Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCompass Kitchener - 2025_05_07 KiT�;�,�, Compass Kitchener Advisory Committee Agenda May 7, 2025, 4:00 p.m. - 6:00 p.m. Schmalz Room - Second Floor City Hall City of Kitchener 200 King Street W, Kitchener, ON N2G 4G7 People interested in participating in this meeting can email Committee Administrator, Allison Remillard at allison.rem illard(a)kitchener.ca. Please refer to the delegation section on the agenda below for the registration deadline. Written comments received will be circulated to the Committee prior to the meeting and will form part of the public record. *Accessible formats and communication supports are available upon request. If you require assistance to take part in a city meeting or event, please call 519-741-2345 or TTY 1-866-969-9994.* Chair: Troy Glover Vice-Chair: James Young Pages 1. Commencement 2. Disclosure of Pecuniary Interest and the General Nature Thereof Members of Council and members of the City's local boards/committees are required to file a written statement when they have a conflict of interest. If a conflict is declared, please visit www.kitchener.ca/conflict to submit your written form. 3. Delegations Pursuant to Council's Procedural By-law, delegations are permitted to address the Committee for a maximum of five (5) minutes. All delegations must register in order to participate in the meeting. Delegation registration is permitted up to the start of the meeting. 4. Discussion Items 4.1 Accelerating Commercial Business Approvals 20 m Review draft. 4.2 Advancing Truth and Reconciliation 40 m Review draft. 4.3 General Comments and Recommendations 60 m Review draft. 5. Information Items 5.1 2024 Strategic Plan Report Card 1 5.2 2019-2022 Strategic Plan Progress Update for Remaining 8 Projects 22 5.3 Compass Kitchener Report Card 2024 Draft 25 6. Adjournment T ""T €E G ///„o, orb. / u% a% € a i LL /// R"T r //i /ii„,,.,,.vii, ,,, ;?ri/� „� ”-,,,, „ �1- �t� ,;,/ ;; „or, Projects Completed in 2023, 2019-2022 Plan Overall Reflections, and Comments on 2023-2026 Strategic Plan June 2024 i 11111FINY kitchenIer ss m li II L it vision V a �s p 1 i o 1 i L,� 1 1 . m ve Ll iii1�,.I I i:)i. Compass Kitchener Compass Kitchener consists of community volunteers and serves as an advisory committee appointed by and reporting to Kitchener City Council. It creates and leads Strategic Plan public engagement processes, determines community concerns, and identifies priorities for action. The Committee also monitors and evaluates progress on implementation of the Strategic Plan and achievement of the community vision and reports to Council on the outcome of this evaluation. This Report Card This report card is the third from Compass Kitchener evaluating completed Strategic Plan 2019- 2022 projects. It focuses on: • a cumulative summary of all the Strategic Plan 2019-2022 projects completed to date; • detailed evaluation of the six most recently completed strategic plan projects and related notes for the future; and • the Committee's overall observations on development and implementation of the 2019- 2022 Strategic Plan and related notes for the future; and • comments related to the 2023-2026 Strategic Plan and its development. Previous Strategic Plan 2019-2022 Report Cards In December 2021, Compass Kitchener presented to Council its first 2019-2022 Strategic Plan Evaluation report sharing the Committee's detailed evaluation of the 12 strategic plan projects that had been completed by that date. Six of the 12 projects exceeded expectations and the balance met expectations. In May 2023, Compass Kitchener presented another report to Council sharing the Committee's evaluation of five more strategic plan projects which were completed in 2023. Of the five projects evaluated in 2023, two exceeded expectations, one met expectations, and two did not meet expectations. 2023 Project Evaluation Findings • This report card reviews six completed projects/sub-projects from the 2019-2022 Strategic Plan. Five were completed in 2023 and one was completed in 2022 (not evaluated in 2022 report card). • Two projects exceeded expectations, three projects met expectations, and Compass Kitchener's usual evaluation framework was not applied to one project as it evolved differently than initially envisioned. • Eight projects/sub-projects remain incomplete: six are targeted for completion in 2024, one in 2025, and one is ongoing. 2 2 2019-2022 Strategic Plan Projects Overall Evaluation of Completed Projects Expected Completion GOAL PROJECT Sub-Projects Separated Out Exceeded Met Expectations Did Not Meet Expectations Expectations Complete Streets ✓ i.—.—.—.✓—...— —.—.—.—.—.—...— —.—.—.—.—.—.—. Bikeshare Program i People Friendly Protected Cycling Network — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — 2024 Transportation Cycling and Trails Materplan- connectivity and winter ✓ maintenance _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ Pedestrian First Streets i. i ______ ...................... i i Corporate Climate Action Plan ✓ Energy Efficiency Reserve Fund ✓ Environmental Community Climate Action Plan ✓ Leadership Sustainable Urban Forest Strategy-tree canopy+tree ✓ planting Waste Diversion Strategy ✓ Urban Design Manual ✓ Incubator and Accelerator Network 2024 Make it Kitchener 2.0 Strategy ✓ City Property Review+Property City Property Review 2024 Vibrant Economy to Market Property to Market Ongoing Develop a Vision for Downtown Vision i-------✓------i._._._._._------i._._._.------ i Downtown,Innovation District Innovation District (Bramm (Bramm Yard)Master Plan and Yards)Master Plan2024 ] I Civic District Master Plans Civic District Master Plan N/A ._._._._._._._. ._._._._._._._._ _._._._._._._. Equity,Diversity and Inclusion Strategy ✓ Affordable Housing Strategy ✓ Reduce Social Stigmas ✓ Mill Courtland Community ! ! ! ! Centre Business Case ! ! ✓ ! ! Caring Community —•—•—•—•—•—•— —•—•—•—•—•—•—•— —•—•—•—•—•—•— Rosenberg Community Centre Open Space Strategy+ + 2025 Equitable Facility Distribution Expansion Business Case Complete Huron Brigadoon ✓ Community Centre Open Space Strategy 2024 Arts and Culture Plan 2024 Multi-language Interpretation ✓ Support Customer Satisfaction Program ✓ Great Customer Service Online Customer Service Portal ✓ Set and Communicate Service Levels ✓ Customer Experience Program ! ! ✓ ! ! TOTAL 8 ------10----- ------10------ -------Z----- LEGEND Grey Background Projects/Sub Projects still to be completed Dotted border Projects evaluated in this report �._._._._._._._._._._._._. 