DEFINITIONS: • Council: City of Kitchener Council. • Gas Supply Program: The program responsible for the purchase of the gas commodity and transportation of natural gas to Kitchener Utilities System Gas customers. It is a pass-through cost program. o Gas Commodity Purchase: the cost of purchasing the natural gas volumes. o Gas Transportation: the cost to move the gas from production location to storage facilities in Ontario. • Gas Supply Rate: Kitchener Utilities volumetric rate to recover the costs of the Gas Supply Program in Canadian dollars per cubic meter. • Kitchener Utilities System Gas Customers: Customers who purchase their gas from Kitchener Utilities at the defined gas supply rate. • KU: Kitchener Utilities. • OEB: Ontario Energy Board. 1 of 3 Page 136 of 180 Policy No: Policy Title: GAS SUPPLY RATES • Pass -Through program: a non-profit program where the costs are passed directly to customers without markups or subsidies. For the gas supply program, only costs related to the purchase and transportation of gas are included in the program and passed through to customers. • Staff: Kitchener Utilities Staff. • Stabilization Reserve: The gas supply stabilization reserve is a financial reserve where budget variances are accumulated or withdrawn. Supply stabilization reserve is governed by City of Kitchener financial policy FIN - RES -770 3. SCOPE: This policy applies to the Natural Gas Supply Program and the setting of Natural Gas Supply Rate for Kitchener Utilities System Gas customers. 4. POLICY CONTENT: 1. Kitchener Utilities (KU) staff shall follow the Council endorsed Gas Purchase Policy # FIN-ACQ-560 for the procurement of natural gas. 2. Staff would review the forward market prices provided by the consultant and the impact on projected stabilization reserve balance every quarter. 3. Staff shall recommend supply rate adjustments based on the projected stabilization reserve balance by the end of the fiscal year. The supply rate adjustment shall ensure that the projected stabilization reserve balance remains within the defined thresholds. 4. Rates would be adjusted on 1St January, 1St April, 1St July, and 1St October. 5. Proposed rates shall be approved by Council through delegated authority. 6. City of Kitchener Chief Financial Officer (CFO) or designates will approve the rates on behalf of the Council. 2 of 3 Page 137 of 180 POLICY APPLIES TO THE FOLLOWING: ❑ All Employees ❑ All Full -Time Employees ❑ All Union ❑ Management ❑ C.U.P.E. 68 Civic ❑ Non Union ❑ C.U.P.E. 68 Mechanics ❑ Temporary ❑ C.U.P.E. 791 ❑ Student ❑ I.B.E.W.636 ❑ Part -Time Employees ❑ K.P.F.F.A. ❑ Specified Positions only: ❑ Other: ❑x Council ❑ Local Boards & Advisory Committees This policy applies to the Natural Gas Supply Program and the setting of Natural Gas Supply Rate for Kitchener Utilities System Gas customers. 4. POLICY CONTENT: 1. Kitchener Utilities (KU) staff shall follow the Council endorsed Gas Purchase Policy # FIN-ACQ-560 for the procurement of natural gas. 2. Staff would review the forward market prices provided by the consultant and the impact on projected stabilization reserve balance every quarter. 3. Staff shall recommend supply rate adjustments based on the projected stabilization reserve balance by the end of the fiscal year. The supply rate adjustment shall ensure that the projected stabilization reserve balance remains within the defined thresholds. 4. Rates would be adjusted on 1St January, 1St April, 1St July, and 1St October. 5. Proposed rates shall be approved by Council through delegated authority. 6. City of Kitchener Chief Financial Officer (CFO) or designates will approve the rates on behalf of the Council. 2 of 3 Page 137 of 180 Policy No: Policy Title: GAS SUPPLY RATES 7. Staff shall notify the Council by e-mail at least two weeks prior to effective rate change date. 8. An information report will be brought forward annually during the budget process summarizing supply rates from the previous year and include projections for potential rate changes for the upcoming year. 9. Staff shall advise KU customers through regular communication options such as KU website, public notice, and bill message. 10. Staff shall inform OEB with proposed rate. 5. HISTORY OF POLICY CHANGES NA 3 of 3 Page 138 of 180 Attachment B CORPORATION OF THE CITY OF KITCHENER NATURAL GAS GENERAL SERVICE RATE M1 Applicability To residential and non -contract commercial and industrial customers that consume less than 50,000 m3 per year. Rate Daily Fixed Charge And S.7800 SUPPLY COMMODITY VARIABLE DE LIVERY NET RATE ¢/m3 ¢/m3 ¢/m3 13.1300 10.8871 24.0171 Meter Readines Gas consumption by each customer under this rate schedule shall be determined by periodic meter readings, provided that in circumstances beyond the control of the Corporation, such as strikes or non -access to a meter, The Corporation may estimate the monthly consumption between the meter readings and render a monthly bill to the customer. Effective November 1, 2024 for Supply rate. To change quarterly thereafter, as necessary. January 1, 2025 for Delivery rate. Policy Relating to Terms of Service 1) Gas purchased under this rate schedule shall not be resold, directly or indirectly by the customer, unless resold as "motor vehicle fuel gas", as that term is defined in Ontario Regulation 805/82. 2) Customers who temporarily discontinue service during any twelve consecutive months without payment of the monthly fixed charge for the months in which the gas is temporarily disconnected shall pay for disconnection and reconnection. Page 139 of 180 CORPORATION OF THE CITY OF KITCHENER NATURAL GAS GENERAL SERVICE RATE — M2 Applicability To residential and non -contract commercial and industrial customers that consume 50,000 m3 and more per year. Rate Daily Fixed Charge And $2.4700 SUPPLY COMMODITY VARIABLE DELIVERY NET RATE RATE ¢/m3 ¢/m3 ¢/m3 13.1300 9.6523 22.7823 Meter Readines Gas consumption by each customer under this rate schedule shall be determined by periodic meter readings, provided that in circumstances beyond the control of the Corporation, such as strikes or non -access to a meter, The Corporation may estimate the monthly consumption between the meter readings and render a monthly bill to the customer. Effective November 1, 2024 for Supply rate. To change quarterly thereafter, as necessary. January 1, 2025 for Delivery rate. Policy Relating to Terms of Service 2) Gas purchased under this rate schedule shall not be resold, directly or indirectly by the customer, unless resold as "motor vehicle fuel gas", as that term is defined in Ontario Regulation 805/82. 3) Customers who temporarily discontinue service during any twelve consecutive months without payment of the monthly fixed charge for the months in which the gas is temporarily disconnected shall pay for disconnection and reconnection. Page 140 of 180 CORPORATION OF THE CITY OF KITCHENER NATURAL GAS FIRM INDUSTRIAL AND COMMERCIAL CONTRACT RATE — M4 Applicability To a customer who A. Enters into a contract for a minimum term of one year, that specifies a daily contracted demand (CD) between 2,400 m3 and 140,870 m3 incluside Rate 1. Bills will be rendered monthly and shall be the total of i) A Fixed Demanc ii) A Variable Deli iii) A Monthly Gas Charge: First 8,450 m3 of the daily contracted demand, 70.9000 ¢/m3 Next 19,700 m3 of the daily contracted demand, 32.8000 ¢/m3 All m3 over 28,150m' of the daily contracted demand, 16.8000 ¢/m3 very Charge (incl. storage): First 422,250 m3 delivered per month 2.0000 ¢/m3 Next volume equal to 15 days use of CD 2.0000 ¢/m3 Remainder of volumes delivered in the month 2.0000 ¢/m3 2. Over -run Charge Authorized overrun gas is available provided that it is authorized by the Corporation in advance. The Corporation will not unreasonably withhold authorization. Overrun means gas taken on any day in excess of 103% of contracted daily demand. Authorized overrun will be available April I through October 31, and will be paid for at the rate of 4.5813 ¢/m3 for the delivery and, if applicable, the federal carbon charge and the total gas supply rate of 13.13 ¢/m3. Unauthorized overrun in any month shall be paid for at the rate of 10.8871 ¢/m3 for the delivery and, if applicable, the federal carbon charge and the total gas supply charge for system -supplied volumes at the rate of 13.13 ¢/m3. 