3 3 Overall Observations and Looking Ahead Compass Kitchener commends the City on the impressive advancement of its 2019-2022 Strategic Plan, despite major disruptions caused by the pandemic. Twenty-three Strategic Plan projects have been completed to date, ten of which Compass Kitchener found exceeded expectations, ten met expectations, two did not meet expectations, and one was reviewed outside the typical evaluation framework. Compass Kitchener highlights the exceptional success achieved on: • the Bikeshare Program; • the Cycling and Trails Master Plan and 3 km increase in trails with year-round access; • the Corporate Climate Action Plan; • the Urban Forest Strategy + Tree Canopy; • the Make it Kitchener 2.0 Strategy; • the Downtown Vision; • the Corporate Equity and Anti-Racism Strategy; • the Affordable Housing Strategy; • the Huron Community Centre; and • the Online Customer Service Portal. The Committee provides a number of observations and suggestions based on its review of projects/sub-projects in the 2019-2022 Strategic Plan and its look ahead to the new 2023-2026 Strategic Plan. The main topics addressed are: • Post-COVID Ramp-Up; • Housing Affordability; • Customer Service; • Delayed/Deferred Projects; • Arts and Culture Master Plan; • Project Budgets and Financial Data; and • The 2023-2026 Strategic Plan. In Closing Compass Kitchener commends the City on: • the 23 2019-2022 Strategic Plan projects/sub-projects that have been completed; • the overall quality of the work done; • the continuing work on projects that remains; • the continued evolution and growing effectiveness of public consultation processes; and • the successful ramping up of the City's activities, programs, and operations post-pandemic, returning them to full capacity. 4 4 As the City's focus shifts from the 2019-2022 Strategic Plan to implementation of the 2023-2026 Strategic Plan, we encourage the City to focus on three guiding themes that Compass Kitchener has identified as being of key importance moving forward with this plan: 1. FOCUS ON STRATEGIC INDICATORS AND PRIORITIZE DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS Compass Kitchener commends the City on the attention being given to the outcomes desired within each goal area and encourages continued focus on refining, the strategic indicators associated with each of the five goal areas in the strategic plan. Use the chosen strategic indicators to refine and prioritize data collection and analysis in order to provide Staff and Council with the best possible information on which to base decisions. 2. BE PROACTIVE, PRIORITY-DRIVEN, AND ADAPTIVE Given the pressing issues our community faces and the rate of change in the environment in which it operates, be proactive, priority-driven, and adaptive: o keep abreast of shifting priorities through public engagement; o review and reassess priorities based on new developments and public input; and o proactively adapt to change. The new, more adaptive, strategic plan provides a platform that enables proactive and nimble responsiveness to change. 3. ADDRESS THE GROWING CRISIS OF SOCIAL ISOLATION AND LONELINESS Compass Kitchener strongly urges Council to recognize the urgent need for action on the pressing issue of social isolation and loneliness within our community. Kitchener, like so many communities across Canada, grapples with an epidemic of loneliness that adversely affects the wellbeing of its residents. Research shows that social isolation and loneliness have profound negative impacts on physical and mental health, leading to increased risk of chronic diseases, depression, and even premature mortality. By declaring social isolation and loneliness an epidemic, the City of Kitchener has the opportunity to lead the nation as the first municipality in Canada to acknowledge and address this critical public health issue. Such a declaration would not only raise critical awareness, but also pave the way for innovative solutions and collaborative efforts to foster a more connected and supportive community in line with the aspirations of our newest strategic plan. At a time when recognition of this crisis remains lacking at the Provincial and Federal levels, the City of Kitchener can seize this opportunity to set a precedent and inspire other municipalities to follow suit, thereby catalyzing a nationwide movement toward combating loneliness, promoting social cohesion, and creating the conditions for a greater sense of belonging. 5 5 II II[.Ae of Cavteir°°i t Executive Summary 2 Compass Kitchener 7 Evaluation Approach 8 2023 Project Evaluations 10 PEOPLE-FRIENDLY TRANSPORTATION 10 Bikeshare Program 10 Pedestrian-First Streets 11 VIBRANT ECONOMY 12 Civic District Master Plan 12 Downtown Vision 13 CARING COMMUNITY 14 Mill Courtland Community Centre Expansion Business Case 14 GREAT CUSTOMER SERVICE 15 Customer experience review program 15 Overall Observations and Looking Ahead 16 Development Et Implementation of the 2023-2026 Strategic Plan 18 In Closing _20 6 6 SEI dherier i This report has been prepared by the following members of the Compass Kitchener Advisory Committee: Judy Stephens-Wells (Chair) Troy Glover (Vice-Chair) Kim Brabazon Alide Forstmanis Wasai Rahimi Linda Terry Lee-Anne Thompson Lori Trumper James Young 7 LN�)­ 10 Compass Kitchener approached this evaluation as interested community members and considered timing, impact, accountability, and budget criteria in its assessment. Compass Kitchener considered evaluation criteria for the strategic actions developed in consultation with Kitchener's Corporate Leadership Team. The following questions guided the evaluation: Were strategic actions completed in the expected timeframe? How did strategic actions deliver on anticipated or desired impacts? �' % • How did progress on, or completion of, strategic actions make a J ? difference in the cit and for citizens? y �n • Were progress reports relevant timely and publicly profiled? ' How wellengaged?was e public �c Were strategic actions completed on or within budget? iii i o�o�o�000000000000000000000000�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0�0������ 8 8 Evaluation Rating After completing the evaluation process Compass Kitchener rated completed actions as: • Exceeds Expectations; • Meets Expectations; or • Does Not Meet Expectations. The following chart explains the classification for the three rating categories: 4) Exceeds Meets noes Not Meet Exll ec°l°a°l°i ns Exll ec°l°a°l°i ns Exll ec°l°a°l°i ris -Set and met challenging - Models values of caring, - Late delivery of Objectives and showed innovation,and vibrancy deliverables without initiative in meeting them -Achieves specified criteria explanation or valid - Proactively planned, reasons - Meets the City's high- problem solved and - Poor quality of performance reputation initiated solutions -Contributes positively to deliverables(lack of clarity) -Stepped outside of the success of the City - Poor quantity of existing responsibilities to deliverables add value - Non-delivery of - Puts the public at centre deliverables of work - Identifies breakthrough Concepts - Is regarded as a knowledgeable resource - Exhibits mastery - Impacts exceed specified criteria - Elevates strategic plan - Is an exceptional contributor to strategic plan success 9 9 III IIC;: ` III IIL...IIC;: IIC 111 111 IIC;:II"' 111:'' 11... a ......III: I �"I'll IIIIlk ... ...III II' Transform how people move through the city by making the transportation network safe, convenient, comfortable, and connected. Bikeshare Program Bikeshare Program Report Card Strategic Goal Action: Encourage and incentivize alternative modes of transportation by developing and subsidizing a bikeshare program by 2021. Compass Kitchener's Specific Community Impact Criteria More people are using bikes and for a wider variety of trips, number of rentals, people, bikes, and bike parking facilities. Overall Evakiatiori: Exceeds Expectatiorls Highlights • A new e-scooter and e-bike share program began on April 14, 2023, throughout the Waterloo Region. • It became a regional initiative in which the city participated, though the city did have significant input into the selection of the provider • Revenue neutral initiative that encourages micro-mobility and mitigates carbon output (i.e. saved 12 tonnes of carbon emissions). • High uptake among the public, including covering over 190,000 rides, totally over 360,000 km travelled. • According to Neuron, the provider, the initiative injected $8.2 million into the region's economy. Notes for the Future • Continue efforts to educate public on proper usage to decrease the potential for injury. • Expand the service area in which a-bikes and e-scooters can be accessed and used. • Collect separate information about usage of a-bikes and e-scooters • Consider a public awareness campaign to promote greater etiquette in using and parking a-bikes and e-scooters. 10 10 Pedestrian-First Streets Pedestrian-First Streets Report Card Strategic Goal Action: Develop a plan to create pedestrian-first streets between Victoria Park and City Hall and between the ION and Kitchener Market by 2022. Compass Kitchener's Specific Community Impact Criteria Number of connected adjacent neighbourhoods (of the total) by a continuous link. Overall IEvudin: Meets IEIps ctatiin Highlights • The pedestrianization of the Gaukel Block was completed in June 2023; with only one item left to finish, the pedestrianization of the Market District will be completed in June 2024. • The Gaukel Block activation was supported by the Federal Economic Development Agency for Southern Ontario. • The Market District Activation includes mid-week markets and concerts, urban agriculture, programming, and seating. • Both activations serve as welcome community hubs for local programming. Notes for the Future • Ongoing community programming will be important to ensure an engaging community space for the public. • Continue seeking public input regarding programming and space use. • Consider other areas of the downtown and wider city in which to pedestrianize streets. 11 11 IIIC;: ` II° u Build a vibrant city by making investments to support job creation, economic prosperity, thriving arts and culture and great places to live. Civic District Master Plan Civic District Master Plan Report Card Strategic Goal Action: Finalize the Civic District Master Plan (CDMP) by 2022. As the CDMP received approval by Council in 2009, the intent was to review and update it. Compass Kitchener's Specific Community Impact Criteria Number and nature of opportunities realized and broad public support for the plan. City Staff's review of the CDMP determined the plan, which was written with a long-term lens, remains relevant with no need for updating. Work on Growing Together, developing the planning framework for Kitchener's Major Transit Station Areas, incorporated changes in support of the goals of the CDMP. As review and revision of the CDMP evolved differently than originally planned, the usual evaluation framework was not applied to this project. Highlights • Importantly, staff reaffirmed the relevance of the CDMP, thereby underscoring its importance as a focus for arts and culture. • Growing Together introduced changes supporting inclusion of an educational institution, residential uses, and public/private partnerships, which will facilitate development in the Civic District. • Building elements supportive of the CDMP into Growing Together reflects an effective use of City resources and ensured inter-related projects are not siloed, but are considered together. Notes for the Future • Update the text in the plan to make it a more current, living document. • Make the CDMP more readily available on the City's website. • Focus on ways to enhance animated connections between the Civic District and Downtown Kitchener. 12 12 Downtown Vision Downtown Vision Report Card Strategic Goal Action: Develop a vision for downtown Kitchener and continue to position downtown Kitchener as a leading destination for redevelopment opportunities. Compass Kitchener's Specific Community Impact Criteria This project involved development of a Downtown Vision. Therefore, no specific impact criteria were developed. Overall Evakiadan: Exceeds Expectatians Highlights • Development of the vision and guiding principles was based on an exceptional public engagement process through which the public provided input in numerous ways. The results reflect an impressive level of public participation and input. • The vision and three principles outlined are clear and well-developed. Notes for the Future • Update the City's Downtown Kitchener Vision project page (.I :�:.:�:. sW// WIklu;cl��eineirWca/ein/su;irau;e :. .::::.plainsand�.. p.lrp) ; ./. owintowin� lkitcheineir vnsioinWasp ) and the Downtown Strategy Ibt. .sW//v ww.lkitcl�ieineir.ca/ein/lbu.�siiness nin 11 tcheineir/ owintowin page (.......................p...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... Ikn.:tch ineir::;stir V: Was m) to reflect the completion and approval of the new vision and guiding principles. • Follow through with the vision and guiding principles to impact the downtown. 13 13 III: III II"' Gi CIDMML,fl` IllI....Y Enhance people's sense of belonging and connection by providing welcoming community spaces and programs; better engaging, serving and supporting our diverse populations and helping to make housing affordable. Mill Courtland Community Centre Expansion Business Case Mill Courtland Community Centre Expansion Business Case Report Card Strategic Goal Action: Complete a needs assessment and business case to determine the requirements for an addition to the Mill Courtland Community Centre. Compass Kitchener's Specific Community Impact Criteria Was the project started on time? Overall IEvakulM>ari: Meets IEI " ctatiri Highlights • Extensive consultation process with the community and users of the centre. • Proposed design elements address many community needs, including accessibility and language considerations, incorporating Indigenous design with sustainability initiatives. • Overall, the business case is well-researched and the recommendations demonstrate innovation, inclusion, and diversity. Notes for the Future • Estimated cost of proposal is approximately $1.5 million over budget, so prioritize critical components in the detailed design phase. • Use this business case consultation process as a model for future recreation centre builds/expansions, especially its use of partnerships to offer meaningful programming and a community hub for the neighbourhoods it serves. 