3. Minimum Annual Charge In each contract year, the customer shall purchase from the Corporation or pay for a minimum volume of gas equivalent to 150 days use of contracted demand. Overrun gas volumes will not contribute to the minimum volume. In the event that the customer shall not take such minimum volume, the customer shall pay an amount equal to the deficiency from the minimum volume times a rate of 2.497 ¢/m3 for the delivery charge and if applicable, a total gas supply charge of 13.13 ¢/m3. In the event that the contract period exceeds one year, the annual minimum volume will be pro -rated for any part year. Effective November 1, 2024 for Supply rate. To change quarterly thereafter, as necessary. January 1, 2025 for Delivery rate. Policy Relating to Terms of Service Gas purchased under this rate shall not be resold, directly or indirectly by the customer. Page 141 of 180 CORPORATION OF THE CITY OF KITCHENER NATURAL GAS INTERRUPTIBLE INDUSTRIAL AND COMMERCIAL CONTRACT RATE — M5 Applicability To a customer who: A) Enters into a contract for a minimum term of one year that specifies a daily contracted demand (CD) between 2,400 m3 and 140,870 m3 inclusive and, B) Has an alternate fuel supply and combustion system available. Rate 1. The price of all gas delivered shall be determined on the basis of the following schedules: i) Monthly Fixed Charge $775.00 a. and ii) Delivery Charge (incl. storage): Dailv Contracted Demand Level (CD 2,400 m3 < CD < 17,000 m3 3.5539 ¢/m3 17,000 m3 < CD < 30,000 m3 2.7611 ¢/m3 30,000 m3 < CD < 50,000 m3 2.6859 ¢/m3 50,000 m3 < CD < 70,000 m3 2.6332 ¢/m3 70,000 m3 < CD < 100,000 m3 2.5955 ¢/m3 100,000 m3 < CD < 140,870 m3 1 2.5584 ¢/m3 iii) A Monthly Gas Supply Charge: Supply Commodity 13.1300 ¢/m3 2. Over -run Charge Overrun gas is available provided that it is authorized by the Corporation in advance. The Corporation will not unreasonably withhold authorization. Overrun means gas taken on any day in excess of 105% of contracted daily demand. Unauthorized overrun gas taken in any month shall be paid for at the rate of 10.8871 ¢/m3 for the delivery and, if applicable, the federal carbon charge and the total gas supply charge for system -supplied volumes at the rate of 13.13 ¢/m3. Unauthorized Overrun Non -Compliance Rate: Unauthorized overrun gas taken any month during a period when a notice of interruption is in effect shall be paid for at the rate of 234.72 ¢/m3 ($60 per GJ) for the delivery. 3. Minimum Annual Charge In each contract year, the customer shall purchase from the Corporation or pay for a minimum volume of gas equivalent to 150 days use of contracted demand. Overrun volumes will not contribute to the minimum volume. In the event that the customer shall not take such minimum volume, the customer shall pay an amount equal to the deficiency from the minimum volume multiplied by 4.0299 ¢/m3 for the delivery charge and if applicable, a gas supply charge of 13.13 ¢/m3. Effective November 1, 2024 for Supply rate. To change quarterly thereafter, as necessary. January 1, 2025 for Delivery rate. Policy Relating to Terms of Reference Gas purchased under this rate shall not be resold, directly or indirectly by the customer. Page 142 of 180 �+ a n Ln N lO lO O \ 00 � n pO,p N N N ('n Ln Ln I� N Ol -Zt y C O n m 1p lO o N o0 00 3 N m rn m Ln H riLn N LO Lr) N N Ln c -I c -I c�-I -1 -1 co m rn�\ o. m Ln \ m rn n pOp n Ol n rz' m n Ln n Ln -Zt y CN -1 O O1 Ln Ln ry .--i o0 3 N m 0 Ln 00c N 41 f0 O co Lu (7 W ^' V/ a s N N Ln c -I N cm -I c�-I n Ln LO Ol �N n .–I 0 \ m N n U N O In W Om N a 0 = 0 LLnn LSO lip W Ln d O d W N LL 0OC O O a! N v > v v -O m Ln N �- O N Ln -1 -1 Q O N N -1 c�-I c�-I o c7 LO Ln � n N z � Ol yW N O- ry O N 00 00 m LO O Ln 00 m m 0 m .� 1p Ln .� m N LO 00 W 3 N N l0 v M co Ln m m Ln N N Ln c�-I -1 -- cn-I -1 c�-I i+ M d N r, n ri n N y N to O N Ln Ln Ol � 0 Ln 00 n an N O r7 m o0 3 NOl m -1 n Ln Lr) c -I I< Ln LO Lr) ci M N N Ln -1 c -I m n ry c -I c -I c -I M I� Ol N Ln n n M �° 1O m Ln O ^ ice+ a N lO lO �N' N m Ln N m n V N m m Ol to n O 11 to LO O N D N LO L Lr M � n n rn O m o0 Q N 00 00 Ol t I Ln c -I m C} Ol Lr)O. a? .--� N lO •--� •--� M ry •--� -1 •--� �+ a n n O m n N N n y H o' o� V 0 LO n nn o O� oho 3 N Ol N lO r} -zt O ry zt LO Ln O Z O O V co M O W � O o. C W _ �+ Cl Y_ 00 en 0 Ln 00c N 41 f0 O U Lu (7 W ^' V/ a s a d n1 N J z W H ~N lO N � Lnn _ cc i +� o m +� o f0 O O In W N C:, = C 0 = O H RE O ? O .d d O d Y w '6 LL 0OC O a! a! N v > v v -O ! N W O 0 v �- O N N Q O N co to n Ln v c7 Ln o c7 cD 0 (D z o O co O m _ ^ O en 0 Ln 00c N Ol n Ln n ^' V/ a s CI N Ol � N ",� N Ol m lO N � Lnn LL N n ^ N O N n .-I m ^ M N Ln M M LO Ln Ln m -, N m N 00 N 00 m co to n Ln Ln '^ M N O Ln 00 m m I� W O m m Lo M W N Ln n n ~ N l0 v M m Ol m LNn a Ln N -- O to Ln n r ri n N N N Ol N N m n N n a N Ln n Ol c�-I N^ Ln N to n Ln n r M N Ln n NN ci M m lO O N m n Ln m N p I� Ol N Ln n n M �° 1O m Ln O ^ m Ol t N N ° m Ln N Ln Ln Lr F n N n N N lO M M N LO N m Ln n M l0 m Ln N m N m N 00 Ol a? m M 00 N N LLnn -ztO Ol M M N m '-' M � n m pNj 0 to O N in N m Ln � M N M N � N N 00 � Ol Ol O N ^ Y Y N N u u V V a) a) i i O O � ? O u > > a) C 0C a) Na! a! to O Q a! ha > t0 z > a! -O C N O N 4% o O 'Y 0 Ln — ++ LL W = Q N w x p O Ln to Q x p Ln v f0 7 a) - — v 0 z •� Y – Y Y VI (n N W O a) Y_ Y T5 a) r W =5Q V n1 E LL Y O =5N O. O N a! N O > W a! N 0 a! L X\ G. Z OO r V V u � u O V 2 O V C Nm m W n1 N m m c C ,+�_+ v E W c m C ai a V m � � >� J Y tw E E l]a •� '-u U Y E f6 m C E d v o o c xa v o 0 0 cxo Z* O Vf O Q Q V V O Q Q Q V d bJD N 3 O m N bJD d N N 3 O m N d bJD N 3 O m N w d C4 bJD N O m N M d N O p N a bJDd a N m N n Ln 0 aO SD Ln p Ol Ol -, m m r` r.l m rn o p SD r` l0 l0 00 00 `" f m m �o �oI �o m op 00 O r` r 06 ziN m m N N �Mum, � � O O m O rrj tvf m �- N m rn m a a D Ol N N m m �- 0 0 ro N SD O ro O 0 O � 0 ,r o0 r, O :Zj� 0 0 00 0 N W O Lf L v m o N r, N O c 00 N O c 00 m o � O Lr) m C Q N N D 00 N N N N N C � O C Q N Sp f6 N C _ Q _ 3 w u x m N d m E r VC) N 0 41 C CLz. N O m •G. Q N O \ o i V v V t0 N N C C C C m f]7 � � f6 > W ; +' N m f6 i 'O C 'O .O Z* O Z C7 O Q Q V leo u Ol c ro u to c Co r ro u r` c 00 0 r, U rri u O u r` U ro u ,-� r 00 r zz r ro u O u m � r �o u ro u c c 2 O co O 0) 0- Staff Report Development Services Department www.kitchener.ca REPORT TO: Finance and Corporate Services Committee DATE OF MEETING: September 16, 2024 SUBMITTED BY: Cory Bluhm, Executive Director Economic Development 519-741-2200 ext. 7065 Amanda Fusco, Director Legislated Services/City Clerk 519-741-2200 ext. 7809 PREPARED BY: Jay Brown, Economic Development Analyst 519-741-2200 ext. 7072 WARD(S) INVOLVED: Ward(s) 8 & 9 DATE OF REPORT: September 5, 2024 REPORT NO.: DSD -2024-372 SUBJECT: Belmont BIA Boundary Expansion RECOMMENDATION: That pursuant to Section 209 of the Municipal Act, 2001, notice of the proposed by-law to alter the boundaries of the Belmont Business Improvement Area (BIA) be sent to every person who is assessed for rateable property that is in a prescribed business property class which is located within the existing and newly proposed boundaries, as outlined in Attachment `A' of report DSD -2024-372. REPORT HIGHLIGHTS: • The purpose of this report is to present the proposed boundary expansion for the Belmont BIA, outline the rationale of the proposed boundary change and initiate the approval process as defined by Section 209 of Municipal Act, 2001. • The key findings of this report are the boundary expansion will transform the BIA through the acquisition of dedicated human resources, support new business growth through improved programing and facilitate new strategic partnerships amongst BIA members. • The financial implication of expanding the BIA boundary could lead to an increase in the levy by approximately $300,000 (estimate only). These additional funds will be collected through the BIA levy, which is separate from municipal property taxes, so there will be no extra cost to the City. The Belmont BIA will be responsible for the costs associated with sending registered mail to each property owner. • Community engagement efforts featured a public information session on February 22nd 2024, individual meetings with key property owners, and a business networking event to be held in October 2024. • This report supports Creating an Economically -Thriving City Together: Focuses on growing an agile, diverse local economy powered by talented entrepreneurs, workers & artists; creating opportunities for everyone and a resilient future that propels our city forward. *** This information is available in accessible formats upon request. *** Please call 519-741-2345 or TTY 1-866-969-9994 for assistance. Page 145 of 180 BACKGROUND: A Business Improvement Area (BIA) is a designated geographic zone within a municipality where businesses are subject to an additional levy on top of their regular municipal property taxes. The levied funds are managed by a board of management and typically used to fund initiatives relating to marketing, promotions, beautification projects and community events. The Belmont BIA was established in August 1977 with the approval of the municipal bylaw #77-103-P. The Belmont BIA boundary has remained the same since its inception forty-seven (47) years ago. The current boundary includes all properties which are located along Belmont Avenue West between Union Boulevard and Glasgow