14 14 � I . .. .... ... ... w Ilk A S Increase people's satisfaction, trust and engagement with the City by providing friendly, easy and convenient services. Customer experience review program Customer Experience Review Report Card Strategic Goal Action: Implement a comprehensive Customer Experience Review Program to help ensure services are easy and convenient to access from the customer's perspective by 2022. Compass Kitchener's Specific Community Impact Criteria Results/improvements are made public and % improvement (i.e. shift from negative to positive feedback) over time is included in reporting. Overall IEvakutiri: Meets IEIps ctatiri Highlights • Data gathered through the Customer Satisfaction Program led staff to identify three customer service areas in need of attention: o The MyUtilities widget in MyKitchener o Accessing Revenue/Kitchener Utilities by phone o ActiveNet program used in community centres • 17 recommendations to improve service have been implemented and 19 are in progress. Several of the improvements in progress will be accomplished upon implementation of the new MyUtilities widget and the new telephone system. • In this active problem-solving project, staff were efficient in their use of time and city resources and avoided redundancies. • The City's innovative custom MyUtilities widget, developed with an outside vendor, led the vendor to develop a standard product template for use by other municipalities. Notes for the Future • Assess the full impact of recent improvements and those scheduled for the near future. • Define a clear follow-up plan for collecting new customer satisfaction data to ensure transparency and accountability. • The number of issues identified and solutions found and being implemented, indicates the value of this program and the benefit of its continuation. 15 15 � I I I bs',�e iiir. "I, yld Ill........... IIheI POST-COVID RAMP-UP Compass Kitchener welcomes the City's successful return to pre-pandemic levels of activity, operation, and programming. It also appreciates the City's development of a policy framework to guide hybrid work where appropriate. HOUSING AFFORDABILITY Housing affordability remains a key concern. While municipalities are not responsible for building housing, there are numerous ways in which they can actively help resolve homelessness and the housing affordability crisis affecting residents across the full housing spectrum (e.g. provision of land for shelters or supportive housing, zoning, inclusionary zoning policies, etc.) Compass Kitchener encourages the City to continue to make every possible effort to actively participate in developing innovative, practical solutions to this crisis, focusing its efforts specifically on those areas in which the City can be impactful. CUSTOMER SERVICE Given that the 2019-2022 Strategic plan put significant emphasis on improvements to customer service, Compass Kitchener welcomes the innovative new Customer Service Centre located on the main floor of City Hall. It provides an accessible and efficient interface for community members to connect with knowledgeable staff regarding the broad range of services provided by the City. DELAYED/DEFERRED PROJECTS Eight projects or sub-projects from the 2019-2022 plan remain incomplete. Compass Kitchener looks forward to receiving updates on their progress to enable their evaluation upon completion. ARTS AND CULTURE MASTER PLAN Compass Kitchener recognizes artists and arts and cultural organizations remain particularly vulnerable in this post-pandemic period. This vulnerability arises for three reasons: • continued disruption of audience attendance patterns; • insufficient public and private funding of the arts arising from competing demands for support; and • inflationary pressures. 16 16 Given the enormous social, economic, and community-building value of arts and culture, Compass Kitchener encourages the City to proceed with developing its Arts and Culture Master Plan. Through it, the City can craft strategies to help strengthen and sustain this sector at this critical inflection point. A strong and innovative Arts and Culture Master Plan will both bolster the vibrancy, livability, and wellbeing of our community and help retain healthy levels of employment in this important sector. PROJECT BUDGETS AND FINANCIAL DATA Given public interest in financial accountability, Compass Kitchener has always intended to review actual project expenses in relation to approved budgets. However, this information has generally been unavailable. Accordingly, we encourage the City to share this information, where available, to inform our evaluation process. 17 17 i iir.i�t ..... III iii.°ii�,.�IIIA� iii.°ii�,.iiir.vti,�vil m r.i )i Jhe 20212026 ��� iii�.,��.�: m�m In 2023, Compass Kitchener planned and facilitated public engagement activities to assist with the development of the 2023-2026 Strategic Plan. Accordingly, it seems appropriate for Compass Kitchener to comment on the new strategic plan and its development in this report card. Overall, Compass Kitchener fully supports the new strategic plan. PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT AND STAFF TRAINING We applaud the level of public engagement invested in the development of the new plan, especially the inclusion of the Resident Panel. Resident Panel members responded positively to being involved in the process and felt their participation had a real impact on and added value to the development of the strategic plan. The Resident Panel represented an excellent example of meaningful public engagement and was of particular interest to Compass Kitchener as an innovative new form of public engagement in the City's strategic planning process. Compass Kitchener welcomes the improvements to the City's public engagement activities that were key to many of the 2019-2022 Strategic Plan projects. Given the value of effective public engagement and the increasing number of City staff called upon to design and carry out public engagement processes, Compass Kitchener wants to highlight the importance of ensuring that all staff leading these projects have access to the facilitation/public engagement training needed to support them in generating the most positive and effective outcomes. SUSTAINABILITY AND CLIMATE CHANGE Numerous strategies to advance sustainability, the impacts of which directly affect life in Kitchener and beyond, received thoughtful consideration in the development of the 2023-2026 Strategic Plan. The City deserves praise for its continued efforts to integrate and localize many of the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals in its strategic plan. We encourage the City to continue its efforts to proactively forecast, mitigate, and adapt to the inevitable and growing effects of climate change. FOCUS ON OUTCOMES AND PRIORITIZE DATA COLLECTION Compass Kitchener supports the City's efforts to identify and measure outcomes for each of the five goal areas in its new strategic plan. The work undertaken to identify strategic indicators underpins the framework for effective evaluation. It will guide efforts to fine-tune and prioritize data collection and ensure that the best and most relevant data are available to staff and Council when making important decisions. 18 18 A MORE ADAPTIVE PLAN Compass Kitchener supports Council and Staff's decision to develop a more adaptive plan that identifies five goal areas and prioritized projects for focus in the first couple of years, while still outlining the projects of focus over the balance of the four-year term. In the past, the City planned more projects (sometimes substantially more) than could be accomplished over the term of the plan, sometimes as a result of unforeseen circumstances (e.g. the COVID-19 crisis). Compass Kitchener believes the City's new adaptive approach will: • strengthen the City's ability to adapt and reprioritize in the face of unexpected changes; • support division of large projects into stages, the impact of which can be assessed along the way; and • aid in planning projects that are ambitious while still realistic in number and scale. To maintain momentum over the four years of the plan, Compass Kitchener encourages the City to set clear timelines for the projects initially outlined, as well as those subsequently added to the plan. A more adaptive plan calls for regular and clear communication with the public about progress on and adjustments to individual projects, while also informing the public about new projects as they begin. TRACKING AND SHARING STRATEGIC PLAN PROGRESS ON THE CITY'S WEBSITE In previous years, Compass Kitchener encouraged the City to add a feature to its website that reports progress on implementation of the strategic plan. Accordingly, we are pleased to see this recommendation adopted. Our committee sincerely hopes that progress on projects in the new strategic plan will be similarly documented on the City's website to keep the public informed about the City's work and accomplishments. 19 19 Ill ri O '') ''iiyl Compass Kitchener commends the City on: • the 23 completed projects from the 2019-2022 Strategic Plan; • the overall quality of the work done; • the continuing work on projects that remains; • the continued evolution and growing effectiveness of public consultation processes; and • the successful ramping up of the City's activities, programs, and operations post-pandemic, returning them to full capacity. As the City's focus shifts from the 2019-2022 Strategic Plan to implementation of the 2023-2026 Strategic Plan, Compass Kitchener suggests three recommendations as the City moves forward: 1. FOCUS ON THE INDICATORS OF SUCCESS AND PRIORITIZ DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS It will be key to: o maintain focus on, and continue to refine, the key indicators of success associated with each of the five goal areas in the strategic plan; and o use that focus to refine and adjust priorities for data collection and analysis to provide Staff and Council with the best possible information on which to base decisions. 2. BE PROACTIVE, PRIORITY-DRIVEN AND ADAPTIVE Given the pressing issues faced in our community, and the rate of change in the environment in which it operates, be proactive, priority-driven, and adaptive: o keep abreast of shifting priorities through public engagement o review and reassess priorities based on new developments and public input; and o proactively adapt to change. The new, more adaptive, strategic plan provides a platform that supports responding nimbly and proactively to change. 20 20 3. ADDRESS THE GROWING CRISIS OF SOCIAL ISOLATION AND LONELINESS Compass Kitchener strongly urges Council to recognize the urgent need for action on the pressing issue of social isolation and loneliness within our community. Kitchener, like so many communities across Canada, grapples with an epidemic of loneliness that adversely affects the wellbeing of its residents. Research shows that social isolation and loneliness have profound negative impacts on physical and mental health, leading to increased risk of chronic diseases, depression, and even premature mortality. By declaring social isolation and loneliness an epidemic, the City of Kitchener has the opportunity to lead the nation as the first municipality in Canada to acknowledge and address this critical public health issue. Such a declaration would not only raise critical awareness, but also pave the way for innovative solutions and collaborative efforts to foster a more connected and supportive community in line with the aspirations of our newest strategic plan. At a time when recognition of this crisis remains lacking at the Provincial and Federal levels, the City of Kitchener can seize this opportunity to set a precedent and inspire other municipalities to follow suit, thereby catalyzing a nationwide movement toward combating loneliness, promoting social cohesion, and creating the conditions for a greater sense of belonging. 21 21 2019-2022 Strategic Plan Progress Update for Remaining Eight(8)Projects People-Friendly Transportation SHOWN EM 1.3 Install a continuous and protected Protected Cycling Network Connected to Darren Kropf 2024 Completed The cycling network was completed and opened for use In late cycling network that connects adjacent the Downtown Transportation Services 2024,with a few finishing touches on the last portion of Duke neighbourhoods to the downtown by Install a continuous and protected cycling Street to be addressed In spring 2025.An official ribbon cutting 2022. network that connects adjacent and celebration will occur on Saturday June 7,1-5 pm on Water neighbourhoods to the downtown by Street next to the public bike counter,Including learn-to-ride 2022. classes,bike scavenger hunts,themed rides and a street party.Come celebrate!More Info posted at bikekitchener.ca. Vibrant Economy MENNEN 3.2 Foster the creation of a city-wide 3.2.2 Incubator,Accelerator and Co- Cory Bluhm 2025 and 2026 One item was The Creative Hub at 44 6aukel Is now fully leased and has a network of Incubators,accelerators and co- Working Space Network Economic Development completed In 2024; waiting list for new tenants. working spaces by completing the buildout Lease all spaces In the Creative Hub, two are delayed— of 44 6aukel In 2019,advancing work on a explore the potential to facilitate a Food n will be Design for the Small Business Centre In the Innovation Arena Is Creative Hub and undertaking business Incubator with a business case pending, completed In 2025 currently underway with build-out and occupancy anticipated In In 2019-2021 for the food and explore partnerships for the Of 2026. casesin and health/med-tech development of manufacturing and and one In 2026 industries. health/med-tech Industry Incubators. A Staff Report Including a Business Case for a food Incubator will be submitted to Council for consideration In Q3 2025. 3.4 Complete a comprehensive review of City-Owned Property Review Brian Bennett 2024 Completed A city-owned property review has been completed and a new city-owned properties by 2020 to determine Complete a comprehensive review of Economic Development City-owned property land disposition framework can be found how they could be effectively used to city-owned properties by 2020 to lierG. advance city strategic objectives. determine how they could be effectively used to advance city strategic objectives. 3.5 Develop a vision for downtown 3.5.1 Downtown Vision and City-Owned Brian Bennett 2024 Completed Downtown Kitchener Is at a critical point In its evolution and Kitchener and continue to position Property Brought to Market Economic Development growth.To ground new and ongoing City Initiatives In equity, downtown Kitchener as a leading Develop a vision for downtown experience,growth and sustainability,the City of Kitchener destination for redevelopment Kitchener and continue to position Initiated the development of a comprehensive vision and set of opportunities,with at least one new city- downtown Kitchener as a leading guiding principles.Nearly 3,000 Individuals from diverse caned property brought to market by 2020. destination for redevelopment backgrounds were engaged In a collaborative and expansive Finalize the Innovation District(Bramm opportunities,with one new city-owned process to gather Input on their experiences with and Yards)Master Plan by 2021 and the Civic property brought to market by 2022. aspirations for DTK.The vision can be found here. District Master Plan by 2022. In a significant step toward addressing the growing need for affordable housing,the City of Kitchener Is unlocking city-owned landto build not-for-profit housing.This Initiative,aimed at rearing long-term solutions to the housing crisis,was carried out through a Request for Proposals(RFP)process,Inviting qualified organizations to submit plans for development. 