Street. The local economy has experienced significant growth extending outside the BIA boundary: east along Glasgow St. (Catalyst 137), south along Belmont Ave. W, (eg: Schreiter's Furniture Store) and west along Gage Avenue. The growth of the Belmont business community is projected to continue with the potential construction of mixed used developments in the area. REPORT: Belmont Village (`the Village') is a vibrant gem nestled between Downtown Kitchener and Uptown Waterloo. One of two BIAs in Kitchener, the Village is home to independent shops, services and eateries. As commercial and residential developments increase in the surrounding area, the Village will continue to be a central gathering place for a growing community. The BIA already serves as a galvanizing body to support collaboration among business in the village. An expansion would enable the BIA to serve and support many more businesses within the surrounding area. The Board of Director's for the Belmont BIA provide the following rationale for the proposed boundary expansion: i) To align the BIA boundary with current and future growth of the local business community. ii) To transform the operation of the BIA from a working board to a governing board of directors with dedicated human resources. The acquisition of human resources will increase the BIA's capacity to deliver more complex and effective programming. iii) To provide enhanced services within the BIA boundary, i.e., enhanced beautification and improvement projects, improved marketing, more community events, and foster collaboration amongst BIA businesses. iv) To promote opportunities for engagement with BIA membership on strategic planning and directions. v) To address inquiries from property owners and businesses requesting membership in the Belmont BIA. The proposed boundary expansion would add approximately 35 additional commercial properties to the BIA. Municipal Act Powers & Process Section 209 of the Municipal Act, 2001 empowers a municipality to alter the boundaries of an improvement area. Before a by-law may be passed to alter the boundaries of the BIA, notice of the proposed by-law shall be sent by prepaid mail to every person who is assessed for rateable property that is in a prescribed business property class which is located within Page 146 of 180 the existing boundaries of the BIA; as well as in the geographic area the proposed by-law would add to the improvement area. Within thirty (30) days all persons who received the notice are required to provide a copy of it to each tenant of the property to which the notice relates who is required to pay all or part of the taxes on the property. In addition, within that thirty (30) day timeframe they are required to provide the Clerk with a list of all such tenants and the share of the taxes that each tenant is required to pay; as well as the share that the property owner is required to pay. A municipality is not permitted to pass a by-law to expand the boundaries of an improvement area if written objections are received by the Clerk within sixty (60) days after the last day of mailing of the notices; and, those objections have been signed by at least one-third of the total number of persons entitled to notice and/or those tenants that pay all or part of the taxes of an effected property. To prevent the passage of the boundary expansion by-law, those objectors must account for at least one-third of the taxes levied for purposes of the general local municipal levy on rateable property in all prescribed business property classes in the improvement area; or at least one-third of the taxes levied in the geographic area the proposed by-law would add to the existing improvement area. The Municipal Act assigns responsibility to the Clerk to determine as to whether the objections to the proposed boundary expansion meet the stipulated thresholds. If the prescribed thresholds are met, then the by-law would not be put forward for Council's consideration and the Belmont BIA's boundaries would retain their existing configuration. If no objections are received, or the number of objections does not meet the requirements set out in the Municipal Act, then it is anticipated that a by-law would be brought forward in the first quarter of 2025 to expand the Belmont BIA's boundaries as proposed in Attachment A of this report. STRATEGIC PLAN ALIGNMENT: This report supports Creating an Economically -Thriving City Together: Focuses on growing an agile, diverse local economy powered by talented entrepreneurs, workers & artists; creating opportunities for everyone and a resilient future that propels our city forward. FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS: The proposed boundary expansion could result in an increase in the BIA levy by up to $300,000. These additional funds will be collected through the BIA levy, which is separate from municipal property taxes, so there will be no extra cost to the City. The Belmont BIA will be responsible for the cost of the registered mailing to each property owner. COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT: INFORM — This report has been posted to the City's website with the agenda in advance of the council / committee meeting. CONSULT — The proposed boundary expansion was considered at the May 30, 2023, Belmont BIA Board of Directors meeting at which time the Board endorsed the recommendation contained within report DSD -2024-372. At the November 28, 2023, Annual Page 147 of 180 General Meeting of the BIA members, the membership unanimously endorsed the proposed boundary expansion. Request by the Belmont BIA The Belmont BIA formally requests the endorsement of Council to expand the boundary of the BIA as presented in Attachment A to Report DSD -2024-372 and proceed with the formal consultation process as described by the Municipal Act, 2001. In addition to the prescribed engagement process of the Municipal Act, 2001, the BIA has undertaken the following additional outreach: A public information session was held February 22nd at 660 Belmont Ave. Individual meetings with key property owners and businesses have been ongoing since the public information session. A business networking event will be held for all proposed BIA members in October to discuss the boundary expansion and answer any questions. PREVIOUS REPORTS/AUTHORITIES: • Municipal Act, 2001 APPROVED BY: Justin Readman, General Manager Development Services ATTACHMENTS: Attachment A — Map of Proposed Belmont BIA Boundary Expansion Page 148 of 180 Staff Report Chief Administrator's Office REPORT TO: Finance and Corporate Services Committee DATE OF MEETING: September 16, 2024 www.kitchener.ca SUBMITTED BY: Margaret Love, Director of Strategy & Corporate Performance, 519-741-2200 ext. 7370 PREPARED BY: Justin Watkins, Manager of Corporate Planning, 519-741-2200 ext. 7203 WARD(S) INVOLVED: All DATE OF REPORT: August 23, 2024 REPORT NO.: CAO -2024-412 SUBJECT: Strategic Plan Update — August 2024 Implementation RECOMMENDATION: For information. REPORT HIGHLIGHTS: • The purpose of this report is to highlight progress made on implementation of the strategic plan, as of August 31, 2024 (Attachment A). • The key finding of this report is that all strategic actions planned for 2024 have now commenced. • There are no financial implications associated with this report. • Community engagement included posting this report to the City's website with the agenda in advance of the committee meeting. • This report supports implementation of the 2023-2026 City of Kitchener Strategic Plan. BACKGROUND: Kitchener's strategic plan sets priorities and actions to guide progress and resourcing over the term of council towards our long-term community vision. Through extensive engagement with the community and council, an initial set of 30 strategic actions were identified and approved with the new strategic plan in August 2023. Progress on strategic plan implementation is reported to council three times per year. REPORT: Since the April strategic plan update, all strategic actions planned for 2024 have now commenced. Project details for these 23 strategic actions can be found in Attachment A. *** This information is available in accessible formats upon request. *** Please call 519-741-2345 or TTY 1-866-969-9994 for assistance. Page 150 of 180 Adjustments in Strategic Plan Implementation The following adjustments have been made to the implementation of current strategic actions since previously reported to council. 1. New project managers have been assigned to the following strategic actions: • Parkland Acquisition Strategy (DSD) — Garett Stevenson • Creative Industries School (DSD) — Lauren Chlumsky 2. Planned completion dates have changed for the following strategic actions: • District Energy Business Case (DSD) — from October 2024 to December 2024 • Community Grants Review (CSD) — from March 2025 to August 2025 • Municipal Newcomers Strategy (CSD) — from June 2025 to October 2025 Despite the above noted changes to planned completion dates, all strategic actions remain on track for completion within their planned completion year, outlined in Appendix A. Update on Strategic Plan Indicators The strategic plan indicators are a new feature of the 2023-2026 strategic plan, intended to objectively measure our performance towards each strategic goal. The strategic indicators, developed by the Compass Kitchener Advisory Committee and the City's corporate leadership team, will be updated annually each spring on the City of Kitchener's website. A new, dedicated webpage to the strategic plan indicators launched in early September and will feature strategic plan project statuses in addition to strategic indicator metrics to track our progress on the strategic plan. STRATEGIC PLAN ALIGNMENT: This report supports implementation of the 2023-2026 City of Kitchener Strategic Plan. FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS: Capital Budget — The recommendation has no impact on the Capital Budget. Operating Budget — The recommendation has no impact on the Operating Budget. COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT: INFORM — This report has been posted to the City's website with the agenda in advance of the council / committee meeting. PREVIOUS REPORTS/AUTHORITIES: CAO -2024-055 Strategic Plan Implementation Update Page 151 of 180 CAO -2024-220 Strategic Plan Update — April 2024 Implementation APPROVED BY: Dan Chapman, CAO ATTACHMENTS: Attachment A — Strategic Plan Implementation — August 2024 Update Page 152 of 180 ai 41 m m Q N O N 7 7 Q C O m C ai E Q E c a u tw d Q C ai E s u m Q v L «Nv mcmE Y mn � - .E O z u w - E. o E ro W w o vcw _° op u , o nOV L O O OO p W N v v op- N -O 'o -o O -o �' ° o Y c Q- w m w >' O N N 'p Y N N w T w .p i0 " m v w c -O O m To Y p w u 0 'po Y N '^ v Y v w 0 -o >' 9 C m E 3 v .c m w a m E > 7 L N tl0 E E- 6 a+ vt 0 m m m c Q w w m `o v o E o y c U o o ,�v on O w m �_ -o Y o E w E° O 3¢ m .3 .°mac `w EL m m H w d o w w f N v N T =i Y e Q w ?i = v c T o L 'O u ,,, o w Y❑ v Q_ n .3 u 3 Y v` ", 'v o p_ c -. °° o o ._ n E Y 3 m m m E a a m u °' `v m E v i� E u v Q ac m o v v c° z a x L. -o v y m > ,� o m- -p E n �_ o m w w r L v fl- E E o v r a w O. m = T ,� - 'o m w N C w E E N w O v E L > v w N aw+ m p on x n o E w° 3 m w o N L v o o "' r w E v o v w S u m ° v c '� m �ry E n o -p n o a o v w E- m L o o -o °1 v EN m E .. �, o N L �' y� o m °- r nmmv I om+� n o fl- v v `0 -p v ¢ O N T w Q - m w c w o 3 u@ >, Q w tl0 V T O i yO mw U oD >o m u E U1 m w ° O o u- c c o p. o O a.+ Q m O '� O u Q 'O > L w E V o > m v c = w c w m m co m v v m> E 3 o >'- o- r m m .'� o E E w w 3 u E v c v E L c o a= '3 v c v u Q c in 3 v o 3 f6 u v m vvi m 1. u Y m H C 0 Y m H C 0 Y m H C 0 Y m H C 0 Y O w L c o 16 m C N OO T m m O w o o a+ +`+ aL+ ,� a N -O Y v Q N° m 0 00 N C N o om L N o .Y vi ° x E c C o w " E e c o ° m w _ v n E w L L o v to z .o a o o ❑ E a Q m o f v o o n o o.vv. r Q v c N 'w o o Q '�'47 a m mow, w p o O c N L Y a o o 6 = 3 m w ' O. o v@ o o E W ml � ` T� O Y E m ` w O w a F. E o° P L T 3 o E '4 o To - E - m L .- 2 m m u -o m m E c - w o U i O_ 'O m 3 2Euj - > w 'G w m m - - v E wvi o o o Ou F aL+ S m m F F o u N 1, H H aL.+ aL+ N C p o a a N V m ry p ao o Ho O o O o O a O o C Y c m O N O N a o O N Q d m > C o N L E W .o o o c 4{ 4 Im p c a E D Y D o m D Y D o W o o c a -E c a om 0 m a o 0 m N m o .o p o p N m m m O Y T; o m y c Ul - U1 01 o w YQ O L p v c L O -O °- j .O m N �n v v i s i au+ E w O L 0 iL+ V'L w m .- o - -p 3 -p o a @ o u m OD T Y 'O 'O v o; m m m o w, L L w v j ;+„ '> a 'L-' m m s m L m .. = +. '" v E m � r c N c .�. o °1 -a _ c_ a %- o -p c s m n a p- s w E s Eo v c m o L v v mLv. `° - .' = o v .. v �`w, m p E p- ° v 3 -o v° E E Y L Y 'O T w w o w u N m N °' O_ w O L U C E O N w E m`v >, `o Tc° -p w> a+ L a+ c@ s .. oL m i1 a+ O v. pD a+ O v"-pL c m O c .@ o >Ty -a .n �u E 3 oo 0 E o m m .E Y m m w `m Y - '.. L v m',� @ v in o E> c ° v =� =. E> - -p m y .� Y 'c w -p r o m ` .. c Y .. L o v 3 o o m +c-- E `m E '�° °1 3 L o> u m v "i o m `o E `�° n c 3 o a o •Z' v o c oo v c =' v -o c -p L v m o o. -2 E> m o LLv o .. .. L o O o o 'O O Y .. n E E E E g u o a .- . c Y .o m ° m Y E c w O _ Q � o C N a+ o ry on v m on °1 c o mo o f v > m = ' o o o. o. 3 m a s m v o m E ��� Ea Ou7 x° iuwo ai 41 M M Q N Q N 7 Q C O M C Gl E G1 O. E C a u .a d f�0 N Q C Gl E M u M Q N N a 'v m O Y OTO CD p m N Ya vv O v m a m Y o o °' o m m E o a r m o° o v o oTnm « '° v .. a o v o " a a o E o v m m- W -O N c o L_= u O .- a �n a U -O m N w .. m '° v O 'O W '^ w m `0 " w Q m o m U m v N Ul v 'Q U v UO v �' 00 m Ul N O s c7 a oa z L o E -° __ m v ,m, v a c m"= E oo m w- v o- > No -° - .- _ ° v L >, `�° s 3 9@ o "' .' v p °% 0 3 °1 ~ w E n" o o - L N -° -° c E v m c v c o T Y@ N > -o -O z > w w a > 3 3 0 .v. 3 m E °° ' T=- ° - 3 3 °' m s c u ''-" m v L u v v u v m m° .Q ,� _ m v O -vo m E ''E p u .� V a O u o -° a m >' m N LL v m O`o 3- 'o o 0o w m r m N N E v a °N C L E '" c L O ? . R O N m O v o m L a`+ O 0° Y E p E O. O Ul W O L C C m v .O H .O o Y -p E o u O v Q vYi er, _M" �n L L `v -o -O c m - O m`o 3 r 'F . Q E f+l T E ° vYi N o o o No @ v v m on ° >>° v '3 m �- m s=? a o °^' in 3 u c N Q 3 3 v o.0 m m a m Y c c'c a@j NO wEa T'G 0 m N 9 Oo LE `UT°vOv'l'i E-vmmvO+D M O c im O T Y '47 .3-° O y m N 47 v O O n v o OO0 U1 E .aO E m o o a , - @>�nm = .N c n> o °u w u m o 'o u o o v m o 0`°u oo W v -.-�'O ° `° m m'' 3 0Y IT nanki vW>Wcl ✓o O O >W c Q 3 Q a OE vY3 no > O O - c O a+ E° 'v m c ° L D OO vm o d o mN QO@u >Nn w O p O m 0 >p a o n ` T °vv -My . OO> �-vvE o vm O >m o°Q v}cam '�ci>-ooD °E .. .. v Y E H c O Y m H c O Y m H c O Y m H c O Y m H c O ifl Y O 16 ifl U N m >M ifl N> c m NN O a - p N HOm- O . A N m 0 N O N . wi NN v O NiLm O N N c N d z v Qm - oN v o O.� .° W o o o va vE O E oov^ E-� m� o o E E O vv0-o u� �3m o O ..3 o0 @•+ a m a@ o v 3 v m M> o- 3 o o m o E c u o °- m E 3 o > om Y L E O T w .vi T� T m O u e+ V - __ a_+ U 3E° �OD 0 6 o v' u OD E o v ..m E v n m E 3 v w n m E v 2 E v- 3 m w E m v o a �YV€ .� v O v o �YVL .� v L c �Y3aE c -O O c m ut N ut N V N �n N ut N N N N N N o V D D c Y c m o N 0 N 0 N 0 N 0 N a a D g .m T ° o E m mu V m O c m a m H e m 2 Y a C U m O o oo 4 Y p ca . p m.O D c a ca VI d O D C a d > m z m p c c ? d 0 c c O c .- a° m E u c .- a° O O x x o o -° ' o m v a+ o o .. Y E Y = v u c v 3 o V v m E v .� u � E° 3 E° m nom`-, x E E o .3 O vv v W V O W m m O v W oD u v a0+ `2(D >,� vow o= «= u T �n .� ` °DO v v v on c L O o v E 0 -mp ro `°.E a> on=o 3� U" D v v �° vL, u E Y o a= °«`� 3 r' > c E V'vi oD o U a L .G m m 0° O U 3 V a E N 0 o `°. E Y v o L p ,� ,� oc m a m .. 0- v >>,. n > V v L' 3 v m m o v _ E v v v E o o E v v w v ._ o m m o v o .. L Y co c N d u " m Q NO- m e m W u omLn c Y E 'O m O N `p E m +' m c ._ m m M M Ti a L C N j E T m a ° m c d d m VI V V d V H VI D fO N- a (7 D VI N N a 2 2 CL � \ N b.0 « � E m { E aiE c m a : ai§ � a 2 E � m a {( a3 Vo j§ \E)Ef 22 f!\)r\ 2{o 9)/f )i 2� \/\;7{ \\o 2 §\rf±3 §2: M. J2! : : o N we j \)((\ oN \ \�}\N E o > \ \\\\c \ , �) 5/ _] �Em >ca o o \\ \ {\ \\\\ �\ � ±w - Z§3) /o> ix \}\\} u o !£o ] 3] Gl 41 m m Q N Q N 7 7 Q C O m ai E Q E c a u .a G1 Q C G1 E s u m Q o N a 3 v °- c � u c v v u -° w 3 E E m y m o > '° s co v' c_ m o o LS O V .� p� Y 0 v °' E '^ �' E Y N O a L y, L .. o ac o f v w o oo u E °° m 3 c o v m o v oD > VTi o °' Z v -� .'7 o s y r m r p i m r a w .n v o v o m `v u °- u Y o o � « -a n 3 E Y v v �' w m -vo '" s° w° -° v 3 °- v r o 42 �0 3 m o a+ c a m a a, w N W .. � o a m Ov r 3 o E a E v y a 3 v v 3 o EL r m °D '>" 3 rODo 'v m _ o - m '" v m° v v a o c > w E m '� a o o u `v onu o m(`oa� v a 0 vEi F r 3- m v Y n w o ` 0000 Q n 3 w o' E `v r °- v w ot1 o v a v v o a 3 c '� om = E o 3 0 a o vu o m -o .v `3c v m yr �-2Yu mm3w v '� > J -m v_ y v v 'm�' Y ° v cn c v - E v a° -vo v°> w v' 3 s c o r s _ a Q E 3 3 o E v J= o E n v v m m> c 3 o n 3 3¢ m o .. v Y oo v c° Y Y H H O O u m � O N u O N. O m o E > c oD I v ' N V N ° o > v O N c O N c v c v°- o v v Z 0 o a oa a o Q m .y E o E o NN d C ^ O Oo m O O E > m o ++ L a+ E o u � b➢ v 'OD v w v E C -p C u V N c C N N a E D Q U o ID Y v No a 0 m 0 N VI j d d U W d N d E Y ry W> o V E E E c E g u -w o u -w o w O p w Q w w O m v = - v u0 L om w U v '^ E m u @ s -o �E v c o c U o .a ° v 00 N vw v E a o m o It Y v 'v v E `o _ 3 -o u c a lu a@ U o c 3 'v `° N v - 0 r °o > Y a a o> o 0 3lw v m 6 E > o v c v uv Dos a u o v a °u E Yn n v LL Im a •0 a" o o s c c w mR Oq > d •� d a `ry ^ m> o m m VS c w u E a Q V m Q ai 41M M Q N Q N 7 7 Q I C O M G1 E Q E c a u tw d Q G1 E M u M Q N N a N T v` l 1 o v ¢` w m �O W o + L -O Ul -' N N C at c 3 C h N a O N o t L 0 A N" a oN L N U` '" .- w OD W Vl ommo o m m _O Q O zo m o .