1 22 The RFP process is part oft he City's broader strategy to increase the supply of affordable and supportive housing for residents. Proposals that can address critical housing needs were welcomed,Including homes for low-income families,seniors, and Individuals experiencing homelessness. The City owned property at 1035 Ottawa St was donated to Habitat for Humanity as the first Initiative In providing land for affordable housing.Construction for the housing project Is expected to start In 2025 and take 18 months to 2 years to complete.You can read more here 3.5.2 Innovation District(Bramm Yards) Cory Bluhm 2024 Completed vision Council approved the revised vision and development principles Master Plan Economic Development and design for the Bramm Yards Master Plan.The plan Includes allocating Finalize the Innovation District(Bramm principles(City of upto$400,000 from the Environmental Remediation Reserve Yards)Master Plan by 2022. Kitchener Scope) for pre-design reports necessary for the redevelopment of Bramm Yards at 55 Bramm Street and 130 Park Street. Additionally,staff will conduct a market assessment to determine the optimal timing for selling the property and Identify potential development constraints to ensure a successful redevelopment process. Procurement Services and Realty Services were authorized by council to Implement a competitive land disposition process, based on the vision and development principles approved as part of report DSD-2024-240,through the Issuance of a public request for proposals(RFP)seeking a Master Developer who k1 acquire the Bramm Yards and lead a multi-phased redevelopment of the property,Including the creation of a Master Plan.The timing of the Issuance of an RFP will be subject to real estate market conditions. An Environmental Site Assessment was approved by Council In 2024,which Is a necessary step to Issue aRequest for Proposal to sell the property.A Request for Quotations from Environmental Consultants was Issued by Procurement In February 2025.Staff are reviewing the proposals received and wi0 be awarding a contract shortly,with work to commence In May 2025. Going forward,staff will collaborate with the University of Waterloo to ensure a shared vision related to the development plan for the Bramm Yards area(given the neighbouring Health Innovation Arena UW Health Sciences Campus).A Master Plan for the site will be completed by the successful developer. Read the full reC rt and ne, 2 23 Caring Community 4.4 Complete the Rosenberg Community 4.4.2 New Rosenberg Community Mark Hildebrand 2024 Completed The needs assessment and business case for the project have Centre by 2021. Centre/School Business Case Neighbourhood Programs&Services been completed,followed by the successful completion of the With the Catholic School board, design stage.Groundbreaking for the joint school and complete a needs assessment and community centre took place In September 2024,marking a business case to determine the significant milestone.Currently,the construction of the requirements for a joint community combined facility Is underway and progressing on track. centre/school In the Rosenberg area. 4.4 Complete an Open Space Strategy by 4.4.4 Open Space Strategy Mark Parris 2025 Completed Places&Spaces:An Open Space Strategy for Kitchener will be 2021. Develop an open space strategy to Parks&Cemeteriesunew guiding strategic document for parks and open spaces explore the value of open spaces,how in Kitchener.The Places&Spaces strategy focuses on two main they function,are planned,maintained, topics: and managed,and Including a review of • Spaces:where we have parks and where we need them permitted uses In parks. • Places:what we need In parks to support our residents and communities The, portion of the Places and Spaces strategy Is complete. Staff have met with Councillors to refine the recommendations of the Places report and the final phase of the strategy—Places- is scheduled to be presented to Community and Infrastructure Services Committee on May 12,2025. The status for this item is marked as complete,as it will be completed prior to Compass Kitchener's report going to Council inlune. 4.S Engage a broad cross-section of the Arts and Culture Plan Andrea Hallam 2025 On Track per the The development of this plan Is currently underway(being community Including the arts and creative Develop a new and Inclusive Arts and Economic Development 2023-2026 retitled"Arts and Creative Industries Action Plan"). industry sector and multi-cultural Culture Plan by engaging a broad cross- Strategic Plan Implementation of the plan Is an action In the current 2023- unities to develop an Inclusive arts section of the community Including the action Item 2026 Strategic Plan,which Is reported on to council through the and culture Plan by 2021. arts and creative Industry sector and strategic plan reporting cycle to council(3x/year). multi-cultural communities. The plan will be completed In 2025 and actioned over a multi- year period,from 2026-2028. 3 24 N ii a r ii v �i ���✓� �i. ,,,,,��� ,;; �i ���ii� L O 7 D # Projects Completed in 2024 and Reflections on the Development and Implementation of the 2023-2026 Strategic Plan June 2025 25 1 ompass k Itchene ommunity vision va:lue�s priorities rOOiorr / �%%�%%///%/%a ii IIIx e" C"",Ll "'. � ��III'""'III""'�III'""'III""'I 26 2 "III Executive Summary----------------_ -----------2 Compass Kitchener ----------------_ -----------4 Evaluation Approach ----------------------------_4 2024 Project Evaluations ----------------_ --------_7 CREATING AN ECONOMICALLY-THRIVING CITY TOGETHER 7 Accelerate Commercial Business Approvals 7 FOSTERING A CARING CITY TOGETHER 9 Advance Truth and Reconciliation 9 Overall Observations and Looking Ahead ----------------_— — 10 In Closing--------------------------------- 13 27 3 Compass Kitchener Compass Kitchener consists of community volunteers and serves as an advisory committee appointed by and reporting to Kitchener City Council. It creates and leads Strategic Plan public engagement processes, determines community concerns, and identifies priorities for action. The Committee also monitors and evaluates progress on implementation of the Strategic Plan and achievement of the community vision and reports to Council on the outcome of this evaluation. This report has been prepared by the following members of the Compass Kitchener Advisory Committee: Troy Glover (Chair) James Young (Vice-Chair) Carlos Abarca Kim Brabazon Srihasya Kandala Rodney Gill Judy Stephens-Wells Lee-Anne Thompson Linda Terry Lori Trumper IIIIII I '''I'I '"I '' IIL.I i: .