- o Y z o o .m v .. o m v o E v O a¢ v m o ai E v >o °- v x LL E w m' m 3 0¢ v m E '" 3 c v n s `0-u o v s c -6 ¢ fl- v -v _ 3 adv myz oo on 2 v m w a vvi m � Y m c m o m v a = v a N a v v o o 3 QN m Y O °- v v -O m 4Z ° m v W °' c c t Y C o a N �, O vt a N L N v, m o v c '47 v° Y .0 3 ° m a E « m V« � ``° v m •F -° « v v m u Y N � Y 12 w E o E w o .3 •d ° v 'v v m m O r o m 3 v nY v nn L ,mom, E o y L " m Y v aQv.m`. m v w _ v v> a m E 3 c `5 o -m r m o o« V o -vo a n ? v v r m m L 'Q c ,� -Occ c N ° o a `v v L ni `v '� c o `v °_ v N $ 3 °° E E m 0 o > w> m 'G O- Q L- c -O a+ ° .� v O L m t� a a+ Wc W N 'O .3 Y� p c v V Ul �` E- c L v m �, C Y O +N '� N m C O L p o N N m p a v m -O o o .- m y m �' w v v v �' o o v E m w -v°` £ m •Fm r -o w r a o v w E .w o 0 o u c mc c -vo` ' o v° w v a,o -° v mY C7 °' o m o 3 o v o m uo n o -o moo v E Ti v c u u 0 v c c o m -° `�' a `v ; v - '^ v .m..3 '� v 'O V L O �n v L v c ° o" 1- a O °c rL' a+ v ° u C o -o v -� O _ E '^ v N Q N amC+ W Y J@ 3 o L v v -° -° m `v O >° E Q V L E _ O m o m a o a o am -I o c E U - O '� v c '> =p }T, -p E F c v o_ m e E w o E E -° ¢_$ u N 'o == m e m o n 3 3 H° w v v ¢ v Y °u Y H O Y H O Y H O Y H O Y H O N o - O oa 0 N N 0 N °- NO V U m Y N U O O_ O N O O vi o v N N Y O v Y m Nam+ O o .�> v 3 16 c v v v c v m E o - o 'c = L v z c o o m o L L o v =>3 o o _o o v m n E° o o E o o '�� o a -u �o E m vi OD Ul h m U _6 m-vo, 'pD C O `O s N uo" .� E usYco C E Ul c`p Ul m m o `3 Ul - `� o N N m - o. o a - ° m s 'm ° o o v o a o o 'u^ v 0 0 u o v o - Y" u m E v La v m= 9 E O O v m Y '� E .. 46 @ o o v .. c c O - 'E O u" o° 3 w o m w =° 1E L a w m N Y m w H O a`+ N H N O H a m N 'N Y H o N m O C -° o IT IT c d o 0 0 0 0 a o V d c Y C m N o N N 0 N N 0 N N 0 N N 0 N a a c N a Y N c Y N c Y N c N o w w w o o o w g g g w 2 2 2 o _ V V V 0 V w O tt: O tt: O tt: V O tt: O O O O m m 'o o va v� +. E L c w m m m m ° c '£ -O m vL ° o°03 E '3 o c o 'O DD w u o T L ° a_ 'O L m c_ cL• V E Y o v o m N Y 'O m m° n v u v '� a+ . 'O N C bw Y c -p c W -° c Y o E 9; m E r m .: u 'O m Ol E ° 'c -vo ° m- v !S u -o ` w m - E w'C° O 'c O °- O v L o m'47 3s o u $ a O O -`v -° E w cw ao v v ona m °-° m E •� moo u° `«N• .O o ° v s° Y a n w v mc s 3 w N E �`o w w m m o -O N a m 0 _6 u W O N U N >, N T" E oo m m o m c L m 'o o O > L _O ° m a+ YO N Y- r Umw > V> -O O° O" L i E.m L '-' N '^ a v 0 o" '. "i c_ `v °D ''' '47 mo `- L v V H e ` V° > m '1 ; avr+ Q N` -O O m o L m O. C w '47 ,� '> m '� c E rv+ 'O 0 0 c w m `O O N �n -° 0 Ul .� ;c O O yT, w o m- o m E ¢ v °u o w -° a -° o`' 3 E z v m E oo' v 3 n v -° V w -v° n v v `o_ m E t CO N c •C 0 ry- a J md N O O W m u o c Nm •y„ '� i v u `mom E c o .�, '° > o m m ¢ utmi2 i7�� N N a 2 2 CL � \ N b.0 « � E m 2 ai E CL E c m a : § � a ai 2 E 5 m a tt_ � { ) {m ; r /{&{{§ � ( o !„ �§ ic _ (\( - w47 -am t \o \\\\ - . ;se§E2l2 !_ ]{{/ o o o o. ) k2 \Ei2§({{ /) : o / i \ ) ƒ d � u/ E{ ){\ §o '17 ,e7 — f:§\; o of £§5«{ \§/{) ») /\ ai 41 M M Q N Q N 7 Q I C O M ai E Q E c a u tw d 2 Q C G1 E M u M Q N N a E v v '� on v c v E v v -0 3 m v m o L c a' o@ oo m ' m -vo a S v` 012 C o N v O a0+ c- c V o L n m u, m mm o v n r 3° o '� 3 3 w m aEi m 6 w v w o v yr o o �c ° Cl o `° ° °-r - n v �> u -vo n o 0 3 '6 L V .- 2 '~� v m E E W . °- T m .m. N w o v D i U U `1 H m O T O W -O N W h N c 0 oD O N Om0 O '^ 3 'o7 E w L 3 .T y L J m v r w° Y E .v. v .m. Up 0 2 ` ¢ v 3 � v -o on -° a v N m .; a v Y u> -u o o '? .Q o � vL. o -o > O c Y O o0 v V v O m~ v U O j NC Ib D W °- E 9 Y O v tO L L C N E �' V o V 00 Y r -O Ul 3 m vmi E o E 0 0 ° O N E m u w o c o L 'O U v j W YJ vYi > -O W G E E v O w O v o Q v Y Q a 0 0 v E E> L Y O w -O E Y Y Y H c O H c O H c O w N m o O v° O 1w w .c - W 0 ? L o o o �' N E -' w o v> o N o N 4 O N O V O N o v O L U `v lo w v ° v w a Z O_ p Q m- O `� w O. O o O_ o S, O c> Y i Y U O Y m tD O Q Q N U o L 'm 3 U o m o 'm= « E -_E -E 3 '- E o a '3 -o � v a N 3 L. w m w v a r o 2 m 3 w o v'�i o m o -° N T o w r N > - m Y- v T E Y C Q W O N mN "`Po V W E O m O = - w O O. r O. - °- lb �^ wc N of O r° m- 0 o H d O N F H d Q p L oo m C ° o n a N � a E v V p v Y C o o a >, T v m o 'c ° v o m c ¢ O c c t o c E LL a` ¢ c, c o c p m o a S N o E= V O O - m LL= o° V N (7 p p 2 d d O - O 0 0 o m .� j, O -O 'O H E p v v a of v 3 - -° O +. C QN '_' W Q m O N C O v N E- 7 Q m- W O v j, E uoD v v m v o o. aV+m Y > w °- v Y o O N v WO v> E v o v O W O -O O C U v oo oo ._ -6 ° D'v Y ov a °- v rw fl -v -O nu > > oo> u 3= m m y N E E .4> U rm+ 2 O O s 6 2 v W N v N a+ m a+ o VO 2 W 0 0 N 9 V O 2 E E L Q O_ t u c m p > C v c u c m v 'a+ E o E N T p N d° ry 0 >> O c N o. V m E3 v� N N a REPORT TO: Finance and Corporate Services Committee DATE OF MEETING: September 16, 2024 SUBMITTED BY: Ryan Hagey, Director of Financial Planning & Asset Management, 519-741-2200 ext. 7353 PREPARED BY: Debbie Andrade, Manager of Budgets, 519-741-2200 ext. 7114 WARD(S) INVOLVED: All Ward(s) DATE OF REPORT: August 7, 2021 REPORT NO.: FIN -2024-404 SUBJECT: June 2024 Variance Report RECOMMENDATION: For Information REPORT HIGHLIGHTS: • The purpose of this report is to provide an update on financial results for City operations. • Tax supported operations are projecting a surplus of $3,083,000. • Most enterprise operations (non -tax supported business lines) are projecting surpluses. • This report supports the delivery of core services. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: This is the first variance report to Council regarding the City's financial performance versus the 2024 budget. The report and attached schedules include information regarding: • Tax supported operations • Rate supported enterprises/utilities, and • Supplementary information related to investment income REPORT: Overall staff is projecting the City's tax supported results for 2024 will be a surplus of $3,083,000. The major contributors to the overall positive variance are the projected surpluses in Engineering, Operations Roads and Traffic, Parks and Cemeteries, Debt Charges, Gapping and Penalties and Interest. These positive variances are offset in part by projected deficits in Bylaw Enforcement, Corporate Communications, Facilities Management and Contract Services. More details about each of the City's tax supported divisions are provided in the report below and in Schedule 1. The City's enterprise (non -tax supported business lines) results to the end of June show most of the enterprises have results that were better than budgeted. However, in the rate supported operations Building is projecting a negative variance to budget due lower than anticipated Page 160 of 180 revenues as a result of the decline in the number of new construction builds with high interest rates slowing the purchase of residential homes. More details about each of the City's enterprises are provided in the report below and in Schedules 2-8. Significant projected tax supported variances (over $200,000) are summarized below. Additional details are provided in Schedule 1 for projected variances that exceed $100,000. Operating Fund — Tax Base (Schedule 1) Staff is projecting the City's tax supported results for 2024 will be a surplus of $3,083,000. Significant Proiected Variances (over $200, 000) Development Services Department: • Engineering is projecting a surplus of $440,000 due to higher than anticipated revenues for site plans and service charge revenue. General Expense: • Contract Services is projecting a deficit of $251,000 due to increased costs related to the existing contract with the Humane Society. Gapping is projecting a surplus of $1,208,000 due to staff savings resulting from vacancies. General Revenue: • Penalties and Interest is projecting a surplus of $1,000,000 due to higher than usual Accounts Receivable balances. Infrastructure Services Department: • Operations —Roads and Traffic is projecting a surplus of $593,000 due to reduced winter maintenance costs resulting from unseasonably warm winter months. Enterprises — (Schedules 2 to 8) Six of the City's seven enterprises are projecting year end positive variances to budget. Details of each enterprise are noted below. Building Enterprise (Schedule 2) The Building Enterprise is projecting a negative variance to budget of $359,000 due to reduced revenues from a decline in the number of new construction builds. The interest rate hikes over the last year has slowed the purchases of residential buildings. The projected deficit is partially offset by a positive variance in operating expense because of staff vacancies. Golf Enterprise (Schedule 3) The Golf Enterprise is projecting a positive variance to budget of $248,000 due to higher than anticipated revenues with a successful start to the Golf season. Parking Enterprise (Schedule 4) The Parking Enterprise is projecting a positive variance to budget of $535,000 due to better than anticipated daily use. Page 161 of 180 Water Utility (Schedule 5) The Water Utility is projecting a positive variance to budget of $2,762,000 due to increased volume of water sold as a result of the warmer weather. Sanitary Sewer Utility (Schedule 6) The Sanitary Sewer Utility is projecting a positive variance to budget of $4,744,000 due to higher than budgeted revenues, which is consistent with increased volume sales also noted in the Water utility. Stormwater Utility (Schedule 7) The Stormwater Utility is projecting a positive variance to budget of $764,000 due to higher revenues from increased development and projected staff savings because of vacancies. Gas Utility (Schedule 8) The Gas Utility (Total) is projecting a positive variance to budget of $3,959,000. • Gas Delivery is projecting a positive variance to budget of $3,315,000 due reduced operating expenses as a result of lower volumes of gas sold and decreased contract charges. • Other Programs (Rental Water Heaters and KU Dispatch) is projecting a negative variance to budget of $102,000 due to higher than anticipated interest and carrying costs. Gas Supply is projecting a positive variance to budget of $746,000 due to reduced operating expenses as a result of lower volumes of gas sold and lower cost of gas. Investment Report (Schedule 9) All investments made were in accordance with the City's investment policy. Short-term investment yields to date have averaged 5.84% which is higher than the average interest rate of 3.35% for all of 2023. STRATEGIC PLAN ALIGNMENT: This report supports the delivery of core services. FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS: Financial implications are discussed above and detailed in the attached schedules. COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT: INFORM — This report has been posted to the City's website with the agenda in advance of the council / committee meeting. PREVIOUS REPORTS/AUTHORITIES: There are no previous reports/authorities related to this matter. Page 162 of 180 APPROVED BY: Jonathan Lautenbach, Chief Financial Officer ATTACHMENTS: • Schedule 1: Statement of Operations — Tax Supported Services • Schedule 2: Statement of Operations — Building • Schedule 3: Statement of Operations — Golf • Schedule 4: Statement of Operations — Parking • Schedule 5: Statement of Operations — Water • Schedule 6: Statement of Operations — Sanitary Sewer • Schedule 7: Statement of Operations — Stormwater • Schedule 8: Statement of Operations — Gas • Schedule 9: Investment Report Page 163 of 180 N O o0 0 M Ln N IR tri N l0 U 41 ci ar O ci N rl u O O l0 Ln l0 rl 41 Ln C4 GJ r O yr DJ N O N u w 0 OJ _ v Ln O Q t ai 0 Ln � a 3 cn U O Q u N -6 41 C � 3 4J 4J C C N N '6 .M (o iF 00 N N Y 0 Q 4 C O p M l0 O i L 00 C -0 (o 7co u N f0 4J �n U O_ Z N > c3) n _ Ln rl O N ci _0 -1 O O aN O Ci O N Li 0) O 0 M uJ a N 3, O m c -I O O u *' N a � N -i l0 IAW f6 M 00 N l0 Q0 N 01 M Ln n LLn M N 01 01 rl zT 0 a 3 N bb rn r4 l0 a N 3 -1 O O m LL = N ci or W m Q M o a QJ QJ rq M rn Ln W 1 .1-+ f6 � NQJ N ri UJ N 3 m a O 24 S(D or u, m a 0 a a N O o0 0 M Ln N IR tri N l0 U 41 ci Ol zT ci N rl O Ln O l0 Ln l0 rl 41 Ln ci DJ N O v Ln Q0 t ai 0 Ln � > U O Q ci -6 41 ci 4J 4J C C N 13 a '6 .M (o iF 00 Ol N Y W Q 4 C O p M l0 O i L 00 -0 (o 7co u rn 4J �n U O_ l00 LMn c3) n Ln Co Ln rl O N ci _0 -1 O O O O Ci O -1 0) 0) M O1 v cI c -I Ln N 0 0 0 rn ^ M m rn lfl ri o -1 lfl OO 00 Ln N M C3) l0 00 00 �O Q0 rl M N O1 N v Ln l0 z Q0 rn 00 N Ol ci Ol zT ci N rl O Ln O l0 Ln l0 rl ci Ln ci DJ N O Q Ln Q0 t ai -i Ln � > U O rn ci O ci 4J 4J C 0D -0 O j N 13 a '6 .M N O 00 Ol N l0 W Q 4 C O p M l0 O Ol 00 -0 (o 41 O co >, u rn 4J �n -1 O l00 LMn c3) n Ln Co Ln rl O N ci _0 -1 O Lr c I 4J Y W 0.0 � N N +-+ ro4J Q Ln M or iJ U 'y U 41 U Ln N -i l0 Ln Ol M 00 N l0 Q0 N 01 M Ln N M N 01 01 rl zT O N ci 00 l0 M ci M -1 O O N LL = zT ci or W 0 0 0 W l0 M � 4i � N Z co � l0 W l0 t J-+ > d4 M Ln Ln w DJ N O Q a+ t ai f !E > 4J O > U O O i U Y 41 O �' Y 4J 4J C 0D -0 O j 13 a '6 .M n o U� w 6 o U U Q W Q 4 C O p w 7 6 C -0 Uo I N -0 (o 41 O co >, u 4J �n U 4J 0D .= OH of U O o v Q> j = O W O2 o I- m O J W W _0 -1 co C -6 co o 4J Y W 0.0 � uz� N +-+ ro4J Q —41 Y t C U u or iJ U 'y U 41 U L I O > u -0 ~ o a_ o O 00 O 00 O O 00 Ln l l0 � N -ZT O v O1 Ln -i a v < 0 0 0 W l0 M O � N Z W U_ l0 W l0 O rn N M Ln Ln w H V N O W N n Lnri l0 6 N N 00 N 0 O 00 6 N l0 N O n M Ln Q0 Q0 O M ci l0 lfl zT r` l0 N 00 N O1 M O Ln -zT Ln r` ci 2 V W a ? O O Z W U_ F or W N W w H V a a+ O > w U Y 13 a W O w > N (, L u OH of = O W O2 H W W O LL. o OJ uz� N or U ��, <zW� ~ o a_ o Z zz a < A� '5 O LL D LL = W or W m Q O o K a W L O a 0 a � S(D or a a a a Y aoa °a O W w° ° 00 00 00 V> w u u u u m oor UV) z a- U u u u u V) v 00 Ln M l0 r` r` M O ci 00 -1 -1 � l0 ci M 00 i m r` zT rl ci r, Ln M l0 Ln l0 ri N 00 zT rl N M O1 Ln rl -ii O loo Lrl n qT Co Ln r, ci N l0 'zT l0 ci lzz N 00 rl 00 M M N N N 00 N ci lzz M ci ci 06 N v v v KLU K FN O N Z w D Q O K W y w Z Q LD Q Q ) � 0 w w W z S J J O O O N 0 O 0 O 0 0 0 0 N L!1 N O O1 MLn N M M S C: a) a) _0 O 00 0 0 0 N 00 W 0 C C O O 0 0 0 0 Ln U! O M L!1 -ZT Q0 M N O M N t v t Q tY U C:Y 1� U Y N Vf as O > ai ai L v ° a: E E (B (B Q a1 _I_-ai t a) a-+(6 7 L L -O L -6 E v Q � O Q O C VI � O m aj a-+ l0 aJ w_ U 0 0 ca (a Q aj l0 Q N Q .0 Q O Q N Q N T M 0) N m o C'� O U L 'O ai 7 -o O 7 L O 0p -o `� c:U .o Q aj Y N N ' _0ate+ U t Q v F U SJ � O U aJ O N G c�-I cLn -I N Q > Q > (6 O- O („) -O O C 'O aJ 'OC N O Q> O ca YC C aJ O C C Q aJ _ C O_ c6 v E} v a v 'U v 'U 'u aj U O_ U U' O U ca U U ca O O O O p C C C N O -1 00 Ol QM � 0 0 0 0 N L!1 N O O1 MLn N M M S C: a) a) _0 O 00 0 0 0 N 00 W 0 C C O O 0 0 0 0 Ln U! O M L!1 -ZT Q0 M N N O1 Il -ZT L!10 1� N l0 N Ln l0 T Ol M M M OM to Ln M l0 00 0 0 M N l0 N' l0 L!1 M 0) N Ln l0 qT 00 O Q0 N Ol v Ol M l0 N Il N c�-I cLn -I M c�-I N Z p QM O ci I� O1 O1 l0 Ln l0 Ln M cc I� n 00 l0 Q0 00 ^ CY, O rl l0 00 N -1 00 -1 00 rl L!1 rl N WA I� N' O � � O Ln l0 l0 O Ol l0 ci l0 ll 00 N l0 N n l0 Ln n M Ln N 'zT 00 N l0 O zT OM 00 Ln 0 LLI Q0 N M l0M M M ci 00 O Ln y� N N N N L!1 l0 N OM M M ci M M a -I ci L!1 Il lzl M0 c -I I� O N l0 -i O O 00 W M0 l0 M A N c -I O1 O1 M r4 v M O O O1 l0 qT N 00 00 Ln l0 M zT IAi fh 00 Q0 0) M 00 Ol M N O Ol zT n Q` O1 M O � 00 l0 Ln 00 O1 O O1 l0 N M L!1 N lzz O 1 N Ln c -I M a-4 M zT e O zT 0) N 00 zT O r Ol N Tr Ol Ol L!1 N r N L!1 n c -I O 1� al T qT n Ol N M 00 ` r l0 l0 a -I Il N a -I 0 Z N W d m NJ a cn � °� 06 (J N z u 0 W0 z O O~ a >w orU > U z w z Y W v a N H Q z0 N w z > F z gor z F o Z L 06 LU N z W Z Z (D ~ Z H O _ W F 0_ w Q 0 N W Z O Q c o z w w w z L J N a or O a a or O O Q a w a a w O or O V) a a J Q J Q J Q Q J F Q Q Z> O U O O O w z Ln U LU OJ -J Z U Z U U U O Q Y = O a Q W > w w z w z C7 z z> w Q a Q Q Q w Q N V \ \ w Z H O O W W > w O > U w Z Q K W W Q Z Z p Z Z N Z w — U VI 0 w 0 w d F Ln 0 LL L.L. Q L.L. L.L. Q LL w O O O Ln L!l N uo 6 Y > a, O O 'u a) a) (B U > A to L -0 E ai ai aiY O U U w v 0i O O tap C (6 C N ai > U .s U A O O O O O O M 00 N O ci N c -I 0 o i 1O 0 0 o Q0 00 lfl L O 00 O 0 0 0 0 0 Ln -i <D Ol ON 0 0 M M 3 t N' N C 00 N O O °u' r, -0 N N ' Y ' aJ ai 00 ci L E ai Y ai n wN A -0 B ai >pi NQO ^ Q a M U Co N Ln ai — a1 a-4 6 K a U Y O_ v O 7 ll a-4 O O _0O -6 L0 U C L Q rl ci Ln N N O N a M N N N T Ym a Ol r` � � Q -0 rl U Y O O O O O O l0O rl O O ci 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 00 O Ol N rl N N zT 00 Ln 00 M M c -I 0 Tt a L0 r` N' N ;: O 00 M N L! O r, � 0 N N ' ' ' Ol r L0 O) 00 ci L!1 00 oo N L0 n wN NQO ^ M ci M c 00 Co N Ln ! C3) ! O a-4 M cM M0 Ol ll a-4 L0 -T M rl ci Ln N N O N M N N N Ol r` O O M O rl O al Il M -i a -I Z p Q00 00 M N l0 W rl L0 r� O O O Ol 00 00 Ln L!1 N O1 oO M 00 Ol 00 � 00 -1 ci Ol zT N 00 00 00 M rn Ol qT N r4 N 0 M LO Ol N ci O O rl Ol O Ol Lfl' -1 O N 00 rl M Ol a-4 dW a�-I CY) N 00 00 00 Ol O L!1 cLn zi 00 rl rl N O N rl L0 L0 00 00 O a-4 O N 00 M c -I m v ci rl ^NI' v Q0 r` O1 O O r` v rn v ci 00 N N v Ln LLI N T l0 00 00 ' LD Co N vl LD Il rl O M O Ol l0 00 vl 00 00 O l0 O l0 M O I� r-i u1 00 Li ^ Ln Lr O1' Lr1 T M M L!1 Ol l0 Ol M N N 00 O M O Lr l0 � O N L!1 M N Ol M O A rl 00 N N Ol O r` NM LnO lI L!l ci Ol ci O N W Ol N Lr r` LD M r4 < rl M Ln 00 M O -4 lAi N Il M N c -I 00 N N Lr QO ^ N v Ol r4 v a -I N T -T u1 O O rl 00 O O Ol LD N Ln O L!1 Ln 00 N O Ln N Ln M Ol l0 O ci O O N r` l0 Q` M n L!l Ol r` N Ol 00 L!l O Ol M N O 00 O rl zT Ln oo r rl 00 N N 00 Ln N r, Ol r` rl rl ci M O On L!1 M ci O 00 Ol M N Ol n 00 Ln O Ln N r4 00 Ln N 00 cy) R Ln 1 ci N Tr 00 r� zT 00 M ci ci Ol zT L!l N r, 00 W 00 M O � rl rl zT l0 v M O v l v v ze 00LLIg v aLn -I .... Z�O 104 W o JL W m 4 z LU or N Z w w > > Q E- N or n w F H O L v H LUL, W {n K N W 0_ X W 0 W D K W > K cw c w 0 W Y W a W w > LU J N N K LU w z W Z w O U Z Z O LU F D Z LL. a r z - d O D� or w o < LL °V) O w W ] �o w or oJw xV Z w LU F U Q w J o LL LL J Q W J Z W co D Q K U Z F K or N 0: W : K K F— K J K 0C Y W > Q a Z C) K Q F 0_ F Z F m O_ d Z Q W 2 X z Q W Z Z F Z F Z W Z> w W 2 Q Z D Z W Z r' V W or Z O LL W C7 Q m O m Q U O U W 0 Q c7 K C7 F 0 Q F K F W Q W0 C7 U O U W (D z — F 0 W a cn W O 0 0 n 0\0 lfl lfl c -I M ^ � M 00 M 00 N ci `Z r a L!1 W o a N M O00 W H r -i Q0 00 M Ln zT N M O1 m r, N 0 M C O M Ol a L!1 O 00 W� j a ci N u I� N H to M cI ci N U KW W DJ DJ 0 6J f6 ai .