� IIIA IIIA �� � Compass Kitchener approached this evaluation as interested community members and considered timing, impact, accountability, and budget criteria in its assessment. Compass Kitchener considered evaluation criteria for the strategic actions developed in consultation with Kitchener's Corporate Leadership Team. The following questions guided the evaluation: 1. Responsible Project Delivery: This criterion focuses on how well project goals, budgets and timelines are managed. It emphasizes the importance of monitoring and tracking progress to ensure projects are completed efficiently and effectively, achieving goals within financial constraints and deadlines. • Note: Given that the 2023-2026 Strategic Plan is intended to be adaptive, responsible project delivery also recognizes that timelines may shift due to shifting priorities and needs. 2. Impact/Public Value: This criterion assesses how the impact of the project will be tracked and evaluated, and the extent to which a project (has the potential) to create positive outcomes for the community and contributes to the goal(s) of the Strategic Plan. 28 4 3. Transparency Et Communication: This criterion focuses on the dissemination of information through staff reports and other channels. It emphasizes the importance of relevant, clear, timely, and accessible communication to the community, ensuring that project goals, progress, challenges, and outcomes/impacts are openly shared. 4. Public Engagement: This criterion evaluates how well a project involves the community and/or relevant parties in its planning and execution. Equity Lens Using the definition of equity outlined in Kitchener's Equity, Inclusion &t Anti-Racism policy, Compass Kitchener will also incorporate an equity lens to underpin the evaluation of all projects. "An equity approach creates the conditions for fair and equal access and opportunity for everyone, by addressing discriminations, exclusions and barriers experienced by distinct groups. Equity is not the same as equality, nor is it the same an inequality." 29 5 Evaluation Rating Compass Kitchener will evaluate each project using the following rating scale: exceeds expectations, meets expectations, and does not meet expectations. The evaluation rating will be determined based on the extent to which all applicable evaluation criteria are met, recognizing that some criteria may not be applicable to each project. Each individual criterion will be assigned a rating, and based on the ratings of all applicable criteria, Compass Kitchener members will determine an overall rating through a consensus vote. The following chart explains the classification for the three rating categories: 41 /", Ili:!), Exceeds Meets Does Not Meet IIpec ati sins ExIpectatiosns ExIpectatiosns -Set and met challenging - Models values of caring, - Late delivery of Objectives and showed innovation,and vibrancy deliverables without initiative in meeting them -Achieves specified criteria explanation or valid - Proactively planned, reasons - Meets the City's high- problem solved and - Poor quality of performance reputation initiated solutions -Contributes positively to deliverables(lack of clarity) -Stepped outside of the success of the City - Poor quantity of existing responsibilities to deliverables add value - Non-delivery of - Puts the public at centre deliverables of work - Identifies breakthrough Concepts - Is regarded as a knowledgeable resource - Exhibits mastery - Impacts exceed specified criteria - Elevates strategic plan - Is an exceptional contributor to strategic 30 6 IIIIIIII !!I'"° plan success :III: III;: .II III III;: `:: INC' II ° IIL....IIL.: i�"......111I..Ih....�III: III III II II � 0I ...III.. Ill :...Ill...11h....�III; We use our collective strengths to grow an agile and diverse local economy powered by talented entrepreneurs, workers, and artists. We work together to create opportunities for everyone and a resilient future that propels our city forward. Accelerate Commercial Business Approvals Accelerate Commercial Business Approvals Report Card Project Description: Facilitate streamlined business process and approvals for brick-and-mortar retail business across the City. . Overall IIS,°�wvul�>ni�°i: 1��� IIS,°�wIps c1� t>nw°i Highlights Responsible Project Delivery • Delivered within the planned timeline (Sept 2023 - Mar 2024); • Defined scope and methodology via a robust Terms of Reference and Lean process involving cross-departmental collaboration; and • Appointed a dedicated internal Project Manager to oversee implementation. Impact / Public Value • Identified 55 process improvements, 65% of which were classified as "quick wins" to streamline approvals and enhance customer service; • Introduced practical tools such as a business roadmap guide, pre- application process, and digital permit review systems; and • Implementation tracking and impact evaluation (e.g., satisfaction surveys and reduced processing times) are underway. • Introduced coordinated onsite meetings where City staff from multiple departments visit business locations together to review the full scope of approvals, streamlining the process and improving clarity for business owners. • Used the online language translation and interpretation services during onsite visits to ensure better accessibility and support for business owners whose first language is not English. Transparency and Communication • Provided project updates to Council through regular strategic plan reporting cycles; final report publicly available; and 31 • Sent closure emails with report links to participating business owners as a gesture of accountability and transparency. Public Engagement • Conducted 12 interviews with business owners and followed up with surveys and updates to maintain engagement; and • Employed user-focused methods such as empathy mapping and process mapping in cross-departmental workshops. Notes for the Future • Consider expanding the project's scope beyond downtown Kitchener to assess applicability and effectiveness across the city. • Revisit the project in a future evaluation cycle to assess long-term outcomes and public value, once more implementation and impact data are available. • Continue to collect and share outcome data, including satisfaction rates, reduced approval timelines, and cost savings for businesses. • Broaden communications efforts to publicly highlight improvements and promote awareness of new business-friendly tools and processes. • Contemplate further engagement with underrepresented or equity-seeking business communities to ensure inclusive benefit from improvements. 