` t '6 v E J Q - L U Y > 6p 7 N L1 � C-' C OO 0 LU 2u OL w 0 LJ O 0 O 0 U 00 W Z 1 � O� . •L ci = 7 •Y Y 7 c6 76 N U J Q 13 =3E r Y to L (CC6 Q W a LL O H V Z a a >'��< C •L Q C a Q Q ai N J N -O U = N toC to to 'O 7 Ou 2i 'O w t06 O U U J-+ U U U L U C U 61 61 Y 7 6 61 C 66 0 C 61 'C N O � N O_ �n Fu VI 6p O_ i >, 0_ N Y O -O vii O- C -OO U C O > C '� f6 co: C 'u E Y >, U N C Y C Y (6 (Ii Q > C C O_ U L > N (Ij .0 N U U n (6 61 U 7 U O U (6 .� w O O O O O O O O O `1 00 ci M O) L!1 N L!1 c -I 0 0 n 0\0 lfl lfl c -I M ^ � M 00 M 00 N ci `Z r a L!1 W o a N M O00 W H r -i Q0 cVN l0 00 L!1 O Ln L!1 I� fh N N O1 00 L!1 ci Ol -1 N n O 00 M Ln zT N M O1 m r, N 0 M O O M Ol a L!1 O 00 l0 a ci N ci M O L!1 I� ci N M cI ci N Q KW W Q � 00 J Q /\ a 0 LU 2u r 0 � n 0 U 00 W Z 1 � O� a N N ci = W m Z N U J Q 13 W r Y Lu V a W or ik D W a LL O H V Z a a >'��< U a L=L w z Q W W_ U ~ J N LL cVN l0 00 L!1 O Ln L!1 I� fh N N O1 00 L!1 ci Ol -1 N n O 00 M Ln zT N M O1 m r, l O .0 0 M --IDO O M rl CY; Ol Ol N 00 O Ol -1 T '3 C, O fh M Il N O1 N O1 O M I� Ol Il O1 L!1 O L!1 l0 N O l0 M L!1 ci N ci M O L!1 I� ci N M cI ci N 0 N N 00 N Lri 0 N O 00 N M N N Ln N 00 f\ O1 N N LA 06 z O 0 W Q KW W Q � J Q a n LU 2u ~O 0 Z_ 0 U ~U 06 Lu K LL N U J Q W Q W QLL Y L V)0 0LU 0 a W W t/1 a Z W Z rw W N W W Z N c c s V W c/1 a V W V a a LL. 0 Z o Z aE J25 V OD > w 0 0 v v m ai ai 0 '0 U ai ai .� u O ++ i -C v v i ai i Y C Y O E t ,� ai C a N 0 OJ tQ 2 0 _0 O 6 Y ai U ai,� ai u a Y u ai ai 0 t v O .0 i 0 0 au 0- 0 ai c 0 -0 0 v C -6 O -:F 6 -0 u C 6 a1 u Y Y U Y u •� YL •� o i uuO U u u N (B u N O O C LO L � LMn LMn N uO1 00 M r4 QJ 04, r •� N V W i OJ � > O a 0 0 0 0 o 0 n 0� 0� OR u 3 N ri N ri rl ri rl ni N i O N ++ 0 rn 1 OJ rn rn O O M 3 rlLnin qT qT M N Ln O C4 m O1 O � O1 M 00 Ln O o 00 Ln cLn i O a�-I N Ol Il ^ to rn Ol rn zT rnLn zT^ T Qj N 3 00 orn I- I- N Y C'4 Q +, f0 ri ri m m a a c f6 N l0 00 N ON v Y N Ill Ln O N N i+ C4 b O M N M rn zT rl fY1 N M M Ln In c 0 'o r4 N M rn C4 3 f0 ,o m (A — f6 Q0 M 00 O1 zT M O) N O O O1 N N v Y 0 k.0 ri 00 0o O 00 � i+ N G ^ O O1 � N O qT to O a N f0 no N O ++ 'a N .� N �m 3 co .3 c jE v r_ ° 0 m Y c v X c9 C c v v Q Q v a w w u v 0 v > N LUN 0 N (Lj N ; ��� V r N v I, Z a I, M ' cW W W G Z N W N W = a a � N o m V Y W W V a a LLZ oLL Z ci _ L!1 o aX a� Y V Q > w ��� V N v I, l0 a I, M ' ci^ M Il `o 00 O N O ro Y O E o O Y N ci _ L!1 M Ol M N O N a L w vu (Dcu U i OO O O O O O O .z cr Ln r` rl ZT 0 1 N N LU! 1 1 1 00 l0 O1 ci O O C N Ln lfl . W Z M W N d W SG W a Z W W ~ N m V Z C a u 05U U W W' a Y 0) V Ol LCL O Z Z L 6 Q 0 Ol Qx aL+ v a > w OO O O O O O O .z cr Ln r` rl ZT 0 1 N N LU! 1 1 1 00 l0 O1 ci O O C N Ln lfl . Y T N N ;: M ajajC aj -o C -0 m rl N N 0 •_ �O � Y S aj N a aj C -1 u 05U U Ci ,- c:i u3 0) > Ol l0 tov I >c> T rl v 6 Q 0 Ol l0 c -I aj jQ -0 l0 N c: L 6 4 N 10 Ln 10 c aj v4 U � 7 > N u L O 6 O O c -I L r O c -I N Ln u -ZT O4, a co N V W OJ i � m m > O L a OO O O O O O O .z cr Ln r` rl ZT 0 1 N N LU! 1 1 1 00 l0 O1 ci O O C N Ln lfl . l0 ;: M r4 m rl N N 0 c W N 00 -1 M r` c -I 4, 0) qT Ol l0 O^ rl v N O Ol l0 c -I N r` l0 N M N 10 Ln 10 0) � N � c -I O r a+ c -I r\ 4J m N m m Y 0 u v f6 Ln r` vY O � N r4 O 'zT v� a Y Ol O L!1 M O^1 3T O O N cu (Iiao - 0 a, l0 W O F N O N 3 C cu v'i QO N� (Ii omo rn r, � LU LU z m O 3 ar ar cI 41 N cI Y 'p M N Q IA f6 1 ci rl M N 00 T OM N Ol l0 l0 lzz O -, N -1 00 r4 aj � O1 M N O l0 c -I l0 M — 00 O1 r, � M Nr4 m�- 00 � co Ln rn or°, rn rl 0 rlo m k.0 0 m rl 0 c clo 4, N qT Ol l0 O rl n N O rl N r` M M 10 lzl 10 0) N � c -I l0 c -I r\ 4J m Y u v o vY A v� a Y O. W 7 U L cu (Iiao - 0 a, N W O F N 3 C cu > N > (Ii Z i u w 4! LU LU z cu N 41 W Y 'p W O co Ot,o ti r Z W SW G a ZN W_ � m c ~ W a 0 O O W Q I V > 25Y w O co Ot,o ti o o � O o 0 O U E U 3 u O O >O o n3 -O 0 .r O > L '� ai ai co .� > ° i > E v > }moi a) a) Y ai U a) a) > t to •Y O >-OaJ C > U JO a) YON U m >(o ro OY E V •� U Y U U ai Y (o U Y v o 0i Y ai O 2ai O O •O O O_ o aJ L 0_ aJ O U 0_ aJ 'O a) Y _0 -O 7 C -6 'O 7 C =3� (o -O to O M to aj m N a) (o OJd4 aJ aJ L om U a) CD L o L to v a) CD L o =3, U -0.� = = U -0 (o O_ to U 10 L O o O O O 00 O N ci N 00 N r4 ci Ol lN0 N m m v N 0 Ln `n n •a •a a r c -j N C4 QJ O 4, r •� N U W i OJ � > O a 0 o 0 L 0 0 0 0 u� m Zo rn rn o o rn Ln o o ai 3 N i O N ++ 0 00 Q0 CY) Ln l`c Ln o o m o 0 3 l0o l0 o ri rn ri -LO of C4 m Qo N O •� ++ N N N N l.0 rn 0 rn 00 -1 to ' N L!1 00 01 L!1 O a�-I N N � Oi Ln N M Ln r, N N3k.0 r` co co r` c Y O a-+ U a., of N of N m ci l0 Ln ci Lri m LO a N Q a c f6 ci O1 O � Ln M l0 O ci v Y Qj l�0 cmi O l00 Cl a�-I N N 3 O Ln LO1n O� O ZT L^n 0 v N bA z l0 O N L!1 00 L!1 Tr c O '0 ar l0 N r, N M ci l0 Ln ci L!1 m 06� C4 m ( — — f6 O 00 00 O Q0 O Q0 l0 � N 0 N L' 00 O O O O N N aJ O -1 Ln O -1 ZT Ln N' v ++ Gp 00 l0 01 00 00 L!1 rl w �4.j•a Ln c -I l0 l0 M L!1 l0 N 0 3 L!1 L!1 N c -I ci L!1 GJ Co L .3 c jE Gl r_ O 0 m c c9 N a v v N v � o v Y Q x v C a a! 7 C n3 t x U N w C (Ii> N i uA O N C Qj a) Lu V) cu > N vw z v L Nz cu Qj t LU Y v C w o u cu v z u 0 0 o w Z O co Ot,o ti v c -i m O O -1 O O .— v CL O O O r 000 M O W Z LLI r W Lu Z cW G W a N V Y u O c~cii a Y LL. o � az= V a a � z � N aL+ V ca/f > w v c -i m O O -1 O O .— v CL O O O r 000 M O zT U a O_ U 0 llc Y u O (Ij O U 00 4% O rl C co O N Ln O C co U to 0D 'O O_ O -O U N to 0o Ln r` O (o N > aJ >, (o O > O 1 •tA �n w bD Y ro > -6 U N' N _ V) a) E > J = J-+ aJ N > to j aJ O > U aJ 7 aJ w O cu W - L LU t OO OaCJ I- �+ 0 > O-0 UC Oa JwC On V) z" O_ O_ i 'O i>O u W- w O 6 v U U ai U o Y aJ u Y v u ai v u > v aJ .O .O � O .O aJ O U aJ > Q O- t ED .O -C Cu 3(Ij 'C j (o `6 -C j O -0 ( (o _0 A (o � Q N O J-+ Y O aJ OJ Y �n •� J-+ Y aJ O aJ v W E J-+ j N O aJ v cD J-+ U O 0D O v L 'O O L '02 L 'O u — U -0 O u O U -0 > =3 aJ U -0 -0 E U 'ate > L O O O 00 O O I 00 O OJ N Ln Ln O O N 0 DO c M TTr r M ci L!l N n a Ln Ln r4 QJ O a-+ •� N V W i OJ � > O a 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 rn oo ^ O O Ln 00 u r O O v N O OO 3 N N i O N a-+ M 0 Ol N ci to M en N Cl DO Ol L!l N � N i i Ol O O 00 Ln N M ci l00 M N M +a rn --- M N m m f6 M N r N O Ol � rn o O zT o^ � N Ln N3 cl opo rrl N U m m m r4 N q Q f6 N to n czT-I CP O en N Ln O M 00 00 OYl ONl O OYl N pp rq o0 0l r` Ln O m m m N � N m m v c -i m zT O -1 O - v CL O r 000 M O zT a O_ 0 llc Lill v 00 4% O rl 00 N Ln O 00 M Npp N to 0o Ln r` O 0 ri O m O N^ N' N _ V) > or � m Z cu W - L LU t i C I- v c bD v _ v CL O r a O_ W v Q u -- u w 3 v o v o _ V) > or ro Z cu W - L LU t i C I- �+ 0 o w u o or V) z" aj r r 0 0 m O Z r W LLI U LLI = W H N m o o u Y lo' V'f 00 Ln Y a U YU LLI V N a a LL 0 N a -ii H 0 > w aj 0 0 lfl T 0 m 0 0 m O 0 LO 0 o U N 00 N O Y N o u Y lo' m 00 Ln rn a U YU lc (B aj Y O N llc -ii O O aj 0o0 O O n N � M E-0 N u n 0 ci N rn 00 N zT 00 M N O c-1 > O Tr O1 m r a)00 O j j N j n C W aj m m ta rn Ln Y u N Ln 000 C N -O Q N C Q 6 N N cu m N = U p 6 Y 6 m j > U W u W u w �-+ ai u Q OQ a a 0 v� O p LLU O_ X aj N aj or 0 F W = J =3 YY 1_(Ij aj tjo Y N 1_(Ij a) c tjo '> L 77 L 7 7 U -0 00 U -0 to L O o O O o O > rn 0 lfl qT - m 00 m Ln 4* O4, a co N V W i � O L a aj 0 0 lfl T 0 m 0 0 m O 0 0 o U N 00 N N N lo' m 00 Ln rn M lc O N llc -ii LLnn 0o0 O r+ n N � M -i N n 0 ci N rn 00 N zT 00 M N O c-1 Tr O1 m N a)00 ci N Ln C W N m m r4 rn Ln n Ln L N Ln 000 N N cu 4 K = 9 N3 m l0 NO l0 T -ii O zT rn 00 LLnn zT rn zT O N � c_i 00 Ln m 00 LLnn m N N u m Q IA 1� Cli -i N lo' m 00 Ln rn M lc O N Ln ON 1, Ol O Ol N N 1� Cli 00 O 00 Tr C4 aj 00 Ln rn M lc O b llc -ii LLnn 0o0 O r+ n N3 m � M -i N n m v 00 O m N w ci N 3 C O LLnn Ln c -I O -1 Tr M M lc lc O lc O 41 Gl CL O r+ +� no 00 M N Ln 1� W W v 00 O Nt N w ci N 3 C Co O > N 0p Y v c Gl CL O r+ 41 O_ W v u 7 C w 3 C O > N 0p Y N cu 4 K = 9 4 W L W �-+ p LLU O_ X N u 0 or 0 F W Z �4 7 � 0 Z � I'D v W N W Z (L LJJ N 0 N W Ql � o = � Q W v v � N ) N Y LL = Q � `O U O r V C7 > o � 0 � � I'D v N N rn (L O J-+ � QJ Ql � O � � x � N ) N Y 00 m a-+ 6 N U O 00 'pai y NbD —0 _ O N m � NbD a N ai m O x x 0 E > U C C > ai O cE E +� U Q Q Cp O v 3U ° v 3 v O u +' U O > o QJ 7 QJ C 7 7 0 6 U "O U ++ Q Q O O Q) O O � O O C LJ � C LJ 7 U Q N 7 U C O O O W L O O 00 00 fC � GJ LO � C L N 1 > GJ �O L a � o c � � 3 N N � O 4+ N � f0 00 m `z GJN U 00 I-�' O NN N > CA f6 Lfl m N �p 3 O 00 0000 m N u Q m N 'A fC 00 O m 't 00 Nt 41 aj O r O N 'a = ++ m N m m � 0 � rn I'D N N rn O J-+ QJ Ql � 76-0 x � N ) N N 00 m a-+ bp N m O 00 'pai + N N m 7 NbD a N Q N m O x x � m ri � 0 � N > N N O O J-+ QJ u N -6 U 76-0 x E rn � C W CD QJ m > n N > 00 'pai + N 6 m m NbD a N Q u O- 0 teai O x x � a) N ri U C C ai O +� Q Cp 3U O u +' U O 0 QJ 7 QJ C 7 7 0 6 U "O U O O O O O O O O O O N M m M M 0 0 0 N 0 N W C; > x J rn rn W CD v m n n D 00 00 -4 6 m m >LU a m u I= O � ri ri L(1 O r -I C L(1 00 00 Lo ai N ri 00 Ln O N M m m N 1-I L(1 ri r, r I N ri n 't Q1 1--I 00r-1 LOO W ,Zt N N N OLn �orn N LLr Ln N r i In L(1 ai o rn `�° N —I -I ^ m N N N Ln Lr 't M N r -I m l0 N O .0 O Ql rI Ln Ln �t r, m r -I m N N LO N N Ln N Q1 Q1 Lfl C 00 -4 rI O00 r, Ln r -I ri Ln cf. -M��r_ N N W > x J N > V) W CD W � C D z W 6 Qt >LU a C7 u I= O N N OLn �orn N LLr Ln N r i In L(1 ai o rn `�° N —I -I ^ m N N N Ln Lr 't M N r -I m l0 N O .0 O Ql rI Ln Ln �t r, m r -I m N N LO N N Ln N Q1 Q1 Lfl C 00 -4 rI O00 r, Ln r -I ri Ln cf. -M��r_ r 7 F- F - 00 rr �n v Z W NJ Z LJJ N 0 N W o ~ Q W � Y V v LL O Z Q L N N r V C7 > o F- F - 00 rr �n v � N O Y O O +� OJ v L u U U C r9 O "6 > Q r0 > Q1 ++ 1 > .0 O O C O Q > N M C J V U U L O 4 O L O Q QO c_1 v C r6 V Q1 r6 "00 i t C O — Q1 >QL1 C N 9 U LJ N0 pQ "6 "6 7 7 N 7 7 C U '6 U -0 O ro O O LU O O O O O O L Ln m Ln a) O M M N fC GJ l0 00 00 -4 C i N 1 > GJ •O a 0 0 o a a rn �q Li o`n ^ N � 0 4+ N � f0 GJ C m u�i N f6 m N N N > fc6 rl 00 l0 N (6 O O r -f In Ln tD N 3 N oo io a 0 4+ 4, 1� n Ln �n N Y N Q o fC Ln Ln O N N 00 � s ri m Ln m m -4 O1 Ill a I io O 41 o -10 r, io io ra v Naj N m m m o N � � rN-i 0 'a 41 r, Ln Ln N c N ° m A 4i� fC I� O n M - :o v Y ri O ri In Ln lD N ) O Y ° GJ r +'bb m Ln a) N N l^D Ln N n n n O 0 � '0 � � O O N rn 3 r H ri ri Co 2 3 o w`iN N N CL v c v x V v a O v x w C Q to w bD Lr) v OC >N � w N > v Waj z ' 6 W GSC > x v � w > v a •� O U O LU 0- O w Z Z F- F - 00 rr �n u 00 N 0 N a r Z Z W Lc a W � F 0 N o 2 V Y � Q N W a a a O ZL Q ° e ~ Q Q Y V C7 > 0 u 00 N 0 N a o � ° v o v Q) 76 U N U N N 6 C 6 > J > .� U U i C > C Qi E � f6 N N f0 E o v a C3 o � O C Q O Q O W p 6 a u Q 7 7 Q 7 7 3 O O O O O O LU W O O O O O O O L- N O � N O I, QJ N U N Ln N Ln N GJ ar m > GJ �O a 0 0, 0, Ln c rn rn r, ^� � 3 N � p ++ N in f6 N O1 N 01 -4 N Ln Ln -4 U 7 ^ 00 ^ 00 N N M O O m m N Nf0 fa ra fC > CA O O O N O N C 00 C, � W W N N LD v N � m m cl cl Y a p ++ N u + , m m - m rn a -° Q c fC r -I Ln r -I Ln N l0 N tD v Y 4,0 W W W cl C v 4+ � i Q1 0) 't �t Lr v N W c p 'a 4� N N0 e -I N 3 m N N N N 4,� m to - fC l0 N l0 N .-I m e -I m N O a f v E 0 Ln Ln I� n N - ++ 41 N ri r -I ri ri N l0 N l0 rn N a i N m pp Cl m m F p 41 'a Lo Lo Oi of N c N Ln N 3 m m m m Co v .3 c * 0 0 E C N GJ CL x x a N 3 a w LU v LLJ V) N Z) z .� N z > v to N Iy > a LU a r v LLJ w z z u 00 N 0 N a CL) o_ rn Q) v v I 41 cco 2 U co v o U Url- f6 Nf �b� a i E U 1 76 / 41 u o N v to Q � L u U Lba O 4- > O o C:) � s +�+ db�?i E C: o a U E L Vii U 17 m 0 V,, N L — L. N ia O O O O O O O O O O O U 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0000000000 Ln O� O O Ln tO m O rl N _4 I I 2 U co v U Nf �b� a 1 u 0 0 2 U co v U Nf �b� a LmO u o N Q � L u U c t6 O 4- E C: o a E U — L. ia 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O O O O O O O O O O O O O U1 O �q O u1 O �q O u1 O Lq O �q O O O ILD lD u1 LO -zT -zT M M N N r -i -1 0 0 0 0 w O co r 4- 0 co ti r a) (6 w p 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 w o +� 0 0 0 0 u O O O O O N 0 Q0 0 0 0 0 r Cl) O O O (D O M P- �n m I` � co N (A LLLG n n LCL O 0 O 0 0 6-1 >- N O N O r clj r Q) tDLO 5 r14 r14 i aL�co a 0 Ul +-) a cn CA 0 0 0 (1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 -00- 4-j J O O O N O O O O J C'7 0 76 = U co L c� L V CL) LL 1 O O O a M > > Q O U- = N 0 26� o N f N U- co 0 0 0 0 0 0 a a 0 0 0 0 0 0 °� a 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N O 00 lD lzt N O O co r 4- 0 co ti r a) (6 w p 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 w o 0 0 0 0 0 O O O O O N 0 J w 0 0 0 r Cl) O O O (D O M P- O I` co N (A LLLG O O O 0 O 0 0 w >- N r r clj r a a cn CA 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 -00- 4-j J O O O N O 00 O O J C'7 0 co I` O O VO CL) LL 1 O O O co O O O U- = N 0 N N U- co a a °� a O O O c O O � Z U 00 0 ti N N Z I` 0 C) Ln O ti co co N 00 0 E Q ti co � Q J m 0 CO LO C6 co cc co(~� rn oro �� W T M > r r 00 N co co r LC ) O coLO E Z _ N /1 ANY W M70 U Q C6 N J N m U N N m CD N ( ca M CD N m 06 � � O = 06O (1)= 0) Mco Z) N N L � a) cn Q _ a) a) .s= � (n -r- � H 06 Q U D 7 U ++ w (D 0 w 0 L Cn v U) U) U Q H 0 O co r 4- 0 co ti r a) (6 Staff Report r NJ :R Infrastructure Services Department www.kitchener.ca REPORT TO: Finance and Corporate Services Committee DATE OF MEETING: September 16, 2024 SUBMITTED BY: Bu Lam, Director, Sanitary and Stormwater Utilities 519-741-2200 ext. 4212 PREPARED BY: Nick Gollan, Manager, Utility Planning and Programs 519-741-2200 ext. 7422 WARD(S) INVOLVED: All DATE OF REPORT: August 27, 2024 REPORT NO.: INS -2024-396 SUBJECT: Integrated Sanitary Master Plan Process Update RECOMMENDATION: For information. REPORT HIGHLIGHTS: The purpose of this report is to inform Council that staff has been directed by the Ministry of Environment, Conservation and Parks (MECP) not to issue a "Notice of Completion", including filing the Environmental Study Report for a 30 -day public review period. All works identified in the report are classified as Schedule 'A/A+' under the Municipal Class Environmental Assessment Guidelines (MEA, 2023) and pre -approved and exempt from the Schedule 'B' notice requirements. This has no material effect on the study recommendations or identified sanitary programs. This is merely a change to the administrative process for completion of the Sanitary Master Plan under the Municipal Class EA requirements. This report supports the delivery of core services. BACKGROUND: On May 13, 2024, staff presented the Integrated Sanitary Master Plan (ISAN-MP) Final Report to the Community and Infrastructure Services Committee with recommendations for Council to approve the report and direct staff to file it for the mandatory 30 -day public review period as required for Schedule 'B' projects under the Environmental Assessment Act. After that meeting, city staff provided the ISAN-MP to MECP staff for a courtesy review before publicly posting the report. Upon reviewing the report, MECP staff determined there were no Schedule 'B' components to the sanitary master plan, and as such, posting the final report for a formal 30 -day review period would be the incorrect approach to follow in formally finalizing the study's outcomes. Rather than posting a "Notice of Completion," city staff were directed to issue a project update to inform stakeholders of the revised status of the project as a Schedule 'A/A+' *** This information is available in accessible formats upon request. *** Please call 519-741-2345 or TTY 1-866-969-9994 for assistance. Page 179 of 180 environmental assessment and that it has now completed all steps necessary in the environmental assessment process. REPORT: Shifting the ISAN-MP to a Schedule `A/A+' rather than a Schedule `B' environmental assessment has no material impact on the recommendations and programs identified in the final report. The Province is currently in the process of modernizing the Municipal Class Environmental Assessment process. The Municipal Engineers Association (MEA) has a bulletin on their website (https://municipalclassea.ca/index.html) stating that additional information about the new process should be forthcoming later this year. Staff will stay informed of these changes as they are rolled out to ensure correct processes are applied in future studies. STRATEGIC PLAN ALIGNMENT: This report supports the delivery of core services. FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS: None. COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT: Consultation is a vital part of the Class EA process. A Consultation Plan was developed to ensure all mandatory requirements were met while providing a more innovative approach. INFORM — This report has been posted to the City's website with the agenda in advance of the council/committee meeting. As identified in INS -2024-223, extensive consultation and collaboration took place during the development of the ISAN-MP. All project stakeholders involved in the project since its commencement in September 2021 will receive a project update to inform them of the revision from Schedule `B' to `A/A+.' An update to the Engage Page will also provide new project status information (https://www.engagewr.ca/sanitarymasterplan). A complete copy of the ISAN-MP final report will be posted there for anyone in the public to access and download. Staff will be happy to have further discussions with any interested parties about the sanitary master plan and any related initiatives as they come forward. PREVIOUS REPORTS/AUTHORITIES: • INS -2024-223 Integrated Sanitary Master Plan Final Report APPROVED BY: Denise McGoldrick, General Manager, Infrastructure Services Page 180 of 180