32 8 OS...iii..iii iiia iii ii .; .viii NG C iii...iii...Y ...iii... iii ...iii...iii....fli We welcome residents of all ages, backgrounds and lived experiences. We work together on the decisions that matter to us and have a meaningful influence in our community. We're healthy and thriving as we easily access the diverse and inclusive programs and services we need to succeed. Advance Truth and Reconciliation Compass Kitchener recognizes that advancing Truth and Reconciliation (T&tR) is not a conventional municipal project, but rather a foundational and ongoing commitment that must be embedded across the City's work. For this reason, and to be consistent with the equity lens the committee applied to this report, the committee has chosen a narrative format for this assessment, recognizing that traditional evaluation frameworks rooted in Western paradigms are often ill-suited to the complex, relational, and long-term nature of reconciliation work. In reviewing the City's actions, Compass Kitchener was encouraged by the depth of the City's commitment and its evolving understanding of the respectful role it must play. This role was particularly evident in initiatives such as the Wiinjindamaan project, an Indigenous land stewardship initiative co-developed with Conestoga College and Indigenous-led organizations. The committee views this project not as a City-led undertaking, but as a community-led partnership in which the City is a respectful participant. In this and other initiatives, leadership is shared across partners, and success is measured not by deliverables alone, but by the depth of relationships, mutual trust, and shared purpose they cultivate. Importantly, Compass Kitchener commends the City's humility in its communication approach, particularly its decision to resist the impulse to publicly spotlight its role in reconciliation projects where such visibility could overshadow Indigenous voices or compromise fragile trust. This restraint reflects a maturity of intent and a recognition that reconciliation requires shifting power, not seeking credit. At the same time, the committee encourages the City to find appropriate, partner-informed ways of communicating progress to the broader public. Doing so can raise awareness, foster understanding, and encourage others in the community to engage meaningfully with reconciliation efforts, so long as the narrative elevates Indigenous leadership and maintains a focus on collective, rather than institutional achievement. In sum, Compass Kitchener affirms the City's role as a committed, learning partner in the journey of reconciliation. The success of this work should not be assessed by traditional performance metrics, but by the strength of the relationships it fosters and the integrity with which the City walks alongside Indigenous communities. As the City continues this work, Compass Kitchener encourages it to remain guided by Indigenous leadership, to foster collective ownership of projects, and to communicate progress in ways that elevate Indigenous voices while preserving the trust and partnerships that have been so carefully built. 33 9 �I ' Ilb �iiir. ��:� �iiy"I ��iiyld Ill � �lll �iiy� ;� III � ,� �I DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE 2023-2026 STRATEGIC PLAN Compass Kitchener commends the City for adopting a thoughtful, adaptive, and resident-centred approach to the development and implementation of the 2023-2026 Strategic Plan. The process reflected important [earnings from past cycles and demonstrated the City's commitment to broad engagement, responsible project delivery, and continuous improvement. Public engagement reached new heights, with the Resident Panel standing out as a particularly innovative and inclusive initiative. Participants reported feeling heard and valued, and the variety of engagement formats—both online and in-person—helped diversify participation and strengthen legitimacy. The plan's adaptive structure, which introduces actions in phases rather than all at once, represents a welcome shift. It enables flexibility to respond to changing community needs and allows for more realistic planning. As implementation proceeds, Compass Kitchener encourages the City to maintain transparency by clearly communicating changes and new project additions to the public. The introduction of project charters, the assignment of dedicated project managers, and the inclusion of a midpoint check-in all suggest a maturing strategic planning culture. These changes support accountability, responsiveness, and better coordination across departments. The committee appreciated being included in the all-committees midpoint review and supports this practice continuing in future plans. The new Strategic Plan Indicators webpage enhances public transparency and offers a valuable tool for tracking progress. The committee encourages continued efforts to ensure this data remains accessible and user-friendly, particularly for non-technical audiences. Recommendations for Future Planning • Deepen engagement with equity-deserving communities and continue to innovate in participatory methods. • Ensure clear public communication of new or revised actions under the adaptive model. • Strengthen storytelling to help residents connect with the plan and see its relevance to daily life. • Expand public education on how strategic indicators are used and what they revea 1. 34 10 Overall, the 2023-2026 plan reflects a more agile and collaborative direction. Compass Kitchener encourages the City to carry this momentum forward as it begins to envision the next strategic planning process. UPDATE ON PROJECTS FROM THE 2023-2026 STRATEGIC PLAN As part of its ongoing accountability and learning role, Compass Kitchener continues to monitor the progress of projects from the 2019-2022 Strategic Plan that remained incomplete at the time of its 2024 report to Council. The following provides an update on those projects, based on available information: Protected Cycling Network Original Target: 2022 (Completion noted in 2024 report as 2024) Now completed. The network was opened in late 2024, with final touches on Duke Street scheduled for spring 2025. A public celebration is planned for June 7, 2025. Incubator and Accelerator Project Original Target: 2019-2021 (Reported as incomplete in 2024) The Creative Hub at 44 Gaukel is fully leased. A food incubator business case will be submitted in Q3 2025. Build-out of the Small Business Centre in the Innovation Arena is expected by early 2026. City-Owned Property Review Original Target: 2020 (Reported as ongoing in 2024) Now complete. The City has adopted a land disposition framework based on this review. Downtown Innovation District (Bramm Yards) Vision Original Target: 2021 (Reported as incomplete in 2024) Delayed due to market conditions. Revised plans are in progress, with the Master Plan now expected in 2027. Environmental remediation and pre-design work are underway. Rosenberg Community Centre Business Case Original Target: 2021 (Reported as incomplete in 2024) Now complete. Business case and design work have concluded. Construction of the joint school and community centre is underway as of fall 2024. 35 11 Open Space Strategy Original Target: 2021 (Reported as incomplete in 2024) Now complete. The final phase ("Places") is scheduled to be presented to Council in May 2025 as part of the Places Et Spaces strategy. Arts and Culture Master Plan Original Target: 2021 (Reported as incomplete in 2024) Development of the plan (now retitled Arts and Creative Industries Action Plan) is underway, with completion targeted for 2025 and implementation to begin 2026- 2028. This initiative is now included in the 2023-2026 Strategic Plan under Creating an Economically Thriving City Together. Compass Kitchener appreciates the City's continued transparency in reporting the status of these projects. In several cases, projects have been carried forward and integrated into the current strategic plan, illustrating the City's adaptive approach. The committee encourages continued clear communication on revised timelines and evolving scopes as the City moves forward. 36 12 ihri rn: ,